I wonder about the percentage of people with business/finance/CS degree that make 100-150k bestrewn the age of 23-30. My impression is that it might be only the top 10%.
I always go back to this.
Explore the occupations and industries of the nation's wealthiest households.
archive.nytimes.com
I love that graphic, but it's not really relevant to the discussion. That shows households in the 1% which is quite different than single earners, otherwise there's no way teachers would be the 5th highest career in the top 1 percenters. It's also talking about the top 1%, which is $400k/yr, very different from 100k/yr.
$100k/yr is around the 82nd percentile for individuals in 2023. 33.5mil individuals in the US made over $100k in 2023. Making over $250k was harder and less than 5mil individuals did in 2023 (data in link, lots of fun numbers to crunch here). I agree that it's probably not a huge percentage of people in their 20's in finance making much more than $100k/yr (old data on that site says $100k is 99th percentile for 23 yo but only 86th percentile for 29 yo), but it's not as difficult as it was even 5 years ago ($100k for 29yo was 91st percentile). I'd be curious to see if it's more difficult to do that vs gaining acceptance to med school. Here's the link:
Income Percentile Calculator for the United States
This site as $100k/yr as 68th percentile for "financial managers" with median income being $75k. They don't have data for job/degree AND age, but they say that for ages 23-30 yo the individual median income is only $26,500. So probably a lot of unaccounted for variables and a poor representation of what you're asking. This site also says median pay for physicians is only $205k with $395k/yr being the 75th percentile for what that's worth.
Income Percentiles by Occupation and Education Level - Personal Finance Data
I can certainly rephrase that as stating that someone who has the mindset that the "point of a job is to make money" is starting down a slope that can often end up in engaging in:
- Fraudulent behavior
- Unethical behavior
- Behavior that compromises patient safety/wellness for personal enrichment or profit seeking
Let's also keep in mind that these forums are easily searchable and open to patients to view as well. I would wonder what patients would think when they peruse the psychiatry forums online and come across such statements.
They weren't really wrong at all though. The reason most people work, including physicians, is to make money. Hopefully people will do something they enjoy a little and find purpose from, but how many people do you honestly know would continue to do their specific job if they were only paid the minimum to get by (housing, food, transport, downtime)? If this were a communist society where everyone got equal pay for hours worked you really think most physicians would still choose to be physicians with everything our job entails? I almost certainly wouldn't given the level of responsibility and liability we have...
I also think there's a big difference between saying the point of a job is to make money and the point of a job is to make as much money as possible through any means necessary. Your statements are implying the latter is inevitable or at least likely, which certainly happens but imo is not to be expected.