Does anyone have any information that they're willing to share about West Virginia University OMFS Program...regarding scope, residents, attendings, call schedule, presence at the medical center etc....
thanks
thanks
Don't know anything personally, but this is about the only thread on SDN about the program. It is slanted to a one sided view of the program, so i am no way saying what is written is true or not.
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/showthread.php?t=638859&highlight=thomas+jefferson
Does anyone know which programs take non "in house" call? I just saw someone posted that at Tufts its not in house...any others anyone knows of?
Thanks
To begin let me introduce myself. I am a 1st year down in good old Shreveport. So if you have any questions about the program, or do not like what I am about to say, please feel free to PM me and we can talk about. I also want to add that I in no way feel the need to defend Dr.Ghali, Dr.Kim , or Dr. Palmieri (yes we have 3 full time attendings plus part time staff). Their individual records speak for themselves. But I will defend the reputation of my program from sad, disgruntled externs who would have just been better off keeping their opinions to themselves. But since you decided to bring this into a pubic forum and speak like you have any idea what is going on, you left yourself wide open for what is about to happen. Obviously from the huge numbers of program interviews you have been posting on this forum, things must be going great for you, so you dont need us anyway. So lets get started breaking down every false remark you made to give these people a real idea of how we do things in Shreveport:
-You feel bad for the intern based on race? The intern you speak has no need to hide behind the race card. He is a hard working SOB who is a good friend and a respected colleague of mine. He would be insulted if he knew you said such things. You should be ashamed of your self.
-Borderline too much trauma? We alternate facial trauma every other month with ENT. Now while we do see our fair share, I have never heard anybody in the program complain of too much surgical exposure to trauma. I think it a critical part of any OMFS program to provide a well rounded trauma experience. When it gets too much for me I will let you know. Apparently we roll a little harder here in the dirty south than at UMKC
-Dr.Ghali only operates at LSU on Wed mornings, usually a big neck whack and/or cranial vault reshaping. That is why you only saw him once. The other days he is either at the Feist or at his private clinic at Schumpert doing craniofacial/cancer/cosmetics/impant/what ever else he feels like. Externs do not get to go to his clinic, hence you did not see him. The man is also active in more committees than almost anyone else in the hospital. Another detail that obviously escaped you is that Ghali is not in the OR babying our upper levels. He is not neglecting them, but he expects them to operate without direct supervision all the the time because he trains surgeons who can act independently and not just stick holding monkeys who can do what their told.
-Back stabbing residents? I get along great with the entire team of residents. I hang out with my co residents all the time. Are you sure that maybe, I know this might sound crazy, but maybe they just didnt like you? Obviously from my posting you didnt win me over with your charming personality. I know you felt during your externship you had everything figured out, but you definitely missed out on the big picture when it came to us residents.
-Our 2 teeth only days as interns is our point and pull dentoalveolar clinic. Most programs have these days and whatever program you get into, god help them, will probably require you to do this. We are Oral Surgeons, we do take out teeth, that is kinda a big part of what we do. You also forgot to mention that we do run sedations on Mon and Fri mornings for 3rds and other things like arthocentesis. Let me add that as interns we get to run the sedations. Dr. Palmieri gives us the latitude to push what drugs we see fit and do the whole procedure ourselves. It truly is a great 1st year experience. We also have a day where we schedule bigger procedure like FMXs, big tori, biopsies and other time requiring procedures.
-Our patient population is gross? I am sorry things are not as up scale in Louisiana as they are in UMKC. I sorry that you feel working on a predominately low socioeconomic status African American (which is our average clinic patient) is beneath you.
-ortho?perio?proths? What the #$#@ are you talking about. I really dont even know what to say. Stupid is the only thing that comes to mind.
-Implant experience? Its funny that you say that. We just started offering implants at our LSU clinic with Dr.Palmieri and things are looking great. That being said we get most of our implant experience in Dr.Ghai/Dr.Kim private clinic, which is something you as a extern were not allowed to go to. Sure there are other places in the country that place more implants than we do, good for them. I personally dont lose any sleep over it.
-Residency positions gone before the interview? I had never even externed at Shreveport before I went there on the interview. I didnt back door my way. If you doubt my, or that of my co-residents ,qualifications I would be happy to compare.
-The hospital sucks? Its dirty, its a REAL hospital, grow up
-How do we rip it off and not finish it good . I am sorry. The more I read your post I am convinced you are truly a idiot. You think we just let mangled patients roam the streets of Shreveport? I will personally let Dr. Ghali/ Dr.Kim know what you think of their work.
-Ok Shreveport is not for you. My wife and I love it here. Housing is affordable are some great areas of town. If you looking for the big city life you need to go somewhere else, if you are looking for a awesome training experience in a town where you can get around and still have things to do, then Shreveport could work for you.
-Pts sometimes dont show up for procedures, big shocker. You were here 2 weeks, get over it.
-My friend told her friend who told my..... are we still in high school? So the chief at your program doesn't like one of my co-residents. Big deal. Who cares. That is hardly a legitimate critique.
-Part of our job as residents is to manage the cancer patients. Flap checks do get a little old, but they are a small part of what we do and I have learned more about medicine from treating these patients than from any other. I think is a worth while experience to get to interact with these patients.
-Again Dr.Ghali practices facial cosmetics galore at his PRIVATE clinic. Just come and look at our OR log.
After all this a quote comes to mind: It is better to be quiet and thought a fool than to open ones mouth and confirm it. Sadly this quote applies to you. I do not wish to start a endless online banter of why you do not like Shreveport with you. Just from now on do not speak of things with authority that you do not know anything about. Also another quote comes to mind, You do not spit on Supermans cape, you do not get into a knife fight with Zoro, and you do not %^%% with RedRaiderOMS!
So let me tell you about Banner. So much is unknown because they just started.
Program Name: Banner OMFS http://www.banneromfsresidency.com/
Program City: Phoenix, Glendale, Arizona
Length: 48mos (potential for back end MD,future integrated, chat with them if you want that)
Residents: 2 per year. 2010 is their first start year.
Program Director and Facts About Them: Dr. Buhrow - Presented himself as being in private practice his whole career and had the opportunity to pursue this career in academics and went for it.
Department Head and Facts: ''
Other Faculty and Facts: I don't remember their names, but as people, they are awesome. They are mostly young attendings. They are coming from Vandy, Christiana Care, and someplace in the midwest I think.
The names are Buhrow, Gillis, Sabol, and Surpure. Here is the PP website.
Describe the city(ies): Per everyone there, Phoenix is a very livable city. Traffic isn't too bad and weather is great sans May-Aug. Glendale is about 30 min away from Banner and is up and coming. The VA is about 5-10 minutes from Banner. There will be a lot of dento alveolar and implants here. There is a great in house lab here. There will be some traveling: Mostly from Banner/VA to the midwestern dental school.
Describe the Program in One Sentence: Fantastic Potential with Great People. I believe it will be very sought after.
Describe the facilities (hospital, dental school, med school, etc.): Banner hospital is a great hospital, on the small size physically but it seemed busy. It's nice. The OMFS has no competition really and the GS department is working hand in hand with Dr. Buhrow to make his program move forward.
Midwestern is the dental shool. This is going to be great private practice experience apparently. The OMFS clinic is being built to order. I believe they are starting ortho also so you'll get that exposure eventually. That place is for profit so I would expect the implants and 3rds numbers to be high. The campus is very nice and lots of money has been spent to attract students to pay insane tuition. Dental, DO, Chiro maybe, nursing stuff, etc.
VA - Normal VA exposure. Nice facility. Nice people. They said the staff isn't the 'usual lazy gov't workers' so that promises to be a enjoyable time. A couple other GPR residents I think were there...
Med School - If the option goes through, it's via University of Arizona and will be MD, not DO via Midwestern. Based out of Phoenix, not the Tucson main campus.
Adding: The dental school and Banner pretty much has given the program carte blanche on anything they need to start up. This will include iCat, software, etc. I believe this will be one of the cutting edge forfront programs in the next 5 years.
Describe the opportunities in the following areas of OMFS:
Anesthesia - Unknown. It's expected to be normal 4mo. They will be providing opportunities for sedation experience. The dental school will provide opportunities as well.
Implants - Unknown, likely at midwestern and VA for the first few years due to lack of dedicated Banner clinic at the moment
TMJ - Dr Buhrow's thing...so should be adequate
Ablative Cancer - ENT rotation only
Cancer/Trauma Reconstruction - Trauma recon only
Facial Cosmetics - Not a goal at this time. There are some Phx OMFS though that do cosmetics only and I'd expect them to be a potential opportunity. I disagree. Since one of the attending's did a fellowship in cosmetics I believe this will play a big part into your training. These procedures are of course economy driven and our current state might lead to less exposure.
Orthognathics - All the attendings do this in their private practice and will likely capture most of the phx gnathic market due to cost. Actually a lot of local OMFS guys have already agreed to bring their cases through the program giving the residents exposure. One of them was at my interview.
Dentoalveolar - Should be good
Trauma - Felt like it was going to be strong and building. One of the few providers in the area and now that residents are there, it should build. Everything that goes to Banner (A level I trauma hospital) that is above the neck would be called to OMFS. Plastics and ENT were kicked out of the hospital a while ago because of their attitudes.
Craniofacial - Not a goal
Didactics - Normal conf, sedation lectures, path time, etc. The schedule in the book they gave us included taking classes during your first year such as: statistics, advanced anatomy, etc. I don't know how much time you would have to devote to these, but they are there.
Describe the call schedule: It was unknown but for a few years I imagine the attendings will still be involved with Primary and Secondary call while the service builds up.
Stipend: Wasn't given to us...but I would expect $45k or so and that'll go well for Phoenix.
Describe the rotations (gen surg, neuro, anesth, ENT, PRS, etc.)
This is unknown at this time. They had a schedule and it's normal stuff. Everything is approved and setup. I think the services will be hesitent at first to have 'the dentists' on board. The GS time is going to be awesome. The attending interviewed us and he was great. He looked at us as one of his own and promises it'll be a tough X months. They also have a ton of GS simulation stations. One of them is a Wii!! And they do alot of research because of it. During GS they will make you play the Wii for two days and they had a lot of simulative laproscopic doodads in the hospital which were fun to work with. Eventually they want to take this tech further with endoscopic/lapro techniques for facial surgery (TMJ, salivary, etc)
Could be some good research coming out of here in this regard.
Describe the Patient Base: Likey a lot of hispanic due to location. That's all I can guess... Normal patients....
Describe interaction between faculty and residents: Unknown, the attendings are genuinely good people. That was obvious. I expect statements like "we have journal club at faculty house, we going skiing, my kids know his kids" types of things.
How important do you feel the OMFS department is to the hospital? Do they contribute and are they respected?
ENT and plastics used to be at the hospital but wanted a huge amount of money to be there. Some other cases where they over plated a guy and over billed and the hospital kicked them out. They approached Dr. Buhrow and now OMFS is the only one called in to take call. Banner respects the department to this point.
What do most of the residents do after graduation? (Private practice, academics, hybrid, etc.)
With their planned scope and personalities, I would think they would chose applicants and personalities that will end up in private practice. But so much is unknown. If you want to be a traditional OMFS I would have no reservations in going here. If for some reason you think you want to be the next TMJ, Orthognathic, Trauma, etc guy the unknowns on their case load may steer you away.
Other notes: While they build up their department, applicants who have an intern year will have huge advantage. Their first 2, one is an intern, the other is just a great guy. See if they'll take an extern. The program will have growing pains no doubt and the attendings don't have alot of academic experience. But the heart is there, and they were great people and you can tell they have financial and emotional support from Banner. We met the Banner CEO, other department heads, etc and they were all happy to have the new department on board. It'll be awesome place.
So much is unknown but the goals of the department are clear. They want to be known as hard working departent that gets stuff done. They want honest, hard working residents, and I think humble applicants will be sucessful there.
Hey guys.......CONGRATULATIONS to all who matched this year! I am a first time poster. I love this site. Lot's of useful information here. I am applying to OMS residencies this fall and I am hoping to get some guidance from those of you who have done this already.
I am a practicing orthodontist. I have been in private practice for 9 years. I have a very successful, busy practice, and treat about 70-75 patients a day. But to tell you the truth, I am bored out of my mind. The thought of doing this for another 20 years is more than I can wrap my head around. So.....I have decided to apply to OMS residencies. Then at least I could be a dual trained specialist and have more variety in the scope of my practice. AM I CRAZY??? Maybe......😱
Because of my age I am leaning toward the 4 year programs. That doesnt mean I am excluding the possibility of attending a dual degree program, however. Through the information I have gleaned from this forum, I already have a fair idea which are the top ten dual degree programs. It is not so clear, however, how the 4 year programs would be ranked. So my question is for those who have already interviewed, or who are residents. If you were to rank the top 10 four year programs, what would they be? Any insights you may have into their strengths or weaknesses would be helpful.
Thanks guys! Hope to hear from you soon.
hi there.i am a resident of us but am a FTD.i wanna pursue oral and maxillofacial surgery residency.when i surveyed, most of univ want d applicant to have a dds/dmd.i appreciate if any one knows vch univs offer a course to a FTD to join oral and maxillofacial residency.my toefl score 106. ece gpa 3.53.plz throw sm light here
This is a very nice thread fellas (aside from OMFS skin's comments)! Valuable information for current applicants. Thanks to all current residents who have posted.
Can anyone give any information on UNC's or Vandy's program? Thanks.
UNC is unbelievable. Ok I've gone too far. But it's a really neat place based upon the interview. I would contact them directly through their coordinator. Most of the residents were very helpful and their 2 new 1st years are great! Email em.
The gist: Just enough trauma, orthognathics is excellent, dentoalveolar is the norm, implants borderline(but not anything that detured me), anesthesia seemed to be tip top with dedicated anesthesia faculty, no cancer unless you want it at their other hospital, good med school, cheap tuition, I don't recall moonlighting policy, faculty seemed awesome, chapel hill is amazing, female friendly. There are far more positives than negatives.
Get in touch with the residents though, chief to intern.
For anyone who went the the Thomas Jefferson University Interview....
Is there some truth to the posts in the link above?
I got the word on Jefferson's OMFS progam. I saw the post above and got nervous about it because I'm seriously considering this program. I think the general consensus from the residents I worked with and other people who knew about that post was that it was some pissed off attending posing as a graduated resident. Apparently the chairman has some enemies, but come on, who doesn't. Basically, I really doubt that everything is as bad as that post made it seem. Most of the guys in the program are good guys and I don't think any one of them would dare write something like that about their program or their attendings. It's something I noticed right away. Yes, the chairman was an intimidating guy, but brilliant. Isn't that what a chairman is supposed to be?!
The program is the program to beat. They blow Penn, Drexel and Temple out of the water on the shear volume they bring in and quality they put out. These guys are doing an enormous amount of orthognathics, implants, trauma (rotate months of facial trauma with ENT service), research. They cover Jefferson, Methodist, the VA and have many transferring hospitals. They do upwards of 10 – 12 sedations in the office a day!! Their service is rocking.
They just increased the number of residents they take from 2 to 3 (two 4 years and one 6 year; I think it should be the other way around with two 6yrs and one 4yr like LIJ) just to handle the increase of volume. They took two 1 yr position residents this year because their service is so busy. They also brought in another attending as well. Personally, I am interested in the 6 yr position b/c I want to know the medicine side of things as well as the OMFS. I also hear that some of the medical governing bodies are trying to limit the practice scope of the single degrees which doesn't bode well for the 4 yrs. Plus, the 6yr is just badass. I hear they're brilliant and although it takes some time coming back to surgery after being in med school for two years, in the long run, they have more options open to them. Just my opinion.
Upcoming chiefs (2011 – 2012) for graduates who are looking to matriculate next July:
-*redacted*4yr – easy to get along with and smart within the scope of OMFS. Medical knowledge and understanding is limited surrounding many of these cases as you would expect since the guy doesn't have an MD. I got the sense that he was lazy/manipulative and everyone in the office seemed to know it, too. really good at looking busy and looking good when the chairman is around. Good example to follow for any intern looking to not get into trouble by slightly shady means. Definitely possible that he will sell his fellow residents down the river to keep his own skin out of the fire. I worry about being a 1st year under this guy.
-*redacted*6yr – seriously intense and meticulous guy, recently back from an extended med school stay b/c he got sidetracked with his personal life, met his wife and eventually got it together and is back on track. Word I hear from previous chief, is this guy is crazy smart in an entire scope of OMFS and medicine, but gets caught up in the small details. Professional and spoke highly of all the attendings when I met him. Word in the office is that he's a very honest guy and is not the type to let someone else take the heat for him. This guy's a worrier which I like b/c it means he won't leave me hanging when I'm the new resident on call.
This service has all the stuff that any incoming resident should be looking for in a program as far as cases and learning. I think it comes down to the people. You are not going to like everyone in a program, that's just how it is. I think for the most part, the attendings and residents at Jefferson's OMFS program are great. They seem like guys you'd want to go out and grab a beer with which means a lot if you're going to be spending years with these people. I think anyone who matches here is going to be a lucky SOB! I hope it's me!
Haha. What?! Your post has no substance AND you are defaming a chief. I highly doubt you're an applicant. Perhaps a bitter chief who doesn't like their senior resident. Doesn't really matter.
How about you remove the direct attacks so this thread can stay useful.
Haha. What?! Your post has no substance AND you are defaming a chief. I highly doubt you're an applicant. Perhaps a bitter chief who doesn't like their senior resident. Doesn't really matter.
How about you remove the direct attacks so this thread can stay useful.

Haha. What?! Your post has no substance AND you are defaming a chief. I highly doubt you're an applicant. Perhaps a bitter chief who doesn't like their senior resident. Doesn't really matter.
How about you remove the direct attacks so this thread can stay useful.
Anyone know which programs allow you to moonlight? I have kids so the extra cash would be useful, they might hold it against me if they have to wear clothes made out of my old scrubs, 🙂
Also, if anyone has any good info on Univ. Of Minnesota I'd appreciate it. I recently heard some bad stuff, but it was passed onto me from a friend of a friend who only did a extern there, so hardly valid. Thanks.
I'm going there for an externship over the summer. . . I'll fill you in in 9 months?
Anyone know which programs allow you to moonlight? I have kids so the extra cash would be useful, they might hold it against me if they have to wear clothes made out of my old scrubs, 🙂
Also, if anyone has any good info on Univ. Of Minnesota I'd appreciate it. I recently heard some bad stuff, but it was passed onto me from a friend of a friend who only did a extern there, so hardly valid. Thanks.
Which programs prepare you well academically? I've heard nice things about Parkland, Michigan, and LSU. Do you agree/ any other ones that come to mind? And what are some particular reasons?
Thanks
do you mean programs with heavy didactic emphasis or programs where graduates flood into academics?
do you mean programs with heavy didactic emphasis or programs where graduates flood into academics?
No, I mean those programs that have time each week dedicated to reviewing articles, discussing cases etc.
I originally meant places with graduates frequently going into academics, but I'm also curious about programs with dedicated weekly academic sessions.
Thanks.