While it is evident the OP is straddling the line of morality (when it comes to hiding the truth), I doubt you are in a position to judge him/her. I am sure there are many issues, on which your own character is predicated, that are questionable at best. I suggest you keep the judgment to a minimum and worry about positioning yourself to become a physician.
I love premeds who stand on their pedestal and preach the code of morality/ethics to others and fail to see their own shortcomings. Good job potential future colleague...good job!!!
This is an interesting post. You say the OP is "straddling the line of morality." If the deliberate omission of previous college coursework, because it will lower the GPA, doesn't cross the line of morality, I'm not sure what does. This is not about my personal moral code. Frankly, I think it's unfair to count grades for college classes taken in high school at all. However, if the coursework has to be disclosed, it has to be disclosed, no matter what the OP, or I, think.
Ethics are a big part of practicing any profession, especially medicine. Do we want doctors to follow the rules, or do we want them to only follow the rules they agree with? Yes, I will "judge" the OP, not by my personal ethical standards, but by the medical profession's ethical standards.
I'm not sure why, or on what basis, you would imply that my character is "questionable at best." If you are saying I'm not perfect, well, no one is.
Also, I am not a typical premed. I am a 15 year attorney considering a career change. Despite some popular opinion to the contrary, most lawyers are very ethical. We are governed by a strict code of ethics. So I do, in fact, know a bit about the subject. I agree that in some situations there can be reasonable debate about whether conduct is ethical. In this case, though, the intentional failure to disclose college coursework is unethical by any objective standard.