It doesn't make legal sense either. This sort of short selling is technically illegal (shorting 140% of the stock?) but not actively enforced by the SEC. Wonder why the hedge funds are begging the SEC to step in now. Things always get very interesting when large amounts of money are involved.
The same group (Melvin Capital) that shorted GME to oblivion (artificially bringing down the share price to $4) in hopes of it going bankrupt (and affecting tens of thousands of working class people) are now on the verge of bankruptcy because they overextended themselves and doubled down when they thought they could shake "retail investors" by heavily manipulating the stock price via short attacks, reaching out to their media friends to demoralize and demonize retail investors and spread misinformation ("Melvin Capital has closed out their positions"), pumping other stocks to divert money away from GME (read: AMC, NOK, BB, etc.), and getting bailed out by Citadel (and subsequently losing that 2.75 billion bailout money in one day). They are hemorrhaging money right now and are panicking, pulling out all the stops by reaching out to their friends in government to investigate and ultimately try to suppress the people who aren't in their little club--you know, like they've been doing to poor people for centuries via systematic disenfranchisement. Big money is getting really desperate, and we are now seeing how deep the rabbit hole really goes.
I've been following GME for a long time and have been wondering when it would reach this forum. Full disclosure, I've now made some serious F.U. money from it. If you all remember, I was the one that made a couple of posts about the perils of daytrading and how abysmal the chances of making money are. I saw this opportunity, felt like it was worth the risk, and invested in it with the full realization that I could lose it all. I bought in very early and built the position over time.
For anyone thinking of investing in GME now, I would suggest doing a lot of reading:
www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/kps5bb/gme_almostultimate_dd/
IMO, investing in GME now has a decent chance of paying off but as always, never invest money you're not prepared to lose. I don't think the short squeeze has even started yet, but the funds who shorted this stock to oblivion are now looking for another bailout from anybody who will give them one (NASDAQ president, Biden administration, CNBC, etc.). They actually may be successful because the money runs deeper than we all realize. We'll find out soon.