Cat's MeoWW - Game Thread
Started by finnickthedog
Yes, I'm always happy to provide reasoning when people ask.
Coopah:
> Threw a lot of accusations out at people D1.
> Poor reasoning for initial D1 lynch.
> Didn't seem engaged/was a lazy player, especially when they didn't change their initial D1 vote even after saying they would change it if better info came up.
PippyPony:
> Your initial D1 vote on kata was interesting.
> Other players have posted as little or less than me, I'm curious why you chose to target me in particular.
> Some of the things you've said haven't made sense.
Really? I feel like when a wolf is up they clam up to try and get people to forget about them and go elsewhere with discussion? There were also a lot of people being discussed yesterday, I would think at least someone out of the like 4 way tie for second was statistically a wolf?
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Can you please clarify what you're asking here?
I'm basically saying that there is a similarity between the people you have been voting for & the night kill choice of AM.
Most wolves don't like active players; it freaks them out. And when those loud players are somewhat on target, it freaks wolves out to the point where they want those players dead.
I think this depends a lot on timing.
Unofficial D3 Caturday Tally
Pipperoo (3) - acanth, Capri, coop aka mel
acanth (3) - pip, cubs, sporty
Mel aka Coop (1) - zigzagoon
Capri (1) - Lawper
Dina (1) - Miz
10/17 voting
Pipperoo (3) - acanth, Capri, coop aka mel
acanth (3) - pip, cubs, sporty
Mel aka Coop (1) - zigzagoon
Capri (1) - Lawper
Dina (1) - Miz
10/17 voting
###unlynch coop
Lynch miz###
Lynch miz###
This is the second day you’ve lynched me. Why am I so interesting?
@acanthuroidei you said my Kata vote was "interesting" -- can you clarify what you thought was interesting?
For the sake of everyone else, this is the exchange from that day:
Then @ziggyandjazzy asked me why I voted for Kata, and I said:
I'm not sure why that is particularly interesting -- I had an early feels read, I voted in accordance with that read, I explained it at the time it happened, and it turned out to be correct.
For the sake of everyone else, this is the exchange from that day:
I thought those all sounded like wolfy "talking but not contributing" statements that I have seen Kata make before as a wolf, so...
Then @ziggyandjazzy asked me why I voted for Kata, and I said:
I'm not sure why that is particularly interesting -- I had an early feels read, I voted in accordance with that read, I explained it at the time it happened, and it turned out to be correct.
And that^ is the tally right after that explanation, in case anyone finds that useful at all, now or later on.Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (1) - AM
miz (1) - Lawpy
acan (3) - Barks, Coop, Mel
AM () -
Lawpy (2) - cubs, ziggy
genny (2) - miz, Sporty
capri (1) - Nav
kata (1) - Pippy
Sporty () -
Mel (2) - Dina, genny
Barks (2) - MsP, dolphin
15/20
acan, you are in the lead
Missing: kata, acan, capri, allie, Paws
lynch close in ~40 minutes
What is she wrong about?
lynch acanthy
Could also go Capri again but I don’t like acanthy’s votes and lack of participation
Could also go Capri again but I don’t like acanthy’s votes and lack of participation
I like the Miz vote
lynch Miz
we are ready for the more participation you mentioned
lynch Miz
we are ready for the more participation you mentioned
Agree to disagree.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Also I just don’t feel that pippy is a wolf
Is no one even looking at our vote trackers?
Ok the mizzy votes are interesting. I'm currently stuck in the Navs-Pawsy-capri triangle because they're looking wolfy to me for different reasons (based on content, voting behavior etc). Capri's voting behavior is bothering me though.
I'm ok with the acanthy/roidy lynch. I don't think Pippy is an original wolf though.
I'm ok with the acanthy/roidy lynch. I don't think Pippy is an original wolf though.
I don't vote based on "feels," and I don't use anyone else's "feels" when making my lynch votes. I think you either are a) a wolf who placed a vote on kata D1 so that you could refer back to that later for "village cred" or b) a villager who got lucky. Obviously I think you're the first since I'm voting to lynch you.
I don't think a lucky D1 vote gives anyone "village cred." Wolves are the only ones who know who anyone is D1 and everyone else has no clue what they're doing, although people sure like to pretend otherwise.
Why do I look wolfy to you? When did you become concerned I was a wolf?
See, now I'm okay with a roids lynch.
Coop/Mel is voting pips
This hasn't been answered this yet, also curious to see what @PippyPony has to say.
Or, third option -- I have been doing this for long enough now where I occasionally interpret things correctly. I know it's not a common occurrence, but I don't always suck lol
But whatever, enjoy being wrong again when I am dead
Oops my bad just saw the answer, sorry Pippy.
This doesn't address the "why."
why?
so this strikes me as weird... do you think I'm village or not? because you implied I was then quickly pulled back like oh no I'm not saying she is. weird...
it will be interesting to navigate this game without night results I think
agree with this 100%
what are the few small reasons?
when did I ever vote for miz?
And in terms of village cred...this tally today should be self-evident as to why that would have been a terrible strategy. I said earlier that it would be the height of stupidity to try to get weak village cred by introducing a bus on an extra kill. Like, numbers-wise and general manipulative strategy-wise, just not a good move and not something I would do because it's never worth it.
But again, you can decide to believe me or not.
But again, you can decide to believe me or not.
That is the "why." I'm not sure what else you're looking for.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Why's that?
@Ms Procrastinator @dolphin106258 @Dinashadow what are your reads?
This is a good grouping and I would also like to hear their reads.
Before when acan was in the lead. They only posted 4 times and they had acquired 2 votes before they even posted (The whole thing was explained yesterday). Now they're starting to talk more and people are having real reasons for lynching them.
@Ms Procrastinator I'd love to know why she hasn't voted yet if she likes the lynch on acantg...
Since N1/D2 because of voting behavior concerns. The Navs stuff is just complicating things.
As for my reads
I'm neutral towards pip right now.
Don't know what to make of Nav and his whole seer thing.
I'm leaning neutral to slightly wolfy for acan based on some things I've seen
Don't understand zigg/SAR
Have no read on Cubs
I'm neutral to slightly village on capri. This is subject to change pending her appearance today.
I'm neutral towards pip right now.
Don't know what to make of Nav and his whole seer thing.
I'm leaning neutral to slightly wolfy for acan based on some things I've seen
Don't understand zigg/SAR
Have no read on Cubs
I'm neutral to slightly village on capri. This is subject to change pending her appearance today.
So essentially you are neutral on everyone?
I'm getting there hold on. I don't like to rush things tho
Not really. I have village reads too.
Then why not vote for me yesterday?
What voting pattern? Does two days of voting make a pattern? How is a pattern affected by being on the block?
This is a whole lot of words to say not a lot. What don't you understand about me? what about Dina, dolph, Allie?
I'm not rushing. Who are you considering voting for?
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Because I don't trust Navs. And capri looks just as wolfy to me.
I was referring to how you voted in D1, since something about that bothered me.
I'm considering Acan right now
You left at around 10 because today seemed pointless to you.
I just don’t think you being argumentative and leaving automatically makes you a villager lol
Idk I’m at work and didn’t look back when I asked that
Scratch wants to contribute to caturday
