Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

[Mad Jack]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I would count this if it had made a tie. Sadly, no content here 😛

I thought it was making a tie, and also lynching CheezyD is always entertaining because he gets all talkative

 

[Animal Midwife]

Although currently leaning MJ (no reason on Mel? maybe this is a thing they do?) Jboo or AM.

Why do you think this considering jboo is voting for me?

 

[Mad Jack]

Don't get me wrong, I see and acknowledge what you did. I'm just waiting for content post #3

But I'm, like, the anti-content

 

[Mad Jack]

Answered! I will lynch vote closer to close because I'm about to be gone for a few hours and give who on why then. Will also break any ties at that time if there are any. Although currently leaning MJ (no reason on Mel? maybe this is a thing they do?) Jboo or AM. Would consider others following more interaction. Not feeling the coop or brynd lynch yet because coop is always sketchy but is making some sense and then I'm not sure how I feel about brynd's lynch of Stella like I get why Brynd wants to but I'm also against a Stella lynch right at this moment just because it is D1 and I want them to post some strategy first. Plus then it'd be me lynching one of them for a bandwagon and I'm not going to do that when I currently don't have strong feels one way or another.

I mean, there's 17 of us and it's D1, strategy is going to be pretty damn hard to come by

 

[MixedAnimals77]

Jboo and AM haven't really posted much strategy either though...how would that be much different than voting for Stella?

AM knows better and last time she was wolf she was quite and simple answers plus I quoted her posts and give her sketch. Jboo I've called out on thread to reply so will wait and see what both have to say. Plus they've both been on and interacted somewhat to give feels other than Stella a "hey and what's Pm rule?" Like I said I'm not discounting it but 2 games ago I pm'ed with her and like legit needed some help so I'm willing to give her somewhat of a chance meaning I'm not I'm gonna lynch her today. If you still want to lynch her go for it.

Why do you think this considering jboo is voting for me?

This means NOTHING. Wolves do what they want #1 rule of wolfing.

I mean, there's 17 of us and it's D1, strategy is going to be pretty damn hard to come by

Ok, but like you can derive some feels...I'm not expecting anyone to write a strategy book D1.
Anyway I'm off for a few hours and will respond to anything later.

 

[Haxx]

I mean, there's 17 of us and it's D1, strategy is going to be pretty damn hard to come by

This. @WildZoo didn't give me credit for verifying my gender, which means I need to make ANOTHER post?!? 😉

I'm not going to do too much speculation day 1. The only thing I have left to say is that before someone accuses me of a double standard not being sketched out by LIS, I know his play style from previous games and therefore can verify with past personal experience. That is all.

Spoiler: memes

 

[bryndiana.jones]

AM knows better and last time she was wolf she was quite and simple answers plus I quoted her posts and give her sketch. Jboo I've called out on thread to reply so will wait and see what both have to say. Plus they've both been on and interacted somewhat to give feels other than Stella a "hey and what's Pm rule?" Like I said I'm not discounting it but 2 games ago I pm'ed with her and like legit needed some help so I'm willing to give her somewhat of a chance meaning I'm not I'm gonna lynch her today. If you still want to lynch her go for it.

That's true about AM and the whisk game, I was just wondering about your reasoning, not trying to harp on your thoughts.

 

[Animal Midwife]

This means NOTHING. Wolves do what they want #1 rule of wolfing.

It must mean something to you since you gave it sketch points...

 

[WildZoo]

The most koala-tea content from two of my favorite people. I feel like I'm being tested 😉

 

[WildZoo]

Official D1 Monsterish Tally of Votes and Content Posts

Kal (0) - Mixy
Mel (3) - Kara, Cray, MJ
Coop (3) - AM, allie, LIS
Mixy (1) - genny
AM (1) - jboo
Bryn (4) - kal, snowy, coop, Haxx
kara (0) - LIS
Stella (1) - bryn
MJ (1) - LIS, Coffee?
LIS (1) - Mel

15/17 votes
Roll Call: @Stella Mudd

@bryndiana.jones You are winning!

Content Posts (not including posts that are just a vote):

Animal Midwife: 5
johnnaboo: 0
Melchizedek: 6
bryndiana.jones: 11
youngkal: 6
Coopah: 12
Crayola227: 5
Stella Mudd: 0
SnowshoeDog143: 1
allieh8607: 1
Mad Jack: 2
LetItSnow: 9
genny: 3
MixedAnimals77: 5
Karabiner13: 7
CoffeeQuestionMark: 2
Haxx: 3

Deadline 10pm EST (<3 hours)

 

[WildZoo]

My lovelies, I must study this subject called "endocrine." It has something to do with "hormones" and "ruining my life." I haven't the foggiest clue whether any of the other mod-like creatures will be around, but you should be prepared to keep your own vote tallies until lynch close.

 

[vetmedhead]

My lovelies, I must study this subject called "endocrine." It has something to do with "hormones" and "ruining my life." I haven't the foggiest clue whether any of the other mod-like creatures will be around, but you should be prepared to keep your own vote tallies until lynch close.

At lynch close I'll be at the gym getting swole or something along those lines

#modbandonment

 

[Coopah]

Content Posts (not including posts that are just a vote):

Animal Midwife: 5
johnnaboo: 0
Melchizedek: 6
bryndiana.jones: 11
youngkal: 6
Coopah: 12
Crayola227: 5
Stella Mudd: 0
SnowshoeDog143: 1
allieh8607: 1
Mad Jack: 2
LetItSnow: 9
genny: 3
MixedAnimals77: 5
Karabiner13: 7
CoffeeQuestionMark: 2
Haxx: 3

Oh! I'm winning! Clearly I need to shut up

 

[jaboo]

Reading to catch up but I wanted to comment on this as an overarching theme and not just in context of this game

I'm so glad SOMEONE is pointing this out. We have players like MJ, Haxx, Nyanko, and Nohika who we just accept as lurkers regardless of affiliation, but we don't have that same attitude with other people when they lurk. Not saying there is fault or criticism aimed at any people in particular, but just an interesting phenomenon that irks me.

I tend to point out all lurkers, vets or noobs. Someone harped on me early on that lurking only helps wolves. I've only seen proof of that ever since.

@johnnaboo are you going to stay on AM? Who would you vote for if not AM?

For now, but I may do a re-read later after I eat. AM has been doing her thing of playing juuuuuust enough so it doesn't look suspicious. Last time she did that she was a wolf.

I don't like the simplicity of AM's answers...not ready to lynch there quite yet, but definitely some sketch points. I would like to of course hear more from the people that have yet to vote, but I'd like to hear more from jboo. They gave AM sketch points, gave great advice to Coffee then poofed I would like game views from @johnnaboo
On another note YK isn't giving me feels yet but I'm not sure of my lynch going forward but for now definitely
Unlynch YK

I'm heeeeeeere! Sorry to go MIA during the day. To be expected tomorrow as well during the day--Wednesday is cow ovary day.

Jboo and AM haven't really posted much strategy either though...how would that be much different than voting for Stella?

Making up for that now. *slaps own wrist* bad noob!

 

[jaboo]

@johnnaboo are you going to stay on AM? Who would you vote for if not AM?

Oh, and to answer your second question, probably Mel. Mel sets off my sketch meter all the time, but in particular his talk about lurkers that I quoted above makes me wary.

 

[Karabiner13]

@genny anyone besides Mixy on lawpys behalf?

You got anyone other than bryndy and sort of stella you're looking at?

Answered! I will lynch vote closer to close because I'm about to be gone for a few hours and give who on why then. Will also break any ties at that time if there are any. Although currently leaning MJ (no reason on Mel? maybe this is a thing they do?) Jboo or AM. Would consider others following more interaction. Not feeling the coop or brynd lynch yet because coop is always sketchy but is making some sense and then I'm not sure how I feel about brynd's lynch of Stella like I get why Brynd wants to but I'm also against a Stella lynch right at this moment just because it is D1 and I want them to post some strategy first. Plus then it'd be me lynching one of them for a bandwagon and I'm not going to do that when I currently don't have strong feels one way or another.

mixy, why you in my head? What you pointed out is why I tagged jboo before you did Did I do too good a job training my wolfatees in my approach to ww?

 

[jaboo]

Content Posts (not including posts that are just a vote):

Animal Midwife: 5
johnnaboo: 0
Melchizedek: 6
bryndiana.jones: 11
youngkal: 6
Coopah: 12
Crayola227: 5
Stella Mudd: 0
SnowshoeDog143: 1
allieh8607: 1
Mad Jack: 2
LetItSnow: 9
genny: 3
MixedAnimals77: 5
Karabiner13: 7
CoffeeQuestionMark: 2
Haxx: 3

I'm really liking this part included in the tallies. Keeps people accountable and makes lurkers more obvious.

 

[youngkal]

You got anyone other than bryndy and sort of stella you're looking at?

Not quite yet.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

 

[jaboo]

@Stella Mudd @SnowshoeDog143 @allieh8607
C'mon, guys, your input is welcome.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Sorry was working. Didn't realize there was a content post requirement. YK has given me some sketch feels but feel bad lynching her again and it's probably noobness.

I agree with mel that on further reading coopah vs bryndy seems like village on village.

Unlynch bryndy

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

Lynch AM

Maybe I'm just extra paranoid that last time she was a wolf, I read her as village the whole time... but she's giving me feelz and is still on her rng vote of coop.

 

[ResoluteMike]

Mods LOVE ties! Officialish D1 Monsterish Tally of Votes

Kal (0) - Mixy
Mel (3) - Kara, Cray, MJ
Coop (3) - AM, allie, LIS
Mixy (1) - genny
AM (2) - jboo, Snowy
Bryn (3) - kal, Snowy, coop, Haxx
kara (0) - LIS
Stella (1) - bryn
MJ (1) - LIS, Coffee?
LIS (1) - Mel

15/17 votes
Roll Call: @Stella Mudd

@Coopah , @Melchizedek , @bryndiana.jones Y'all are winning!

 

[genny]

@genny anyone besides Mixy on lawpys behalf?

Maybe you? 😱

 

[genny]

But I'm, like, the anti-content

I think all posts should count as strategy. I'm less inclined to kill funny wolves than dingus wolves. Therefore, any joking post = strategic content designed to make the poster live longer.

 

[SnowshoeDog143]

 

[Melchizedek]

I fell asleep at my computer and woke up to this?
Everyone leading the board is a bad idea, but if you're all making me choose between bryn, myself and coops then

Unlynch LIS
Lynch Coops

 

[genny]

Thoughts so far:
I don't like how Coop is tunneling on Bryndy. Time to switch horses, coop. It's just making you look wolfy.

YK seems to be hanging back and waiting to see how the rest of the group is going to go before making a commitment. Worked for Lawpy, don't think it will work this game. I'd like to see more firm statements of opinion there.

And Snowy... I'm really tempted to vote there, and not just for funsies. AM sounds like typical AM, I don't know what crack Snowy is smoking.

My vote for Mixy started as a joke, but I'm tempted to leave it. She's said a whole lot of nothing in her content posts.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lynch AM

Maybe I'm just extra paranoid that last time she was a wolf, I read her as village the whole time... but she's giving me feelz and is still on her rng vote of coop.

What feelz? And I feel like you should be familiar with the bolded considering how many games we've played together.

 

[jaboo]

Lynch AM

Maybe I'm just extra paranoid that last time she was a wolf, I read her as village the whole time... but she's giving me feelz and is still on her rng vote of coop.

I call you out for ghosting and you bandwagon my lynch vote with a non-committal reason? You definitely just shot up on my sketch list.

 

[youngkal]

YK has given me some sketch feels but feel bad lynching her again and it's probably noobness.

What is sketch?

Maybe you? 😱

Sad!

Thoughts so far:
YK seems to be hanging back and waiting to see how the rest of the group is going to go before making a commitment. Worked for Lawpy, don't think it will work this game. I'd like to see more firm statements of opinion there.

Hanging back cause i haven’t given more than 2 people I’m watching? I feel like it’s dumb when people list half the list...like yeah duh.. most people besides yourself are gonna be on your radar it’s how the game works... I’m not waiting on anyone, my vote has cast and i will watch for someone to get on my radar but I’m not unlynching left and right that confuses the **** out of me lmao

I’d be worse than LIS and his “Unlynch whoever and Lynch...”

 

[bryndiana.jones]

What is sketch?

Sad!


Hanging back cause i haven’t given more than 2 people I’m watching? I feel like it’s dumb when people list half the list...like yeah duh.. most people besides yourself are gonna be on your radar it’s how the game works... I’m not waiting on anyone, my vote has cast and i will watch for someone to get on my radar but I’m not unlynching left and right that confuses the **** out of me lmao

I’d be worse than LIS and his “Unlynch whoever and Lynch...”

I get not wanting to switch your vote back and forth, but you claimed the only reason you were voting for me was because you thought the mods chose me to wolf. Then they came on here and said specifically that it was RNG, and you have yet to change your vote.

Just to get it out there I am going to

Lynch B.jones

Because even though WZ said there was a RNG maybe she wanted to be like KDubs and give some noobs a chance to wolf. I really would like to not lose Jonesy because she was good in WWinter but if she’s a wolf she’s got-to-go!

Only D1 logic I have so far...until one of you sounds wolfie

Addition to last post:

I was aiming at people I know have played and haven’t been wolves yet (to my knowledge, I didn’t search too hard for this). That’s why I was picking BJones and Stella.

To be clear

All roles were RNG. Completely. 100%.

 

[ResoluteMike]

Mods LOVE ties! Officialish D1 Monsterish Tally of Votes

Kal (0) - Mixy
Mel (3) - Kara, Cray, MJ
Coop (4) - AM, allie, LIS, Mel
Mixy (1) - genny
AM (2) - jboo, Snowy
Bryn (3) - kal, Snowy, coop, Haxx
kara (0) - LIS
Stella (1) - bryn
MJ (1) - LIS, Coffee?
LIS (0) - Mel

15/17 votes
Roll Call: @Stella Mudd

@Coopah, you are winning![/QUOTE]

 

[Karabiner13]

Not quite yet.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

That was a quick response with no additional content...

Took you a bit to post again and it's another reactive post. Makes me wonder

 

[Karabiner13]

@Animal Midwife if not coop, who would you be going for?

 

[youngkal]

That was a quick response with no additional content...

Took you a bit to post again and it's another reactive post. Makes me wonder

Quick response from mobile (app) the. Got on again for real. That’s all. So i shouldn’t defend myself? I clearly don’t get this game......and i literally already said that I was going to watch for something to catch my radar.......

 

[Crayola227]

Reading to catch up but I wanted to comment on this as an overarching theme and not just in context of this game

I'm so glad SOMEONE is pointing this out. We have players like MJ, Haxx, Nyanko, and Nohika who we just accept as lurkers regardless of affiliation, but we don't have that same attitude with other people when they lurk. Not saying there is fault or criticism aimed at any people in particular, but just an interesting phenomenon that irks me.

TDLR:
It *is* different. For them, quietness is not an indication of wolfiness, it just isn't, as time has proved. So that's 1.
Also, both have proven that despite quietness as wolf or villager, they are being strategic and contributing to the game. That's 2.
Until someone proves it's their meta and they're useful.... and even then, all the players mentioned come under a lot of heat a lot of the game.

I've pushed pretty hard for Ny's lynching because sometimes she is just checked out, last game where she was village, her few terse posts carried some value. First game I ever played with her that I recall her behavior.

Nohika, I managed to see behind the scenes manator, and she also brings a lot to the game even quiet.

You know how quiet DocE can be on thread..... while he tries to be some PM mastermind.

It also keeps the game more interesting.

Last, but not least, we are addicts, and we gotta keep our numbers up and have enough people in rotation for a game at all times. Less irksome to me when I looked at it as above.

 

[Crayola227]

Why does it irk you? (Serious question, no nastiness implied.)

I mean, it's essentially just evaluating based on meta. When someone like Nyanko shows up and doesn't say much, it's *shrug* that's Nyanko's meta. When someone who doesn't normally do it - or who is a new player and therefore an unknown - does it, it's viewed with at least a bit of skepticism.

I think that's reasonable?

At least, as much as any "curse of the n00b" stuff is.

Curse of the noob is very, very real.

 

[youngkal]

I get not wanting to switch your vote back and forth, but you claimed the only reason you were voting for me was because you thought the mods chose me to wolf. Then they came on here and said specifically that it was RNG, and you have yet to change your vote.

Haven’t decided on anything else yet. But you have been asking a lot of others opinions which you did last time so doesn’t throw me but i haven’t see you giving as many of your reads which still makes me wonder. Still have 30 minutes not saying i won’t change i just like to stick to my guns and use my own logic to try and pick someone.

 

[genny]

Hanging back cause i haven’t given more than 2 people I’m watching? I feel like it’s dumb when people list half the list...like yeah duh.. most people besides yourself are gonna be on your radar it’s how the game works... I’m not waiting on anyone, my vote has cast and i will watch for someone to get on my radar but I’m not unlynching left and right that confuses the **** out of me lmao

I’d be worse than LIS and his “Unlynch whoever and Lynch...”

Hanging back because there's so much hedging in what you say. Villagers are wrong, lots of times. So it's OK to be wrong with your vote. Watching for someone to get on your radar is pretty much the same thing as waiting. If you end up piled on the majority lynch every time, that's going to throw up some red flags.

 

[youngkal]

Curse of the noob is very, very real.

Being a noob sucks, i liked the noob game we were all basically noobs it made me happy and less hated

 

[Animal Midwife]

@Animal Midwife if not coop, who would you be going for?

I could also pressure Haxx/Snowy.

 

[youngkal]

Hanging back because there's so much hedging in what you say. Villagers are wrong, lots of times. So it's OK to be wrong with your vote. Watching for someone to get on your radar is pretty much the same thing as waiting. If you end up piled on the majority lynch every time, that's going to throw up some red flags.

Yeah i get that but i don’t like to get on unless i really can find it on my own typically didn’t get on common lynches which is probably not great but i was using my own little brain. I know I’ll be wrong, I’m just not a fan of it .

 

[genny]

I'm really liking this part included in the tallies. Keeps people accountable and makes lurkers more obvious.

I find it hilarious that you quoted this, and you're listed as having 0 content posts.

unlynch mixy
lynch jboo

 

[Crayola227]

Would have included this quote in my last post if I wasn't ninja'd but Coops is kinda proving my point that I don't think she's catching subtleties this game

Do NOT agree. I didn't catch the "two possible reasons for that vote" and I don't consider myself the master of subtlety.

Coop had a point about Bryndi's vote, even if Bryndi's answer addressed one reason, and she didn't even think of the other. Considering there might be more than one motivation to place a vote and asking even if it's not immediately apparent is not "not catching subtleties."

In fact, this is the sort of "missing subtleties" and just, Mel missing the point, that I don't expect from you, and the last time I saw it from you I said "WOLF GET MY GUN" and was right. I don't feel that here, but I read Coopah as village for once (I hope), but I got my eye on you. Feel better about this D1 vote. Always feels good voting Mel.

 

[LetItSnow]

I’d be worse than LIS and his “Unlynch whoever and Lynch...”

Explain.

 

[Karabiner13]

Quick response from mobile (app) the. Got on again for real. That’s all. So i shouldn’t defend myself? I clearly don’t get this game......and i literally already said that I was going to watch for something to catch my radar.......

You can defend but timing wise it's seemed like you've appeared lately when your name comes up. Could be a coincidence but it is something I look at

Being a noob sucks, i liked the noob game we were all basically noobs it made me happy and less hated

Don't take it as being hated. Keep playing, you'll get there 🙂

Yeah i get that but i don’t like to get on unless i really can find it on my own typically didn’t get on common lynches which is probably not great but i was using my own little brain. I know I’ll be wrong, I’m just not a fan of it .

independent thinking is great. I don't think anyone has been telling you that you shouldn't think for yourself though

 

[youngkal]

Explain.

Lol i wouldn’t even remember to unlynch 😛 it was a joke cause you say that frequently

 

[Crayola227]

General advice but don't compare someone else's play to a completely different person this game. It's not as helpful as it seems and it's better to stick to this game as much as possible



Who is the you that you refer to that you are paranoid of? (I bolded it above)

The "you" was Mel, I was responding to him, but also naming him in the post...
oh punctuatoin. Should have said, feel paranoid about LIS, Kara, and y9u; Mel. LIS, Kara, Mel.

 

[Coopah]

Unlynch Bryn lynch mel self prez

 

[LetItSnow]

In fact, this is the sort of "missing subtleties" and just, Mel missing the point, that I don't expect from you, and the last time I saw it from you I said "WOLF GET MY GUN" and was right. I don't feel that here....

So the last time Mel did this you called him wolf and were right, but this time he is doing the same thing and it isn’t wolfy?

Why would you interpret it differently this time if you were right last time?