- Joined
- Jan 20, 2018
- Messages
- 966
- Reaction score
- 859
Last edited:
For med school, I am not very confident aside from the specific connections that the MSMS has. Unrelated schools will likely not want to take a chance, especially if you have a sub 500 MCAT. The MCAT is one of the main predictors of success on board exams.If nothing else, the program was to fix my failure at optometry school more than anything else. With the previous low MCATs and my undergrad GPA (it also wasn't that good, but a strong post-bacc did help somewhat), I did get two DO interviews, but those were ultimately waitlists.
The MSMS program does have linkages, which what I'm partially gambling on as well.
So your opinion is that my application is DOA, even if I do well in the MSMS? That was definitely my concern after being dismissed - I wasn't long in the program: just about one term before they voted to sack me. I'm aware that this is going to haunt me for any professional school, but I was trying to do my darnest to get over the hump.
My recommendations believed that it somewhat alleviates the issue, but I've heard opinions from many folks - that it is effective, not effective for med but for others and your app is DOA for all healthcare fields.
See LizzyM's staircase analogy:I understand. Just wondering how I got those interviews in the past though. They too saw my meh MCATs and still tried to take a chance on me.
I suppose that is an option. That is where I am at the moment though. My attempt at optometry school was to go higher, but I blew it. That would mean that this program was frankly a waste of time and money.
Concerning the boards though, my program will be requiring the NBME Comprehensive Basic Science Self-Assessments to graduate. They say it is to prove to adcoms readiness for the test.
How many MCATs are we talking?and a slew of failed MCATs (like below 500 bad).
I really don’t want to say, which is kinda a hint of how bad it is.
Fine! Its past 3. I nearly used up all my chances for the MCAT for a lifetime. To preface, my program director in the MSMS program knows about this because I had to turn in all my documents to him to apply for the program.
Sorry for the outburst.
Question: Running the numbers for a worst-case scenario (all B's) puts me at a 3.43 GPA for the Master's Program. I'm obviously not gunning for that low amount, but could that still put me in the running for DO schools? I'm aware that it isn't the sterling 3.5 (and I'm sure Goro will roast my record because of the professional failure), but I'm curious.
Oh! I meant worst case scenario for my last term. Thus far, I only have one B and all A's, including a nine credit monster in the form of Anatomy. That is why the program director agreed to write a recommendation for me - he liked that progress.
I'm within shooting distance for at least two A's (not exactly A's, but the program rounds grades and adjusts the curve - I luckily never had to use it yet, but it has given people a boost in grades). The other two courses are a bit far away B's, but I'm hoping to raise them up before the term ends in May.
Why did you flunk that first quiz so hard?I flunked my first quiz hard (like so bad that the professor said it had to be a record)
There is a clinical aspect in med school, as well as OMM for DO schools, so those would still be areas of concern. While I do not know the scope of your lab course and how involved it was, there will certainly be tests for physical exams for things like accommodation, visual field etc in addition to other organ systems.I saw @Goro roaming around these parts.
I'm guessing that I'm DOA at med school in general. If that is the case, then what can I do with this master's degree? I'm starting to think that I should've quit when I was ahead...and that these A's mean jack nothing.
A point of argument I was going to bring up was that the two failed courses were optometry-specific classes that have no equivalent in medicine: a math-based optics course (glorified physics) and an optometric clinic lab. The regular sciences like anatomy, physiology, histology and neurology are courses I either passed or did better than pass. Medicine obviously doesn't have optics or other such optometry courses, so I would say that it could be worth arguing against when paired with my master's program grades - that optometry just wasn't really what I can do and that my science skills aren't completely pickled.
If nothing else, the program director said as much, in his opinion. I'm mostly perusing medicine again based on his advice and his willingness to supply me with a med school recommendation letter.
Yipes. This is unequivocal. The door is closed.I might shadow one more time, though I’m not overly fond of feet.
I did contact my local podiatry school though for the heck of it and they effectively implied that I’m DOA at their school, even if I did alright in the masters program.
According to my program director, my case is probably going to be a case-by-case issue. He even told me that some nursing and tech programs may not take me due of my past failures.
Is there an actual linkage with the home medical school? Be aware that conflicts of interest have to be managed properly. He may be on the admissions committee, but your file discussion will occur without him or any of the other Master's program faculty serving on the committee. If your admission can be guaranteed if you meet conditions of an articulation agreement/MOU, then sure... it would be your only shot.Well, closed for that school. I only talked to one. There are lots of podiatry schools after all. Anyways, I’m not too interested in feet…
The program director actually recommended I tried for medicine because his school is looking to recruit more masters students - he is on adcoms alongside my other professors. He reasoned that they don’t get the culture shock that happens from undergrad to graduate work, which is frankly what caused my spiral in optometry school. The work load is insane going from the first level to the second.
Not DOA; you do need to show that you can handle medical school.I saw @Goro roaming around these parts.
I'm guessing that I'm DOA at med school in general. If that is the case, then what can I do with this master's degree? I'm starting to think that I should've quit when I was ahead...and that these A's mean jack nothing.
A point of argument I was going to bring up was that the two failed courses were optometry-specific classes that have no equivalent in medicine: a math-based optics course (glorified physics) and an optometric clinic lab. The regular sciences like anatomy, physiology, histology and neurology are courses I either passed or did better than pass. Medicine obviously doesn't have optics or other such optometry courses, so I would say that it could be worth arguing against when paired with my master's program grades - that optometry just wasn't really what I can do and that my science skills aren't completely pickled.
If nothing else, the program director said as much, in his opinion. I'm mostly perusing medicine again based on his advice and his willingness to supply me with a med school recommendation letter.
The MS program and a good MCAT score.Okay! Will the master's program help with that then? I'm just pleasantly surprised that I'm doing relatively alright in the classes, though I'm always shooting for more A's.
Despite my emotions leaking out here and then, I do appreciate you and the other's advice on this forum. Its tough love that is appreciated.
It may be a good idea to self analyze and find out why you keep failing, otherwise you will continue to repeat the past.To add onto this, any opinion on school lists would be helpful as well. I'm busy crafting my reapplication materials in anticipation for potentially trying again. I'm frankly not being picky - I just would like to get into somewhere, God willing.
I’d leave healthcare altogether if I could reset. Take the gift and run. But seriously, multiple MCAT attempts don’t bode well for you. I’ve had classmates waste 4 years trying to take step 1 before getting kicked out all the while paying full tuition.
OPs posts sound like they want to hear reassurance but I think the key thing to consider is plenty of DO or IMG schools will look at your stats and maybe even accept you l. The problem is they may not actually help you enough to graduate and that sucks.
my point is don’t go just because you can get inOh please don’t advertise img school. Especially with the new DO school expansion, IMGs are being pushed out even more.
I mean maybe they made it past step 1 then also failed step 2. Same result of 4 yrs. No degree and only dept.I thought med schools kicked you out way before that
I’m only considering it because it was brought up by my program director, who is willing to write a recommendation for me.OPs posts sound like they want to hear reassurance but I think the key thing to consider is plenty of DO or IMG schools will look at your stats and maybe even accept you l. The problem is they may not actually help you enough to graduate and that sucks.
Healthcare, in my opinion, is still a pretty secure job environment. I’ve frankly been grinding it out so long that everything else in my life has atrophied. I’m pretty old too - late 20s with nothing to show for it.I’d leave healthcare altogether if I could reset. Take the gift and run. But seriously, multiple MCAT attempts don’t bode well for you. I’ve had classmates waste 4 years trying to take step 1 before getting kicked out all the while paying full tuition.
My opinion, the OP has failed out of optometry school. Medical school is much more demanding. If he or she wants to become an advanced provider, I’d suggest RN to NP, but honestly I would recommend a different career. You should go to medical school or optometry school to be those professions, not because you failed out of the other one. Find a career, then decide if you need training. I honestly would get a job, work for a while before committing to a long academic course.
Hi sorry to hear about what happened. I admire your persistence and I wish you the best.That was what I was doing prior to applications: working in an eye clinic in both a medical and research capacity.
I was on my third try for medicine when I decided to shoot my shot with optometry, which I thought I would do fine because of my work background. I was very mistaken. I am somehow doing a lot better in this graduate program, which is why I'm lookng at applying into professional school again. This was also recommended to me by another optometry school, though I have now shifted my attention back towards medicine.
Alternative careers wise, I was playing with the idea of law because I did pretty well on the GRE (which is accepted by many institutions). I could potentially pair my medical knowledge with either patents or malpractice, I suppose - utilize this graduate program for something other than a money sink.
Hi sorry to hear about what happened. I admire your persistence and I wish you the best.
You mentioned bad grades in optometry that led to the dismissal.
1. Did they give you a chance to remediate?
2. What was the problem that led to your course failure, and do you think you've corrected them?
To be frank, I would've just waved the flag if I was flunking the master's program. I mean...it isn't easy because we get the same tests as the med students, but I studied hard and pulled decent results. I'm just worried that I'm now an academic leper because of what my optometry school did. It wasn't unjustified, but it feels like I'm effectively doomed - that top-tier healthcare as a profession is now a complete dead end, despite what I do in my master's program.
1. They did not give me a chance to remediate. I was there for my first year of fall term and I was kicked out after that. I was quite disappointed that I wasn't given a second chance, but it is what it is. It wasn't like they were out of bounds for throwing me to the curb.
2. I think it was just adapting to the whole affair: I left my home state for the first time in my life and wasn't used to the deluge of grad school courses. I adapted to most of them, but ended up failing at two courses - both very optometry-related (a math-based optics course and an optometric-focused clinic course).
I am unfortunately unable to correct those two courses on my own (they're very specific to optometry school), but I enrolled myself in a medical school-like master's program and am doing well in it: all A's and one B over two terms. I'm hoping to get more A's this coming and final term.
---
To be frank, I would've just waved the flag if I was flunking the master's program. I mean...it isn't easy because we get the same tests as the med students, but I studied hard and pulled decent results. I'm just worried that I'm now an academic leper because of what my optometry school did. It wasn't unjustified, but it feels like I'm effectively doomed - that top-tier healthcare as a profession is now a complete dead end, despite what I do in my master's program.
I believe the OP indicated this happened earlier and it is likely too late to change that #1Most schools allow some form of remediation.
Please check your student handbook regarding remediation policy and let me know what you find out.
I should have elaborated. I wanted to know if they offered him remediation as part of their student handbook policy (if remediation is part of it since most schools offer it). If it was part of their policy and the OP indicated they did not offer him that opportunity, then he may have a case against them, retroactively speaking.I believe the OP indicated this happened earlier and it is likely too late to change that #1
From what they have shared about their experience, I do not think they would want to try going back to that school at this point either.
I cannot recommend an MD application in which you will not know the outcome of the MCAT until September.I’ve been talking with schools whether I can have them hold my application till September since I plan to take it in August.
Let me explain further. I don't think it comes off as arrogant. It comes off as unsure of yourself. If you get interviews and you are asked about improved grades you shall NOT answer with any verbiage that seems like it's 'luck' or you 'surprised yourself'. That sounds like you didn't really know what you did but somehow the grades just happened. We all know that's not the case, but that's what it comes off as.Apologies about the “luck” rant concerning the classes. I’ve definitely figured out some regimen to study for these courses, so my way of tackling them is different from how it was in yesteryear. I think that is paying off - I just surprised myself, though it isn’t coming from a place of arrogant confidence.
As the DO cycle lasts longer, it could work, but you have spent a year doing a degree whose only value is to improve your odds of acceptance at a medical school. It would seem reasonable not to skimp on any aspect within your control.I understand.
What about DO chances? I’ve talked to some schools: some seen receptive, others think a new MCAT may be prudent (though some also pointed out the multiple retakes is obviously a bad look) and then there were a few that have outright said I have no chance fulll stop.
For your circumstances, you would a polished application that is ready to be submitted on the first day. As I said before, a DO letter would be essential too.I understand.
What about DO chances? I’ve talked to some schools: some seen receptive, others think a new MCAT may be prudent (though some also pointed out the multiple retakes is obviously a bad look) and then there were a few that have outright said I have no chance fulll stop.
I'm just pleasantly surprised that I'm doing relatively alright in the classes
pleasantly surprised
everything else in my life has atrophied. I’m pretty old too - late 20s with nothing to show for it.
Healthcare, in my opinion, is still a pretty secure job environment. I’ve frankly been grinding it out so long that everything else in my life has atrophied. I’m pretty old too - late 20s with nothing to show for it.
Optometry was a Hail Mary that instead exploded in my face: a reckless waste of money and storytelling to adcoms.