Supernatural WW 2019 Edition Sign Ups & Game Thread

[PippyPony]

---

Members do not see this ad.

The redacted post I thought was hilarious, one or two people got the joke, was hoping for more unfortunately as I was saving it for a bigger game.

Lol did you actually plan a humor post in advance and deploy it like a joke bomb?

Everyone should go like that post

 

[Animal Midwife]

I still havent received an answer about what the list was.

The redacted post I thought was hilarious, one or two people got the joke, was hoping for more unfortunately as I was saving it for a bigger game.

What the hell is wrong with asking sporty when the last time she ever read me village?

So youre going to take that sampling of posts and say im more wolfy than the people that said nothing and didnt even vote? That goes against every WW principle in your body.

What list?

Nothing wrong with what you asked. It's not even a sampling of posts. I legit took out the fluff so it's a focused view on what happened. If the non-voters are wolfier, why didn't you vote for any? The issue lies, again, in what is missing from these posts.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Lol did you actually plan a humor post in advance and deploy it like a joke bomb?

Everyone should go like that post

Yep, and the even better part is that FTF is actually playing!! I thought he was banned and it was going to be in honorare, but hes actually playing and loved the post lol

 

[SARdoghandler]

Because she immediately voted for me D1 (last night) and then immediately contingency voted for me N1. Theres 25 players, how is she so absolutely sure im a wolf? Thats pretty absurd. This is classic "cubs is a wolf until he dies and proves otherwise" strategy. Sure, you can play that game, but how often is it actually going to work versus how often youre going to hurt village? Do people just not care and want me out of the game regardless because im too suspicious at all times?

No, this is classic "AM tunnels and sticks to her tunnel". I don't know how one vote from her yesterday and one today as a contingency = "people don't care"

Just seems like a whole lotta noise for something pretty small in the grand scheme of things

 

[SARdoghandler]

FWIW for future analysis, I likely would've voted Paws today and

Contingency lynch Paws

For tomorrow just in case

 

[Animal Midwife]

FWIW for future analysis, I likely would've voted Paws today and

Contingency lynch Paws

For tomorrow just in case

Why's that?

 

[SARdoghandler]

Why's that?

Hold please. I'm trying to organize my read-through thoughts into something semi-coherent since I read and made notes real fast so I could go to bed

 

[cubsrule4e]

No, this is classic "AM tunnels and sticks to her tunnel". I don't know how one vote from her yesterday and one today as a contingency = "people don't care"

Just seems like a whole lotta noise for something pretty small in the grand scheme of things

I guess Im just annoyed that Im usually her tunnel? Its like when she gets NKed N1, or so and so gets lynched D1. You just get tired of the same old thing.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I guess Im just annoyed that Im usually her tunnel? Its like when she gets NKed N1, or so and so gets lynched D1. You just get tired of the same old thing.

That last time I lynch you was three months ago. And you were a wolf.

 

[SARdoghandler]

Village leans - mostly based on tone of early posts today and placed in a general order of most to least villagery
AM
genny
mpm
Miz
capri
Dina
Pippy
FTF

Scum leans

Cubs - tone, pockety posts (i.e., #372), a bit over-reactionary
Paws - earlier posts wigged me out but I just made a "soft wolf lean" note until I got to #403 and both the tone and content of that post put all my hackles up. Nothing since then has made me feel any better and the naked lynch vote for Mel feels very out of character and made me more uneasy

Everyone else is neutral so far

 

[SARdoghandler]

I'm hoping to be done earlier and be able to contribute more thoughts in real time tomorrow guys.

But to be real, I'm in a different city and having a great time so we'll see how it goes

 

[Animal Midwife]

Village leans - mostly based on tone of early posts today and placed in a general order of most to least villagery
AM
genny
mpm
Miz
capri
Dina
Pippy
FTF

Scum leans

Cubs - tone, pockety posts (i.e., #372), a bit over-reactionary
Paws - earlier posts wigged me out but I just made a "soft wolf lean" note until I got to #403 and both the tone and content of that post put all my hackles up. Nothing since then has made me feel any better and the naked lynch vote for Mel feels very out of character and made me more uneasy

Everyone else is neutral so far

Why is mpm and capri so high?

 

[SARdoghandler]

Why is mpm and capri so high?

Because their tone read felt good enough for my notes to say "village lean" instead of "soft village lean"

 

[cubsrule4e]

Village leans - mostly based on tone of early posts today and placed in a general order of most to least villagery
AM
genny
mpm
Miz
capri
Dina
Pippy
FTF

Scum leans

Cubs - tone, pockety posts (i.e., #372), a bit over-reactionary
Paws - earlier posts wigged me out but I just made a "soft wolf lean" note until I got to #403 and both the tone and content of that post put all my hackles up. Nothing since then has made me feel any better and the naked lynch vote for Mel feels very out of character and made me more uneasy

Everyone else is neutral so far

So I would have been better off just saying nothing? So then I get put in the "quiet cubs is a wolf" camp of MsP and Dina. Damned if I do, damned if I dont

 

[SARdoghandler]

So I would have been better off just saying nothing? So then I get put in the "quiet cubs is a wolf" camp of MsP and Dina. Damned if I do, damned if I dont

No, damned if you sound like a wolf. Which you have so far to me. Don't woe is me at me just because I tone read you wolfy - happens to everyone

 

[Animal Midwife]

@cubsrule4e what are your current reads?

 

[cubsrule4e]

@cubsrule4e what are your current reads?

Not much. FTF's last minute actions/comments did strike me as wolfy even though I, as you said, wasnt going off of anything, but you have to vote for someone day 1.... unless youre the people that didnt vote, who all get a "watch" mark. Youre being annoying with your pursuit of me but that doesnt make you wolfy, same for SAR. Paws seems ok in PM. Have not spoken to Barks yet. Nav didnt strike me as anything wolfy, because if there was even a glimmer there you know Id be the first to vote for him. Sporty pulled that tinfoil out about me and FTF being cubs/miz 2.0 which was strange... and then she backtracked it and changed her vote. It makes me think she was testing me to see if Id stay on FTF if we were really both wolves and he was in real danger of being lynched, then once she convinced herself that wasnt the case she changed votes - seems like a village play there.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Not much. FTF's last minute actions/comments did strike me as wolfy even though I, as you said, wasnt going off of anything, but you have to vote for someone day 1.... unless youre the people that didnt vote, who all get a "watch" mark. Youre being annoying with your pursuit of me but that doesnt make you wolfy, same for SAR. Paws seems ok in PM. Have not spoken to Barks yet. Nav didnt strike me as anything wolfy, because if there was even a glimmer there you know Id be the first to vote for him. Sporty pulled that tinfoil out about me and FTF being cubs/miz 2.0 which was strange... and then she backtracked it and changed her vote. It makes me think she was testing me to see if Id stay on FTF if we were really both wolves and he was in real danger of being lynched, then once she convinced herself that wasnt the case she changed votes - seems like a village play there.

So no one other than FTF sticks out?

 

[cubsrule4e]

So no one other than FTF sticks out?

Sporty did, and then seemed to go the other way. If Im gonna lean FTF wolfy I could do the same with you based on your defenses if you really want another rather stretched wolf lean. I mean we havent even heard from 1/5 of the field. Why are you so adamant that we all have solid leads in all directions after 24 hours? Every game I say Im not a D1-2 player, im just not good at picking up subtle things immediately.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

I had an injury today that I never imagined having

Tore off half of my finger nail by whacking it with a vegetable peeler

Blood was gushing

After re-reading, I have liked Barkley, Dina, and SAR's posts the most. I also felt OK about Sporty and Mel's posts. I feel most poorly about Pippy and Paws' posts.

Since Paws has a vote already I will lynch pippy for now

 

[Animal Midwife]

Sporty did, and then seemed to go the other way. If Im gonna lean FTF wolfy I could do the same with you based on your defenses if you really want another rather stretched wolf lean. I mean we havent even heard from 1/5 of the field. Why are you so adamant that we all have solid leads in all directions after 24 hours? Every game I say Im not a D1-2 player, im just not good at picking up subtle things immediately.

But we have heard from the other 4/5 of the field. Just saying. I'm not even asking for a read on the absent ones (despite you doing so for SAR). Just don't know why your only other wolflean would be an omgus given that you apparently don't even have a read on the people who were voting FTF with you.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I had an injury today that I never imagined having

Tore off half of my finger nail by whacking it with a vegetable peeler

Blood was gushing

After re-reading, I have liked Barkley, Dina, and SAR's posts the most. I also felt OK about Sporty and Mel's posts. I feel most poorly about Pippy and Paws' posts.

Since Paws has a vote already I will lynch pippy for now

What's bothering you about Pippy and Paws' posts? Why did you like Mel's posts?

 

[PippyPony]

$20 says the thing that bothers her about my posts is that I voted for her yesterday

Sorry coffee but it had to be done

 

[PippyPony]

I had an injury today that I never imagined having

Tore off half of my finger nail by whacking it with a vegetable peeler

Blood was gushing

Also this is horrifying

Are you ok?

 

[WildZoo]

You have 20 minutes to submit your actions, or else face the wrath of grumpy early morning dubz

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

What's bothering you about Pippy and Paws' posts? Why did you like Mel's posts?

Pippy:
I was bothered by reading through her posts and how focused she was on Mel today.
There were a couple of times she addressed other players gameplay, but I believe unless I missed something just towards FTF and Nav whom later she said neither were particularly wolfy. Specifically, the "mini-threat" just is odd

Ok.

I don't disagree you should vote based on reads, but I just find that switch to be somewhat odd timing tbh.

Cheezit likes to try to pocket me early when he is a wolf. He just tried to do that. Therefore, you switching from him to me while you are in danger of getting lynched looks bad for him if you flip wolf. Just FYI.

like what is this supposed to be? Advice for him if he *is* a wolf? I'm not sure how he would know about Pippy and Mel's relationship so I don't see how FTF's behavior can be linked to it.

Finally, a note that goes for Paws too, is recognizing the tie but not doing anything about it.

Additionally going for Paws is the fact that ~10% of her posts have contributed to discussion and ~90% have been fluff

also this quick interaction

@sportpi saw the tag, are you looking for anything in particular,?
Updated thoughts:
Not sure what am thinks people missed but I need to go reread.
Was going to ask why people thought which side of up was good on ftfs list but I see that has been discussed.
Still sad nav never came back

Pippy, why are you surprised by mel? Have you forgotten his thing?

which one of his things?

His d1 thing

that she never came back to respond to pippy to about which d1 thing

also for Mel, I didn't say I like his posts, I said I felt OK about them.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Also this is horrifying

Are you ok?

Yeah it clotted from the bandaid pretty quickly and I got a rush of endorphins

Spoiler

The line of blood about a half a cm under the tip is where it is torn, I'm not ready to cut it off tho

 

[PippyPony]

Just because you don't see how something could be wolf-wolf behavior doesn't mean I'm sketchy for sharing what was in my head at the time

That move struck me as weird timing on the heels of Mel's post like they were worried about the optics of how the "sort of random" vote would look if FTF got lynched

Maybe it's nothing, but I thought it was weird so I said so.

I also only mentioned Mel like... twice? today and also asked a lot of other people for their input.

But I guess this just drives home how talking on D1 is a bad idea, which is dumb that it has to be like that

 

[Animal Midwife]

Pippy:
I was bothered by reading through her posts and how focused she was on Mel today.
There were a couple of times she addressed other players gameplay, but I believe unless I missed something just towards FTF and Nav whom later she said neither were particularly wolfy. Specifically, the "mini-threat" just is odd


like what is this supposed to be? Advice for him if he *is* a wolf? I'm not sure how he would know about Pippy and Mel's relationship so I don't see how FTF's behavior can be linked to it.

Can you elaborate on the bolded? Are you reading FTF as village?

Finally, a note that goes for Paws too, is recognizing the tie but not doing anything about it.

Additionally going for Paws is the fact that ~10% of her posts have contributed to discussion and ~90% have been fluff

Which posts of Paws are fluff? I only remember two.

also this quick interaction
that she never came back to respond to pippy to about which d1 thing

Which posts of Paws are fluff? I only remember two.

also for Mel, I didn't say I like his posts, I said I felt OK about them.

What's OK mean in terms of alignment?

 

[PippyPony]

like what is this supposed to be? Advice for him if he *is* a wolf?

I thought I already explained that.

I thought there was a chance that FTF would get lynched, and -- as I have learned from dying hella freaking early in a lot of games in a row now -- I wanted to acknowledge something I found weird at the time it happened.

I don't see how that's an unusual thing to do in a game where people die

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Can you elaborate on the bolded? Are you reading FTF as village?


Which posts of Paws are fluff? I only remember two.

What's OK mean in terms of alignment?

elaborate on bolded:
I am confused by trying to think of a way in which the manner that FTF was behaving in with regards to that particular post can be attributed to a wolf-wolf interaction between him and mel based on mel and pippy's relationship

I think FTF is more likely to be village than wolf

I think Mel is OK

So you are just excited that it is tuesday

Ok. Clearly I am at a disadvantage having not seem this show.

Welp it was really fun talking to you nav lolololol

Yeah it would be null now that I've mentioned it for at least a little bit. How do you think I should feel about being stood up for this convo?

So who should I vote for?

this post and

Sad

*clicks pen*
And how does that make you feel?
*unclicks pen*

Are there really 25 people playing? Geez

The limit does not exist

Can you elaborate on the trap though?

this post could've been contributing but she didn't follow through, so seems like didn't even care about the answer

 

[Animal Midwife]

elaborate on bolded:
I am confused by trying to think of a way in which the manner that FTF was behaving in with regards to that particular post can be attributed to a wolf-wolf interaction between him and mel based on mel and pippy's relationship

I think FTF is more likely to be village than wolf

I think Mel is OK

So how do you feel about cubs then since this implies there were at least two village counters to him? Also, why did you want Paws to break the tie if you're reading it v/v? And this doesn't clarify what OK means.

this post and
this post could've been contributing but she didn't follow through, so seems like didn't even care about the answer

I still see only two fluff posts. What part wasn't followed through? Do you think miz didn't answer adequately?

 

[capri1722]

Spoiler: gif/somewhat off topic

I was only at work for FOUR HOURS and y'all added FIVE PAGES.
Side note, it was a great forking day at work. For the first time in ~5 months there were ZERO prescriptions in queue when I left. Thanks, Snowmageddon!

So roles aren't indicative of alignment. Well knowledge of the show doesn't help there. There are multiple characters on the show that kind of constantly switch back and forth between good and evil so I can kind of understand why roles aren't indicative of alignment.

Also I think the first post mentioned something about basically everyone being Sams and Deans from various universes so I think it's safe to guess everyone is some variation of Sam & Dean.

and any names with a z get automatically shifted down
same with numbers

Spoiler: img

Miz is an objectively bad choice
so am I
wake up sheeple

IIRC just like 2 pages ago you had her pretty sketch. I'm not one to go get quotes to support my ridiculous claims but literally the quote before this one has your "reasoning" for ranking her lower.

Does anyone think FTF sounds like a jester

Not to throw out more tinfoil distractions, but.

what's a jester

comeon midwife that was slick sketch as hell

FTFY

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

So how do you feel about cubs then since this implies there were at least two village counters to him? Also, why did you want Paws to break the tie if you're reading it v/v? And this doesn't clarify what OK means.


I still see only two fluff posts. What part wasn't followed through? Do you think miz didn't answer adequately?

I don't know about cubs
Because if 2 villagers are tied, it's better to lose just 1 than 2?
I don't know Mel's affiliation, AM. If I did this game would be a piece of cake.

Also you and I must have different definitions of fluff posts
I don't think Miz answered adequetely to the first post I flagged; the second one I missed the response, that one is actually fine

 

[Animal Midwife]

Spoiler: gif/somewhat off topic

I was only at work for FOUR HOURS and y'all added FIVE PAGES.
Side note, it was a great forking day at work. For the first time in ~5 months there were ZERO prescriptions in queue when I left. Thanks, Snowmageddon!

What do you think about the five pages?

Spoiler: img

IIRC just like 2 pages ago you had her pretty sketch. I'm not one to go get quotes to support my ridiculous claims but literally the quote before this one has your "reasoning" for ranking her lower.

Spoiler

what's a jester

A 3p who needs to get lynched before village or wolves win.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Took me some time but

Dr. ForgotToFlush

Animal Midwife
CoffeeQuestionMark
genny
mypetmoose
Mad Jack
Lawper
kraskadva

acanthuroidei
Ms Procrastinator
fromthebox

Melchizedek
SportPonies
muttmanager
Dinashadow

StartingoverVet
SARdoghandler
kcoughli

Barkley13
capri1722
cubsrule4e
SnowshoeDog143
StayingPositive2017

Navilly
FTF
mizchiefmanaged
PippyPony

So again, what is this? And if its some form of reads list/village to wolf rankings why is Lawper on the list?

 

[Animal Midwife]

So again, what is this? And if its some form of reads list/village to wolf rankings why is Lawper on the list?

Y'all finally noticed.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Y'all finally noticed.

And yet I still dont have an answer after asking 3 times.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

I don't know about cubs
Because if 2 villagers are tied, it's better to lose just 1 than 2?
I don't know Mel's affiliation, AM. If I did this game would be a piece of cake.

Also you and I must have different definitions of fluff posts
I don't think Miz answered adequetely to the first post I flagged; the second one I missed the response, that one is actually fine

What didn’t I answer?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I don't know about cubs
Because if 2 villagers are tied, it's better to lose just 1 than 2?

That's what ended up happening today, yes? What would have happened if Paws voted for FTF?

I don't know Mel's affiliation, AM. If I did this game would be a piece of cake.

So you 100%, without a doubt, know Pippy and Paws' alignment?

Also you and I must have different definitions of fluff posts

What your definition of a fluff post?

I don't think Miz answered adequetely to the first post I flagged; the second one I missed the response, that one is actually fine

Okay, so how does this affect your read on Paws?

 

[Animal Midwife]

And yet I still dont have an answer after asking 3 times.

You're still skimming too hard then. It's been fluffed to oblivion. Start reading again from when that post was made.

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

What didn’t I answer?

paws asked who she should vote for as alternative to you

 

[capri1722]

Y'all finally noticed.

Is there a reason you couldn't point it out?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

That's what ended up happening today, yes? What would have happened if Paws voted for FTF?


So you 100% without a doubt know Pippy and Paws alignment?


What your definition of a fluff post?

Okay, so how does this affect your read on Paws?

If Paws had voted for FTF, FTF would've died.

no. I didn't say that either. I disliked their posts the most.

something that is not helping to evaluate

 

[Animal Midwife]

Is there a reason you couldn't point it out?

Because like five other people have today already. This is just D1. If we're going to find any wolves, there's need to be some more extremely close reading occuring on this thread.

 

[Animal Midwife]

If Paws had voted for FTF, FTF would've died.

Are you factoring in FTF's self-prez?

no. I didn't say that either. I disliked their posts the most.

So why can't you talk about Mel then?

something that is not helping to evaluate

Would you say your posts prior to lynch close today met said evaulating criteria? Or otherwise point out why the quotes from Paws fail to progress the game?

 

[CoffeeQuestionMark]

Are you factoring in FTF's self-prez?

So why can't you talk about Mel then?

Would you say your posts prior to lynch close today met said evaulating criteria? Or otherwise point out why the quotes from Paws fail to progress the game?

I said Mel was OK

 

[Animal Midwife]

I said Mel was OK

Is OK third party?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

paws asked who she should vote for as alternative to you

I find it interesting that this kept getting asked. I listed like 4-6 people that gave me at least some sort of feels and that I’d like to vote between. But I got asked like 5 times after that who else to vote for besides me. I’m not sure what answer people want beyond my initials answer.

Tomorrow at work doesn’t currently look insane. I’m going to try to reread the end of day. Cub’s appearance and disappearance and convenient reappearance stuck out to me and still kinda does. My normal tunnel buddy mutts hasn’t come after me yet and that’s a bit weird to me. MsP still hasn’t posted a lot. Flushy’s weird timing of self prez wa interesting and I don’t think I like it. But weird for a wolf to hard core protect a villager if he is a wolf.

I’m reasonable happy with AM, capri, I thinkkkkk sporty, and I think mel.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I find it interesting that this kept getting asked. I listed like 4-6 people that gave me at least some sort of feels and that I’d like to vote between. But I got asked like 5 times after that who else to vote for besides me. I’m not sure what answer people want beyond my initials answer.

Tomorrow at work doesn’t currently look insane. I’m going to try to reread the end of day. Cub’s appearance and disappearance and convenient reappearance stuck out to me and still kinda does. My normal tunnel buddy mutts hasn’t come after me yet and that’s a bit weird to me. MsP still hasn’t posted a lot. Flushy’s weird timing of self prez wa interesting and I don’t think I like it. But weird for a wolf to hard core protect a villager if he is a wolf.

I’m reasonable happy with AM, capri, I thinkkkkk sporty, and I think mel.

What makes you okay with capri and Mel?