The problem with "playing devil's advocate" is that you say things that don't make any sense and then expect a discussion. Where does it show that a "Score of 24+ have shown to be fine for future board performance". Are you referring to
@GrapesofRath or
@ZedsDed posts? "Promising for success on Step 1". Do you know what success on Step 1 is?
Do even know you know what Step 1 is?
#1 There is a fundamental difference between 24+ and taking MCAT 3 times and maxing out at 24.
#2 There is a fundamental difference between doing well on Step 1 or being successful and passing.
#3 It is not acceptable to expect a student to have a 10% Step 1 failure rate. It is one thing to know that in a group of people 10% will fail. It is an entirely different story to admit someone knowing that they will be at 10% chance of not passing.