Anyone else considering it between undergrad and med school?
Dang, you got denied after the interview? That's rough.I considered it, applied, interviewed, and was ultimately denied a position. Talk about a humbling experience! But it is a very competitive thing so if you are accepted, it does say something. Plus, according to the friend of mine who was accepted, it's an amazing experience and sure to be a great talking point during interviews.
Plus, according to the friend of mine who was accepted, it's an amazing experience and sure to be a great talking point during interviews.
Dang, you got denied after the interview? That's rough.
OP, I am doing TFA for the next two years, before I go to med. school. If you have any questions, feel free to PM me.
Well I'm already accepted and doing the interview thing now (for med school), so I wouldn't be doing it for any type of resume-building. I'd just defer my admission for 2 years (I hear most schools will do this if it's for TFA). I think I'm going to apply and see what happens and then make my decision.
I've been working in medicine, not as a physician obviously, for 6 years or so and I think I might need a refreshing break doing something else before I'm back to being gung-ho about med school and ready to work my butt off.
I don't think anyone is a shoo-in for med or dent.my friends have the notion that its a shoe in into med/dent school once you do teach for America? is it really? anyone do tfa and get rejected to professional schools? just curious....
you will definitely work your butt off in TFA...period. (Unless you don't really buy into the relentless pusuit of success they'll try to sell you) I can only speak about the urban settings they use, not rural. But it's no cake walk...
Good article about Teach for America here.
Hey Man! I have a respectable major! Recreation, Sports, and TourismGood article about Teach for America here.
Well... I've also heard it's a disillusioning experience that turned several people off of teaching. You'll be working in some of the worst school systems in the US, and many naive kids who just graduated college suddenly have their idealistic, help-thy-neighbor vision shattered by the reality.
Then again, I hear medicine does the same thing
If you are interested in teaching, also think about your responsibility toward the kids you'll be teaching. I've heard from several sources that TFA doesn't provide with adequate training and practice to prepare you to handle the kinds of classroom situations you'll be put in (I could be wrong - maybe it's changed since I last talked to people). If, because of lack of training or experience, you are spending a lot of time/energy on classroom management and keeping your class from going crazy, how much material will you be able to teach your kids? I feel strongly that if you're committed to teaching, then do the kids the favor of giving yourself adequate tools to do it well.
Good article about Teach for America here.
I am currently doing something similar to TFA. It is called NYCTF- newyork city teaching fellows program, where you get to teach in inner city schools (mainly in the Bronx and queens). It is def a very challenging experience, but it makes you a stronger person. You also become more aware of the minority community. Its is very competitive. gluck applying if you decide to.
God, I would've thought TFA did a better job at screening potential applicants. He reeks of dejection and disillusionment -- not the type of guy I'd want teaching at my school. The problem with these Cullen types is that they're doing TFA primarily for themselves: for that "life-changing" experience that they will talk about that for the rest of their life. I'm glad he got reality beaten into him, but what about the students in his class who will forever be stuck in these decrepit school systems?
This is the second time in two days that people have responed to an article in the Onion as if it were cnn.
Haven't you guys ever heard of this "newspaper?"
Not sure what you mean by this? - Become a teacher if you want to teach?
This is the second time in two days that people have responed to an article in the Onion as if it were cnn.
Haven't you guys ever heard of this "newspaper?"
Not sure what you mean by this? - Become a teacher if you want to teach?
Good point. Although, I don't want to have to spend the time and money getting certified the traditional way, just to teach 2 years in an underprivileged classroom.
I want to do it both for the challenge and also for as much benefit as I can be to the students.
I wanted to respond to those that say TFA doesn't train adequately. I am an '05 alum who taught high school chemistry in south LA. I have some criticisms of the organization, but training isn't one of them. The training is hell, but it definitely helps. When you finish Institute (the summer TFA boot camp) you will have a fair amount of classroom time under your belt... Not as much as someone who did student teaching, but you get feedback every single day and learn teaching techniques and theory from 7 am to 10 pm. Furthermore, that classroom time will be with kids very similar to the ones you will be teaching, i.e. in a rough school with below-grade-level kids, which would not necessarily be true in a normal teaching program. And trust me, if you do student teaching in a normal decent public school, you are NOT ready to walk into a troubled one. Honestly the teachers that came into my school as first year teachers from student teaching programs did about the same as TFA-trained teachers, not noticeably better or worse. Furthermore, in many of the really difficult schools that TFA serves, they simply can't get enough "trained" teachers. They simply aren't there; teachers don't exactly flock to classrooms of 40+ rough high school kids with 3rd grade reading and math skills. The result is that requirements have been relaxed such that you can actually get a job teaching in some places like LA with NO education training, and you start training as you start teaching. Several teachers were doing this as I started, and a lot of them didn't make it through the first semester. We were definitely more prepared than them. Even with this relaxed restriction, we were unable to fill some science positions, and two biology classes were taught for 5 months by day-to-day subs. That is, people with NO biology background, no teaching credential, frequently no management skills, and they rarely stayed for more than a week. You better believe those classrooms were destroyed and the kids learned NO biology. They colored a lot, though. Sometimes on their assignments, sometimes on the walls, and without any red colored pencils as the Bloods steal them all. If the administration gets picky about training, then they have this situation, which is also clearly unacceptable.
I think that those that say that TFA doesn't train adequately are correct in the sense that NO ONE is trained adequately to walk into the situations we walk into, and everyone is going to struggle mightily for at least a year. But we are not at a disadvantage compared to even the "most-prepared" first-year teachers, and we are at an advantage compared to many. Furthermore, while many people do the 2 years and get out, there are lots of great people (my roommate, several others at my school) who stay beyond that commitment who never would have majored in education initially but are fabulous teachers, so I do believe that TFA gets some pretty great people into the profession.
Do NOT do TFA for your resume. If any of you have questions about it, please feel free to PM me at any time! Good luck!
I think is another one of those threads that pops up every once in a while without anything new really coming from it. That's not necessarily a bad thing, of course. I finished my two years of TFA in June, and would definitely do it again if I had the choice. At the same time, I was very ready to move on at the end. Spending a couple of years in another profession actually made me more certain that medicine was the right path for me. If you don't feel rushed to start the career you'll stick with for the rest of your life, if you like kids, and if you've got just the right touch of OCD and, as someone else said, thick skin, I think TFA's a great way to spend a couple of years between UG and med school. I got a call from one of my former 3rd-graders the other day, and it brightened my whole week.
In response to the question of competence and readiness, it was my personal experience that TFA teachers inevitably were better-prepared than first- and second-year teachers coming through traditional paths. TFA isn't particularly liberal about releasing real data on how their teachers compare to others, but the one big independent study that's been done found that kids with TFA teachers tend to perform about the same in ELA as those with regular teachers (including veterans), and to outperform them in math and sciences.
I was wrong about them outperforming veteran teachers as well as other new teachers--looks like it was about the same. I had actually never read the study until I googled it just now, but I'm pretty sure that Hoover Institution one is the one I'd heard of.
When people ask me whether I thought teaching was more like Dangerous Minds or Dead Poets Society, I tell them neither, it was more in line with Half Nelson...
"Dan Dunne (Ryan Gosling) is a young inner-city junior high school teacher whose ideals wither and die in the face of reality. Day after day in his shabby Brooklyn classroom, he somehow finds the energy to inspire his 13 and 14-year-olds to examine everything from civil rights to the Civil War with a new enthusiasm. Rejecting the standard curriculum in favor of an edgier approach, Dan teaches his students how change works – on both a historical and personal scale – and how to think for themselves.
Though Dan is brilliant, dynamic, and in control in the classroom, he spends his time outside school on the edge of consciousness. His disappointments and disillusionment have led to a serious drug habit. He juggles his hangovers and his homework, keeping his lives separated, until one of his troubled students, Drey (Shareeka Epps), catches him getting high after school."
"Dan Dunne (Ryan Gosling) is a young inner-city junior high school teacher whose ideals wither and die in the face of reality. Day after day in his shabby Brooklyn classroom, he somehow finds the energy to inspire his 13 and 14-year-olds to examine everything from civil rights to the Civil War with a new enthusiasm. Rejecting the standard curriculum in favor of an edgier approach, Dan teaches his students how change works on both a historical and personal scale and how to think for themselves.
Though Dan is brilliant, dynamic, and in control in the classroom, he spends his time outside school on the edge of consciousness. His disappointments and disillusionment have led to a serious drug habit. He juggles his hangovers and his homework, keeping his lives separated, until one of his troubled students, Drey (Shareeka Epps), catches him getting high after school."
It's not too bad. As you'd expect, teachers will go and see pretty much any movie involving teaching, usually to make fun of how unrealistically its portrayed. If you're actually in the mood for a movie like that, Akeelah and the Bee is a lot better, I think.
I was kidding about the heroin addiction part of my teaching experience, lest there be any confusion. Or any AdCom members sniffing around.
No way. Freedom Writers was great with the inspiration, but how creepy is it that the teacher followed some of her students to college. The update said Erin Gruwell went to a college where some of her students attended. She should have prepared them for success without her.
I have to agree with someone above about Stand and Deliver. Loved it and I totally relate to it. I'm a current TFA Corps Members in Houston. I can't even begin to describe the happiness my TFA experience has brought me and I can tell you many of my other TFA Corps Member friends would agree. Not only is it great to make a difference in the lives of these students, but TFA is also great about providing many opportunities. For those of you considering Teach for America, I would recommending looking at their graduate partnerships page on teachforamerica.org
Let me know if you have any questions for a first year Corps Members. I'd love to tell you about my experience in inner-city Houston.
Yeah, if you're a Teach For America cheerleader I'd be very careful about citing one or two studies as evidence that TFA teachers are better instructors than the fully-trained and experienced full-time teachers on staff. Most studies I've read have been pretty contradictory.When you Google "How do test results from "Teach For America" teachers compare?", multiple conflicting papers pop up. Interestingly, I'm pretty sure there are big differences in how TFA teachers compare to their traditional colleagues dependent on which city or area they teach in, with a few areas performing unusually well or poorly. That's based on conversations with TFA administrators with access to TFA's raw internal data.
All time classic teaching movie, in my book. Very very good...Stand and Deliver is great as well.