If the gov't didn't hand out loans like candy bars...
It's practically 2008 all over again, I'm just waiting for the bubble to pop
It's practically 2008 all over again, I'm just waiting for the bubble to pop
So ridiculous it made the New England Journal of Medicine:iF pEOplE DidNT aPpLy tO tHOse sChOoLs tHEy wOuLd lOWer pRiCEs.
How about if nobody applied to any dental school so all dental schools would lower their price??? See how ridiculous that sounds?
There are plenty of people who attend the Ivies and still cannot specialize. You know what they get as a reward? Worse hand skills and 200K more debt.
Ahh yes if you go to an Ivy but don’t specialize you might as well drop out since you’re so screwed. People like this ( Jessica Wyatt, D.D.S. (@dr.jessicawyatt) • Instagram photos and videos ) are just struggling to be a dentist.
Sent from my iPhone using SDN
Very little to no one in the real world is impressed by pedigree. If anything it can be the opposite where people are biased against you because a lot of the kids coming straight out of ivey league schools have an over inflated opinion of themselves and are entitled when they have literally accomplished nothing. All of the ivey leaque kids I worked with out of school were terminated within 6 months. Going to an ivey leaque school does not gurantee your employer a return on their investment for hiring you.
You’re a D1 at MUSC. What do you mean all the ivy league kids were terminated within 6 months.....? Unless you’re not talking about dentistry, which in that case wouldn’t be applicable to this discussion.
But why pay 200k more lol. But I get what you are saying. Majority of us will be just fine, but some people will take longer to knock off the loans.
But why pay 200k more lol. But I get what you are saying. Majority of us will be just fine, but some people will take longer to knock off the loans.
I think it depends on people’s individual situation. For a lot of people they shouldn’t pay more. For some it makes sense. Rarely in life is something one size fits all.
Sent from my iPhone using SDN
Yeah it's ironic because a lot people at Penn are probably paying less than or equal to what MUSC students are paying because of all the scholarships that Penn gives out.Imagine trying to talk smack about how expensive an Ivy is while going to one of the most expensive public schools in the country.
Sent from my iPhone using SDN
They want to switch so that all the OMFS people they produce will be DMDMD 😛Eh hard to justify paying 200k more for a name. My DDS is equivalent to your DDS when you graduate. Our scopes of practice is the same. There’s nothing seperating my degree from yours.
You are Wengerout DDS and I am Likkriue DDS. Of course Columbia wants to switch to DMD like all the ivies. So possibly Wengerout DMD.
Trust me, I have zero grudges with the education provided by the Ivy League schools. They are fine programs. I just can’t stand the idea that the cost differential is warranted because specializing is that much easier. I also can’t stand programs like Midwestern that justify the cost because they’ll make you a “super GP.” I don’t think most of you young guns realize the long term effects this debt will have on you. It’s not good for you or for the profession. It’s funny, why do I even care about your loan balance? It ain’t my problem.It would help if you spelled Ivy correctly.
As for no one is impressed/this “bias” against those who went to an Ivy, empirical data shows this is false.
Of course it’s no guarantee and one must still work very hard.
Sent from my iPhone using SDN
If I was a program director I’d pick the student who chose the cheapest school because then at least I know they have some common sense.
However, there are two schools that I have zero respect for after having worked with their graduates. I will not name these schools, so don’t ask; suffice it to say I’d never hire one of their graduates. Ever.)/QUOTE]
Damn you’re really gonna leave us with this suspense
It would help if you spelled Ivy correctly.
As for no one is impressed/this “bias” against those who went to an Ivy, empirical data shows this is false.
Of course it’s no guarantee and one must still work very hard.
Sent from my iPhone using SDN
Ahh yes if you go to an Ivy but don’t specialize you might as well drop out since you’re so screwed. People like this ( Jessica Wyatt, D.D.S. (@dr.jessicawyatt) • Instagram photos and videos ) are just struggling to be a dentist.
Trust me, I have zero grudges with the education provided by the Ivy League schools. They are fine programs. I just can’t stand the idea that the cost differential is warranted because specializing is that much easier. I also can’t stand programs like Midwestern that justify the cost because they’ll make you a “super GP.” I don’t think most of you young guns realize the long term effects this debt will have on you. It’s not good for you or for the profession. It’s funny, why do I even care about your loan balance? It ain’t my problem.
Big Hoss
You're proving my point! She practices in Fort Lauderdale, a very saturated area. This hits home with my point how she has 200K more debt over a public school and will have a very hard time paying off 470K with a salary of 120k/yr.
Also one can't judge the quality of dentistry they get via instagram. Only other dentists know not patients. My statement on hand skills could still be correct.
I spoke with someone from one of these schools who told me exactly thisbut they feel the pressure to specialize.
Ivy leagues produce a lot of specialists because that is the culture in their school. D1/D2 students are very impressionable and mimic what they see D3/D4 students doing. If D1/D2 see a majority of their upperclassman applying to specialty programs, they will too.
Does Ivy League increase your chance at landing a specialty? Yes and no...
Yes, because with so many classmates applying to specialty school, you will have a greater probability at finding upperclassman mentors that will guide you through the game of specializing. (Yes, it is a game, and knowing how to play it helps tremendously). Not only that, upperclassman that MATCHed to a program you are applying to can speak in favor of you and really swing votes in your favor when it comes to ranking. With so many Ivy Leaguers in specialty school, the likely hood of finding an upperclassman you know at a residency is high.
Now the No. Ivy Leagues send a deluge of applicants into specialty. For Example, UPenn had over 40 applicants this year for Pediatrics, of a class size of 130. Almost 1/3 of the class applied to Peds. Residency Program Directors are going to limit the number of interview spots for students from certain schools, no matter how qualified they are. Our program, when seeing a large number of applicants from a certain school, limited the number we interviewed to 5. So lets say we had 30 UPenn applicants, we would only invite 5 for to interview.
Along with that, your application means everything in landing that initial interview. It needs to be refined, with a strong statement and strong letters of rec. Again, lets take UPenn as an example... The Pediatric chair had to write 40 Letters of Rec. Do you think he/she was able to put ample time into writing a strong letter of rec or in helping look over your application? At schools with large specialty applicants, you are just another applicant, making it hard to stand out or to receive ample attention from faculty. With that logic, it's nice going to a school where there are only a handful of applicants because there you can receive the one-on-one attention, as well as there is less competition for events that will help on your CV.
Now, how did these schools become so specialty heavy?
It is my belief, after hearing from many students from these schools, it stems from lack of sufficient clinical exposure. (And this is no fault of the students) Because these schools lack sufficient patients of the right caliber (i.e. Pts that are willing to pay for necessary dental work), students feel inadequate at being GP providers. (I have heard from too many of these ivy graduates of graduating having done only 1 or 2 crowns, and 2-3 canals, not teeth, for endo...not to mention they are not allowed to do molars or premolars, only anterior endo.....).
There are schools that do well over 30 crowns on average/graduate. Middle ground schools average 15 crowns/graduate.
So imagine being a D3, and having very minimal exposure to clinical dentistry. It's time to start thinking about post graduate plans. You don't really have any exposure performing (yourself) endo, ortho, peds, OS, perio, etc... and not much more exposure to life as a GP. You see upperclassman applying to specialties, and they share about how much they learned and how much they love it, and you equate that information as "success." So, you follow suite....the cycle repeats itself year after year, and wham! 80% of students are applying to specialty (There are alot of other factors, but not going to discuss them here)
Ivy League students (and this is a large generalization) in my discussions with them, are often times lost. They don't really know what they want to do, but they feel the pressure to specialize. You hear from them, a lot, "Oh I was thinking about doing OS.. Or I was also thinking doing Ortho.... but yeah, Im glad I chose Peds." They appear peer pressured into applying to specialty school, with no real life, hands on experiences as to WHY they are applying (i.e. I was doing a lot of ______, and I fell in love with it) They always have a shadow of doubt as to if they chose the right specialty..... (again, this is not just limited to Ivy Leagues)
My interaction with applicants from clinical heavy schools is the exact opposite. I see less of them applying to post graduate programs. It is my belief, that this is because they found the beauty of general dentistry, and feel some-what confident in working straight out of school. Schools that struggle clinically will have more PGY-1 applicants because students feel the need for more training before venturing out. Again, even those at the clinically strongest schools will need further education, but GPR/AEGDs are not always the best in providing beneficial training.
If I had to mentor a Pre-Dent, the advice I would give is the following:
1) Go to the strongest clinical school you get into. This will help you feel confident in your decision to specialize or to stay GP. There are also less specialty applicants, allowing you to take advantage of opportunities to grow-in and experience the specialty before applying.
2) Forget above if you get into a school that is cheaper and will save you >$80-100k
3) If deciding between expensive schools, go the strongest clinical one, regardless of name.
Kids are awake. Santa time. Merry Christmas!
Well for starters, considering she owns her own practice and is getting veneers from Dr. Apa it’s highly unlikely she is only making 120k a year.
any dental student who think they are only going to use the skills they learned in four years to practice for the next 30 is fake news. The modern GP is going to learn the tools of their trade in a GPR/high level CE, not packing class II’s.
While Dr. Wyatt looks like a great dentist, and has a great social media presence which is essential in today's dental environment. It seems to me that she didn't really care about debt when she chose her school. She went to undergrad at the University of Miami, which is 50k a year for just tuition, then living expenses in the Miami area are insane. So I would assume that she has had parental help for some if not most of her dental education if they could afford that undergrad. Therefore choosing Columbia, and then not specializing is not as big of a deal as it would be for most taking full loans out.Well for starters, considering she owns her own practice and is getting veneers from Dr. Apa it’s highly unlikely she is only making 120k a year. However, the point of my response was to shoot down the narrative that just because you’re going to an Ivy means your hand skills are trash and will forever be the case. You can still be successful out of an Ivy even if you don’t specialize. Hell there’s some folks who do the dual degree program with the business school and end up never becoming clinicians.
I go to Columbia. Yes historically we got less time to work with our hands, however this is no longer the case. Plus, any dental student who think they are only going to use the skills they learned in four years to practice for the next 30 is fake news. The modern GP is going to learn the tools of their trade in a GPR/high level CE, not packing class II’s.
Sent from my iPhone using SDN
when should students do externships in dental school? during what year and is it usually done in the summer time?
What if I've had experience in that specific speciality working as an assistant?? could I do it earlier and then return and do it again in late years? Thanks!For our school most people do it 3rd year. You need to have had some patient exposure to really have a good experience. Some schools will give time off but a lot of schools don’t so you’ll just have to schedule it over Christmas break, spring break, semester breaks, ect.
What if I've had experience in that specific speciality working as an assistant?? could I do it earlier and then return and do it again in late years? Thanks!
thanks!Depends on the specialty and the externship. You can do as many as you have time for. Your best bet would be emailing the program you’re interested in specifically. Showing your face and networking won’t ever hurt you!
Honest question: how many programs taut high board scores?I send my GPR's to lot's of post grad specialty programs every year. I know their stats, scores, see their letter of rec, and know them well. I feel I have some real experience with this, for almost 15 years. So here goes:
Lots of people get into ortho, omfs, and pedo without being in the top 5. They also can come from non ivys and state schools. The toughest ortho to break into is a paid residency. I have sent two. One was #3 in her state school, and did a GPR with me. One was in the top 50% of the class (a large private school). Several of my residents are now OMFS. None were in the top 10 and only one was from an ivy. I have sent countless residents on to pedo. None were in the top 20, and come from a large variety of schools. Another former resident is now an ortho...she was in the lower 50% of her class,...and no she was not a legacy.
Many others have gone on to endo and perio, but few paid positions with this.
My point....don't listen to urban legends. A lot has to do with how you handle yourself in school and after. A lot has to do with how well your application is set up and how well you interview...far more important than for D school.
This advice does not apply to programs which tout hi board passage rates. Those PD's want the smartest applicants to keep this average going.
Do you know if prosthodontics is generally really competitive? I don’t ever hear people talk about it. Thanks!I send my GPR's to lot's of post grad specialty programs every year. I know their stats, scores, see their letter of rec, and know them well. I feel I have some real experience with this, for almost 15 years. So here goes:
Lots of people get into ortho, omfs, and pedo without being in the top 5. They also can come from non ivys and state schools. The toughest ortho to break into is a paid residency. I have sent two. One was #3 in her state school, and did a GPR with me. One was in the top 50% of the class (a large private school). Several of my residents are now OMFS. None were in the top 10 and only one was from an ivy. I have sent countless residents on to pedo. None were in the top 20, and come from a large variety of schools. Another former resident is now an ortho...she was in the lower 50% of her class,...and no she was not a legacy.
Many others have gone on to endo and perio, but few paid positions with this.
My point....don't listen to urban legends. A lot has to do with how you handle yourself in school and after. A lot has to do with how well your application is set up and how well you interview...far more important than for D school.
This advice does not apply to programs which tout hi board passage rates. Those PD's want the smartest applicants to keep this average going.
I don’t ever hear people talk about it. Thanks!
Oh no 🤔 Haha I was told it was a good residency route for those interested in engineering, but now I know haha@DSchoolorBust202X In the words of my grand father prosth is just expensive general dentistry
Don't listen to them. Prosthos are the engineers of dentistry. They're king when it comes to materials and dentures: fixed and removable. Prosth is even getting more involved with implants. People just don't know what they do until they go to schoolOh no 🤔 Haha I was told it was a good residency route for those interested in engineering, but now I know haha
It's definitely something I'll continue to look into, so thanks for the encouragement! I just have not EVER seen it mentioned here, so I was curious as to why more than anything.Don't listen to them. Prosthos are the engineers of dentistry. They're king when it comes to materials and dentures: fixed and removable. Prosth is even getting more involved with implants. People just don't know what they do until they go to school
Cause people think they only do crowns and dentures which their general dentist can do. But prosth has its place just like endo does even though general dentists can do thatIt's definitely something I'll continue to look into, so thanks for the encouragement! I just have not EVER seen it mentioned here, so I was curious as to why more than anything.
Another generalization, urban legend, or random thought that has no justification in fact. Since I actually know the people I am talking about, their grades, and full app, what I can say is that everyone has an individual situation which plays into the application process. Not every situation is based on grades and scores. Basically, people do what works for them. It's that simple. And don't forget, I'm in NY.Honest question: how many programs taut high board scores?
Also, would you say you’ve only had 1 resident from an Ivy league school match to OMFS because most match directly out of dental school and don’t need to to an AEGD or GPR?