Hey guys......
Here is my daughter's experience from last year:
In her favor: completed BS in Pre-professional science, good EC's, great PCAT (86)
Not in her favor: Average GPA (~3.0), out of state applicant, late application (barely made cupoff date), still missing 3 pre-reqs specific to that school
Now, when she applied to her school of choice, she barely made the final cut-off of March 1 (she took the January PCAT and was waiting for scores). At that time she was an out-of-state applicant to a public institution and through rumor mill, we found out that the school was actually looking at filling about 10 remaining spots. At that time, they were re-reviewing ALL applicants from their ED onward, so she was competing against every appllkicant who hadn't been outright rejected/denied (I have no idea how many) for ten spots. The school was primarily interested in admitting in-state applicants who were pretty darn good, but hadn't quite made the cutoff for the earlier reviews and had been deferred.
My daughter was denied admission. Upon speaking to the lead person on the adcom, she was told that her application definitely stood out, but because she was such a late applicant, and from out of state, she was denied. She was also told that if she had applied earlier, she most likely would have gotten admitted.
That's some serious food for thought for you two.
She's now a resident of that state (got the voter card, driver's license, and bank account to prove it!), and she'll be applying ED by the end of this month. We're hoping for a positive outcome for her.
I wish you both the best of luck. ;-)