- Joined
- Mar 24, 2010
- Messages
- 4,074
- Reaction score
- 5,188
Also to the guy who is obsessed with doximity, your link says that their ranking is based off a survey, which is basically a popularity contest like I said.
Reading is hard, isn't it?
I'll help you out and highlight the important parts:
RESIDENTS’ SATISFACTION SURVEY
All physician members who were current residents or recent graduates of U.S. residency programs were surveyed beginning June 2015. The survey is still ongoing: interested residents and recent residency graduates are encouraged to contribute responses about their experience through October 2015.
MEASUREMENT OF RESEARCH OUTPUT
Profile data of all U.S. physicians, regardless of membership with Doximity, were used to calculate research output score for each residency program’s recent alumni base. This score was calculated from a combination of the collective h-index of publications authored by alumni graduating within the past 15 years, as well as research grants awarded. Each program’s research output was then compared to all other programs within the same specialty to create a percentile score.
REPUTATION DATA AMONG BOARD CERTIFIED PHYSICIANS
The 2015 survey for peer nominations across 22 specialties was conducted from June to August 2015. Surveyed specialties were limited to those that participated in Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS).
Design for the survey was modeled, with permission, on the annual physician survey that is a component of U.S. News & World Report's Best Hospitals rankings. U.S. News editors also provided informal input into the design of the survey.
Each physician could nominate up to 5 residency programs using a survey instrument
30,163 verified, board-certified physicians participated in the peer nomination process. The results of the 2015 reputation survey were pooled with those of the 2014 survey such that only the most recent (2015) responses were counted for physicians that responded to both years.
To account for “self-votes”, raw votes were divided into alumni-votes and non-alumni votes. Alumni votes were weighted according to the % of the eligible physician population that a particular program accounts for within that specialty (number of alumni divided by total eligible within the specialty).
If you were trying to come up with some sort of a list of the top programs in a particular field, how would you go about it? A ranking list is nothing but a survey, a popularity contest. That's all a F&@$ing rank list can be. I respect anyone who goes beyond determining program quality by your apparent criteria...
By interviewing at top programs and talking to other top applicants, none of which applied to Cleveland Clinic. Cleveland clinic's internal medicine residency is not very well respected either
🙄
Last edited: