i don't have a problem with that thought process. i probably would have waited, but it's harder to defend just rng if you wait until hour 35.Like, here's the thought process he's describing:
1) receive gun
2) immediately RNG use options
3) RNG roster to randomly shoot someone
Is it possible he did that as town? Yes. But to me it's more likely he's scum that went "ah, a chance to kill!" and is now trying to cover it up.
-
CycleTrack and SDN are teaming up to make medical school admissions more transparent and accessible! Read the announcement to learn how we’re supporting the future of CycleTrack’s free application-tracking tools .
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Impromptu WW Game Thread
Started by kaydubs
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
unyeet santy
I have a lot of problems with that thought process. We're in an eight person game. Shooting randomly will more likely hit a villager. Why not try to optimize your chances by shooting within the PoE?i don't have a problem with that thought process. i probably would have waited, but it's harder to defend just rng if you wait until hour 35.
That's why I asked how long he had to make a choice to shoot because I could maybe see RNG if you have like an hour, but if you have a whole cycle or something, the earlier you shoot the more anti-village the action feels.
Addressing this specifically, why do you need to defend just RNG? As in, why do it at all?it's harder to defend just rng if you wait until hour 35
genny, talk to me about this. Why'd you agree a villager wouldn't shoot AM that early but now you're saying maybe it could be so?yeah, i don't see a villager shooting AM that early in the game. great wolf move for you, though
because when i made the initial post, i assumed it was role-related, not item-related.genny, talk to me about this. Why'd you agree a villager wouldn't shoot AM that early but now you're saying maybe it could be so?
you mistake my meaning. the shooter needs to defend their choices regardless of when the shot happens. if clem's method was rng, i find that fits better with taking the shot super early, rather than waiting.Addressing this specifically, why do you need to defend just RNG? As in, why do it at all?
I’m still thinking on Santy. Why are you voting Santy over Clem?So why aren't you voting Clem?
as someone who's shot a lot of villagers as a villager myself, i'd probably have better chances using rng. i'm not terminator!sporty. maybe clem knows he isn't either.I have a lot of problems with that thought process. We're in an eight person game. Shooting randomly will more likely hit a villager. Why not try to optimize your chances by shooting within the PoE?
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
Because I don't know what to do about the whole situation.I’m still thinking on Santy. Why are you voting Santy over Clem?
You just seemed pretty convinced a wolf shot AM, so logical conclusion would be to vote Clem.
If I had taken that shot as mafia I wouldn't have posted for much longer than half an hour lolThis is what I’m thinking. I think it’s likely wolf/wolves had a day vig shot and used it immediately at day open.
It’s just hard to imagine that a villager took that shot.
At least the shot was probably (hopefully) a 1x since none of the rest of us are dead.
Or I would've just claimed it immediately
I mean idk why id kill am with it then lolLike, here's the thought process he's describing:
1) receive gun
2) immediately RNG use options
3) RNG roster to randomly shoot someone
Is it possible he did that as town? Yes. But to me it's more likely he's scum that went "ah, a chance to kill!" and is now trying to cover it up.
Or why I'd claim it at all
This assumes my reads would be better than rngI have a lot of problems with that thought process. We're in an eight person game. Shooting randomly will more likely hit a villager. Why not try to optimize your chances by shooting within the PoE?
That's why I asked how long he had to make a choice to shoot because I could maybe see RNG if you have like an hour, but if you have a whole cycle or something, the earlier you shoot the more anti-village the action feels.
I don't really think they're likely to be tbh, and I dont really have confidence someone else's would be to sheep them, so I shot randomly. Its d1, it doesn't lose a kill, its fine.
I dont understand why you think I am mafia
What do you mean it's fine?This assumes my reads would be better than rng
I don't really think they're likely to be tbh, and I dont really have confidence someone else's would be to sheep them, so I shot randomly. Its d1, it doesn't lose a kill, its fine.
It's a waste of a shot that could've been used to kill a wolf. Instead you killed a villager that was also N1'd last game so she got to play for like an hour.
Literally all you have to do is fine twoish town reads and you're better than RNG.
It's D1, yes, and now that's one less misyeet wolf/wolves have to get.
I think you are a pitied and loved weaklingI dont understand why you think I am mafia
Well I think maybe mafia decided who got a gun, and maybe you TMIed thatI dont understand why you think I am mafia
I'm not real confident in it lol, kinda think maybe I'm wrong atp
So you’re saying you would have claimed it sooner…or waited even longer to post?If I had taken that shot as mafia I wouldn't have posted for much longer than half an hour lol
Or I would've just claimed it immediately
But when you did post was in this Goldilocks zone between the two that makes you village?
No it isn't lol, they need the same number of miskills. Game started with 8, going from 8 to 7 doesn't lose us a killWhat do you mean it's fine?
It's a waste of a shot that could've been used to kill a wolf. Instead you killed a villager that was also N1'd last game so she got to play for like an hour.
Literally all you have to do is fine twoish town reads and you're better than RNG.
It's D1, yes, and now that's one less misyeet wolf/wolves have to get.
Not exactly, but sure close enough I guessSo you’re saying you would have claimed it sooner…or waited even longer to post?
But when you did post was in this Goldilocks zone between the two that makes you village?
I’m definitely leaning more towards a wolf shot AM. I’m still not convinced it wasn’t Wolf!Santy who shot AM.Because I don't know what to do about the whole situation.
You just seemed pretty convinced a wolf shot AM, so logical conclusion would be to vote Clem.
I am literally telling you I shot am lolI’m definitely leaning more towards a wolf shot AM. I’m still not convinced it wasn’t Wolf!Santy who shot AM.
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
I’m definitely leaning more towards a wolf shot AM. I’m still not convinced it wasn’t Wolf!Santy who shot AM.
Yeah that lolI am literally telling you I shot am lol
Can I trust you?I am literally telling you I shot am lol
It's more that we don't know whether it was a wolf action, and Santy's "reaction test" was all based on assuming it was. So I'm poking at it to see if it was just an assumption on his part or whether it was TMI.I think Nate is getting at the vig **** potentially being a village action.
I disagree with that idea but it's possible.
what the heck is this question??? who answers this with "No!" 🤣Can I trust you?
So like…. Immediately after AM was shot, momentum started moving towards Clem, and then Santy came in and claimed it. Like “it was me, look over here! Not at Clem”. Idk how to interpret thatYeah that lol
It was more intended as a “I can’t trust you” but formatted as a question.what the heck is this question??? who answers this with "No!" 🤣
Also genny pls.what the heck is this question??? who answers this with "No!" 🤣
You would 100% respond with “No!” Or some ultra sketchy “yes 😉” for the lulz
only if i were a wolf 🤔Also genny pls.
You would 100% respond with “No!” Or some ultra sketchy “yes 😉” for the lulz
In this case, the team would have to be *exactly* Santy/Clem. Do you think that's likely with Clem now trying to turn it back toward Santy?I’m definitely leaning more towards a wolf shot AM. I’m still not convinced it wasn’t Wolf!Santy who shot AM.
I'm more confused than I was last night.
🤦♀️Can I trust you?
Day 1 Vote Tally
PSV ()
Santy (2) - DubZ, Clem
Clem (1) - PSV
3/7
missing: @NateTheLesser @Santygrass @Zenge142 @genny
Vote closes at 10pm EDT TODAY (~3.5 hours)
PSV ()
Santy (2) - DubZ, Clem
Clem (1) - PSV
3/7
missing: @NateTheLesser @Santygrass @Zenge142 @genny
Vote closes at 10pm EDT TODAY (~3.5 hours)
Do you have any other thoughts?I'm more confused than I was last night.
For those unfamiliar with me, I try to include a tally link in the Table of Contents post. Just started, it’s been a busy weekend as always.
Clem pls. You’re outted. If you really did shoot AM idk how that was possibly a village decision.unvote santy
vote zenge
Do you think I can be a wolf if Clem is Villa?So like…. Immediately after AM was shot, momentum started moving towards Clem, and then Santy came in and claimed it. Like “it was me, look over here! Not at Clem”. Idk how to interpret that
Like, you seem to be sussing me assuming Clem is a wolf in that scenario
You have a poor imagination then lolClem pls. You’re outted. If you really did shoot AM idk how that was possibly a village decision.
Yeah, if it was a Villa handling the gun, they would have went to your ass 100%.Well I think maybe mafia decided who got a gun, and maybe you TMIed that
I'm not real confident in it lol, kinda think maybe I'm wrong atp
And tbh I dont think if its that scenario I would be the only one thinking that you can have the wildest shot tbh?
Idk. I’m still just really confused about why you claimed the shot initiallyDo you think I can be a wolf if Clem is Villa?
Like, you seem to be sussing me assuming Clem is a wolf in that scenario
Because it seemed funIdk. I’m still just really confused about why you claimed the shot initially
No regrets tbh. I know it was prob suboptimal play but seeing people reactions to it while I stayed in character was fun. Would do it again
I still have no idea what Santy's gameplan was. But if he's town I wouldn't be surprised to find a wolf in his early voters, because it'd be an easy vote to justify. Excluding Dubz from that because her vote was before he "claimed", the other two early votes were Genny and you. Genny in particular seemed eager to pin the kill on someone, she voted Clem, kind of low-key shaded you (said something like she could see you taking that shot), and then voted Santy after he claimed it. So I was thinking of voting there. But idk, now we have the claim that the vig shot was just RNGed, which seems bad on pretty much every level.Do you have any other thoughts?
I think I saw a PSV townread that you based on reactions, what else did you get from it?No regrets tbh. I know it was prob suboptimal play but seeing people reactions to it while I stayed in character was fun. Would do it again
Slight sus on Wildzoo too, but knowing it was Clem who shot it, the reads I got from there are far more weaker tbh.I think I saw a PSV townread that you based on reactions, what else did you get from it?
Genny vote switch from Clem > Me > Clem again I'd say ehhhh its not bad? Idk
Oh genny didn revote Clem. Only unvoted. I have Skill Issue
What I am at rn is:
Clem is a wolf > Well obv yeet there(?)
Clem is Villa > A wolf handed him the gun. They knew Clem was the one who shot, so shading there was something a wolf may tend to do because of TMI
Clem is a wolf > Well obv yeet there(?)
Clem is Villa > A wolf handed him the gun. They knew Clem was the one who shot, so shading there was something a wolf may tend to do because of TMI