- Joined
- Dec 20, 2004
- Messages
- 30,873
- Reaction score
- 10,063
appleluver7 said:Law2Doc: Let's assume you are right: AMCAS and others have sophisticated technology to tap all records at all times and under all circumstances without any legal necessity. In fact, they could even search our houses without warrants for evidence of "lying"! LOL. Why even have us submit our transcripts voluntarily? Wouldn't they just be able to pull them from every school we've ever attended?
Joking aside, how do you feel about Brown University, which allows students to fail classes without being recorded on the transcript? If you fail a class at Brown, the class is not recorded. In fact, there is no evidence the student even took the class. Do you think this is unethical of Brown? Students at Brown could effectively take orgo a couple of times, failing each time and then finally achieve that grade of A. Only of course the A would be recorded and it would only show that the student took the class once. Even if someone found out the student took orgo multiple times, how would this affect the student, since it wasn't the student's fault that Brown didn't release the previous failing grades? In other words, the student sent her transcript from Brown to AMCAS, but Brown was the one doing the concealing. Law2Doc: In a court case: who would be responsible for concealing? Brown or the student?
Regarding your first paragraph, I don't think I ever suggested anyone had the right to "tap" information, warrantless or not. When you apply for a license, you will be required to submit to a background check, fingerprints and the like, and sign forms indicating that the investigator has the right to look into your background, academics, etc. All professions do this. AMCAS is not this.
Regarding the latter paragraph, you must follow the instructions on AMCAS. If Brown doesn't that's fine. But you don't get around not having submitted every transcript from every school you ever intended by using Brown as an example where you would have been allowed to retake had you gone there.