Yeah I want MD only as well. And thank youu
I was kinda in a slump last week trying to figure out if it was worth retaking or not and I decided not to and just continue doing my research and what not
Yeah I imagine it all is relative to what your app is like, and what you truly want.
I had a 3.84c/3.94s GPA with lots of exciting EC's (Police Officer, Paramedic, worked for BP during oil spill doing rescues, etc), and a little research going into this application season with the MCAT being the last piece of my puzzle (tested in July, received scores in August). I was hoping for a 32+ and my dream school was Cornell back this July. I scored a 504, which is about a 28 - so it made me completely change up my school list, and what I was hoping to be my more "safety" schools are now the ones I'm hoping to receive II's from...
In the end, I'm okay with that. I just want to go
somewhere - and I feel that my 504 will achieve that for me.
If you're dead set on going to a top 25, then you'll surely need to retake. There certainly are people who score in the 20's, and retake and score 34+, but they are few and far between. Especially on an online forum there is a selection bias, you will hear 100x more success stories than you will hear failing ones just because those who made such a drastic change as more likely to be ecstatic and share.
If the rest of your app is solid, I wouldn't stress it. A lot rides on what state your a resident of as well.
Now that it's been two years since I've taken biology, 8 months since organic/physics/biochemistry, and 3 years since general chemistry ... if I don't get in this cycle I'd rather establish residency in Texas or Louisiana and have a much better shot than to retake the MCAT. The MCAT wasn't too bad for me, I actually enjoyed taking it. But I'm thankful I took the exam directly after my pre-reqs when it was fresh in my mind.