Ladies and Gentlemen... a Noob WW Game Thread!

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Animal Midwife said:
I really don't want to vote for Dr. S, but am torn by the red flags.
Click to expand...

I agree. I just don't really understand her character or the way she is communicating. It also bothers me that she hasn't posted in a while to defend herself against any of this
 
finnickthedog said:
😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛


Someday you'll give up on correcting people.


😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉😉
Click to expand...
😳😳😳😳😳
I know you're a lady and I still sometimes forget
:bag::bag::bag::bag::bag:
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Hmm kittens I am thinking about changing my lynch vote over this comment..

I don't think DrS is a wolf. She might be a chaos, but if she is, there is a better chance she's going to be on our side vs the wolves right now as the wolves are killing us two at a time and we haven't killed any of them. She talks in riddles and seems to be giving away her role which makes me think she wouldn't be a wolf (too different and always getting threatened to be lynched - wolves more would want to blend in) I really think we should go for a wolf this time and if DrS is a chaos (which someone already said there's a good chance hyge was the only one "lonely") then she will be fine with that because chaotics don't care about who we lynch as long as they stay alive. So if anyone has anymore theories on who would be a wolf that would be great.
Click to expand...

I honestly thought it would help since everyone knows what their own role is, that if someone tried to make up a role or double up roles, then we would know who was trying to lie.

Do you have a theory for why DrS is talking that way?
 
Animal Midwife said:
I really don't want to vote for Dr. S, but am torn by the red flags.
Click to expand...

I know, I'm not sure it's the right decision but it's hard to make sense of her. She sways between kind/comforting in one breath, and then calling people out in another. It's weird that her possible "redirection" or whatever her paralysis was didn't make it into the write up.

No matter who I vote to lynch, I will always feel a bit guilty.
 
wallydo said:
I know, I'm not sure it's the right decision but it's hard to make sense of her. She sways between kind/comforting in one breath, and then calling people out in another. It's weird that her possible "redirection" or whatever her paralysis was didn't make it into the write up.

No matter who I vote to lynch, I will always feel a bit guilty.
Click to expand...
Don't feel guilty! In my heart, I'm like ohhh I love my new WW fam, but in my head I'm like :pompous: looking for wolves.
 
I feel like it's not the right decision to vote for her even though she's suspicious of me for unknown reasons... I think the things she's saying are kind of weird but I think she might be right with her talk about being wise and saying that she's someone to keep around...
 
in a lot of games that I've read, it's not uncommon for someone to claim to be attacked or have a night action performed on them, when nothing is mentioned in the write up. I think the choice to believe or not to believe them is all part of the game. Usually deaths are the only things reported in the write up. Maybe there's a game out there where more things were included, but I don't think it's the norm.
 
Again, that's another reason as to why I'm not going to vote for DrS, but everyone should have their own ideas and vote however they see necessary.
 
So a thought as I get caught up...the last two nights, one human and one animal have been killed but if the one human/one animal things is relevant how is it that the wolves know they are actually killing one human and one animal (compared to killing two humans or two animals)...no one is openly telling their roles or anything...
 
Ski and Raf, valid points. I haven't read other WW games which is probably hurting me a bit here. I just think her cryptic communication is weird.

Bottle of Bear, you did a decent job defending yourself...

Who else seems wolf-y?
 
wallydo said:
Ski and Raf, valid points. I haven't read other WW games which is probably hurting me a bit here. I just think her cryptic communication is weird.

Bottle of Bear, you did a decent job defending yourself...

Who else seems wolf-y?
Click to expand...
who do YOU think is wolfy? any post inconsistencies or anything that just makes you raise an eyebrow?
 
raf2769 said:
who do YOU think is wolfy? any post inconsistencies or anything that just makes you raise an eyebrow?
Click to expand...

Actually, before today started, I was leaning towards serher. She's been quiet overall, and had a few "what if's" about DrS that made me think she was trying to plant seeds. Her very minor activity today hasn't really swung me one way or the other.
 
wallydo said:
Ski and Raf, valid points. I haven't read other WW games which is probably hurting me a bit here. I just think her cryptic communication is weird.

Bottle of Bear, you did a decent job defending yourself...

Who else seems wolf-y?
Click to expand...
Her cryptic communication IS somewhat weird, but that could be something that she was forced to do. Like in another game(I'm pretty sure one of the noob ones. Maybe the first?) someone had to talk backwards and someone had to talk in all caps. So maybe her cryptic posts are just something she's been cursed to do, like cdo miming
 
But I worry that's more of a "feeling" without enough evidence to back it up.
 
SkiOtter said:
Her cryptic communication IS somewhat weird, but that could be something that she was forced to do. Like in another game(I'm pretty sure one of the noob ones. Maybe the first?) someone had to talk backwards and someone had to talk in all caps. So maybe her cryptic posts are just something she's been cursed to do, like cdo miming
Click to expand...

That's good to know! I can't imagine having to do that for a whole game. Lol. Definitely would throw me for a loop. I think that is enough evidence to make me ...

Unlynch DrS
 
My post count was near the middle-top of the list (that was posted yesterday), so I am interested that you feel I have been quiet.
 
A lot of WW is based on feelings. But look, now we have another name out there that we can discuss. I also
wallydo said:
Actually, before today started, I was leaning towards serher. She's been quiet overall, and had a few "what if's" about DrS that made me think she was trying to plant seeds. Her very minor activity today hasn't really swung me one way or the other.
Click to expand...
A lot of WW is based on feelings. But look, now we have another name out there that we can discuss! Personally, I thought serher has been decently active and seems to have quite a few game solving posts. I tend to think wolves will be posting enough to remain active, but won't actively try to game solve, because they DO know a lot of information that the rest of us don't. If they actively try to game solve, they have a much higher chance of having inconsistencies or accidentally revealing that they know more. Hence my vote for kittens tonight. HOWEVER, this is not going to be a rule to find all wolves, I'm sure there are active wolves, and also inactive villagers. This is just what I'm kind of going by for right now. 🙂
 
whoops, obviously messed up the formatting of that post. oh well.
 
Officialish Lynch Tally!
Dr-S (3) - SAR, h&h, BYOB
BYOB (2) - Lyra, Snowshoe
SkiOtter (1) - Dr-S
kmittens (1) - raf

7/17 - Check your vote. Deadline 9pm EST (Only ~1.5 hrs!)
 
Yeah I tend to think out loud on the thread as well. The reason I talk about a bunch of different scenarios is to look at every side of the story. Sorry if it seems suspicious.
 
Ok, I'm heading to a Christmas part-ay! So my new lynch vote will be placed...

Lynch kittenmittens

Unless I waffle, I'll see you guys on the other side.
 
raf2769 said:
A lot of WW is based on feelings. But look, now we have another name out there that we can discuss! Personally, I thought serher has been decently active and seems to have quite a few game solving posts. I tend to think wolves will be posting enough to remain active, but won't actively try to game solve, because they DO know a lot of information that the rest of us don't. If they actively try to game solve, they have a much higher chance of having inconsistencies or accidentally revealing that they know more. Hence my vote for kittens tonight. HOWEVER, this is not going to be a rule to find all wolves, I'm sure there are active wolves, and also inactive villagers. This is just what I'm kind of going by for right now. 🙂
Click to expand...
I'm sort of leaning a bit towards kittens too
 
At the same time, I wonder if a wolf would so blatantly try to get people to reveal roles. The idea screams wolf almost too much lol
 
mmmdreamerz said:
At the same time, I wonder if a wolf would so blatantly try to get people to reveal roles. The idea screams wolf almost too much lol
Click to expand...

Maybe an experienced wolf would know better? Though I assume her mentor discussed not wanting to role reveal with her.
 
kittenmittens524 said:
oh right, you're right. I keep forgetting that we have figured out almost nothing lol
Click to expand...

raf2769 said:
how are you forgetting that we have nothing really figured out? are you trying to keep up with us not knowing anything? do you know more than us? wolves are the informed minority in this game.
for this statement alone, I'm going with
lynch kittenmittens
Click to expand...

Like raf, im also concerned by the fact that she forgot that we've figured out nothing
 
Here's an updated list on how many times each person has posted:

1. mmmdreamerz--84
2. SnowshoeDog143--35
3. Karabiner13--27
7. SkiOtter--191
9. Doctor-S--59
10. sheltermed--41
11. serher--69
12. TrashPanda--24
13. Animal Midwife--22
14. raf2769--60
15. SARdoghandler-41
17. jmo1012--8
18. hurtem&healem--29
20. kittenmittens524--39
21. Bottle of Bear--75
22. LyraGardenia--37
23. wallydo--27
 
mmmdreamerz said:
Here's an updated list on how many times each person has posted:

1. mmmdreamerz--84
2. SnowshoeDog143--35
3. Karabiner13--27
7. SkiOtter--191
9. Doctor-S--59
10. sheltermed--41
11. serher--69
12. TrashPanda--24
13. Animal Midwife--22
14. raf2769--60
15. SARdoghandler-41
17. jmo1012--8
18. hurtem&healem--29
20. kittenmittens524--39
21. Bottle of Bear--75
22. LyraGardenia--37
23. wallydo--27
Click to expand...
AAAAAYYYYYY STILL IN THE LEAD!!!! (@WildZoo Do I get an award for that?????)
 
I'm not saying we need to this vote, but I think moving forward it would be beneficial to strongly consider some of the people that aren't posting much. We have suggested that thought a lot, but never really done it.
 
Half of me is tempted to lynch the least active poster on that list (maybe other then jmo because she stopped playing....but then again weren't we going to lynch her the first night?)
 
putting this in order of most to least, just because I needed to for my own good.
7. SkiOtter--191
1. mmmdreamerz--84
21. Bottle of Bear--75
11. serher--69
14. raf2769--60
9. Doctor-S--59
10. sheltermed--41
15. SARdoghandler-41
20. kittenmittens524--39
22. LyraGardenia--37
2. SnowshoeDog143--35
18. hurtem&healem--29
23. wallydo--27
3. Karabiner13--27
12. TrashPanda--24
13. Animal Midwife--22
17. jmo1012--8
 
raf2769 said:
putting this in order of most to least, just because I needed to for my own good.
7. SkiOtter--191
1. mmmdreamerz--84
21. Bottle of Bear--75
11. serher--69
14. raf2769--60
9. Doctor-S--59
10. sheltermed--41
15. SARdoghandler-41
20. kittenmittens524--39
22. LyraGardenia--37
2. SnowshoeDog143--35
18. hurtem&healem--29
23. wallydo--27
3. Karabiner13--27
12. TrashPanda--24
13. Animal Midwife--22
17. jmo1012--8
Click to expand...

Thanks...I almost did that but then was like nahhh too much effort lol
 
Lynch kittenmittens

raf is doing better game solving than I am so far. Guess I probably should make a spreadsheet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
163
Views
10K
kaydubs
kaydubs
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
SportPonies
Noob WW Game 2023 Sign Ups OPEN!
Replies
40
Views
2K
SportPonies
SportPonies
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
30K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top