Noobs...in SPAAAAACE - 5th Annual Noob WW Game

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I'm scanning posts in between work. I will be able to post a list of comments, hopefully within the next hour because I'm on-call for work.

Oh cool paranoia settled

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

I think they focused so hard on making me look like chaos because they knew claiming I am a wolf wouldn’t fly since I’ve killed a wolf and voted to lynch them. But for some reason they haven’t night killed me and I think they need to get me lynched in order to get me killed.

 

[Matthew9Thirtyfive]

Contingency Lynch Killer

I’m not totally convinced but I’m about to go on a date with my wife and might not make the deadline. I trust soggy and coffee though.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I think they focused so hard on making me look like chaos because they knew claiming I am a wolf wouldn’t fly since I’ve killed a wolf and voted to lynch them. But for some reason they haven’t night killed me and I think they need to get me lynched in order to get me killed.

That doesn't make sense unless you ARE chaos or have 2 abilities

 

[Barkley13]

My only problem with the killer lynch is that there were 3 wolves on it day 1. For now I’m going to

Lynch MSU

Based on past suspicions and hope to get on later to look at things more

 

[SkiOtter]

Contingency Lynch

*******
You don’t need to say contingency when we’re in the regular day cycle. That’s only for votes during the night cycle that you want for the next day.
*******

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Yeah shelter and em are a little strange given that they apparently have been post restricted for like 2 full day cycles now. That seems strange. A bunch of people are being very quiet, which makes me suspicious because I feel like they are being quiet since they can’t collude in the group chat.

Did your item specifically limit them to not being able to talk in group chat? Or can they not say anything on the thread AT ALL? That could be a reason for all the silence as well.

I'm not sure we have heard from @emlady09 at all today. And we haven't heard from @Dinashadow or @MSUcvmHOPE since this morning.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial Manator Tally Takeover D6 Lynch Tally

Dr. S () -
killer (3) - koffee, zigzag, Matt
barkley (1) - shelter
MSU (1) - Barkley

5/10

Role call: emmy, Dina, Dr. S, MSU, killer

Deadline 10pm est (~3 hours)

 

[Dinashadow]

Do we think chaos is causing the infections? I assumed it was wolves but this is my first game and I don't completely understand the chaos roles?

I find it really strange that shelter and em have mostly been silent and today shelter is on limited post and em still hasn't said a word.

I don't have strong wolfy readings on anyone, except I really think Matt has the village's best interests and literally every single wolf has gone after him. Could he still be chaos? Possibly, especially considering we don't know what the win condition is.

Going to look back through the posts for today and try to figure out who might be a wolf.

 

[MSUcvmHOPE]

Can @Dinashadow or @Doctor-S say what they were trying to act on me with last night with? My ability only tells me who, but not what they were trying to do.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

unlynch killer Lynch emmy

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Do we think chaos is causing the infections? I assumed it was wolves but this is my first game and I don't completely understand the chaos roles?

I find it really strange that shelter and em have mostly been silent and today shelter is on limited post and em still hasn't said a word.

I don't have strong wolfy readings on anyone, except I really think Matt has the village's best interests and literally every single wolf has gone after him. Could he still be chaos? Possibly, especially considering we don't know what the win condition is.

Going to look back through the posts for today and try to figure out who might be a wolf.

I think at this point it is chaos, not wolves. I could be wrong but it seems to be adding a lot of confusion.

I find it extremely odd that shelter "vouched" for emmy and yet we have heard nothing about this, and no one has elaborated on the meaning of it. It seems to be highly suspect to me at this point and points toward chaos. I am beginning to wonder if the OG chaos converted people, or if this is a thing.

So this is her response saying they can both still talk to one another. Yet we have heard nothing from shelter about this.

I can't say that they are both village per say, but my ability let's me know who tries to act on me at night, and I'm able to avoid most night actions at the same time. They both tried to do something with me last night, and since another villager died last night, unless either of them are able to perform two actions a night, I'm inclined to think neither of them could have caused the kill and thusly unlikely wolf.

Sent from my Pixel 2 using SDN mobile

Hmmm... I am wondering what they tried to do as well. Were they acting together or independently? or do you know?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

unlynch killer Lynch emmy

I could go here too.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

I could go here too.

I'm a bit torn. I really want to hear from the people who aren't talking. It's making me suspicious. I could see killer as the original chaos who converted people but idk. Trying to figure out more info about chaos...

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I'm a bit torn. I really want to hear from the people who aren't talking. It's making me suspicious. I could see killer as the original chaos who converted people but idk. Trying to figure out more info about chaos...

I'd like to hear from @Barkley13 about it since she saw inside shelter's pm

 

[Dinashadow]

Can @Dinashadow or @Doctor-S say what they were trying to act on me with last night with? My ability only tells me who, but not what they were trying to do.

I used my night action on you because I'm still not sure if you're a wolf. How important is it for me to share my night action was? I would happily share if I knew there weren't wolves reading this too.

I'm really torn on shelter and em. I could also go for an em vote tonight but I'm still not sure. Maybe shelter could at least give an explaination

 

[Barkley13]

I'd like to hear from @Barkley13 about it since she saw inside shelter's pm

I was just told that I didn’t see anything. That’s why I wasn’t alarmed or anything because it didn’t really sway me either way

 

[MSUcvmHOPE]

I used my night action on you because I'm still not sure if you're a wolf. How important is it for me to share my night action was? I would happily share if I knew there weren't wolves reading this too.

I'm really torn on shelter and em. I could also go for an em vote tonight but I'm still not sure. Maybe shelter could at least give an explaination

I don't want to give you away I'm just curious why you both would choose to do something. Granted if your actions could help you try and figure out my affiliation I can understand that. Couldn't remember if either had previously outed your abilities yet.

Have people that have been infected or restricted been able to chat in the PMs? Obviously we know shelter and em can from their gif responses, but have others been able to speak to the affected?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I was just told that I didn’t see anything. That’s why I wasn’t alarmed or anything because it didn’t really sway me either way

Hmm that's not really telling one way or another.

 

[Doctor-S]

Can @Dinashadow or @Doctor-S say what they were trying to act on me with last night with? My ability only tells me who, but not what they were trying to do.

I couldn't do anything to you at all because you “zoomed away” out of my reach. However, at the same time, I also had the “distinct feeling” that someone was following me.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I don't want to give you away I'm just curious why you both would choose to do something. Granted if your actions could help you try and figure out my affiliation I can understand that. Couldn't remember if either had previously outed your abilities yet.

Have people that have been infected or restricted been able to chat in the PMs? Obviously we know shelter and em can from their gif responses, but have others been able to speak to the affected?

I played hangman with WZ while I was silenced.

 

[MSUcvmHOPE]

I couldn't do anything to you at all because you “zoomed away” out of my reach. However, at the same time, I also had the “distinct feeling” that someone was following me.

That's weird. Yeah I was "too quick" for you guys, kinda wish I could decide what actions I avoid. But I didn't have anything else in my message after that. Do you think that's because Dina also tried to act on me? @Dinashadow did you have anything more to your message than that I got away?

 

[MSUcvmHOPE]

I played hangman with WZ while I was silenced.

I don't know if that counts exactly. Lol I meant player to player. But good to know. 😛

 

[Dinashadow]

The infection doesn't seem consistent. Sometimes people it seems people can use gifs, sometimes they can't talk, sometimes they can't vote.

 

[Dinashadow]

That's weird. Yeah I was "too quick" for you guys, kinda wish I could decide what actions I avoid. But I didn't have anything else in my message after that. Do you think that's because Dina also tried to act on me? @Dinashadow did you have anything more to your message than that I got away?

WZ said that you sped away from me so basically the same as DrS

 

[MSUcvmHOPE]

The infection doesn't seem consistent. Sometimes people it seems people can use gifs, sometimes they can't talk, sometimes they can't vote.

You know what I just thought of. What if the way it infects people is related to their affiliation??
Need to look back and see if there are any consistencies.

 

[MSUcvmHOPE]

WZ said that you sped away from me so basically the same as DrS

Ok so maybe Drs added part was because you were trying right after? Otherwise idk what his extra bit could mean.

 

[Dinashadow]

Lynch Emmy

For now at least. I'm hoping Shelter might be able to explain some things.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

You know what I just thought of. What if the way it infects people is related to their affiliation??
Need to look back and see if there are any consistencies.

Good thought but unfortunately I dont think it is an accurate tell because the only wolf that was restricted by the microbe was picklegurl and I highly suspect she was lying about certain aspects of how it worked.

 

[Dinashadow]

Ok so maybe Drs added part was because you were trying right after? Otherwise idk what his extra bit could mean.

Yeah I didn't have any feelings of being followed. My guess was somebody was using an ability on DrS totally separate from yours

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

The infection doesn't seem consistent. Sometimes people it seems people can use gifs, sometimes they can't talk, sometimes they can't vote.

I think you are getting confused here.

People haven't been able to vote because there was attempted conversion on them. I haven't seen someone claim to not be able to vote while infected. I have no idea why emmy and shelter decided not to vote or if they were stopped from doing so. Did they say?

I have not seen someone claim the inability to talk, besides Coffee, which was related to her ability.

 

[Karabiner13]

Unofficial Manator Tally Takeover D6 Lynch Tally

Dr. S () -
killer (2) - koffee, Matt
barkley (1) - shelter
MSU (1) - Barkley
emmy (2) - zigzag, dinamite

6/10

Tie! 😏 😏

Role call: emmy, Dr. S, MSU, killer

Deadline 10pm est (~2 hours)

 

[Dinashadow]

I think you are getting confused here.

People haven't been able to vote because there was attempted conversion on them. I haven't seen someone claim to not be able to vote while infected. I have no idea why emmy and shelter decided not to vote or if they were stopped from doing so. Did they say?

I have not seen someone claim the inability to talk, besides Coffee, which was related to her ability.

You're right we don't know why shelter and emmy aren't voting, I just assumed it was infection, though is it possible one of them was converted and it would convert the other? Or are we pretty sure there was only one conversion and that was stagg because of the transmission?

 

[MSUcvmHOPE]

Good thought but unfortunately I dont think it is an accurate tell because the only wolf that was restricted by the microbe was picklegurl and I highly suspect she was lying about certain aspects of how it worked.

True but she didn't have to only speak in memes. I just thought I remembered the other people that were village that were infected seemed to be allowed to vote and speak in non-sense, while (I'm guessing that 'lovers' like supposed Em and Shelter are neutral?) seem to only be able to meme it up. So it seemed like there were similarities and differences. But yes now that I think about it if it was just Pickle infected I'd say nothing she said was legitimate/usable...

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

True but she didn't have to only speak in memes. I just thought I remembered the other people that were village that were infected seemed to be allowed to vote and speak in non-sense, while (I'm guessing that 'lovers' like supposed Em and Shelter are neutral?) seem to only be able to meme it up. So it seemed like there were similarities and differences. But yes now that I think about it if it was just Pickle infected I'd say nothing she said was legitimate/usable...

I had the microbe, and I know how it works (unless it has changed). I have to say, shelter and emmy could've been 1000% more useful than they were. It didn't really seem like they were trying to say anything at all. Wasn't very helpful imo. I also called pickles out for claiming the microbe was working differently on her than on me. I'm wondering if that is the case with them as well.

 

[Barkley13]

I have no problems with this lynch and I want to change before my phone dies

Unlynch MSU

Lynch emmy

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Unlynch killer
Lynch emmy

 

[sheltermed]

3

As far as I know, only I was infected on d5. I do not believe em was. However, both of us share something in common and thus both of us were post restricted, for reasons outside of the infection. Neither of us could vote on d5 due to the restriction. -I- was post restricted because of our shared reason AND because of the infection. Does that make sense?

Also, em was allotted 5 posts today as well. I am not sure why we haven't heard from her. If it means anything, I haven't heard anything from her today either.

I have 2 more posts allowed for today, so if anyone has specific questions please ask them wisely.

 

[Karabiner13]

Unofficial Manator Tally Takeover D6 Lynch Tally

Dr. S () -
killer (1) - Matt
barkley (1) - shelter
MSU () -
emmy (4) - zigzag, dinamite, barkley, koffee

6/10

@emlady09 you are in the lead!

Role call: emmy, Dr. S, MSU, killer

Deadline 10pm est (~1.5 hours)

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

3

As far as I know, only I was infected on d5. 1. I do not believe em was. However, 2. both of us share something in common and thus 3. both of us were post restricted, for reasons outside of the infection. 4. Neither of us could vote on d5 due to the restriction. -I- was post restricted because of our shared reason AND because of the infection. 5. Does that make sense?

6. Also, em was allotted 5 posts today as well. I am not sure why we haven't heard from her. If it means anything, I haven't heard anything from her today either.

I have 2 more posts allowed for today, so if anyone has specific questions please ask them wisely.

1. Then why would she say she was infected and act like it?
2. You're really going to have to elaborate on this or she is going to get lynched (and possibly you next)
3. what is this new post restriction then?
4. what restriction?
5. No
6. How do you know this?

Feel free to not answer these until other people have posted as well, I wouldn't want you to run out of posts 😉
Make sure to vote on your 5th post

 

[emlady09]

I've been at work all day today. Extremely busy that I was even able to skim the threads...that being said I have 5 post today only. As Shelter just mentioned we both were put on "post restrictions" due to what we have been trying to do over the past two days to help US (THE VILLAGE).

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I've been at work all day today. Extremely busy that I was even able to skim the threads...that being said I have 5 post today only. As Shelter just mentioned we both were put on "post restrictions" due to what we have been trying to do over the past two days to help US (THE VILLAGE).

Your post restrictions are a RESULT of what you are doing?

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Your post restrictions are a RESULT of what you are doing?

They haven't claimed they have done anything to help us today... interesting it is just getting brought up. And now they are saying they are post restricted due to their actions, which seems like a weird mimic of your ability

 

[emlady09]

Post #2

I never claimed to be "infected," it was assumed by everyone. Granted I can see why since Shelter was infected by the microbe she got double post restrictions, per say. I did NOT get infected by the microbe, yet had the same post restrictions for the first day our actions were working. (only talk in images or gifs, cannot not like posts or vote). Day two of our restrictions were only allowed to have 5 posts, to include lynch votes. Once those 5 are used we can no longer change our votes. If all goes as planned our action will be highly beneficial for us as a village.

@CoffeeQuestionMark, my post restrictions are a result of what (shelter and I) are trying to accomplish. Though someone did hit her with the microbe the first day, but we have been able to PM with no interruption.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Post #2

I never claimed to be "infected," it was assumed by everyone. Granted I can see why since Shelter was infected by the microbe she got double post restrictions, per say. I did NOT get infected by the microbe, yet had the same post restrictions for the first day our actions were working. (only talk in images or gifs, cannot not like posts or vote). Day two of our restrictions were only allowed to have 5 posts, to include lynch votes. Once those 5 are used we can no longer change our votes. If all goes as planned our action will be highly beneficial for us as a village.

@CoffeeQuestionMark, my post restrictions are a result of what (shelter and I) are trying to accomplish. Though someone did hit her with the microbe the first day, but we have been able to PM with no interruption.

This sounds INCREDIBLY sketchy

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

I couldn't do anything to you at all because you “zoomed away” out of my reach. However, at the same time, I also had the “distinct feeling” that someone was following me.

What were you trying to do to MSU?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

IF this is really supposed to be helping village, why didn't your post restrictions start earlier? This is really late in the game

 

[Doctor-S]

After scanning thread, here are my thoughts and leans right now:

1. Villager.

Dolphin - posting, reviewing, and discussing other players’ posts; received item to monitor someone’s role PM (showed shelter infected with microbe confirmed) and dolphin was also infected with microbe. Mod-confirmed villager due to NK on N5.

Ziggy - posts and feels, actively searching for wolves; consistently contributing to discussion about different players on thread and calling them out; methodical questioning of players who seem sketchy, infected by microbe.

Shelter - analyzing posts, actively searching for wolves; revealed close gal-pal connection to emlady; infected by microbe; shelter and emlady did not vote on D5, may have been silenced/post-restricted, and unable to vote on D5. Said it was unlikely Barkley received an upgrade from Dolphin (agree with Shelter for the same reason).

Coffee - mod-confirmed as villager healer on D5; role revealed.

2. Neutral or Village Affiliation, or NAI, or Whatever.

Emlady - shelter’s friend/gal-pal/soulmate, close connection; infected by microbe; shelter and emlady did not vote on D5, may have been silenced/post-restricted and unable to vote on D5. Neutral, village … or NAI? But wondering *why* she has been absent from thread today and non-responsive. Waiting to hear from her so I will tag her right now @emlady09.

MSU - process of elimination based on review and analyses set forth above, not analyzing game play; didn't seem to be actively searching for wolves. Believe she has ability she claimed because she revealed ability on thread, much more conversant in thread in past few days. Village or neutral.

killer - 3 wolves (mutt, pickle and grebes) joined the line to lynch killer on D1 because grebes (wolf) was in danger of being lynched on D1. Mutt, pickle and grebes all changed their votes to lynch killer to make sure that killer received more lynch votes than grebes, so grebes could stay in game. It didn’t make sense for 3 wolves to lynch killer if killer was already a wolf because killer could be NK’d by them. Otherwise, killer has been pretty quiet even though she is staying near her phone and could be more active in game (even claimed she had an "argument" with husband about how she has been "watching phone"); seems to be under the radar unless prodded by other players; doesn't seem inclined to search for wolves or non-villagers. Leaning neutral or NAI,or whatever? Still wondering about @killerleaf 's affiliation and feels so will tag her right now to see if she can contribute to the thread (because she only seems to respond to questions if she is tagged or pressed).

Dina - neutral or NAI. She has been absent for long periods of time in game and that worried me. Really wanted to hear more from her since she had been absent from thread for while and wasn't engaging in much conversation to find wolfy players until now. Just saying @Dinashadow

3. Converted Wolf.

Stagg - questioning different players and consistently analyzing posts, didn't want Coffee or M935 lynched; actively looking for wolves, non-villager and chaos; pushed players to clear-up some inconsistencies which I also thought were inconsistencies related to items. Forced to reveal due to tied lynch vote on D5 for self-prez. Confirmed village-welder, converted to wolf ability seer, mimic. Stagg was searching for CHAOS.

4. Chaos or some Other Wolfy Role.

Barkley - active on today's thread, posting and engaging in discussions; voted to lynch mutt (wolf) on D4; claimed role as vigilante who shot grebes (wolf).

Now, *doubting* her claim that she received "upgrade" from Dolphin before Dolphin died because Dolphin immediately voted to lynch Barkley on Tuesday morning and never changed her lynch vote until the close of D5. Ultimately, there was a lynch-tie between Barkley and Stagg; and Dolphin did not go after Stagg to break the lynch-tie. However, Stagg changed his lynch vote from M935 to Barkley for "self-preservation." In this game, Stagg seemed to be searching for chaos because Stagg wanted to win the game and not let Chaos win. Just saying.

Matt935 – lots of conversation but can be confusing, can be distracting; sometimes seems funny, and sometimes seems angry; Stagg (converted wolf) seemed to be tunneling on M935 because Stagg really wanted to find Chaos and Stagg didn’t seem to be searching for wolves anymore because he really wanted to find chaos. My feels. Chaos role unless other villagers strongly disagree? Just my thoughts. Please feel free to share.

 

[sheltermed]

4

1. Then why would she say she was infected and act like it?
2. You're really going to have to elaborate on this or she is going to get lynched (and possibly you next)
3. what is this new post restriction then?
4. what restriction?
5. No
6. How do you know this?

1. When and where did she say she was infected
2. We share an ability that takes 2 days that is presently pending and its results should appear either tonight, n6, or tomorrow, d7
3. We share a PM and were told by mods that today, d6, we were given 5 posts each. Yesterday, d5, we were only allowed to post in gifs and images. In addition to this, I was informed of being infected by a microbe in my personal mod PM
4. The restriction placed on us due to the use of our ability
5. sorry I guess
6. See #3

I already voted and I'm keeping my vote there.

Forcing us to reveal this much likely puts one or both of us in jeopardy for tonight's night cycle, but since our ability takes 2 day cycles I believe it will be completed anyway. I am willing to take the hit for the village if it means allowing our ability to complete.

IF this is really supposed to be helping village, why didn't your post restrictions start earlier? This is really late in the game

we didn't initiate use of the ability until n4

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Matt935 – lots of conversation but can be confusing, can be distracting; sometimes seems funny, and sometimes seems angry; Stagg (converted wolf) seemed to be tunneling on M935 because Stagg really wanted to find Chaos and Stagg didn’t seem to be searching for wolves anymore because he really wanted to find chaos. My feels. Chaos role unless other villagers strongly disagree? Just my thoughts. Please feel free to share.

This is bothering me too. Matt has been 100% playing for village but mutts and Stagg were both claiming he is chaos.

The only reason I'm suspicious is that they seemed so fixated on him, Stagg even tried to shoot him which resulted in his death

Matt has claimed he cant be night killed.

Its just a little weird. Like did the wolves have proof? But uf they did, I think they would've said something.

So, I'm trying not to fixate on it too much.