SIU says No

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

bokermmk

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2003
Messages
221
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I jsut got my first letter back from a med school. It was from Southern Illinois, and it was a rejection - presecondary, pre interview. My MCAT was 35, my GPA was 3.9 I am an Illinois resident (albeit Northern Illinois) and I had (at least I thought) good lOR and personal statement. So what gives?
Any thoughts would be great and may even cool my nerves.
 
Originally posted by bokermmk
I jsut got my first letter back from a med school. It was from Southern Illinois, and it was a rejection - presecondary, pre interview. My MCAT was 35, my GPA was 3.9 I am an Illinois resident (albeit Northern Illinois) and I had (at least I thought) good lOR and personal statement. So what gives?
Any thoughts would be great and may even cool my nerves.

Since you didn't interview, the only logical reason I can come up with is that they assumed because you have high numbers, you will be accepted at higher ranked schools and are only using them as a backup.

Don't worry. I'm sure you'll be getting more favorable responses from your other schools.
 
i'll tell you why.....you are from the north....they dont care about you.... i had a 4.0, 35, central il....and got an interview....and waitlisted (i know i got waitlisted cause my numbers are too good for them)....but you got rejected solely on the fact that you are northern....it's stupid i know....but they are like that. dont worry...you will obviously be going to medical school
 
same thing happened to a friend of mine last year. siu was probably the "least competitive" relatively speaking of the schools he applied to, and his first rejection. needless to say he still ended up at a great school and is doing well there now.
 
First, sorry about the rejection. Second, I disagree with Bolton. No numbers are "too good" for a particular school. SIU is VERY clinically oriented. Not only are you learning the "basic sciences," but you're also learning how things relate clinically, some thing most school's don't bother with until 3rd year. The curriculum is very similar to the "Top Tier Schools." More and more programs are recognizing that incorporating clinical skills with science is very beneficial. As for being from northern IL, there are quite a few people from northern Illinois there now. SIU has a tendency to admit people from central and southern IL in hopes that they will STAY in central and southern IL and serve the people there. That's the mission of SIU. If you in some way projected that you were not even thinking about staying in that area, they might have singled you out based on that. No one (except the admissions committee) knows why you were rejected. Did you have solid EC's? Did you prove your ability to lead? Do you work well with others (since SIU is PBLM)? PBLM is different and if an admissions person didn't feel you would fit well there, it was probably better for you if you didn't go there. Based on your numbers, I'm sure you'll get into a great school. UIC and Loyola are probably very real possibilities for you. Shake this one off and move on. But seriously, if you really want to know why you were rejected, ask the admissions committee why. I'm almost positive there's a line in that letter that lets you do just that. (by the way, I'm assuming the letter was a flat out rejection and not a "we're putting you on the back burner until we interview all the applicants from central and southern IL.") Good luck. I'm sure you've heard it before, but med school admissions is a crap shoot. It sucks, but we've gotta play the game in order to get in.
 
Originally posted by kidmel45
First, sorry about the rejection. Second, I disagree with Bolton. No numbers are "too good" for a particular school. SIU is VERY clinically oriented. Not only are you learning the "basic sciences," but you're also learning how things relate clinically, some thing most school's don't bother with until 3rd year. The curriculum is very similar to the "Top Tier Schools." More and more programs are recognizing that incorporating clinical skills with science is very beneficial. As for being from northern IL, there are quite a few people from northern Illinois there now. SIU has a tendency to admit people from central and southern IL in hopes that they will STAY in central and southern IL and serve the people there. That's the mission of SIU. If you in some way projected that you were not even thinking about staying in that area, they might have singled you out based on that. No one (except the admissions committee) knows why you were rejected. Did you have solid EC's? Did you prove your ability to lead? Do you work well with others (since SIU is PBLM)? PBLM is different and if an admissions person didn't feel you would fit well there, it was probably better for you if you didn't go there. Based on your numbers, I'm sure you'll get into a great school. UIC and Loyola are probably very real possibilities for you. Shake this one off and move on. But seriously, if you really want to know why you were rejected, ask the admissions committee why. I'm almost positive there's a line in that letter that lets you do just that. (by the way, I'm assuming the letter was a flat out rejection and not a "we're putting you on the back burner until we interview all the applicants from central and southern IL.") Good luck. I'm sure you've heard it before, but med school admissions is a crap shoot. It sucks, but we've gotta play the game in order to get in.


you forgot to put:

SIU Class of 200X after your post.



*jk*
 
Originally posted by kidmel45
UIC and Loyola are probably very real possibilities for you.

Thanks for the encouragement but I think I have quite a few more possibilities than that.
 
Originally posted by bokermmk
I jsut got my first letter back from a med school. It was from Southern Illinois, and it was a rejection - presecondary, pre interview. My MCAT was 35, my GPA was 3.9 I am an Illinois resident (albeit Northern Illinois) and I had (at least I thought) good lOR and personal statement. So what gives?
Any thoughts would be great and may even cool my nerves.


did you go to a decent undergrad?
 
University of Dayton.
I took 44 credit hours my Junior year and am graduating with 175.. I am in the Honors Program (basically top 40 students). I also am captain of our rowing team, was voted MVP of the team, have won awards for my research, and have done a decent ammount of volunteer work
 
Top Bottom