Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

[LetItSnow]

---

Members don't see this ad.

***************************
The above post is why you shouldn't believe rumors.
***************************

 

[Haxx]

I'm going to vote on AM's suspicion because she was right last time and seemed to have info somehow. That being said, I also think that YK's play has been erratic and there hasn't been anything else that has seemed amok to me throughout today.

###lynch YK###

 

[kaydubs]

D5 PurgatorYAY Tally

Skimble (2) - mel, allieh
Coops (2) - yk, Skimble
yk (3) - Coops, Weim, Haxx

7/10 votes

Not voting:
7. Crayola227
8. Stella Mudd
11. Mad Jack
@youngkal is in jeopardy

 

[vetmedhead]

*********************
Rumor has it in case of a tie, I get to decide who dies.
*********************

I think you're on to something here

 

[Melchizedek]

Unlynch Genny/Skimble
Lynch YK

I'm okay with a YK lynch and want to give Skimble a chance to give me data to assess my read on Genny.

 

[Melchizedek]

@Skimble can I have your thoughts on Stella and Allieh's ISO?

 

[Skimble]

@Skimble can I have your thoughts on Stella and Allieh's ISO?

As I mentioned in the meat thread sign up (where wz posted asking for a sub) I have not, nor do I intend to read back through the first 26 pages of this thread. I just don't have that kind of time. I'm happy to give my reads on things said starting on pg 26, feel free to quote posts you feel I should see, or give cliff notes.

As I posted above, I thought allieh's question was weird and seemed like she was fishing. The fact that she claimed to not recognize why the question was weird at first didn't make me feel any better. I could easily vote that way.

In fact, since I'm no longer in a close second place;

unlynch coop
Lynch allieh

I currently have no thoughts on stella as I don't think I've seen her post anything yet (at least not anything that I took notice of).

 

[Melchizedek]

Oh if its vote pressure you need then:

Unlynch YK
Lynch Skimble

Spoiler: Stella Quotes for Skimble

###ublynch brundi

##/lynch mel###/

Saw tally. Please don't kill my manator

Voted bj because she said false things about me. Saw mel or coop wpuld die instead. Why would I want coop the ONLY one not trying to kill me to die instead of mel??

Context for above: D1 Coops, BJ, and Mel#1 were up for lynch. Stella came in pretty close to lynch close and tried to save coopah.

Keep an eye on all the people that wamt to kill me

Lynch bj

D2 trying to explain actions near lynch close of D1

Give me some time to get back to you.

@Stella Mudd you never actually did get back to AM on this. You've had plenty of time. Lets hear it.

Coffee, earlier you mentioned something about LIS and his ability. I didn't understand that post. Can you explain that post to me?

Lynch coffee

LIS was sure bj shouldn't get lynched, didn't want AM lynched & was the village vigilante who wanted coffee dead.

I want to see the how that would have gone down...

Spoiler: Allie Quotes for Skimble

She gave a reason for this vote already..

I basically already gave my reason by quoting Coop's post involving Bryndy, but it's because Bryndy gave what I found to be a suitable D1 reason for lynching someone (albeit wrong in her stella wolf statement) and Coop pressed for further reasoning. Also called Mel out for "throwing shade early" and then Coop proceeds to do exactly that as well. Just hard to tell if this is village play coming out swinging or a wolf trying too hard to find reasons to lynch people. Nothing major but in the interest of voting often and early, Coop stood out most to me.

Nope, I was saying Coop called Mel out for throwing shade, and then proceeded to throw out shade. Sorry if it was unclear!

I kind of want to lynch cray. Something about her play is starting to feel different than the last few games I’ve played with her as a villager. Not sure if it’s because normally she reads me really well and this game she’s not reading me right. She’s not voting for me, but just keeps mentioning me as being on her sketch list from my D1 actions but not really following through with more reasons? I don’t know.

Context: Allie putting Coop on the spot D1.

Double quoting this here so Stella doesn't miss it.

Give me some time to get back to you.

@Stella Mudd you never actually did get back to AM on this. You've had plenty of time. Lets hear it.

 

[kaydubs]

Day 5 PurgatorYAY Tally

Skimble (2) - mel, allieh
Coops (1) - yk
yk (3) - Coops, Weim, Haxx
allieh (1) - Skimble

7/10 votes

Not voting:
7. Crayola227
8. Stella Mudd
11. Mad Jack
@youngkal is in jeopardy

 

[Skimble]

Oh if its vote pressure you need then:

Unlynch YK
Lynch Skimble

Spoiler: Stella Quotes for Skimble

Context for above: D1 Coops, BJ, and Mel#1 were up for lynch. Stella came in pretty close to lynch close and tried to save coopah.





D2 trying to explain actions near lynch close of D1



@Stella Mudd you never actually did get back to AM on this. You've had plenty of time. Lets hear it.

Spoiler: Allie Quotes for Skimble

Context: Allie putting Coop on the spot D1.

Double quoting this here so Stella doesn't miss it.



@Stella Mudd you never actually did get back to AM on this. You've had plenty of time. Lets hear it.

Do you have any idea how hard it is to interpret all of that out of context? Sure you gave some context, but not enough. Also, did you die early and sub in for someone? I'm confused by the mel#1 part.

Do you think stella, coop, yk. allieh and I are all wolves? Or is that not what you were trying to point out with your quoted posts and lynch votes?

 

[youngkal]

I like your vote but I don't get the reasoning. Seems like you made a much better case to lynch genny and then didn't....

and why do you suspect you're going down today?

I felt that I would be going down today because I (type all that up last night before night close) assumed AM would be on my lynch today and I figured Cray would be as well since she had been for the last two days and that enough other people mentioned my name and since I wasn’t on the wolf vote yesterday and that I wanted to Lynch AM before she was cleared. Basically thought everyone would think I had to go since I hadn’t followed.

PS TO ALL IM GOING AND RESPOING AS I READ TO CATCH UP!

 

[Melchizedek]

Do you have any idea how hard it is to interpret all of that out of context? Sure you gave some context, but not enough. Also, did you die early and sub in for someone? I'm confused by the mel#1 part.

Do you think stella, coop, yk. allieh and I are all wolves? Or is that not what you were trying to point out with your quoted posts and lynch votes?

You asked for quotes. I gave you quotes. I'll give you the reason behind why I picked those quotes and who I picked after you give me a little analysis.

Yeah I got lynched D1 and am subbing for Snowy.

 

[youngkal]

Hey YK, why do you think that AM wished you good luck? Can you explain?

I think she had every intention of being on my lynch because I was wrong about her and BJones and then because I didnt go coffee today. I assumed she was aware that I would be under a lot of eyes today, hers included.

 

[Crayola227]

Literally woke up. Haven't even peed or had b-fast. Getting caught up.

 

[Crayola227]

D1 Lynches
Kal (0) - Mixy
Mel (5) - Kara, Cray, MJ, Coop, Stella
Coop (4) - AM, allie, LIS, Mel
Mixy (0) - genny
AM (3) - jboo, snowy, Mixy
Bryn (2) - kal, snowy, coop, Haxx, Stella
kara (0) - LIS
Stella (1) - bryn
MJ (1) - LIS, Coffee?
LIS (0) - Mel
jboo (1) - genny

Day 2 Official Tally of Tallies

allie (1) - Coffee?
AM (5) - Karabou, jboo, coop, kal, MJ, Mixy
genny (0) - LIS
MJ (1) - allieh
jboo (7) - Haxx, Karabou, genny, snowy, AM, bryn, Cray
snowy (1) - AM, LIS
bryn (1) - Stella
allie (0) - Cray

Day 3 Killing My Darlings FINAL Tallies
coffee (3) - LIS, MJ, AM
LIS (0) - coffee
BJ (4) - Haxx, allie, stella, cray
AM (4) - coop, mixy, kal, coffee?
kal (0) - cray
coop (1) - genny
MJ (1) - Bjones
haxx (1) - snowy

Day 4 FINAL Tally

Coffee? (5) - AM, Haxx, Weim, MJ, stella
kal (1) - cray
cray (3) - coop, MJ, coffee, YK
Genny (1) - cheez
Coop (1) - genny
Dead seer BJ (0) - MJ
AM (0) - MJ
MJ (1) - Allie


Again to look at

Can someone teach me to analyze these? they mean nothing to me 🙁

 

[Skimble]

You asked for quotes. I gave you quotes. I'll give you the reason behind why I picked those quotes and who I picked after you give me a little analysis.

Yeah I got lynched D1 and am subbing for Snowy.

I can't analyze it because I don't know what's going on in those quotes and don't have good context. I'm curious what allieh means about the "stella wolf" comment. Maybe I'm looking at this from a different perspective because I think allieh is shady, and I still have no reads on stella.

 

[Mad Jack]

Lynch YK

AM has really good reads. Plus YKs game has improved 1000000x almost like they've had some coaching this game. I don't actually think they've been original though. What I mean by that is they've always jumped on someone else's vote which is similar to what Lawper did last game.

I've noticed a similar trend, YM is highly concerning

 

[Mad Jack]

Lynch YK

 

[Mad Jack]

I am going to
Lynch Coop

I think coop slipped back down from since day one? Maybe that cause veteran players had said too many times they have him as village? I’m not sure but looking at the voting patter I feel comfortable starting here. Also that comment after lynch close could have been a cover to try and distract everyone away from them and to focus on the noobs. ( only players I would consider noobs left would be myself, Stella, idk about Allie or WM)

Spoiler: IRL

I work 8a-4p EST in ER, so probably wont be out on time and will be low posting like yesterday.

Spoiler: :/

giving my thoughts as I suspect I’m going down today and wont be able to defend for a while.

I think you're deflecting, but that's just me

 

[youngkal]

Can someone teach me to analyze these? they mean nothing to me 🙁

Lol it was the only time I caught a wolf in the noob game so I’m going to pretend I know what I’m doing but maybe @TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo can help she was my teacher and helped me look at it 😛 Idk if I’m on to anything but I’d like to think so

 

[Skimble]

Can someone teach me to analyze these? they mean nothing to me 🙁

It's just helpful to see where known wolves voted and who voted for known wolves. Like if someone consistently voted for coffee since d1, they likely aren't a wolf. Things like that.

 

[Mad Jack]

Not that it really helps, but genny had some IRL stuff going on that caused her to not be as active this game. I only know because I was added to her mod pm where she asked to be subbed out.

That's kind of a troubling violation of confidence

 

[Mad Jack]

YAY! A three way tie! 🙄

I all about the three ways, but let's not do this particular one

 

[youngkal]

Ahahahaha so LIS was retalitory? Wow how noob of a pack was it?

What do you mean by this? Do you expect to die AM?

I just think she should be pressured a little more tomorrow. And defending is hard so I wished her luck.

Lynch YK

AM has really good reads. Plus YKs game has improved 1000000x almost like they've had some coaching this game. I don't actually think they've been original though. What I mean by that is they've always jumped on someone else's vote which is similar to what Lawper did last game.

All of this from coop just come off weird to me. Like the do you expect to die to AM and then she did and the comment about a noob pack. I felt that I had more to go on with coop and the voting patterns that I found over just Genny’s voting patterns. PS I dont remember who asked me about this and apparently I didn’t quote it and I dont wanna go back mid type, but I will after and tag you!

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

Lol it was the only time I caught a wolf in the noob game so I’m going to pretend I know what I’m doing but maybe @TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo can help she was my teacher and helped me look at it 😛 Idk if I’m on to anything but I’d like to think so

Lol. Thanks for the vote of confidence but there are far FAR better players you could ask. 😛

 

[youngkal]

Oops and in response to @Coopah vote, after a wolf is caught I feel its so much easier to read and find things, I dont have any coaching, I’m just maybe (finally) learning how to play this game! Yay!!!

 

[youngkal]

Also @Skimble who were you previously?!

 

[youngkal]

Also @Skimble who were you previously?!

Like username

 

[youngkal]

All of this from coop just come off weird to me. Like the do you expect to die to AM and then she did and the comment about a noob pack. I felt that I had more to go on with coop and the voting patterns that I found over just Genny’s voting patterns. PS I dont remember who asked me about this and apparently I didn’t quote it and I dont wanna go back mid type, but I will after and tag you!

@WeimMama This is to answer your question 😛

 

[Skimble]

That's kind of a troubling violation of confidence

Confidence? or Confidentiality? If the latter, it wasn't anything terribly personal.

Also @Skimble who were you previously?!

Jilary

 

[Coopah]

All of this from coop just come off weird to me. Like the do you expect to die to AM and then she did and the comment about a noob pack. I felt that I had more to go on with coop and the voting patterns that I found over just Genny’s voting patterns. PS I dont remember who asked me about this and apparently I didn’t quote it and I dont wanna go back mid type, but I will after and tag you!

I'm sorry did you find the noob wolf pack comment offensive? 😉

Also of course AM was going to die, she was a confirmed villager and a damn good player. I was surprised she didn't go down the night before last, but I'm guessing the wolves seered LIS after he made comments about coffee and saw he was the vigilante. The more you talk under pressure the wolfier you seem.

 

[youngkal]

YK actually had a lot of good insight, she just didn't always follow her instincts, or post her ideas on thread.

This makes me feel a little bit better about myself and this game 😛 I have tried to improve both of those this game so we will see 🙂

 

[youngkal]

I'm sorry did you find the noob wolf pack comment offensive? 😉

Also of course AM was going to die, she was a confirmed villager and a damn good player. I was surprised she didn't go down the night before last, but I'm guessing the wolves seered LIS after he made comments about coffee and saw he was the vigilante. The more you talk under pressure the wolfier you seem.

I mean I just think its a wonderful cover for someone to use...like yourself 😛

Haha okay if you say sooooo!

 

[Coopah]

Current tally anyone?

BTW from those color coded lists @Crayola227 I got that allieh and MJ are village. Coffee lone voted them first two days with little chance of them getting lynched.

 

[vetmedhead]

D5 Careless Whisper Tally

If you are being tagged below, you have not met today's content post minimum.

~1 hour until lynch close!

Content Posts
5. yk - 16 -> content minimum met
6. Coopah - 7 -> content minimum met
7. @Crayola227 - 2
8. @Stella Mudd
9. Melchizedek - 4 -> content minimum met
10. allieh8607 - 6 -> content minimum met
11. Mad Jack - 3 -> content minimum met
13. Skimble - 11 -> content minimum met
14. WeimMama - 4 -> content minimum met
17. Haxx - 3 -> content minimum met

AM Quest for 20 Question (Marks): 😢

 

[Coopah]

I mean I just think its a wonderful cover for someone to use...like yourself 😛

Haha okay if you say sooooo!

What's a wonderful cover?

 

[Coopah]

D5 Careless Whisper Tally

If you are being tagged below, you have not met today's content post minimum.

~1 hour until lynch close!

Content Posts
5. yk - 14 -> content minimum met
6. Coopah - 5 -> content minimum met
7. @Crayola227 - 2
8. @Stella Mudd
9. Melchizedek - 4 -> content minimum met
10. allieh8607 - 6 -> content minimum met
11. Mad Jack - 3 -> content minimum met
13. Skimble - 11 -> content minimum met
14. WeimMama - 4 -> content minimum met
17. Haxx - 3 -> content minimum met

AM Quest for 20 Question (Marks): 😢

You da best mods ever

 

[youngkal]

What's a wonderful cover?

Claiming noob wolf pack.

 

[youngkal]

Current tally anyone?

BTW from those color coded lists @Crayola227 I got that allieh and MJ are village. Coffee lone voted them first two days with little chance of them getting lynched.

Same.. I said this already...

 

[vetmedhead]

Day 5 PurgatorYAY Tally

Skimble (2) - mel, allieh
Coops (1) - yk
yk (4) - Coops, Weim, Haxx, MJ
allieh (1) - Skimble

8/10 votes

Not voting:
7. Crayola227
8. Stella Mudd
@youngkal is in jeopardy

@Crayola227 @Stella Mudd I need your votes before lynch close in ~1 hour!

 

[vetmedhead]

You da best mods ever

I didn't realize you wanted the content post tally. I made that whole other tally for nothing 😛

But also yes. Shower praise unto the mods 😀

 

[youngkal]

Lynch YK

Where is everyone, dang it!

Unlynch Genny/Skimble
Lynch YK

I'm okay with a YK lynch and want to give Skimble a chance to give me data to assess my read on Genny.

Lynch YK

I may have missed you reasons? But if any one cares to elaborate I’d like it 🙂 Ill clarify anything you may be confused about as well.

Also MJ and WM I dont think these would count towards your count cause there isn’t a reason, just trying to help out!

 

[Melchizedek]

I can't analyze it because I don't know what's going on in those quotes and don't have good context. I'm curious what allieh means about the "stella wolf" comment. Maybe I'm looking at this from a different perspective because I think allieh is shady, and I still have no reads on stella.

Alright I'll try to make it concise.

So yesterday Crayola was at 3 votes and Coffee? was at 4. About 15 mins before lynch close Stella voted Coffee and said that she was sheeping LIS because LIS was a Vig who correctly read AM and BJ as village.
Coffee? flipped Wolf.

What are your thoughts on that?

 

[Skimble]

Current tally anyone?

BTW from those color coded lists @Crayola227 I got that allieh and MJ are village. Coffee lone voted them first two days with little chance of them getting lynched.

Meh. I've voted for fellow wolves d1, including the first time I ever wolfed. It's especially useful if there is no risk of them actually getting lynched.

 

[Coopah]

Claiming noob wolf pack.

Yes except I'm sure there's a plentiful chance there would be a noob in the Wolfpack as there are 33% noob in the game and only a 3 person pack. Even if there's only one veteran wolf they can't be on all the time. Therefore noob wolfpack. Also I've reconsidered the retribution of killing LIS in my earlier statement. I've determined they seered him instead.

 

[Skimble]

Alright I'll try to make it concise.

So yesterday Crayola was at 3 votes and Coffee? was at 4. About 15 mins before lynch close Stella voted Coffee and said that she was sheeping LIS because LIS was a Vig who correctly read AM and BJ as village.
Coffee? flipped Wolf.

What are your thoughts on that?

So Stella put the nail in a wolf's coffin? 15min before lynch close is a bit different than 5min. Currently I don't feel like it tells me a lot about stella, especially since I've only seen 2 of cray's posts so far, so I don't have much of a read on her either. If you think cray is a wolf, well then maybe I see your concern, but if you think she's a wolf, why have you voted for me and yk today and not cray or stella?

 

[Coopah]

Same.. I said this already...

Where? Pls quote.

 

[vetmedhead]

I may have missed you reasons? But if any one cares to elaborate I’d like it 🙂 Ill clarify anything you may be confused about as well.

Also MJ and WM I dont think these would count towards your count cause there isn’t a reason, just trying to help out!

You are correct that MJ's & WM's lynch votes with no justifications did not count as strategy. I believe they have both hit content minimums though

 

[Skimble]

Yes except I'm sure there's a plentiful chance there would be a noob in the Wolfpack as there are 33% noob in the game and only a 3 person pack. Even if there's only one veteran wolf they can't be on all the time. Therefore noob wolfpack. Also I've reconsidered the retribution of killing LIS in my earlier statement. I've determined they seered him instead.

Wasn't coffee a noob? So therefore there was for sure one noob wolf?

 

[Crayola227]

Oh if its vote pressure you need then:

Unlynch YK
Lynch Skimble

Spoiler: Stella Quotes for Skimble

Context for above: D1 Coops, BJ, and Mel#1 were up for lynch. Stella came in pretty close to lynch close and tried to save coopah.





D2 trying to explain actions near lynch close of D1



@Stella Mudd you never actually did get back to AM on this. You've had plenty of time. Lets hear it.

Spoiler: Allie Quotes for Skimble

Context: Allie putting Coop on the spot D1.

Double quoting this here so Stella doesn't miss it.



@Stella Mudd you never actually did get back to AM on this. You've had plenty of time. Lets hear it.

I don't mind that people pull up posts to make a point, but I take them with a grain of salt, because I would think a wolf would be just as happy to do so to spin things, especially to someone new and catching up.

It's a better point to make to someone who's played along the whole time and can decide if they like your spin on things.