I haven't read all of the posts ahead of me, please forgive if I am repeating something.
The bottom line is that Anesthesiology will always be a physician occupied specialty. Anesthesiologists are trained to deliver anesthesia, give perioperative care, pain management et al, AS PHYSICIANS.
CRNAs can have autonomy all day long, but that doesn't give them physician rights. It allows them to do procedures without physician supervision. I'm a future anesthesiologist hopeful and this doesn't bother me at all.
If you look at all other mid-level positions, there are similarities and they wont effect doctors as bad as previously thought. For example, a paramedic is trained to do intubations, and some other techniques that only physicians perform, but they are not doctors. FNPs can freeze off warts, suture, write prescriptions and have autonomy already in many states, but I don't see the extinction of Family Docs anytime soon. RTs can do a ton of "doctorly" procedures and evaluations but the medical specialty of pulmonology is still needed.
I don't think for one minute that anesthesiology is threatened by increasing practice rights for a discipline that will never be "physician level." Even with the influx of CRNAs and their future doctorate entry level change and their increased autonomy, their is a big time shortage of anesthesia providers. Also, physician pain management practice will continue to be for docs. If you wanna give gas, you will have the opportunity.
These doomsday scenarios have been prognosticated over-and-over again and it usually ends up changing very little. I can't cite any better examples than the FNP(independent in many states) and PA situation.
All that said, I think it is still a good idea for all of us students to get active and educate the public and our legislators.
Limited research shows that CRNAs can deliver anesthesia care alone as safely as Anesthesiologists but there should be more studies, aimed at larger groups as a whole. The biggest study cited looked specifically at Medicare patients. Well knowing that the type of surgeries for medicare patients can differ greatly throughout lifespans should leave room for more study.
Overall I think there is plenty of room at the table for CRNAs as well as Anesthesiologists, with the shortage and all. Don't think much will change.
Sorry for being so wordy this morning folks.