Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
bryndiana.jones said:
ISOed Allie and she seems like her normal self to me (in my experience). She was not very present on D1, but she has been more so (and contributing pretty well) since then. I can post all of what I ISOed and bolded if anyone would like that.
Click to expand...

Also, careful with ISO'ing. It's best used to find a particular post, and if you read the context. Sometimes it can reveal patterns, still, context is key.

Also, I sort hate the huge wall posts of quotes. Sometimes you need to string quotes together to a make a point.

If you have comments to make on bolded portions of someone's quotes, that's great.

Otherwise, I'm not loving the ISO quote fests. I want to see someone's response/analysis of someone elses posts.

Too much of this ISO and quote wall without substance is also pinging my radar. It smacks of wolf trying to contribute.
 
Crayola227 said:
None of this should have an impact on what affiliation you think she is.
Click to expand...
Not getting enough reads. The other thing only happened today so it’s not really overall
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Okay I'm on the road home again for 5 hours. Just a quick check in. Y'all WSU is an interesting school. Sorry everyone for losing my cool. Just hate being called a liar when like real life is needing my attention.

In lunch LIS
Lynch AM
Click to expand...

You are STILL putting words in my mouth. I did not call you a liar.

If you're referring to the "I'll be busy" thing - I didn't say you were lying. I said that sort of thing has to be discounted when it comes to evaluating someone's game play.

If you HONESTLY can't see the difference between me saying you're lying (which I didn't do) and me saying I'm ignoring your 'real life' claim because there's no way for me to validate it .... then I guess there's just no point in even talking.
 
Animal Midwife said:
...You literally went against your own reads list.
Click to expand...

Really? Seemed to me she called you sketchy/wolfy. You can't expect someone to vote for everyone they find sketchy, since they can only cast one vote.

Crayola227 said:
LIS vs noob is a common occurrence and isn't always clear if w/v vs w/v
Click to expand...

Maybe it's just w/v. ;-)

Stella Mudd said:

I'm sure you do, coming from the guy whose name acronym spells LeTits😛
Click to expand...

Coming from someone who has "Doctor's companion" next to their forum name.... 😛

Stella Mudd said:
Seriously, tho, from a veteran player can you help make sense of what was going on yesterday?
Click to expand...

No. It's your job to interpret it. Me interpreting it for you means that if you're a wolf you get to ride my coattails and if you're a villager you aren't puzzling it out for yourself and coming up with your own interpretation. Mine is probably not right (just statistically speaking) so I'd rather have you come to your own conclusions if you're village, and I'd rather not give you something to hide behind if you're wolf.

Stella Mudd said:
LIS, who besides noobs are on your radar?
Click to expand...

Nobody is really standing out to me right now. Primarily because everyone's play is pretty erratic. I'm not even all that sold on my current vote; I just don't have anything pulling me more strongly to another vote.

I am getting seriously tired of AM's constant questions without any evaluation/analysis, though, so I'm almost ready to move my vote there just to put that to rest.
 
(But for the moment I'm leaving my vote on Coffee. I think there's reason to be concerned that Coffee has a higher than normal chance of being a wolf based on gameplay, AND I'm getting super tired of Coffee distorting my words, which is sketchy in and of itself.)
 
Stella Mudd said:
Ok, please explain how this logic is working and not wolfy?
Click to expand...

Beats me.

What I learned last game is that BJ's style (as much as she has one, for a n00b) makes me misread her. I tunneled her last game and she turned up village. So I'm trying to be more ......... reluctant to tunnel her this game.
 
Day 3 Killing My Darlings Tallies Unofficial

coffee (3) - LIS, MJ, AM
LIS (1) - coffee
BJ (2) - Haxx, Allie
AM (4) - coop, mixy, YK, Coffee
YK (1) - Cray
Coop (1) - genny
MJ - (1) Brindi

Deadline 10pm EST -> in ~30 min

@Stella Mudd need a vote!
 
Day 3 Killing My Darlings Tallies

coffee (3) - LIS, MJ, AM
LIS (0) - coffee
BJ (2) - Haxx, allie
AM (4) - coop, mixy, kal, coffee?
kal (1) - cray
coop (1) - genny
MJ (1) - bj

@Animal Midwife You are winning!

12/14 votes
Deadline 10pm EST -> in ~30 minutes

Not voting:

6. @Stella Mudd
7. @SnowshoeDog143


Content Posts
If you are being tagged below you have not met the content post minimum for today

1. Animal Midwife - 21
4. BJ - 10
5. youngkal - 18
6. Coopah - 13
7. Crayola227 - 16
8. Stella Mudd - 3
9. @SnowshoeDog143
10. allie - 5
11. Mad Jack - 3
12. LetItSnow - 20
13. genny - 7
14. MixedAnimals77 - 5
16. CoffeeQuestionMark - 9
17. Haxx - 4

AM Question Quest Tally - 16
 
Well. As much as I'd prefer to lynch Coffee.... can't say I'm sad to see AM go down with all this pestering questions-with-no-explanations.

Didn't like it when STL did it, either.

But, STL made it pretty effective. So there's that.
 
Hey guys, so I'm getting a sub after this lynch, but so you have thoughts from me:

I re-read D1 and Am gets village points for first post. Bryndy I like her vote, but haxx had a good point about her overexplaining may be due to wolfyness. YK had weak reasoning for staying on the bryn lynch and kara was really pushing for her and she's now dead. Cray is reading village and she's reading coop as village so since early game coop is always sketch for me, I'll go with that. Stella had a village swap to save coop just because she was her manator. Allie seemed like herself. Genny seemed like herself, but she also pointed things out that had already been pointed out before. Mixy was suspicious of MJ after only one post. Coffee just sounds like a normal noob. Hax thought LIS was "playing normal so not sketchy" which is weird 1. from D1 analysis only and 2. he plays the same meta no matter his affiliation so playing normal is not an indication of wolfyness or not.
 
Crayola227 said:
Also, careful with ISO'ing. It's best used to find a particular post, and if you read the context. Sometimes it can reveal patterns, still, context is key.

Also, I sort hate the huge wall posts of quotes. Sometimes you need to string quotes together to a make a point.

If you have comments to make on bolded portions of someone's quotes, that's great.

Otherwise, I'm not loving the ISO quote fests. I want to see someone's response/analysis of someone elses posts.

Too much of this ISO and quote wall without substance is also pinging my radar. It smacks of wolf trying to contribute.
Click to expand...
I'm not the best at picking up inconsistencies when they happen, so I'm trying this ISO thing to see if that helps me, and I'm largely looking for the types of comments people are making (content/no content, etc), but noted
 
Crayola227 said:
Really not loving this AM lynch! Again.

I may be tunneling her as village, and maybe I'm just fighting the mob too much.
Click to expand...

Thank you for not saying "AHHhahahahahahahahaha I TOLD YOU ALL AM WAS VILLAGE" before the lynch results are actually out.

(No, seriously.)
 
Stella Mudd said:




Ok, please explain how this logic is working and not wolfy?
Click to expand...
Explain how what isn't wolfy? I was trying to get you to talk, voting for you didn't really go the way I wanted it to, meaning it didn't get you to add to the thread. As for me posting later in the day...I already explained that I work, so you can believe me or not, but you also show up towards the end of the day (right before lynch close), so I don't see how that's any more wolfy than what you're doing.
 
I forgot MJ, who didn't give much so neutral, and LIS who was slightly sketchy for a couple reasons, but all I have is that he said he would probably lynch coffee over a comment that I didn't think was something he was and I was tinfoil hatting he was trying to sound like what he did when he put in the first YK vote last game (not great reasoning I realize and probably doesn't make sense to most people)
 
I'm thinking of switching to BJ just because my YK vote isn't going to get anywhere today, and I'd rather preservate AM while taking down another one of my top suspects (assuming that someone else may end up switching there too). BJ has just really dug a hole for herself.

But maybe it's better to crack the AM egg which seems inevitable, and give BJ another day to prove more or less wolfy.

But I don't know why we don't give AM also another day to prove her colors.

Grump grump.
 
LetItSnow said:
Beats me.

What I learned last game is that BJ's style (as much as she has one, for a n00b) makes me misread her. I tunneled her last game and she turned up village. So I'm trying to be more ......... reluctant to tunnel her this game.
Click to expand...
*shrugs* I'm not really sure why my "style" sends up flags for people, I'm just playing as best as I know how.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
I forgot MJ, who didn't give much so neutral, and LIS who was slightly sketchy for a couple reasons, but all I have is that he said he would probably lynch coffee over a comment that I didn't think was something he was and I was tinfoil hatting he was trying to sound like what he did when he put in the first YK vote last game (not great reasoning I realize and probably doesn't make sense to most people)
Click to expand...

I'd reply to this, but I have absolutely no idea what it's saying.
 
Crayola227 said:
Really not loving this AM lynch! Again.

I may be tunneling her as village, and maybe I'm just fighting the mob too much.
Click to expand...
I second this, but I also feel like Coffee might just be a feisty noob villager, so I don't feel like I should waffle onto her and cause a tie.
 
bryndiana.jones said:
Explain how what isn't wolfy? I was trying to get you to talk, voting for you didn't really go the way I wanted it to, meaning it didn't get you to add to the thread. As for me posting later in the day...I already explained that I work, so you can believe me or not, but you also show up towards the end of the day (right before lynch close), so I don't see how that's any more wolfy than what you're doing.
Click to expand...

I will jump in here, even if it's bad form, because I have taken issue with you and found you wolfy. You called Stella out for being quiet at 9 am PST D1. Even at noon EST that's ridic.

It's possible that the whole thing was just poorly handled, a pressure D1 lynch vote with poor reasoning and overjustification, but it didn't look good, I can see why someone doesn't like getting called out for near-deadline play (especially PST-ers) when you also do that.

I'm not calling it wolfy in you or in Stella. And hypocrisy on v vs v gameplay criticism abounds.

My issue with you are toher things mostly.
 
D2: Allie posting more content then normal and not a huge fan of most of her conclusions/reasoning, MJ role hunting for the blocker? But then allie votes for mj. Mixy is sounding sketch, but I heard she's not around anymore so not voting there tonight. I don't know why everyone is suspicious of AM, she's actually sounding like her village self now.
 
lynch haxx

for now. But I don't know what the tally is at.. haven't gotten there yet.
 
Crayola227 said:
I will jump in here, even if it's bad form, because I have taken issue with you and found you wolfy. You called Stella out for being quiet at 9 am PST D1. Even at noon EST that's ridic.

It's possible that the whole thing was just poorly handled, a pressure D1 lynch vote with poor reasoning and overjustification, but it didn't look good, I can see why someone doesn't like getting called out for near-deadline play (especially PST-ers) when you also do that.

I'm not calling it wolfy in you or in Stella. And hypocrisy on v vs v gameplay criticism abounds.

My issue with you are toher things mostly.
Click to expand...
She has been a historically quiet player, so I wanted to start out by putting some pressure there. I don't see how that's any worse than a joke vote on D1, I was just trying to get her to participate.
 
Crayola227 said:
I'm thinking of switching to BJ just because my YK vote isn't going to get anywhere today, and I'd rather preservate AM while taking down another one of my top suspects (assuming that someone else may end up switching there too). BJ has just really dug a hole for herself.

But maybe it's better to crack the AM egg which seems inevitable, and give BJ another day to prove more or less wolfy.

But I don't know why we don't give AM also another day to prove her colors.

Grump grump.
Click to expand...

Because we can’t give everyone another day silly, then we’d never get anywhere!
 
Cray i was told to vote what you feel cause then it’s out there even if it’s not doing anything, do you disagree with this?
 
D3: people think allie is being quieter while I think she's talking more. Don't know what to make of coffee/LIS this morning. I don't think a noob wolf would usually be that gutsy to try to twist someone's words. YK trying to read into kara's votes like the reason she was killed was because her thoughts were good (but also doesn't quote kara, just states her thoughts - wolfy thing to do). I actually like mj's reasons for his vote for coffee.
 
youngkal said:
Cray i was told to vote what you feel cause then it’s out there even if it’s not doing anything, do you disagree with this?
Click to expand...
Not that i want you to stay on my lynch it’s just the second time I’ve seen you do this so I’m curious. Is it just different play styles?
 
Crayola227 said:
I'm thinking of switching to BJ just because my YK vote isn't going to get anywhere today, and I'd rather preservate AM while taking down another one of my top suspects (assuming that someone else may end up switching there too). BJ has just really dug a hole for herself.

But maybe it's better to crack the AM egg which seems inevitable, and give BJ another day to prove more or less wolfy.

But I don't know why we don't give AM also another day to prove her colors.

Grump grump.
Click to expand...
Jk nevermind
 
Crayola227 said:
I don't love the Coffee vote, and I'm not sure about your noob tunneling, either. Hard to know your affiliation in these cases

I have higher suspects, they read as noob ? to me
Click to expand...

It is not hard to know my affiliation - I'm always in favor of killing everyone.

I get you have higher suspects - but those votes aren't going anywhere. Whereas you might have a chance to preserve AM, which seems to be a priority to you. Be practical, here.
 
LetItSnow said:
It is not hard to know my affiliation - I'm always in favor of killing everyone.

I get you have higher suspects - but those votes aren't going anywhere. Whereas you might have a chance to preserve AM, which seems to be a priority to you. Be practical, here.
Click to expand...

yes, but doesn't my brindi vote cinch her and save AM? if I can get my higher suspicion, I will go for that
 
Alright then, if that's how this is going to go. I would switch my vote to AM for self prez, but even if I do you all probably wouldn't let me live for long. I'm the village seer, so here's the information I have gotten so far.

Haxx- village
AM- village

Would post the lynch tallies with colors but....it's not copying correctly. Happy hunting!
 
Crayola227 said:
yes, but doesn't my brindi vote cinch her and save AM? if I can get my higher suspicion, I will go for that
Click to expand...

Oh.... I thought AM/Coffee were the two leading candidates. I haven't seen an actual tally in a while. If BJ has snuck up there, fine, fair, I get why you won't move.

But if it's still an AM/Coffee shootout, you not moving to Coffee is irrational and therefore sketchy because it would mean you aren't as interested in protecting AM as you say you are.

I guess I need to see a tally to know which it is?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
250
Views
17K
supershorty
supershorty
WildZoo
Supernatural WW Shenanigans Part 5 Sign Ups [OPEN] - Game Start Sept 12th (tentative)
5 6 7 8 9
Replies
412
Views
23K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
110 111 112 113 114
Replies
6K
Views
60K
Lissarae06
Lissarae06
supershorty
Here It GGOATS Again (GGOATS ThWWee) - Sign Up Thread - Sign Ups CLOSED
2
Replies
68
Views
3K
SARdoghandler
SARdoghandler
Top