Human beings are complex b/c they are multidimensional, and in reality, much within these dimensions is still not as well understood as we might like to believe. In fact, it would seem that some either don't believe or have only an inkling in how these dimensions overlap/intersect. I think probably unbelief is a big factor for some. To me, the closed thinking to that is sad, but whatever.
Humans are also complex b/c they are individuals--individuals that often have very involved or complex histories. Just b/c we have seen a lot of media presentations about some compelling stories, well, this doesn't mean it's all the same deal. The core belief against a holistic paradigm leads, IMHO, often to a lack of finding the particular value of the individual. Genetics alone make people complex. Heck, I haven't had two dog's personalities or even presentations that were exactly the same, and I have owned, bred, and raised a lot of dogs.
Now, I am thinking you may be a cardiologist. Over time problems with the heart can affect other organ systems--making even physiological management complex. Most things don't act in isolation--hence there is an inherent complexity with most things and the human body is no exception. The things of the mind and spirit are even more so. Life is complex, and people are included in what in life is complex, both physiologically and otherwise.
Listen, my mother is managed by an excellent EPS cardiologist, who really could seem to give two craps about taking a holistic approach. He's more an aloof kind of guy. Yes. He is very up on what's going on with her. He's very excellent at what he does in general. I trust his expertise. But he doesn't have that sense of respect for the whole person, and I guess he doesn't see the need to have it. That's his own particular complexity at work perhaps. I have worked with some surgeons like this. And b/c they are so skilled and adept at what they do, I stand by them and respect them. At the same time, personally, I think in some respects, he/they are losing out and so are his patients somewhat. Now some of that has to do with the sheer core demands of their jobs. But at the end of the day, that they seem to think they are just doing a job will take something away rather than protect them. And you see this from time to time with them. Some are just careful, but every once in a while a particular patient will affect them more on a personal level. Yes, people have to self-protect in this profession. But there are those that set proper boundaries
and still believe and maintain a truly holistic approach with patients and families. These people I give the utmost respect,
b/c I see how it positively affects patients, families, and staff. They are real leaders.
Now, please don't get me wrong. I don't want a provider that is all understanding and appreciates the multi-dimensionality of people, but who is not highly skilled or is less than highly competent.
It's not an either or proposition.
When it is genuine, and the professional understands and embraces the holistic paradigm, there is absolutely nothing tawdry about it. It's so sad and disheartening that you would use this word. In fact, it is judgmental against those that do genuinely employ the holistic paradigm.
No one is saying being truly holistic in approach means holding someone's hand every time you see them. That's not it at all. It's a paradigm that begins and ends with a sense of respect that goes beyond understanding of the physiological state of the individual. And often it is something some healthcare providers don't
get until they are on the other side of bed--or they have a child on death's door or another close loved one that is being tossed from in-hospital department to department-- and usually they get it most when it is for something serious and often prolonged.
The value of a real holistic paradigm genuinely applied is that it increases empathy, and it helps to expand the picture in terms of things that could be missed which may indeed be relevant to the patient and his or her condition. It also brings a respect for the fact that a patient may not be a medical person, but they, however, are often experts in their own bodies and how they feel. So, they can clue into the trends--what alleviates the pain and what exacerbates it, for example. It also incorporates a sense of empathy, something we have dire need of in today's world. Some professional people have the strength to develop this, and others don't. It means in effect, working alongside the person--like a good coach that is rooting his player along to success--whatever that ultimate success may be--a better life or a respectful and quality ending of one.
That's my piece on that. It's neither here nor there to some folks, and that's quite sad to me. People fear what's not a black and white kind of thing. So many things in life just aren't.