Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Okay I read it. So uh, that blocker willing to talk anyway? 😉

Doubt the protector would want to out themselves.

 

[jaboo]

Calling people out is village AM's jam. The fact she wasn't pressuring people for more reads yesterday is actually what has put her on my radar and is the opposite of what you are saying.

You just put yourself on my radar manatee

Follow up to my last quote of you, if not AM (and the quiet ones) who would you be going for?

From what I remember from Michigan, AM kinda popped in periodically to ask questions and put pressure on people. Not often, though. But for a long time I forgot she was playing. Hence my reasoning—she’s been much more present.

And I agree with you about reads. I meant that she’s been throwing shade but not really pressuring people.

Besides that, I agree that allieh’s lurking yesterday was weird. But I also agree with Coffee’s point about Jones. She’s been posting a bit but it kinda seems like hypothetical pondering and less helpful analysis. Pulling a Cray, maybe? 😉 From my playing with her in the noob game, that’s a bit OOC

 

[jaboo]

Just an FYI, I’ll be back on for my lunch break but I’m going to be MIA until 6pmish EST. Not ghosting, promise.

 

[Mad Jack]

Note: Night posts will not count toward daily content post tallies, but will be considered as evidence of participation if a player is in danger of modkill.

I long for death

 

[WildZoo]

I long for death

But you've provided so much good content today! 😉

 

[Mad Jack]

But you've provided so much good content today! 😉

 

[Animal Midwife]

Coop
I suspect villager, somehow became an easy target for trying to defend another player.

Who was Coop defending?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Who was Coop defending?

**my last post before work

Stella

 

[Crayola227]

Generally the rule is if it doesn't die (death avoidance, not resurrection), kill it twice. Rezzes aren't as clear cut.

I think I'm slaughtering an SPN quote which is funny given the game and how many times they been rezz'd.

 

[Crayola227]

His application to be considered a main brother and released from hell was denied because he's not handsome enough and we also didn't want Dean making Sam Adams jokes all the time.

I think I might be willing to reconsider the application.... I will say, he's not Jensen but worth rezz'ing and killing again.

Spoiler: Adam grew up

 

[LetItSnow]

Lol no one ever really dies in SPN.

Although, with an "open" set up, what are the chances of there being a rez? God I hate rezzes. Did LIS teach me, "if you kill it, and it doesn't stay dead, kill it twice?"

Maybe. But then mods did a couple games with 2 death avoidances just to be clever and make sure the village can't figure it out. So now I just grumble.

I mean, more than usual.

 

[allieh8607]

@allieh8607 can we get an answer to this?

I don't know. I came onto the thread early to vote because I knew I had a busy afternoon/evening and it ended up being even more unexpectedly busy. So now I've done a quick skim of the thread and need to go back and re-read more thoroughly but at first glance not many people pinging my radar too much yet. With the exception of Stella. That waffle right at the end of the lynch reeked of veteran wolf coaching, especially with the convenient excuse of "don't kill my manator!"

 

[allieh8607]

Are you saying Bryndy called Mel out for throwing shade? Coop is actually the first one to mention Mel throwing shade after I said Mel wasn't looking at the context of my post that Mel had called out

Nope, I was saying Coop called Mel out for throwing shade, and then proceeded to throw out shade. Sorry if it was unclear!

 

[LetItSnow]

That's a strange rule to apply to rezzes when they mostly been village as of late. There's a zero percent chance anyways. An open setup is WYSIWYG.

The kill-it-twice "rule" (not really, but...) was meant to apply to known wolves. As in, you kill something and get result of wolf, but it doesn't die or it comes back.

I agree with you regarding std rezzes. I don't see any reason to put them down again right away.

 

[Mad Jack]

The kill-it-twice "rule" (not really, but...) was meant to apply to known wolves. As in, you kill something and get result of wolf, but it doesn't die or it comes back.

I agree with you regarding std rezzes. I don't see any reason to put them down again right away.

I'm a fan of killing anything that doesn't die the first time, wolf or unknown.

 

[jaboo]

To clarify: In terms of the game, dead. However on the show it was never really explained what happens to monsters when they die in purgatory. They're already dead. So...super extra double purgatory it is 😛

I'm still going with the theory that no one actually dies. Because that's how SPN works.

Lol no one ever really dies in SPN.

Allow me to show you this super outdated infograph from TV Guide

Spoiler: Lots of SPN death spoilers

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Bryndiana.jones

Not much of a team player on first day. Created a very loud distraction that inevitably just made everyone loco towards each other. Wolf or villager, personally dislike that she’s turning people against each other.

I would hardly call voting, then defending that vote when pressed, a "distraction". If you don't address challenges made against you then you are likely going to get killed pretty quickly, and sometimes even then it doesn't save you.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

AM, MJ, do you have any thoughts on potential lynches for today? Would like to hear more from these two and some additional thoughts from Youngkal.

 

[jaboo]

Cancel that warning that I'll be MIA all day. Weather is **** here, so lots of things got cancelled.

 

[allieh8607]

Gonna ISO some people that give me feels from my re-read. Starting with Snowy...not much to go off of (which yes I realize the same can be said for me).

Yeah I didn't like that coop/bryndy interaction from either of them, but since coop is already in the lead and is good at talking herself into a D1 lynch, I'll lynch my mantee for now. Not feeling that strongly about either so might change my vote if I can get on later today.

lynch bryndy

Reads kind of hedgy to me, but at least she did come back and switch votes.

Sorry was working. Didn't realize there was a content post requirement. YK has given me some sketch feels but feel bad lynching her again and it's probably noobness.

I agree with mel that on further reading coopah vs bryndy seems like village on village.

Unlynch bryndy

If YK is giving you sketch feels, lynch her. "Feeling back for lynching again" is not a good reason. YK was a wolf last game...yes she was caught early and we didn't get to see much of her wolf meta but I am a firm believe that emotions from past games should not carry over into current games.

Snowy's subsequent vote for AM seems like a throwaway vote... @SnowshoeDog143 can you elaborate more on those AM feels besides her sticking with her random Coop vote?

 

[LetItSnow]

Hm. I don't want to get on the AM train yet. Seems too close to being on the edge of runaway status.

lynch genny to see if we can get her playing more

 

[WildZoo]

I'm still going with the theory that no one actually dies. Because that's how SPN works.


Allow me to show you this super outdated infograph from TV Guide

Spoiler: Lots of SPN death spoilers

View attachment 228979

So that's why it was season gr8

 

[allieh8607]

I mean, there's still six hours in the cycle. Why are you just singling out me?

Just pressure voting at the moment. I'm prone to switching.

I could also pressure Haxx/Snowy.

These posts are interesting to me. When Coop first pressed AM for her reasons, she refused to give any, then later said it was just a pressure vote. She even gave others that she may have switched to for additional pressure. Yet she never did switch. @Animal Midwife at the end of the lynch did you really feel that Coop was a wolf?

 

[Karabiner13]

From what I remember from Michigan, AM kinda popped in periodically to ask questions and put pressure on people. Not often, though. But for a long time I forgot she was playing. Hence my reasoning—she’s been much more present.

And I agree with you about reads. I meant that she’s been throwing shade but not really pressuring people.

Besides that, I agree that allieh’s lurking yesterday was weird. But I also agree with Coffee’s point about Jones. She’s been posting a bit but it kinda seems like hypothetical pondering and less helpful analysis. Pulling a Cray, maybe? 😉 From my playing with her in the noob game, that’s a bit OOC

Maybe it’s because I was working with AM in MI but I feel AM is more present when she is village vs wolf. You’ve pretty much been saying the opposite of me but getting the same conclusion. Also, Allie only half counts as answering the question as she is/was one of the quiet ones

Cancel that warning that I'll be MIA all day. Weather is **** here, so lots of things got cancelled.

Thanks for the update but how does that translate into actual participation. Come on manatee, you know better than this 🙂

Hm. I don't want to get on the AM train yet. Seems too close to being on the edge of runaway status.

lynch genny to see if we can get her playing more

Why genny over others who aren’t playing much?

 

[Karabiner13]

Can we stop with all the life updates on what people are doing? We’re all busy but it has no bearing on whether you’re a wolf or not and just adds clutter

 

[Karabiner13]

For once I feel like I’m talking to myself and talking a lot

@Animal Midwife what are your thoughts today? You’re awfully quiet

 

[allieh8607]

I tend to point out all lurkers, vets or noobs. Someone harped on me early on that lurking only helps wolves. I've only seen proof of that ever since.

Oh, and to answer your second question, probably Mel. Mel sets off my sketch meter all the time, but in particular his talk about lurkers that I quoted above makes me wary.

I'm really liking this part included in the tallies. Keeps people accountable and makes lurkers more obvious.

@Stella Mudd @SnowshoeDog143 @allieh8607
C'mon, guys, your input is welcome.

Who are you, Chief of the Lurk Police?

I call you out for ghosting and you bandwagon my lynch vote with a non-committal reason? You definitely just shot up on my sketch list.

You noobs still don't seem to quite comprehend what a bandwagon is. One vote on top of yours is not a bandwagon.

 

[jaboo]

Thanks for the update but how does that translate into actual participation. Come on manatee, you know better than this 🙂

Can we stop with all the life updates on what people are doing? We’re all busy but it has no bearing on whether you’re a wolf or not and just adds clutter

Fair, but also since my plans changed and I started posting, I thought someone was going to call BS on me. While I agree that life posts are not needed, people were pressuring me yesterday because I was gone during the day and I felt like I needed to address it. But it's kind of a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation. I won't post any further life updates.

 

[jaboo]

Who are you, Chief of the Lurk Police?

Forgive me for actually listening to advice from veteran players.

You noobs still don't seem to quite comprehend what a bandwagon is. One vote on top of yours is not a bandwagon.

Fair point. Bandwagon wasn't the best word to use. But it was still an odd vote.

 

[Karabiner13]

Fair, but also since my plans changed and I started posting, I thought someone was going to call BS on me. While I agree that life posts are not needed, people were pressuring me yesterday because I was gone during the day and I felt like I needed to address it. But it's kind of a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation. I won't post any further life updates.

The last one wasn’t aimed at you. It just seems like it’s the thing to do this game and it’s unnecessary. You also know it makes me look at those people more 🙂

 

[allieh8607]

Not sure if I'm not used to MJ's current play style but a few red flags up for me currently...
lynch MJ

@Mad Jack can we hear some more from you today besides "mwahahah", arguing about what counts as content, and discussing things that are irrelevant to this current game? Maybe who you actually find sketchy from yesterday's postings?

 

[LetItSnow]

Why genny over others who aren’t playing much?

Because I can only lynch one. And because my recollection is that she didn't participate much yesterday either. Although it may have been allieh. I can't remember.

 

[LetItSnow]

Not sure if I'm not used to MJ's current play style but a few red flags up for me currently...

Which red flags?

 

[Crayola227]

This is really saying something, or not, lol, but even *I* can't follow the huge multiquote wallposts. I follow best when people just reply to each separate post with its own reply, or if they are stringing them together for a purpose.

 

[Crayola227]

Because I can only lynch one. And because my recollection is that she didn't participate much yesterday either. Although it may have been allieh. I can't remember.

That's when it's time to take away grampa's gun. 😉

 

[Crayola227]

My fingers are itching to type novels, but if I start, it might be an entire page of posts. I tried paper notes by hand and it failed. Not sure what to do.

 

[Mad Jack]

Not sure if I'm not used to MJ's current play style but a few red flags up for me currently...
lynch MJ

@Mad Jack can we hear some more from you today besides "mwahahah", arguing about what counts as content, and discussing things that are irrelevant to this current game? Maybe who you actually find sketchy from yesterday's postings?

I'd love if you could contribute literally anything besides random baseless accusations. I'm still feeling out today before I make any decisions.

 

[LetItSnow]

That's when it's time to take away grampa's gun. 😉

Bah. As long as I can shoot <somebody> that's all that matters.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Not sure if I'm not used to MJ's current play style but a few red flags up for me currently...
lynch MJ

@Mad Jack can we hear some more from you today besides "mwahahah", arguing about what counts as content, and discussing things that are irrelevant to this current game? Maybe who you actually find sketchy from yesterday's postings?

I do agree, claiming to "want" to be killed?
Not forming concrete accusations?
As well as seeking out power roles a little too obviously.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I would hardly call voting, then defending that vote when pressed, a "distraction". If you don't address challenges made against you then you are likely going to get killed pretty quickly, and sometimes even then it doesn't save you.

I don't really think it is suspicious, it just caused quite a bit of chaos, while then the wolves slipped under the radar because they were being a lot more quiet and forming good arguments. I would guess that would make a good wolf.

 

[Mad Jack]

I do agree, claiming to "want" to be killed?
Not forming concrete accusations?
As well as seeking out power roles a little too obviously.

I'm fairly depressed in real life and am always making dark jokes about it, that has nothing to do with WW

 

[Coopah]

I'm not sure what to think about AM. Has she said anything today at all? @Haxx Have any thoughts (in general not specifically on AM)? I'm reading MJ as MJ so not necessarily wolfy because that's just how he is. Coffee? I like your thoughts, they are very well reasoned especially for a noob.

 

[Coopah]

These posts are interesting to me. When Coop first pressed AM for her reasons, she refused to give any, then later said it was just a pressure vote. She even gave others that she may have switched to for additional pressure. Yet she never did switch. @Animal Midwife at the end of the lynch did you really feel that Coop was a wolf?

Did you think I was a wolf at the end of the last lynch?

 

[Coopah]

@Crayola227 You seem to be restraining yourself, do you have any thoughts about who is wolfy?

 

[Haxx]

I'm not sure what to think about AM. Has she said anything today at all? @Haxx Have any thoughts (in general not specifically on AM)? I'm reading MJ as MJ so not necessarily wolfy because that's just how he is. Coffee? I like your thoughts, they are very well reasoned especially for a noob.

No thoughts about AM, but I am going to Lynch Johnnaboo because in my experience noob wolves tend to be very vocal about their "lists of who is sketch and who isn't" as a way to try to cover.

 

[youngkal]

We don't need to figure out any mechanics as everything has been handed to us as to what the set-up is. All we need to do is focus on player and vote analysis to find the wolves

It was more for clarification about what she was because I didnt not read it as Mel was a werewolf (monster name), a vanilla villager; but rather as a wearwolf and a vanilla villager which led me to be super confused. So I just wanted someone else to clarify with what they were thinking was being said.

 

[Haxx]

Also, in regards to Genny, this certainly isn't a vouch by any means, but this play style so far is consistent with her style from the lounge game we just played when she was village. Just FWIW for @LetItSnow and @Karabiner13

 

[youngkal]

In reality as I said yesterday, everyone is technically on my list to watch cause like duh... but night was short and it says that it would be max of two hours, so I guess I think I want to watch people who seem more active near the end of the day but idk how much this will give me. I’m not saying necessity who is lynching because I get that most people will cast a lynch later but idk its an idea.

 

[youngkal]

I am still somewhat skeptical of Bjones because she doesn’t seem to playing as she did in Winter, she is calling people out to get reasons as she previously did but I feel like she is giving us less original content than she did in Winter. This may be because its early but also could be because she is wolf and is having a harder time using logic that would be based on lies or fake feelings. I plan on watching her becuase I really like when she gave her original thoughts and would love to keep her if she is village.

 

[youngkal]

Sorry I think more posts that are short are easier, if its too annoying to too many of you I will do fewer in upcoming days.

I’m kinda side eyeing Genny only because I have only seen her play as wolf and the number of post she had was similar to how she played in the last game. Nothing too much more here..yet.