• Hi! The search index is currently updating, search results will not include the full scope of the forums until it is complete.

Pediatrics vs MBA

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

loststark

New Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Hi there, I am currently doing intern year, after completing my MBBS.
Some facts which can be helpful for providing your opinions.

1. I love Pediatrics as medical field. I have always excelled in my Pediatrics rotation. I have three months of clinical experience as house officer in the field, two months of electives under an accomplished pediatrician of my country. I know how to deal with kids easily, how to counsel and talk to parents. I have always been greatly rewarded by patients, attendants and consultants alike. And i like kids.

But my issue with the field is of general residency issue. I can't tolerate long working hours. I am a sleepy head who needs 6 hours of sleep. Even though in my country, especially in government hospitals the working hours are manageable. I can't tolerate studying in a way which cuts me off from the people (but that is more of how I study issue). Plus it is difficult for me to grasp anatomy and biochemistry concepts (And I will need to master these along with others for residency tests).


2. I love management and psychology. These two things come naturally to me. I know how to deal with people, how to assign tasks, how to find solutions and how to be strategic. The concepts of psychology come easily to me. I excelled in my psychiatry rotation. I don't like psychiatry because it is more logical and concrete whereas psychology is bit more abstract and i like that aspect. So I have cancelled pursuing psychiatry for this and some other reasons. (I have mentioned this in case this part comes up in reviews). If I can I can get MBA with major in general and strategic management and later on certification/masters in organizational psychology. I will have some concentrated working hours but nothing on par with pediatrics working hour.

Now there are few issues here as well. I haven't had any contact with mathematics since grade 10 (7 years by now). If I get an MBA that too in management I will be completely away from medicine but I will be working in management and will not have to deal with concepts like H-K ATPase blocking in PUD (and gazillion other details which I have to remember in anatomy, biochem, pathology, microbiology)


3. Some more general facts:
I have tried and done electives in almost every field of medicine and couldnt get around any other field except for pediatrics.
I almost quit medical school in second year because I just hated how my medical school dealt with basic sciences and since then I find it irksome to even study those things again.
I have always been over achiever in school and high school. In med school, I averaged in every class except those concerning pediatrics rotations.

And I have altruistic, extroverted personality. If some here accept Meyer Briggs test, I always end up as ENFP even when I took tests at different stages of my life.

In my country as pediatric resident I will earn 650 dollars a month for 4 years.
As an MBA from a good B school in my country I will earn 650 dollars a month initially.

I am a resident of Pakistan
 
Could you do both?

Practice Peds for a while and then go into Management.

Also, I'm not sure whether or not some or any hospitals/clinics would take a "fresh" doctor for management roles.
 
Could you do both?

Practice Peds for a while and then go into Management.

Also, I'm not sure whether or not some or any hospitals/clinics would take a "fresh" doctor for management roles.


Hi,

Well the way it is for me, I will rather try to be one way or the other instead of doing both.
I once had a mentor, telling me, that it is important to be as good as possible with minimum degree hoarding.

And it just made sense to me.

I can start from small roles and go higher from there.

The only issue is more flexibility of time vs prestige of being a doctor
 
Top