Just finished COMLEX!!! So glad to have that behind me. Now for the dirty details.
I feel that the previous write ups about test experiences were similar to what I had today. Question stems were quite long but nothing too difficult. You really just have to get in that focused zone and not let anything break your concentration. There were also quite a bit of 1-2 sentence questions. I got a lot of first and second order questions that were amateur hour compared to what is seen on the USMLE.
My test tended to repeat the same concepts over and over again. I swear I got the same question 4 times but worded differently. I even had the same histo image in two different questions where the answers were obviously the same both times. This test had it's share of WTF questions. I particularly did not like the video questions where it showed a physician performing a treatment then asked you to give them the dysfunction being treated, but these were few and far between.
Heaviest tested topics on my test: Cardio, OMM, Neuro, Micro, and Respiratory.
Cardio: Extremely vague questions with little detail that required some leaps of faith.
OMM: Straightforward questions. I used Saverese and Kaplan Comlex Q bank to prepare and they didn't let me down.
Micro: Lots of classic buzzwords. Picmonic saved me. I had several questions that were nearly verbatim from the Kaplan Comlex Q bank.
Neuro: Mostly stuff that can be found in Saverese. Dermatomes, spinal root levels, viscerosomatics, etc.
Respiratory: Probably my toughest questions. I would know your chest Xray's and CT's cold.
I took Step 1 last week and did almost 2.5 passes through Uworld so to prepare for COMLEX I only read Saverese and and cherry picked through the Kaplan Q bank. I specifically did the Kaplan comlex bank and did all of their OMM, micro, and MSK questions. I didn't do COMBANK of COMQUEST so I can't speak to their effectiveness but I will say that I was VERY pleased with Kaplan's OMM an micro. There was hardly an OMM question I couldn't confidently answer and I'm definitely not the greatest at OMM. Kaplan asks weird questions like asking you to diagnose a parasite based off of some vague description of their eggs....... those won't show up on the exam, right?? Wrong, they're on their and Kaplan prepares you for them. I highly recommend only Kaplan for micro and OMM. Everything else is in Uworld. I think that's about all I got. Best of luck to you all!