Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
bryndiana.jones said:
AM, MJ, do you have any thoughts on potential lynches for today? Would like to hear more from these two and some additional thoughts from Youngkal.
Click to expand...

Karabiner13 said:
For once I feel like I’m talking to myself and talking a lot

@Animal Midwife what are your thoughts today? You’re awfully quiet
Click to expand...

I'm still looking at Snowy. She seems hedgier than usual.

allieh8607 said:
These posts are interesting to me. When Coop first pressed AM for her reasons, she refused to give any, then later said it was just a pressure vote. She even gave others that she may have switched to for additional pressure. Yet she never did switch. @Animal Midwife at the end of the lynch did you really feel that Coop was a wolf?
Click to expand...

I don't know. I wasn't really feeling a need to switch at the end.

Lynch Snowy
 
Coopah said:
Except AM voted after that and YK hadn't yet, why are you throwing shade so early?
Click to expand...

This was what I thought was a good point you made about Mel, and one reason I felt better about his lynch over yours. It had me reading you as village. Oddly enough, it still does. But it makes me look harder at others. More to follow as I do my thread reread.
 
I see people on AM and while I hate joining in on major groups, I am watchful because she is going towards the quiet player which already have it set up to be mod-killed if they stay too quite. Maybe its cause she’s a villager wanting to get these players on to give us a better chance, maybe she just really likes it when people play (dont we all), maybe she’s a wolf. I am watching I just dont know if I’m ready to jump on this yet. I haven’t heard too much useful stuff but I really blame this on it being so early in this game.

I will be away for a bit now. I dont feel comfortable lynching anyone just yet.
 
LetItSnow said:
For the record, I wasn't setting myself up to waffle. I was just calling it like it is - your reason was weak as hell. Just like almost every D1 vote. That's just me being blunt.

I can see your point, though. I go pretty hard with my votes. It's not quite conviction, though - you're misinterpreting. It's more .... well, we have to vote, so I'm not gonna sit here and second guess myself all day long and fret, I'm just gonna go with the vote and let the chips fall.
Click to expand...

Not helping me at all that I'm pretty sure wolf you said this exact same sentence multiple times.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Yeah I didn't like that coop/bryndy interaction from either of them, but since coop is already in the lead and is good at talking herself into a D1 lynch, I'll lynch my mantee for now. Not feeling that strongly about either so might change my vote if I can get on later today.

lynch bryndy
Click to expand...

Not seen much from Snowy. Feels weak/throwaway here, but D1, but haven't seen follow up. Makes me nervous because she tends to be a more quiet hard to read player. She's getting really smart but almost seems to be hiding behind the wishy washy thing as a meta intentionally now.
 
Coopah said:
@Crayola227 You seem to be restraining yourself, do you have any thoughts about who is wolfy?
Click to expand...

lol you won't think that when I'm done, I'm on page 6 of the reread

I am trying something new where I don't reply to every single post I want to comment on as I go (last game that took up a whole page, which was fine middle of the night, today it would post bomb discussion), I took notes and will just give my run down.
 
Haxx said:
This. @WildZoo didn't give me credit for verifying my gender, which means I need to make ANOTHER post?!? 😉

I'm not going to do too much speculation day 1. The only thing I have left to say is that before someone accuses me of a double standard not being sketched out by LIS, I know his play style from previous games and therefore can verify with past personal experience. That is all.

tumblr_inline_niwm5zKSLU1syeoau.gif
Click to expand...

Not sure why you're acting so cagey. I get it, you only do "quality" posts. I'm not against people posting 1% of the number of posts I do, but it's more the attitude.
 
Coopah said:
I've said before I typically read her as wolfy so I'm giving it some time. I need to keep watching her but it seemed more village vs village yesterday.
Click to expand...

What is typically?
 
Coopah said:
Did you think I was a wolf at the end of the last lynch?
Click to expand...
Lol I knew someone would ask me this.
Honestly, no. I felt that you did an adequate job of defending yourself after you got some heat. But there is a difference between being around at the end of lynch and not switching your vote, vs. not being around. I was the latter and had I been online I most likely would have switched.

But I'm not 100% comfortable with Stella's waffle at the end of the lynch to "save" you. I'm leaning more towards noob behavior right now but it's still in the back of my mind that Stella could have been coached by veteran wolves to either 1) do the last minute waffle to save you, knowing that this is ballsy for a wolf but assuming we'd think it's just nooby since you're her manator or 2) last minute waffle to take out Mel, who they knew was a villager but still keep suspicion on you, who they would also know is a villager (if you are). I have a feeling I'm not articulating well what I'm actually trying to say but basically...still have my eye on you and Stella even though you're not my top candidates today.
 
Karabiner13 said:
That was a quick response with no additional content...

Took you a bit to post again and it's another reactive post. Makes me wonder
Click to expand...

Animal Midwife said:
Yeah.
Click to expand...

Kara was watching me because I would respond when called with quick posts and for having no additional content sooo then I ask, @Karabiner13 how do you feel about what AM is doing because I feel like we are getting short quick responses with no strong content.
 
youngkal said:
Kara was watching me because I would respond when called with quick posts and for having no additional content sooo then I ask, @Karabiner13 how do you feel about what AM is doing because I feel like we are getting short quick responses with no strong content.
Click to expand...

Why are you asking for Kara's opinion?
 
youngkal said:
Cause she was after me for this.. so why not other players? I’m trying to get more feels....why are you asking for other peoples opinions on other players....?!
Click to expand...

Well, it seems like you be should be forming your own opinion on it. Is that sketchy to you? Is it normal?

The bolded seems odd though.

youngkal said:
Like here....
Click to expand...

And?
 
Crayola227 said:
This is really saying something, or not, lol, but even *I* can't follow the huge multiquote wallposts. I follow best when people just reply to each separate post with its own reply, or if they are stringing them together for a purpose.
Click to expand...

I just grab quotes as I read through but I try to limit how many in a post. It’s easier this way as I then don’t lose my spot when I read through

Crayola227 said:
My fingers are itching to type novels, but if I start, it might be an entire page of posts. I tried paper notes by hand and it failed. Not sure what to do.
Click to expand...

I still want to hear your thoughts even if it means you take up a lot of the thread
 
Coopah said:
I'm not sure what to think about AM. Has she said anything today at all? @Haxx Have any thoughts (in general not specifically on AM)? I'm reading MJ as MJ so not necessarily wolfy because that's just how he is. Coffee? I like your thoughts, they are very well reasoned especially for a noob.
Click to expand...

At the time you posted, she had only posted once today. Haven’t caught up to see if she’s posted yet since

Who are you leaning towards today? Maybe I should keep reading but if you haven’t posted anything, I’d like to know
 
Haxx said:
No thoughts about AM, but I am going to Lynch Johnnaboo because in my experience noob wolves tend to be very vocal about their "lists of who is sketch and who isn't" as a way to try to cover.
Click to expand...

In pre-vet lately we’ve been doing lists

Haxx said:
Also, in regards to Genny, this certainly isn't a vouch by any means, but this play style so far is consistent with her style from the lounge game we just played when she was village. Just FWIW for @LetItSnow and @Karabiner13
Click to expand...

I’ve played with genny before. I was just curious why Lis was going that way not whether that was normal for genny
 
LetItSnow said:
Which red flags?
Click to expand...
Take this all with a grain of salt because I don't think I've played with MJ since I've started playing again so not sure if this is his normal or not. I'm not that critical of his joke vote for Mel, because it was D1 and joke votes happen. I guess I'm just used to MJ taking this game a little more seriously? He seemingly voted for Mel just to entertain himself. I like to go back and look at the people who voted for the person who was lynched last and I am comfortable with those that actually found Mel sketchy but according to MJ's posts that's not why he voted Mel. MJ has contributed next to nothing to the game, as I mentioned in my lynch vote for him. Arguing about what's considered content, making comments about killing things that don't die the first time....it looks like he's trying to post to be present but isn't actually wolf hunting. Kind of like what you mentioned about Stella. Stella able to read the thread and come on to say "I'm PST, don't lynch me yet" but didn't say much else. I want to see some reads from MJ...day 2 ends in 5 hours and he can't tell me a single person he finds sketchy from D1 or what has been posted thus far today? My vote is sticking.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Well, it seems like you be should be forming your own opinion on it. Is that sketchy to you? Is it normal?

The bolded seems odd though.



And?
Click to expand...


Okay you are not really being consistent. I’m trying to see if she is being consistent to get an opionion on her. I have my opinions and they are posted on the thread. I dont know how the bolded seems odd as it points out that you are asking why I am doing something when you are doing the same thing.. which is sketchy and inconsistent.
 
youngkal said:
Okay you are not really being consistent. I’m trying to see if she is being consistent to get an opionion on her. I have my opinions and they are posted on the thread. I dont know how the bolded seems odd as it points out that you are asking why I am doing something when you are doing the same thing.. which is sketchy and inconsistent.
Click to expand...

Okay, so I'm not being consistent because Kara might not be consistent? And because I'm asking for your motivation behind this it's sketchy?
 
youngkal said:
I am still somewhat skeptical of Bjones because she doesn’t seem to playing as she did in Winter, she is calling people out to get reasons as she previously did but I feel like she is giving us less original content than she did in Winter. This may be because its early but also could be because she is wolf and is having a harder time using logic that would be based on lies or fake feelings. I plan on watching her becuase I really like when she gave her original thoughts and would love to keep her if she is village.
Click to expand...

This is a complete 360. Yesterday you like bryndy’s thought process but if she’s a wolf she has to go. Now you want to keep her if village but are still unsure of her. Which is it? Does she need to stay because she contributes well or she needs to go because she could be a sneaky wolf

youngkal said:
I see people on AM and while I hate joining in on major groups, I am watchful because she is going towards the quiet player which already have it set up to be mod-killed if they stay too quite. Maybe its cause she’s a villager wanting to get these players on to give us a better chance, maybe she just really likes it when people play (dont we all), maybe she’s a wolf. I am watching I just dont know if I’m ready to jump on this yet. I haven’t heard too much useful stuff but I really blame this on it being so early in this game.

I will be away for a bit now. I dont feel comfortable lynching anyone just yet.
Click to expand...

Don’t feel bad about getting a vote out. There’s no majority rule in play and you can always unlynch
 
LetItSnow said:
Hm. I don't want to get on the AM train yet. Seems too close to being on the edge of runaway status.

lynch genny to see if we can get her playing more
Click to expand...

LetItSnow said:
Because I can only lynch one. And because my recollection is that she didn't participate much yesterday either. Although it may have been allieh. I can't remember.
Click to expand...
It's amazing you ever manage to find any wolves when you can't be bothered to remember whether it's me or allieh that you really want to lynch. 🤣
 
A
Animal Midwife said:
Okay, so I'm not being consistent because Kara might not be consistent? And because I'm asking for your motivation behind this it's sketchy?
Click to expand...

Im actually very confused with you. I am saying that I asked Kara to see if she would be consistent or not regarding what she found to be odd or sketchy because she is on my watch list, not too high but like I said earlier today everyone is really on there as they should be.

Second I am saying that I think it is weird that you find my bolded statement about why I was asking for her thoughts inconsistent because you are literally asking people for their thoughts on everyone else so why are you calling me out for doing that.

With the fact that this rings super sketchy to me and you are throwing all this confusion around, you seem like you are not actually doing anything useful


Lynch AM
 
Karabiner13 said:
This is a complete 360. Yesterday you like bryndy’s thought process but if she’s a wolf she has to go. Now you want to keep her if village but are still unsure of her. Which is it? Does she need to stay because she contributes well or she needs to go because she could be a sneaky wolf



Don’t feel bad about getting a vote out. There’s no majority rule in play and you can always unlynch
Click to expand...


OH I was saying as a villager she previously contributed well and if she was doing that I’d love to keep her to get more of her feels cause she was super accurate last game (although she may have had a power role, i dont remember) I think she is high on the has to go list currently because she hasn’t been playing as she previously had when I knew she was village, but I only have one game to meta off of so I’m waiting for more to make me feel stronger one way or the other with her. As I said she is high on my watch list.
 
youngkal said:
A


Im actually very confused with you. I am saying that I asked Kara to see if she would be consistent or not regarding what she found to be odd or sketchy because she is on my watch list, not too high but like I said earlier today everyone is really on there as they should be.

Second I am saying that I think it is weird that you find my bolded statement about why I was asking for her thoughts inconsistent because you are literally asking people for their thoughts on everyone else so why are you calling me out for doing that.

With the fact that this rings super sketchy to me and you are throwing all this confusion around, you seem like you are not actually doing anything useful


Lynch AM
Click to expand...

You still haven't answered my question.

What is your "watch list" ranking that everyone's on anyway? When did I say you were inconsistent? You're getting really defensive...
 
Animal Midwife said:
I'm still looking at Snowy. She seems hedgier than usual.

I don't know. I wasn't really feeling a need to switch at the end.

Lynch Snowy
Click to expand...

What do you feel about coop today considering you didn’t see the need to switch off yesterday? And how do you feel about haxx?

youngkal said:
Kara was watching me because I would respond when called with quick posts and for having no additional content sooo then I ask, @Karabiner13 how do you feel about what AM is doing because I feel like we are getting short quick responses with no strong content.
Click to expand...

Seriously? I think my lynch vote is answer enough.

You also don’t understand the reason behind what you quoted. I had posted the question to you and you popped up in less than 5 minutes but then didn’t add anything of substance after responding. AM doesn’t fit what you quoted. Yes, she is giving short answers but she didn’t respond right away when tagged. She’s improving but still doesn’t feel like her village self
 
Crayola227 said:
Not helping me at all that I'm pretty sure wolf you said this exact same sentence multiple times.
Click to expand...

I definitely might have.

Keep in mind I basically play the same game as villager or wolf. I mean, my whole wolf strategy is based around doing my best to forget that I'm a wolf.
 
Animal Midwife said:
You still haven't answered my question.

What is your "watch list" ranking that everyone's on anyway? When did I say you were inconsistent? You're getting really defensive...
Click to expand...

Are you reading my posts? I never said YOU said I was being inconsistent. Not getting really defensive I’m just tying to explain, because obviously you are not getting what I am trying to say.

I dont know where you asked me a question that I haven’t answered. I answered the first questions about the inconsistency, which you read incorrectly in the first post so I clarified and then. I didnt say that you asking for my motivation was sketchy but the fact that you asked why I was asking others was because you are asking others.
 
allieh8607 said:
Take this all with a grain of salt because I don't think I've played with MJ since I've started playing again so not sure if this is his normal or not. I'm not that critical of his joke vote for Mel, because it was D1 and joke votes happen. I guess I'm just used to MJ taking this game a little more seriously? He seemingly voted for Mel just to entertain himself. I like to go back and look at the people who voted for the person who was lynched last and I am comfortable with those that actually found Mel sketchy but according to MJ's posts that's not why he voted Mel. MJ has contributed next to nothing to the game, as I mentioned in my lynch vote for him. Arguing about what's considered content, making comments about killing things that don't die the first time....it looks like he's trying to post to be present but isn't actually wolf hunting. Kind of like what you mentioned about Stella. Stella able to read the thread and come on to say "I'm PST, don't lynch me yet" but didn't say much else. I want to see some reads from MJ...day 2 ends in 5 hours and he can't tell me a single person he finds sketchy from D1 or what has been posted thus far today? My vote is sticking.
Click to expand...

Ok. This isn't even <remotely> a vouch, but ... his play has shifted quite a bit to erratic. My suspicion is it's the same type of erratic play that I have - some games I'm more visible because I've got time off and free time, some games I get buried with work and I rush through and post a couple times a day and that's it. And, some days I feel more stressed out and have one 'tone' and some days I don't and have a different 'tone'.

That's my take on his play in the last several games he's played in. Bottom line, I think his meta is pretty hard to peg.

I agree that he's contributed almost no content - it's getting bad enough that I'm wavering on moving a vote to him. Initially I was kinda like "well, that's within his meta if he's busy" but ... he's had time to post snark but not content, and that's always a trigger/flag for me.
 
Karabiner13 said:
What do you feel about coop today considering you didn’t see the need to switch off yesterday? And how do you feel about haxx?
Click to expand...

Coop is still very neutral to me. I don't understand the "bryndy always reads wolfy" thing. I'm pretty sure they've never even played together.

Haxx doesn't seem any different than the Lounge game right now. Quiet but I like that he's putting out more original content today.
 
Karabiner13 said:
Seriously? I think my lynch vote is answer enough.

You also don’t understand the reason behind what you quoted. I had posted the question to you and you popped up in less than 5 minutes but then didn’t add anything of substance after responding. AM doesn’t fit what you quoted. Yes, she is giving short answers but she didn’t respond right away when tagged. She’s improving but still doesn’t feel like her village self
Click to expand...

Oops sorry, I didnt pay attention to who voted today. My b!
 
Does anyone else have trouble reading people's posts with run-on sentences in them?

I don't mean to be the grammar police, but it's kinda hard to interpret meanings when sentences go on forever without pauses or anything. Maybe it's just me, but I'm having a really hard time reading YK rn.
 
LetItSnow said:
Ok. This isn't even <remotely> a vouch, but ... his play has shifted quite a bit to erratic. My suspicion is it's the same type of erratic play that I have - some games I'm more visible because I've got time off and free time, some games I get buried with work and I rush through and post a couple times a day and that's it. And, some days I feel more stressed out and have one 'tone' and some days I don't and have a different 'tone'.

That's my take on his play in the last several games he's played in. Bottom line, I think his meta is pretty hard to peg.

I agree that he's contributed almost no content - it's getting bad enough that I'm wavering on moving a vote to him. Initially I was kinda like "well, that's within his meta if he's busy" but ... he's had time to post snark but not content, and that's always a trigger/flag for me.
Click to expand...
Does MJ ever post content? When he's not forced to? I feel like the games I've played with him, he's posted snark + an unexplained lynch vote.
 
johnnaboo said:
Does anyone else have trouble reading people's posts with run-on sentences in them?

I don't mean to be the grammar police, but it's kinda hard to interpret meanings when sentences go on forever without pauses or anything. Maybe it's just me, but I'm having a really hard time reading YK rn.
Click to expand...

Lol I’m sorry. I will try to add more periods. Is choppy better for most? I LOVE run ons, its my favorite grammatical mistake to make 😛 May be cause I like to rant in real life :shrug::smuggrin:
 
johnnaboo said:
Does anyone else have trouble reading people's posts with run-on sentences in them?

I don't mean to be the grammar police, but it's kinda hard to interpret meanings when sentences go on forever without pauses or anything. Maybe it's just me, but I'm having a really hard time reading YK rn.
Click to expand...

Also is there something you’d like to me to clarify?
 
youngkal said:
Are you reading my posts? I never said YOU said I was being inconsistent. Not getting really defensive I’m just tying to explain, because obviously you are not getting what I am trying to say.

I dont know where you asked me a question that I haven’t answered. I answered the first questions about the inconsistency, which you read incorrectly in the first post so I clarified and then. I didnt say that you asking for my motivation was sketchy but the fact that you asked why I was asking others was because you are asking others.
Click to expand...

So me asking you about asking others about something they already clarified on earlier is an issue?

And my question was about how you felt about how I responded to Coop. You then voted for me without a reason.
 
genny said:
It's amazing you ever manage to find any wolves when you can't be bothered to remember whether it's me or allieh that you really want to lynch. 🤣
Click to expand...

Oh c'mon. If I manage to lynch someone who is actually playing the game - and not dead - I'm doing pretty well.
 
Animal Midwife said:
So me asking you about asking others about something they already clarified on earlier is an issue?

And my question was about how you felt about how I responded to Coop. You then voted for me without a reason.
Click to expand...

I’m so confused with you wording... what are you trying to ask in the first question?

And I didnt see the coop things so let me go find that?

And PS i gave a reason just cause you dont like it doesn’t mean I didnt give one 🙂
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (OPEN)
2 3
Replies
146
Views
6K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
supershorty
Here It GGOATS Again (GGOATS ThWWee) - Sign Up Thread - Sign Ups CLOSED
2
Replies
68
Views
3K
SARdoghandler
SARdoghandler
SportPonies
Noob WW Game 2023 Sign Ups OPEN!
Replies
40
Views
2K
SportPonies
SportPonies
kaydubs
WW sign ups April 2024
Replies
47
Views
2K
kaydubs
kaydubs
Top