A lot of good advice on this thread. Also just matched this year, so ymmv, but I agree with a lot of what was said. I think step 1 is overblown; if you look at the otomatch google sheet, people with 240 steps did just as good if not better than many people with 250 or 260. The letters you have, the quality of your home program, and I would say the quality of your medical school play a large factor as well. Do not discount the value of aways either. I have a well recognized home program, but many of the top 10 programs I was shut out of. Howvever, the ones that I did get were those that were either regional or that I did an away at. People care a lot more about if you fit with them than if you went to x brand name school or got a 270+ on step 1. Also, I am not sure how necessary it is to apply to a back up. We had a student in my class with similar grades to yours who had less research and ended up getting >15 interviews and matching. But, if you want to be safe, by all means its good to do so. Finally, about the grades in surgery. It was something I was worried about when I was applying because I also did not honor surgery, however, it never came up once on interviews. It also didn't prevent me from getting my #1 choice, so I wouldn't worry if I were you. Just continue to do the best you can on the rest of 3rd year, take step 2 early and crush it, do a few aways and work hard, and you have a good shot of matching.