I wouldn't fret on what pays well. Focus on satisfaction and what you like. There's adequate money in the mundane/exotic as long as a few criteria are met
(a) It must be done effectively and efficiently with a well managed post-op. Without unbundling, small add on procedures that don't change the overall recovery do increase reimbursement. The simple truth is nothing goes better with a bunion than a few hammertoes.
AND
(b) You must be hospital/MSG/ortho employed
OR
(c) a private practice owner performing the service on someone with higher reimbursing insurance.
I have 4 cases on Monday
(a) a 5th metatarsal head resection. It will take 10-15 minutes, pay $800 and be discharged with sutures out in 11 days.
(b) a cheilectomy. It will take sub-30 minutes. I have a bad insurance contract so it will pay $400ish. It should be double that. I will discharge at 11 days.
(c) a gastrocnemius recession, plantar fascial release, ...f&*&& my life - tarsal tunnel release that bounced around through a bunch of other providers. Let's say an hour. Guestimate $1500K. The patient will follow me the full 90 day global and the rest of my career.
(d) a revision fusion of a lapidus non-union performed by someone else with hardware removal, fusion, and bone grafting. Again, I have a bad contract with the patient's insurance so no matter how I code it - lapidus, single joint fusion, revision of non-union etc - the insurance pays less than $700 + whatever I get for the add on procedures (removal of hardware, possible bone graft harvest). Not kidding, probably less than $1K total for the case. The fusion alone should be double. Good insurance would pay $2K with add-ons. Goal will be in shoes at 6 weeks.
I'm doing it at a surgery center that I have a block at. They always start me a little late, but they turn over the room quickly. I co-own the practice so I'll keep 40% upfront and then anything left over at profit sharing time. Were all the cases done on good insurance the day would possible be $1500 more in collections. I'm dependent on the patient's to pay - if they don't they go to collections and I get even less money. I'm dependent on the insurance company to not pull garbage shenanigans and claim they needed a prior auth. That's a classic United move.
If I owned shares in the surgery center I'd potentially get a cut of profits down the road. I don't. All 4 are private insurance. The surgery center will receive many times over what I will receive for these cases. They routinely get $3K for a single toe amp on private insurance where the surgeon gets $200-300.
Were I hospital employed you could simply multiply all my procedures by their RVU value and your $-conversion value to determine what shows up on next paycheck. It would be substantially larger than I will make as an owner because several of these cases are private insurance but with poor contracts. Its otherwise not fair to compare owner vs hospital because ultimately their pay is coming out of the total compensation the hospital is receiving while I'm obviously leaving the surgery ownership money on the table.
Now - if you thought all the above was going to be worth $10,000 - it isn't unless you charge cash. There used to be a thread stickied at the top of this forum describing the fact that there's money to be made in this profession but its a grind. Two of the above patients need CAM boots. We might make $200 or so on boots except both patients already own them. We'll do a few x-rays to the tune of $25-32. The fusion patient might be a candidate for custom orthotics down the road if she keeps coming back complaining.
Meanwhile, a rep came out pushing amnion to my office. They wanted me to know that a 15mm circle costs like $250 and pays like $800ish from Medicare and can be applied like 10 weeks in a row or something ridiculous.
I'm putting actual numbers down because students go into this with zero idea what our work is worth. There are people who make substantially more money than I do for the same services. My kids eat fine, but I will be sending them to public school. Someone else on here said on average they receive $700 for a surgery. That's often nearly the total reimbursement. If the patient keeps coming back you are seeing them for free. Solid post-operative management is important - hopefully discharging two of the patients above quickly and effectively will open up spots for new paying patients not in a global.
Good luck.