But again when people tell what adcoms say or adcom members like NJBMD says stuff, they don't reveal what school it is coming from. So what may be true of one school is not true of others yet when they post they post such that it is true of every school in the nation and not just their state schools or their particular schools.
People want to maintain their anonymity but want to share info. but you can't do both always. You need to sometimes give the info in full with regards to the school that you are hearing such from because that school might do things differently then some other shcool. You also can't say just because you heard something is done at one school one way that all schools must do things that way because that is false.
As another example of this,
LizzyM always says to maintain short terse bullet points for AMCAS and that's how her school might like it but USF's adcom members told me to state what I learned and why I did it and what I did not just short terse statements of what I did.
In that respect, I love talking to REL because he has been upfront about where he was an adcom at and where he currently is an adcom at from the very beginning of his posting on here. So you know when he gives his perspectives it is as a Fl. state school adcom vs. say Harvard or a top tier university with very different ways of doing things. Cuz a school like Harvard, for instance, might not take seriously a nontrad postbac who might have had done bad in the past but now doing well but a school like Fl. state schools might overlook a person's past if they've shown that the present is better reflection of their capability.
The problem I have with almost every other adcom member on here is that they want to give their two cents but they don't even want to clarify whether they are at a top 10-20 ranked school vs. state school or what state they are in so people understand their perspective better.
Perspective of a harvard admissions officer is just not the same as some random state school. Perspective of a rural med focused school is just not the same as a school gearing more towards research. See what I mean??