WWhy is Dexter a sociopath WW game

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I'm skimming between episodes of american horror story. If I seem out of it, its cause I feel out of it.

But with that said I have no idea who is who except I'd probably suggest eliminating those with useless roles now (JJ though likely she is innocent, LIS, Harry. Etc). Technically I'm smack dab in that list too. Take it as you will.

But if people have a hunch then follow the hunch. I've been way too out out of it today to make good decisions... but I do trust ftbs intuition so I'll go with that.

unlynch devyn, Lynch nohika I get the feeling tjebrest of the game is just going to be a grind. So let's do it quicker.

Members don't see this ad.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
*****unlynch FTB, lynch nohika******

I can get behind a hunch. If its wrong I'm going back to FTB tomorrow.
 
********************
Keeping this updated for SOV, because I have nothing better going on this Friday night...

Lynch vote tally

JJohnston 3 (Nohika, Devyn, trematode)
Devyn 3 (WS, LIS, JJ)
nohika 5 (FTB, DocE, Escalla, Dyachei, hedgie)

Uncast votes: I think 1... I don't recall how many people are left.

Deadline: 8pm EST
***********************
 
I need to go for a run and then we're going out tonight.

My vote won't count very much anyways in this lynch. I couldn't change the majority if I tried.

Lynch nohika.


While this isn't my favorite option, it will augment the suspicions I have if we are wrong.
 
Lynch vote tally

JJohnston 3 (Nohika, Devyn, trematode)
Devyn 3 (WS, LIS, JJ)
nohika 6 (FTB, DocE, Escalla, Dyachei, hedgie, WTF)
 
A thought.

Why are the pinkies pink. I know they are all killers with at least some redeeming facet. But generally color means a lot. Throwing this out there and I am definitely not saying I'm sure about this: there has to be some meaning yo them being pink. Being able to pm is not enough.

But what is it? Do they have their own win criteria? Are they the only convertible ones? Am I totally off base? Idk. Maybe its my fever talking, but there has to be something to the pinkies more than being pink.

Sort of brings me back to day 1 and everyone in that group assuming they were wolves. Little tidbit shared by glorious leader LIS.... they were all so convinced they were wolves that they sent in kill actions only to find out they weren't the (true?) Wolves. LIS is no newbie. How does he make that mistake?

unlynch nohika, lynch JJ. I may be out of my mind. But both players claim their roles are all used up. I can almost justify following this thread out because worse case scenario we go from 12 to 8 testing my theory and we still have a huge advantage over what must be obe one wolf at 7 to 1.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
A thought.


But what is it? Do they have their own win criteria? Are they the only convertible ones? Am I totally off base? Idk. Maybe its my fever talking, but there has to be something to the pinkies more than being pink.


Ok...maybe I have COMPLETELY missed something....

If Viktor is a bad guy, why did he kill another bad guy....

If Viktor is a pinky, this suggest to me that the pinkies as a group have a win condition - something probably like the wolves must all be dead and they must outnumber the villagers...perhaps?

Why else would Viktor kill a wolf? And why are we voting to lynch someone who killed a wolf?

I'm not defending the Viktor character by any means, but this whole thing is weird.

Sigh. No one listens to me :(
 
Sigh. Congrats on lynching a villager.

I guess this is good timing. Heading out of town for a bit this weekend.

I haven't been converted, but my role is pretty much completely used up, so.

Gotta check who started this bandwagon, pretty please. Because it's definitely not in my best interests.
 
Sigh. Congrats on lynching a villager.

I guess this is good timing. Heading out of town for a bit this weekend.

I haven't been converted, but my role is pretty much completely used up, so.

Gotta check who started this bandwagon, pretty please. Because it's definitely not in my best interests.

voting still isnt technically closed yet. WTF can still save the day (maybe?) if she swaps her vote.
 
voting still isnt technically closed yet. WTF can still save the day (maybe?) if she swaps her vote.

SOV stated that after 8pm no matter whether it's closed or not things don't count, I do believe. :)

Could be worse. Being a villager is generally boring anyways.
 
also WTF I did see your comment. just forgot to give you credit. like i said. fever is a hell of a mind altering state.

images
 
I know for a fact I'm not pink. Therefore, I'm fine with lynching pink people until they're all gone, because that way I know my group (villagers) will be safe. Not saying we shouldn't keep a last wolf on our minds, but....

They cannot only be in the game to confuse us - that's too simple.

The only other scenario I can come up with is that they were specifically linked to Dexter. My guess is probably that if all the pinkies were dead, something would happen with regards to Dexter, since his goal is to obviously rid the world of serial killers.
 
My issue initially arose because jj killed dvmd....hence my initial hesitation...but now thinking on it more I think that if the serial killers can kill all the wolves and then outnumber the villagers, they will win.

I could be totally off base. But I think it's a solid theory overall.
 
There was even a game (Doctor Who) where there was a second group of 'wolves' that couldn't kill but who could have won the game.
 
I killed DVMD because as far as I know, I'm on the side of the villagers. We don't have a specific win condition. I think we're pink because we get special abilities? We weren't given a definitive reason.
 
Final Lynch vote tally

JJohnston 4 (Nohika, Devyn, trematode,doce)
Devyn 3 (WS, LIS, JJ)
nohika 5 (FTB, Escalla, Dyachei, hedgie, WTF)

SDN doesn't like me tonight :(
 
Who killed Roger Rabbit? No, I mean who killed Swingnsave? No I mean DVMDream? Oh, forget it, misread the message. And what is up with those pinkies? And no-name roles? And Viktor? What is he? And what about dreaming in the middle of the day? And SDN server problems? WTF?

In a day with a lot of talk, not a lot was decided, except that lynching Nohika was not a good idea, but alas, that is what you have done. You have killed Nohika, Harry Morgan, villager who unfortunately never got to communicate with his son from the dead... parents are NOT supposed to outlive their children, even in WW.

It is Night 9 . PM deadline is 7am.

There are 11 players left.

Here is your roster:

2- dyachei
6 - Escalla
7 - jjohnston
9 - Devyn
15 - The LIS
16 -Wolfspeaker
19 - Trema
21 - WTF
23 - FTB
24 -hedgie
27. DocISwearImNotAWolfThisTimeEspana

4-tropictuco Debra Morgan
11 - kpowell14 Joey Quinn
12 - sheepdog Nadia
14 -Lupin21 Angel Batista
18 - nohika Harry Morgan
20 -Swings Frank Lundy
22 - Orcagirl Jane/John Doe?
26- FH Rita Bennet

17 - that redhead Dexter

1-SnS Miguel Prado
10 - wildcatj Lumen Pierce
13 - Lab Rat83 Isaak Sirko

3-DVMD , Travis Marshall, Doomsday Killer
5 - kaydubssss, Brian Moser
8 - Jamr0ckin, Jordan Chase, Eugene Greer, Motivational speaking killer
25- FFM Arthur Mitchell, The Trinity Kiler

Reminder: links to all results can be found on post #1
 
Ummm no I'm not. That is a typo by SOV. That was a vote from JJ for me.

I'm at the pub trying to follow along here. I voted for JJ. If you see I am on the vote twice.

I am Captain Matthews. I can investigate relationships. I have not been converted. Do not lynch me.

Sorry. :( I haven't caught up on the thread, so I don't know if you're alive or dead, but I should have noticed that you were on there twice, which wouldn't make sense either. I threw my vote for DocE (which, btw, I'm still feelin'), then saw SOV's total, and made the change hastily on my way out.
 
A failed lynch leads to a failed life. Someone makes the villagers pay for their poor choice of lynching, as Trematode, aka Vince Masuka is murdered. Too bad,we will miss Masuka's porno pics. Well, sort of.

It is Day 10 . Lynch deadline is 8pm or earlier if you have some sudden insights.

There are 10 players left.

Here is your roster:

2- dyachei
6 - Escalla
7 - jjohnston
9 - Devyn
15 - The LIS
16 -Wolfspeaker
21 - WTF
23 - FTB
24 -hedgie
27. DocISwearImNotAWolfThisTimeEspana

4-tropictuco Debra Morgan
11 - kpowell14 Joey Quinn
12 - sheepdog Nadia
14 -Lupin21 Angel Batista
18 - nohika Harry Morgan
19 - TremaVince Masuka
20 -Swings Frank Lundy
22 - Orcagirl Jane/John Doe?
26- FH Rita Bennet

17 - that redhead Dexter

1-SnS Miguel Prado
10 - wildcatj Lumen Pierce
13 - Lab Rat83 Isaak Sirko

3-DVMD , Travis Marshall, Doomsday Killer
5 - kaydubssss, Brian Moser
8 - Jamr0ckin, Jordan Chase, Eugene Greer, Motivational speaking killer
25- FFM Arthur Mitchell, The Trinity Kiler

Reminder: links to all results can be found on post #1
 
But what is it? Do they have their own win criteria? Are they the only convertible ones? Am I totally off base? Idk. Maybe its my fever talking, but there has to be something to the pinkies more than being pink.

Dude, if you figure out what it is, let me know. I've gone back and reviewed our initial role PM, and as far as I can tell, our sole purpose is to create confusion. Which, you'll note, was pretty damn effective on SOV's part. We had one of the most glorious days of arguing and then through some good/lucky investigating went on a wolf streak... and now we're back to wondering about the pinkies.

Sort of brings me back to day 1 and everyone in that group assuming they were wolves. Little tidbit shared by glorious leader LIS.... they were all so convinced they were wolves that they sent in kill actions only to find out they weren't the (true?) Wolves. LIS is no newbie. How does he make that mistake?

Let's pretend it's the beginning of a game. Let's pretend you open up your mail and find a PM from the mod telling you that you're Lila the frickin pyromaniac who tried to kentucky fry chicken Dexter and two kids. Oh, and you're described as 'killers'. (Toothless killers, to be exact, but still killers). Did I pause and wonder at the 'toothless'? Yeah. For a second. Then I shook my head and said "Ok, whatever" and moved on.

Yeah, I assumed we were wolves. *shrug* And so yeah, we operated that way for the first night (including sending in a kill move), until we got a late-round PM from SOV saying "Yo, douchebags, you can't kill, you aren't wolves."

*shrug*

I still think you're crooked, DocE. Could people have figured out that LR was a pinkie? Sure. But there's no reason for the wolves to go after her (him?) that specific night unless they knew LR was key to putting the hammer down on the wolves with that rez move. The *most consistent* thing is that you were converted, I told you the plan, and you said "****, wolves, we have to take out LR." Am I positive? Hell no. But it's the most likely and consistent scenario. So I'm going with it until the rest of you lynch me or DocE gets lynched and I get to find out if I'm right or wrong.
 
A failed lynch leads to a failed life. Someone makes the villagers pay for their poor choice of lynching, as Trematode, aka Vince Masuka is murdered. Too bad,we will miss Masuka's porno pics. Well, sort of.

It is Day 10 . Lynch deadline is 8pm or earlier if you have some sudden insights.

There are 10 players left.

Here is your roster:

2- dyachei
6 - Escalla
7 - jjohnston
9 - Devyn
15 - The LIS
16 -Wolfspeaker
21 - WTF
23 - FTB
24 -hedgie
27. DocISwearImNotAWolfThisTimeEspana

4-tropictuco Debra Morgan
11 - kpowell14 Joey Quinn
12 - sheepdog Nadia
14 -Lupin21 Angel Batista
18 - nohika Harry Morgan
19 - TremaVince Masuka
20 -Swings Frank Lundy
22 - Orcagirl Jane/John Doe?
26- FH Rita Bennet

17 - that redhead Dexter

1-SnS Miguel Prado
10 - wildcatj Lumen Pierce
13 - Lab Rat83 Isaak Sirko

3-DVMD , Travis Marshall, Doomsday Killer
5 - kaydubssss, Brian Moser
8 - Jamr0ckin, Jordan Chase, Eugene Greer, Motivational speaking killer
25- FFM Arthur Mitchell, The Trinity Kiler

Reminder: links to all results can be found on post #1
lynch JJ cause pink is no different than villager, but they are still pink. Apparently I'm strategically xenophobic.
 
Hey. I said it from day 2 onwards. I dont blame anyone who wants to off me. I've had the most f**king ridi ulous character arc this game. But it still doesn't involve conversion. My feeling is: if SOVs goal was for you to only represent confusion, you wouldn't be a different color all together.

Could it be wtf or escalla who is the wolf? Oh totally. But too many questions remain about the pink crew for me to be able to look past them and their unusual predicament forever. I'm with you. I need to know if I'm right. If the game ends when you two kick the bucket.
 
lynch DocE for the same reasons as LIS. I said it then and I'll say it again. The killing of LR was entirely too coincidental. It was either LIS or DocE, and for the moment I still believe that LIS hasn't been converted.
 
Not sure who to lynch, but jj is clear. I've used my last power in the game and her role description says she was resurrected "Ironically" still a pinky and as Viktor could kill once.

No mention of a pinky win condition in the description.
 
Not sure who to lynch, but jj is clear. I've used my last power in the game and her role description says she was resurrected "Ironically" still a pinky and as Viktor could kill once.

This is all true. It's also why I wasn't lying when I said the pinkies had a one-time kill ability (namely, my role-stealing ability). At the time I said it, it was true. When LR rez'd JJ, fresh JJ came with that ability.

Whoever LR rez'd would have been a pinkie with that ability. The "ironically" comment is no doubt because JJ was a pinkie and came back a pinkie.
 
I voted for nohika because I wasn't sold on jj or devyn and I felt she was a good conversion candidate. I would look hard at those who voted for nohika w/o a vested interest in saving their own butt from lynch.

My instincts suck, my role info is good though.
 
Lynch vote tally:

DocE 2 (LIS,jj)
JJ 1 (DocE)
LIS 1 (Dyachei)

4 uncast votes. 1/2 way there.

Deadline is 8pm. Hopefully earlier. I will be in and mostly out all day, so deal with it.
 
Got home from the pub last night and passed out. Lol

Not really sure who to lynch but I still think the labrat thing was odd and since LIS brought it to our attention I am inclined to think he is ok

So for now.

lynch DocE
 
Lynch vote tally:

DocE 3 (LIS,jj, Devyn)
JJ 1 (DocE)
LIS 1 (Dyachei)

5 uncast votes. Roll Call: FTB, WS, Hedgie, WTF, Escalla

Deadline is 8pm. Hopefully earlier. I will be in and mostly out all day, so deal with it.
 
I don't care which pinky I kill.

unlynch JJ, lynch lis

Again. Totally not a wolf or convert. Anyone with a brain could have pit together lr was sirko and had the opportunity to die there.
 
Lynch vote tally:

DocE 3 (LIS,jj, Devyn)
LIS 2 (Dyachei, DocE)

Waffle-o-meter; -1-

5 uncast votes. Roll Call: FTB, WS, Hedgie, WTF, Escalla

Deadline is 8pm. Hopefully earlier. I will be in and mostly out all day, so deal with it!
 
I have NO idea who to vote for.

I'm tempted to vote for Escalla JUST because she would be an obvious choice NOT to convert.


Lynch DocE
 
Lynch vote tally:

DocE 4 (LIS,jj, Devyn, WS)
LIS 2 (Dyachei, DocE)

Waffle-o-meter; -1-

4 uncast votes. Roll Call: FTB, Hedgie, WTF, Escalla

Deadline is 8pm. Hopefully earlier. I will be in and mostly out all day, so deal with it!
 
*****lynch dyachei*****

I'm not feeling either of the options right now although I buy DocE as a convert over LIS. Dyachei is a good wolf and she's been pretty under the radar. Plus she has a new player backing her hard saying she assumes that role couldn't be converted. Unless explicitly told they can't be I would always assume every role could be converted.
 
Top