I am curious. I have been reading the profiles on this thread. Most people who have posted on this thread only apply to three to five schools, and almost all of these schools are in the South. This is very different from the typical SDN profile where generally an applicant will apply to 15-20 schools located in various geographical areas all over the United States. Why is this? Deep afinity for the South, fear of leaving the familiarity of the South, no interest in living in another area of the country, stronger family ties in the South. I understand that attending your state school is less expensive, but there must be more to it than just that - since that factor applies to everyone other than those who do not have a state school such as New Hampshire. I don't see this with applicants from the East Coast, the West Coast, or the midwest who apply to med schools scattered around the country. It is an interesting sociological phenomena. The principle of applying broadly and widely does not seem to apply to applicants from the South in general.
I am from the South and I applied pretty broadly, I think you are making a fantastic generalization. Anecdotally, many of my friends from all over the country went/applied to their state schools and then added on a few reach and a few safety. That being said where they ended up depended on stats and financial resources. My friends from the South applied as broadly as my friends from other parts of the country. I think you're taking anecdotal evidence from a thread clearly titled "Alabama Schools Thread" and blowing it out to a whole class of applicants, of whom maybe 90% haven't posted here.