if this thread has made me realize anything is how different guys and girls really are...
and the mystery method may be good for picking up girls, but i hgihly doubt that it will often lead to any meaningful relationships.
This is where you girls (and some of the guys) keep missing the point. I challenge you to determine what makes you attracted to your significant other. I'm willing to bet most of the factors contributing to your attraction stem from his or her character and personality traits that became apparent to you after spending some time with this person. I'm also willing to bet that if you were in a social situation with that person before ever meeting them and they just sat quietly on the other side of the room without ever saying anything to you, that you would probably pay them little attention (again you have to imagine that you had never met them before). But if they walked up to you and began a conversation and began conveying their personality to you, you would communicate back with them and maybe the attraction would eventually spark.
Relationships are built on attraction to the deeper values and character traits, not on the initial approach and small talk. In order to have a relationship you must have some sort of initial interaction. The goal of the mystery method is to make that initial interaction easier for men who uncomfortable in such a situation and allow them a chance to get your attention and convey who they really are to you.
Granted many people meet through mutual relationships with friends or by being friends first. But if you think about it, such a situation is just allowing you to get to know who the other person is in a no-pressure situation which is exactly what mystery is trying to accomplish. You can't convey a personality that doesn't exist so there is no falseness to it.
Futhermore, those of you who say you prefer to meet people through friends first are missing out on tons of opportunities. Sure, you might find the perfect person in your current social group, but what if the perfect person is somewhere out there in those millions of other people whom you likely will never have a social interaction with? Just think about all the opportunities you will miss by limiting yourself to only interacting with friends. I am a very interesting and attractive guy, but I wouldn't be in the relationship I am in currently if I hadn't had the initial interactions with my girlfriend at some point. Whether that interaction happened naturally or with the help of mystery's methods doesn't really matter because my girlfriend doesn't even remember what we talked about for the first few minutes/hours of getting to know each other and neither do I.
The real game is what kind of partner do you want. If you want a girl like those on SDN (I am looking at you pianola), then you treat them with respect and be yourself. But if you want some no-name, used to look good in HS, personality to come home with you, don't be afraid to try the Mystery Method.
I want a respectable lady, and not a pincushion.
Completely incorrect. See above.
I bet that if you approached any of these girls in a social situation (at least the ones that have any self value) with the attitude that you have about it you will be very unsuccessful (unless you have the looks of brad pitt or something) because you will convey little value in yourself and if you don't see yourself as valuable then why should they? And if you did have success with them, it is because you are subconsciously conveying traits which display your value to them. Some guys don't have this natural ability and that is what I'm trying to explain.
hitch definitely had some good moves i think
Also incorrect. What hollywood makes you think you are attracted to and what you are actually attracted to are different.
The reason you think Hitch had good moves (while I'll admit some of his stuff is good) is because you see his true character as developed throughout the movie. He has a natural confidence and charisma about him that makes him attractive (plus he's good looking). If someone like Alfred Breneman (or whatever his student's name was) approached you like a bumbling idiot with no confidence or charisma you would probably turn your backs and walk away. He does not convey any self value and therefore there is no reason you should be attracted to him.