InFreudWeTrust
Full Member
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2020
- Messages
- 61
- Reaction score
- 272
Thanks ERAS, for the whole 510 characters for "Awards and Accomplishments"...I almost fit the titles and dates for two of them.
Thanks ERAS, for the whole 510 characters for "Awards and Accomplishments"...I almost fit the titles and dates for two of them.
Yes you can apply to multiple at one program, very common for specialties that have both a research track and regular track as wellI somehow thought the application would be a lot more intricate ha. Seems fairly basic.
Anyways...it's cool to apply to multiple tracks at the same hospital, right? Like, if they offer regular IM and also IM primary care, I can apply to both?
None is fine. Or you can leave it blank. In the past, this section was titled "Honors and Awards". My fav was when people listed all of the courses / clerkships they got "honors" in. My super fav were people who did this in medical schools that have a High Honors / Honors / Pass grading system.That’s more than enough for me to write “None.”
Gotta wonder how many people are out here listing stuff like eagle scouts and high school valedictorian, tooNone is fine. Or you can leave it blank. In the past, this section was titled "Honors and Awards". My fav was when people listed all of the courses / clerkships they got "honors" in. My super fav were people who did this in medical schools that have a High Honors / Honors / Pass grading system.
I put Eagle Scout on my application. It came up in almost every interview as a positive thing and one PD told me it was one of the reasons they wanted to interview me.Gotta wonder how many people are out here listing stuff like eagle scouts and high school valedictorian, too
I watched my sibling do it and it seemed to basically amount to building some benches for a schoolI put Eagle Scout on my application. It came up in almost every interview as a positive thing and one PD told me it was one of the reasons they wanted to interview me.
Reminds me of a kid I went to undergrad with who listed taking care of his dog (“Think what you want! It’s hard work and shows responsibility!”) as a meaningful activity on his med school appGotta wonder how many people are out here listing stuff like eagle scouts and high school valedictorian, too
That's not what getting an Eagle Scout entails.....I watched my sibling do it and it seemed to basically amount to building some benches for a school
Are physicians really out here awarding interview slots to other physicians over benches they built in high school ??
That was their "service project"That's not what getting an Eagle Scout entails.....
Right, which is a tiny aspect of it. I wouldn't put Eagle Scout in the same basket as listing the rotations you got Honors in as an "Honor."That was their "service project"
My hobby always came up too, but that's been ongoing. I guess if it's still fun to talk about 10 years later why not put it down!Right, which is a tiny aspect of it. I wouldn't put Eagle Scout in the same basket as listing the rotations you got Honors in as an "Honor."
I'm not kidding. I went on almost 20 interviews, and it came up in just about every single one in a very positive way.
If that's how you want to view it I guess. I could be more specific with what was said to me about it but all I will say is that it wasn't in the same context as hobbies.My hobby always came up too, but that's been ongoing. I guess if it's still fun to talk about 10 years later why not put it down!
Dang do people put stuff like national merit and high level highschool sports on their ERAS too?People view Eagle Scout as a signal for character and leadership. Also, in the South people love it.
It could be mostly bull**** for people in highschool now. No clue. But "scout's honor" and knowing astronauts and presidents were eagle scouts is still common knowledge and sets the brand. It's definitely something to include.
Edit: and to dovetail with my recent post about research I think it holds far more real world weight IMO than doing a couple case reports lol.
Do the 80, even if you're lukewarm on the other 30. You can always cancel interviews. I have friends who would trade a lot more than the app cost to have applied more places.Struggling to get to 50 programs on my list. I literally only want to be in one place, so anything else I add just feels completely random and the websites are often so crappy I can't get any good info from them. Simultaneously, I'm panicking and thinking I need like 80 programs. Rip this process sucks I wish I could just apply to the 20 programs I actually love and call it a day.
Do not do 80.. with your stats and the specialty youre goin for I doubt you even need 50, but I understand that thinking. But 80 is overkill..Struggling to get to 50 programs on my list. I literally only want to be in one place, so anything else I add just feels completely random and the websites are often so crappy I can't get any good info from them. Simultaneously, I'm panicking and thinking I need like 80 programs. Rip this process sucks I wish I could just apply to the 20 programs I actually love and call it a day.
It's more the struggle of finding programs. Just feels like randomly throwing a dart out. Websites suck 95% of the time.Do the 80, even if you're lukewarm on the other 30. You can always cancel interviews. I have friends who would trade a lot more than the app cost to have applied more places.
It's actually because of her stats I say it. I've seen 250+ candidates with great applications fail to match specialties with average boards, and a big part is that nobody believes they'd be interested except the extremely competitive upper end. Yield protection can be bad newsDo not do 80.. with your stats and the specialty youre goin for I doubt you even need 50, but I understand that thinking. But 80 is overkill..
Forgive me if you're being sarcastic but I've not heard of anybody doing that or being a valedictorian or something like that. In fact, the only things I've heard of people doing in high school listed were things that you might be on TV for aside from being an eagle scout.Dang do people put stuff like national merit and high level highschool sports on their ERAS too?
I have conflicting feelings on this. It's my biggest fear about this cycle. Also, as a DO 250+ applicant it's hard to gauge where I fit because the programs where my step is actually in line with their matched residents (based on residency explorer) typically have zero DOs in their programs.It's actually because of her stats I say it. I've seen 250+ candidates with great applications fail to match specialties with average boards, and a big part is that nobody believes they'd be interested except the extremely competitive upper end. Yield protection can be bad news
Dang do people put stuff like national merit and high level highschool sports on their ERAS too?
Not kidding I have no idea what people feel was important from their teenage years. My ERAS was all college and medschool stuff but I didn't earn 20 merit badges for camping skills so I have no idea how much that sticks with you later in life as a secret handshakeForgive me if you're being sarcastic but I've not heard of anybody doing that or being a valedictorian or something like that. In fact, the only things I've heard of people doing in high school listed were things that you might be on TV for aside from being an eagle scout.
If targeting old boys club type programs and specialties then it's not silly. It's a branding opportunity to appeal to these old white dude PDs.
Everyone should include UCSF for rads, they knocked my socks off at interview day. Only major west coast program that is protecting independent call at all their sites - Stanford, UCLA and U of WA have all caved and started transferring to partly or fully attending overread. They would've been my #1 if it wasn't $4,000/mo for a 2bedroom apartment.I've got 58 DR programs saved, but I'll probably apply to the top programs for ****s and gigs. Worst that can happen is that they say no. I mean, realistically no way am I going to get an interview invite to MGH or UCSF, but if I did, I would 100% go for the experience.
Maybe they don't practice it themselves but many places do. This is an obnoxious humblebrag so I apologize in advance, but I can tell you I got 12 of the "top" 15, and only a handful of invites from the other dozens of places I included, many of which I would have actually preferred because we wanted to buy a house. The only way to insulate yourself is to apply to a ton of places and if you have particular ones you'd like that aren't usually filled with 250 applicants, write them a letter and say soI have conflicting feelings on this. It's my biggest fear about this cycle. Also, as a DO 250+ applicant it's hard to gauge where I fit because the programs where my step is actually in line with their matched residents (based on residency explorer) typically have zero DOs in their programs.
Anyways, I've heard from a couple of PDs that yield protection doesn't exist in residency apps. But I can understand the idea of not wanting to 'waste' an interview on an applicant you think is using you as a safety. But like...what does an applicant like me do?? This is why I like the idea of app caps.
Hey man, never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidityAt this point you’re starting to sound like you’re just hating.
That would likely keep me from UCSF as well. I’m also a DO so there’s that massive barrier.Not kidding I have no idea what people feel was important from their teenage years. My ERAS was all college and medschool stuff but I didn't earn 20 merit badges for camping skills so I have no idea how much that sticks with you later in life as a secret handshake
Everyone should include UCSF for rads, they knocked my socks off at interview day. Only major west coast program that is protecting independent call at all their sites - Stanford, UCLA and U of WA have all caved and started transferring to partly or fully attending overread. They would've been my #1 if it wasn't $4,000/mo for a 2bedroom apartment.
Maybe they don't practice it themselves but many places do. This is an obnoxious humblebrag so I apologize in advance, but I can tell you I got 12 of the "top" 15, and only a handful of invites from the other dozens of places I included, many of which I would have actually preferred because we wanted to buy a house. The only way to insulate yourself is to apply to a ton of places and if you have particular ones you'd like that aren't usually filled with 250 applicants, write them a letter and say so
Not at all, I appreciate the honesty. This process is muddled enough already. I'll take another look at my list and try adding some more higher-ranked places.This is an obnoxious humblebrag so I apologize in advance
Dang do people put stuff like national merit and high level highschool sports on their ERAS too?
Is it? I think of national level sports in high school as more impressive than boy scouts, personally. Still would seem weird to put on a physician CV a decade laterMaybe try a little self awareness. This comes across super condescending.
Is it? I think of national level sports in high school as more impressive than boy scouts, personally. Still would seem weird to put on a physician CV a decade later
I didnt list that stuff myself but some PD might have specifically interviewed me from it, so jokes on meYeah, it comes across very much like you’re belittling people who would list that stuff.
Wait i thought @efle was just finding it weird that PDs are highly valuing eagle scoutsYeah, it comes across very much like you’re belittling people who would list that stuff.
I didnt list that stuff myself but some PD might have specifically interviewed me from it, so jokes on me
I'd certainly prefer to think those kinds of minor decisions arent what steer one to their college, medschool and residency programs. But sometimes I bet it does. Weird to think about.Eh it obviously didn’t hurt you.
I'd certainly prefer to think those kinds of minor decisions arent what steer one to their college, medschool and residency programs. But sometimes I bet it does. Weird to think about.
I played national level sports in high school and had a D1 opportunity in one of the big 3. Didn't list that. Eagle Scout is an honor that follows you for life, and like @Neopolymath said is often used as something that is viewed as representing character and leadership. And no, it isn't just at the good old boys programs either, the PD who was the most into it and literally told me it was one of the main reasons they interviewed me was the exact opposite of an old white guy.Is it? I think of national level sports in high school as more impressive than boy scouts, personally. Still would seem weird to put on a physician CV a decade later
Hard to blame a cycle outcome on someone not including their summer lifeguard gigs instead of boardscores, grades and letters, but agree about high value talking points. Stuff I put in the hobbies box with little thought ended up being most of the discussion for some of my interviews. I think often they just want to make sure you're a normal human being that can have a good conversation though (especially in rads haha)I played national level sports in high school and had a D1 opportunity in one of the big 3. Didn't list that. Eagle Scout is an honor that follows you for life, and like @Neopolymath said is often used as something that is viewed as representing character and leadership. And no, it isn't just at the good old boys programs either, the PD who was the most into it and literally told me it was one of the main reasons they interviewed me was the exact opposite of an old white guy.
I listed my ES because of two reasons,1. I had multiple physician mentors tell me to, and 2. my dad told me his has come up in every job interview he's ever had. It's definitely something that can be a talking point, and more than a few people in positions that matter obviously take it as an important accomplishment. After what happened this application cycle and seeing how much it came up I will list it on my CV until I die.
I think people forget residency is a job application, and there is more to life than just excellent academics. On similar train of thought since it came up a bit ago in the thread, I have no idea why anyone would not list work experiences that didn't occur in medical school or weren't healthcare related. Work experience is significant to employers, even if it is just being a part-time McDonald's employee in college. No you can't overcome crappy academics with tons of ECs, work, and life experience, but if you only have academics you're going to struggle pretty bad as well and then post on Reddit complaining how you didn't get the residency you wanted even though you did "everything right." I've seen that story play out far too many times for it to be a coincidence.
/end soapbox
Maybe it was just rads, but I had a hard time breaking out of the region of my school, even though my hometown was listed on ERAS and I primarily applied to that region. I strongly recommend you look into programs in your school region that you’d like, even if you wouldn’t like the location.Struggling to get to 50 programs on my list. I literally only want to be in one place, so anything else I add just feels completely random and the websites are often so crappy I can't get any good info from them. Simultaneously, I'm panicking and thinking I need like 80 programs. Rip this process sucks I wish I could just apply to the 20 programs I actually love and call it a day.
Yeah, Texas was my 2nd highest applied to state for residency after Florida. Didn’t get my favorite bites and so they ones I did ended up ranked lower.@fldoctorgirl Have you looked at Texas? I was short 4 programs (trying to get up to 60) and found 14 more hiding in Texas.
Actually, yes. A good chunk of my OOS programs are Texas ha.@fldoctorgirl Have you looked at Texas? I was short 4 programs (trying to get up to 60) and found 14 more hiding in Texas.
I am applying to all programs in my med school state (and a couple in the neighboring area) that are decent. It's ~8 programs right now.Maybe it was just rads, but I had a hard time breaking out of the region of my school, even though my hometown was listed on ERAS and I primarily applied to that region. I strongly recommend you look into programs in your school region that you’d like, even if you wouldn’t like the location.
The stupid yield protection is real. As a DO with high stats, low tier programs you’re interested in might not bother and think you’re applying wherever and not really interested. Meanwhile, more competitive programs don’t want a DO. I’ve actually wondered if my interview yield would’ve been higher if I shaved 15 points off my boards.
But hey at least we know sacral rocking so it evens out.