MarWWel -- GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
There's no other way to read a statement that ends in ma'am

Especially since I've spent most of my life in the south :laugh:
I lived in the south until last year and it's still hard to believe how many dialectical differences I have with Minnesotans

These monsters and their ""pop"". It's soda!!
 
yeet Mel

he's threatening me :scared:
did......did you just try to pull the "help I'm being bullied and I'm helpless" card, when you take pride in making me rage!cry myself to sleep? Not buying it.

Isn't this like your third game? 🤔
Wait a second……
Not the time, the order of responses.
To acknowledge TE’s post that came after mine (and was not direct quoting you so you don’t get a ping) then going back to my posts
this is a lot of mental gymnastics.
(I see it’s been discussed, but yeah I don’t think this is as incriminating as you think)
Starting to look like a fluff-pile-on
this was strange (*sigh* I see it’s already been discussed as I keep reading)

Lol felt this

Hey, it’s not me this time😀
its about to be.
Remind me again as a pretty-much-still-noob:

How are we supposed to productively wolf-hunt on day 1?

Feels like 36 hours of WIFOM leading into a misyeet every time
logic. Follow people’s reasons for voting for other people and then figure out if you think they’re being genuine or making up reasons to plant their vote.
 
logic. Follow people’s reasons for voting for other people and then figure out if you think they’re being genuine or making up reasons to plant their vote.
You can do the same with people's reasons for their village reads too btw @Truenamer
 
did......did you just try to pull the "help I'm being bullied and I'm helpless" card, when you take pride in making me rage!cry myself to sleep? Not buying it.


Wait a second……

this is a lot of mental gymnastics.
(I see it’s been discussed, but yeah I don’t think this is as incriminating as you think)

this was strange (*sigh* I see it’s already been discussed as I keep reading)


its about to be.

logic. Follow people’s reasons for voting for other people and then figure out if you think they’re being genuine or making up reasons to plant their vote.
Ya find my mental gymnastics wolfy?
 
It strikes me that she’s referring to herself as “me” despite dubz in the 3rd person. Dunno why.
Eh…..I think you’re reading too much into wording. Though I feel like Dubz has been steering conversation vs generating it, so she’s on my radar. Thoughts?
ehhh not much from day 1. still reading samac/fluff as both village. true seems to be striking the same tone as he has been the past few games, but clearly im horrible at reading him because of how strongly i thought he was the cult leader in the last game. TME also sounds the same as when we played together in the noob game, but I've only played with her as a wolf.
can you show me the things that sound the same?
i have to agree that reading through it, i got the same vibes that it was a little fluff pile on. sure, only one vote, but the overall feeling was focused on fluff being sketch
who were the others that would have been the “pile-on” besides Samac?
Oh that reminds me that to me it felt a titch too soon just based on post content to say cubs is powervillaging.

Which made me raise my eyebrow at barks a little.

Ok back to my nap.
I also eyebrow raised at that Barks post as well as her intro.

Iam a tiny bit confused why my more direct pushback on the fluff suspicion isn't being discussed at all vs Zenge saying he could understand the general feeling of the thread momentum turning against fluff.
:grump: okay the above two posts by WZ give me a begrudging D1 village lean on her.
 
Assemble Yourselves Day 1 Vote Tally

DubZ (1) - Sporty
samac (2) - Bob, True
TME (1) - AM
True (2) - genny, Barks
Mel (1) - DubZ
Fluff (1) - samac
Sporty (1) - violet
Violet (1) - cubs

10/19

Missing: @Dana_May_B @justafluff @kdswg @The_Breadmann @Melchizedek @Zenge142 @TelemarketingEnigma @SARdoghandler @potentialsheltervet

Vote closes at 10pm ET/9pm CT/7pm Fantasyland on Tuesday, 2/15/22 (~11.5 hours)

the avengers GIF
 
I suppose because we're getting actually close I'm going to go ahead and

Unyeet samac
 
can you show me the things that sound the same?
had to do some digging, but here's some examples of posts that reminded me of the noob game (as well as just her general tone too- but i can't quote the entire 30 page wolf chat to describe that haha):
Sketchy intro post!
Sketchy intro post!

did someone say tinfoil??

youtube fashion GIF
I need more to foil about!! aka mechanics. gimme some mechanics and I'll tinfoil to your hearts content. Not enough in the intro post to work with atm

My current slight tinfoil-that-isn't-really-tinfoil is that something feels wolfy between dubz or Fluff. Can't decide if it's wolfier to bring the Lupin rule up first knowing you're in the group to get ahead of someone calling you out with it (dubz) or to seem defensive about it being useful (fluff).

Just wait till you get heavily village read as a wolf and then you’ll never be trusted again! (or at least the next few games)

It’s all about that sketch balance
i will warn you though when you're this village read your first wolf outing, no one will ever trust you again
 
had to do some digging, but here's some examples of posts that reminded me of the noob game (as well as just her general tone too- but i can't quote the entire 30 page wolf chat to describe that haha):
oh hey nice to see my consistency between affiliations!

(you haven't played with me as village, but i could find examples of my village self saying all of these things too)
 
oh hey nice to see my consistency between affiliations!

(you haven't played with me as village, but i could find examples of my village self saying all of these things too)
haha that is extremely fair, and its exactly why im not wolf reading you right now. but im glad youre consistent because im really excited to play a game with you again, and i hope its just as fun if me, and you (hopefully) are villagers!
 
haha that is extremely fair, and its exactly why im not wolf reading you right now. but im glad youre consistent because im really excited to play a game with you again, and i hope its just as fun if me, and you (hopefully) are villagers!
I suspect there's plenty of things I'm inconsistent about that experienced players pick up on but these specific ones hold up between games haha
 
who were the others that would have been the “pile-on” besides Samac?
For the record, I wasn't planning on yeeting anyone because of that. In my experience, posting early is NAI, and more often than not it's excited villagers.

Isn't this like your third game? 🤔

skimming while actively getting my haircut so searching is hard but was fluff in the first 5

Trying to decide if the defense feels icky or not

This fluff and samac convo is interesting

In that fluff sounds a little sketchy in it

At least for me, I like to engage with people sitting on me.

like i said before- there was just one vote so maybe even "pile-on" is the wrong term- but i definitely agree with zenge that the thread momentum was going towards seeing fluff as sketchy
 

like i said before- there was just one vote so maybe even "pile-on" is the wrong term- but i definitely agree with zenge that the thread momentum was going towards seeing fluff as sketchy
Did anyone specifically stick out as sketchy that was contributing to the conversation?
 
like i said before- there was just one vote so maybe even "pile-on" is the wrong term- but i definitely agree with zenge that the thread momentum was going towards seeing fluff as sketchy

Wow, I had missed the barks quote… my work procedure today got canceled so I’ll be around to re-read the thread with a fresh mind.
 
Did anyone specifically stick out as sketchy that was contributing to the conversation?
my initial impression is that samac wasn't sketchy even tho she was driving the convo- i think she didn't like fluff's comment and was sticking with her initial read while pushing back on fluff's defenses. however, the comments from barks and TME felt weird because they shared they were thinking about fluff being maybe sketchy without adding really any of their own reasoning
 
my initial impression is that samac wasn't sketchy even tho she was driving the convo- i think she didn't like fluff's comment and was sticking with her initial read while pushing back on fluff's defenses. however, the comments from barks and TME felt weird because they shared they were thinking about fluff being maybe sketchy without adding really any of their own reasoning
So how would you say you're reading Enigma in conjunction with thi earlier response?
haha that is extremely fair, and its exactly why im not wolf reading you right now. but im glad youre consistent because im really excited to play a game with you again, and i hope its just as fun if me, and you (hopefully) are villagers!
 
So how would you say you're reading Enigma in conjunction with thi earlier response?
solidly neutral. im not ready to wolf-read her yet for her fluff post and ive never seen her play as a villager, but im also not finding reasons to give her village points at the moment.
 
Ya find my mental gymnastics wolfy?
not at the moment, I just think you’re being reachy. Occam’s razor and whatnot. If you have to drill down to the specifics of the order of things someone responds to, you’re trying too hard to make the theory fit.

This is the other zenge comment I agreed with, nothing to do with s'mack's post.
But does lurky zenge mean wolf zenge? The last wolf!zenge game he was pushing a villager the first couple of days right? I want to say it was fluff that game for sure on D2 but there was also someone D1? @Animal Midwife correct me

it's a similar gut feeling to MHA I think. Bold village zenge goes after others, bold wolf zenge gets prickly when others go for him. That said, I'm not 100% sure that's what's happening in this zenge vs. samac tiff, it's just something i'm pondering over
I don’t think Zenge has been prickly, his posts felt more like “hey this is what actually happened.” I wouldn’t characterize it as prickly.
 

like i said before- there was just one vote so maybe even "pile-on" is the wrong term- but i definitely agree with zenge that the thread momentum was going towards seeing fluff as sketchy
Yeah, I used the term "pile on" first and it was mostly because I was skimming the thread quickly and thought several folks were posting at fluff, when it was just one poasty samac
 
What did Barks do to ping you, again? I'm demonstrably bad at reading her, you see
Her quick powervillage Cubs remark, and I actually didn't note her comment on fluff earlier but that's a possibility too. Nothing really strong.
 
Yeah, I used the term "pile on" first and it was mostly because I was skimming the thread quickly and thought several folks were posting at fluff, when it was just one poasty samac
no, i do think there were several folks posting at fluff, hence the wall of quotes you just replied to in my post haha
 
Her quick powervillage Cubs remark, and I actually didn't note her comment on fluff earlier but that's a possibility too. Nothing really strong.
Ah, makes sense. Yeah, that's definitely not enough for me to jump on a wagon while I'm still in Maximum Guilt mode over a certain woodcutting 'accident'. 😢
 
not at the moment, I just think you’re being reachy. Occam’s razor and whatnot. If you have to drill down to the specifics of the order of things someone responds to, you’re trying too hard to make the theory fit.


But does lurky zenge mean wolf zenge? The last wolf!zenge game he was pushing a villager the first couple of days right? I want to say it was fluff that game for sure on D2 but there was also someone D1? @Animal Midwife correct me


I don’t think Zenge has been prickly, his posts felt more like “hey this is what actually happened.” I wouldn’t characterize it as prickly.
I didn’t really have a theory though, I just thought it was an interesting choice.

Yes, zenge pushed fluff. We needed to get her misyeeted to level up our Wolfpack.
Lurky zenge is NAI
 
But does lurky zenge mean wolf zenge? The last wolf!zenge game he was pushing a villager the first couple of days right? I want to say it was fluff that game for sure on D2 but there was also someone D1? @Animal Midwife correct me
Lurking is NAI. He did it last game and almost every game before and after. He also doesn't deepwolf so he's almost always going to be pushing solely villagers.
 
Hey @cubsrule4e, I did a very brief @violetvett iso (brief because 6 posts) and I'm curious about your thoughts on yeeting her; there's basically no meat to go off of except for her very first post (where she votes Sporty).

Is it more of a "vote here and see if/how she responds" thing, or do you feel more strongly about it than that?
 
Top