There is a lot of good info in the thread from the class of 2009 if you search for it. Otherwise here is my quick run-down of the best places that are CLOSE to campus (ie around a mile). This is also my just my opinion...keep that in mind.
I don't know too much about places that are a little further...as traffic around here is brutal and I didn't even consider living further then a few miles from the school. In no particular order my top two: Beekman Place (where I live- 100% satisfied) and Greenbriar. Both are all-inclusive w/ utilitites, extremely close to campus and decent amt of space...great bang for your buck. There are some other very popular ones right around here, but for different reasons I don't like them as much as the above 2.....Presidential, Duffield, Lincoln Green and Imperial. Good luck w/ your search...I would reccommend setting up few days to come up here w/i the next few months to actually check the places out and form your own opinions.