Originally posted by NE_Cornhusker1
i guess i just don't understand how you could forget that you went to school somewhere. perhaps i'm just blessed with an incredible memory. i can see where there might be some confusion as to whether or not it was a college level course [and thereby college credit was earned] but that can [and should be] be easily enough cleared up with that school.
NE_Cornhusker1, you are seriously taking this way to an extreme, and no, youre not being helpful at all. Im not entirely sure what about this post has turned you into some kind of application nazi.
Let me recap this issue. AID took a SINGING class that was half a credit and got an A in it in high school. Now, singing class isnt exactly organic chemistry or quantum mechanics (though, with my terrible singing voice, it probably is much harder). Half credit courses are generally for fun anyway (ie PE classes). Also it was 7 years ago.
So not only does he not have a motive for hiding the class (since he got an A), but it was a freaking singing class taken 7 years ago for half credit as part of an EC. It would be quite easy to forget the class part of the EC and just attribute that memory to the EC itself.
NE_Cornhusker, I think you are creating Potemkin villages here, because you keep saying "if it had been this" or "if instead it had been that" it would be bad. And yes, if AID had gotten an F in general chemistry and wanted to hide it, that would be bad and everyone would be jumping all of it. But this is not such a situation, its forgetting a trivial class that has no bearing whatsoever on his application. And in terms of honesty, at least AID is trying to address something he knows is trivial (otherwise this thread wouldnt exist), and Im assuming he will inform adcoms about it.
So I ask you again NE, whats the problem?