The 7th gWWuest - Game thread!

Started by GoSpursGo
Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
GoSpursGo said:
Day 1 Vote Tally

SAR ()
JJJ (4) - dya, apop, beans, CG
katie (1) - AM
RDR (1) - JJJ
beans (4) - moon, SAR, genny, Clem
apop (1) - Black Kat

11/16

Leading: @beans2020 and @Jagged Jimmy Jay
Missing: @reddeadrobin , @chilly_md , @Alex_DVM , @katiemcat , @basille

Vote closes TODAY, 8/24/26 at 9pm EDT (2.25 hours)
Click to expand...
now this is podracing the phantom menace GIF by Star Wars
 
moonstermash said:
Hey @reddeadrobin - I'd be interested in any thoughts you have on this game. Anyone you want to vote? Anyone you wouldn't vote?
Click to expand...
I'm not particularly ready to vote on AM, she usually pings me as either bbge or not pretty early on, but I think I'll need some time to watch a little more.
Same with JJJ, even though his vote should be considered Jay on Jay violence 🫠
I've not played with Chilly, Alex, or Basille so I'll tentatively put them in my IDK pile
I don't know, Moon how are you feeling?


 
reddeadrobin said:
I'm not particularly ready to vote on AM, she usually pings me as either bbge or not pretty early on, but I think I'll need some time to watch a little more.
Same with JJJ, even though his vote should be considered Jay on Jay violence 🫠
I've not played with Chilly, Alex, or Basille so I'll tentatively put them in my IDK pile
I don't know, Moon how are you feeling?
Click to expand...
Eh, I'm feeling alright. I still feel best voting beans, but the JJJ votes are fine enough (but I'm always nervous JJJ's a wolf when he's not in trouble and town when he is lol). If I had to vote elsewhere, I might go apop (or basille if she didn't have newb armor tbh). The post-restriction on SAR kinda has me scratching my head on mech, but IDK if that's alignment indicative for her.

Bbge = ... babygirl energy??
 
moonstermash said:
@beans2020 Do you have any more specific thoughts about my case, or anyone else's sus of you?
Click to expand...
I do see where your thoughts on me are coming from. If it helps explain things at all, the first post was after I skimmed the first page of the thread. It all looked like playful banter - I didn't realize that some of what dya and JJJ were saying was actually more serious stuff (re: dya's read on AM).
The second post came after reading JJJ's discussion with Kat overnight and looking back at what dya had said on page 1.

I don't recall other people's specific sus of me other than me not having more fleshed out reads, which I wouldn't say I ever have in early D1, especially not when I am busy irl
 
reddeadrobin said:
I'm not particularly ready to vote on AM, she usually pings me as either bbge or not pretty early on, but I think I'll need some time to watch a little more.
Same with JJJ, even though his vote should be considered Jay on Jay violence 🫠
I've not played with Chilly, Alex, or Basille so I'll tentatively put them in my IDK pile
I don't know, Moon how are you feeling?
Click to expand...
Wow, this is far more than I'm used to from you on D1. Could you explain what you mean by Jay on Jay violence? And why I was brought up as a vote candidate?
 
moonstermash said:
Eh, I'm feeling alright. I still feel best voting beans, but the JJJ votes are fine enough (but I'm always nervous JJJ's a wolf when he's not in trouble and town when he is lol). If I had to vote elsewhere, I might go apop (or basille if she didn't have newb armor tbh). The post-restriction on SAR kinda has me scratching my head on mech, but IDK if that's alignment indicative for her.

Bbge = ... babygirl energy??
Click to expand...
bbge = big bad evil guy but i like babygirl energy better
 
Animal Midwife said:
Wow, this is far more than I'm used to from you on D1. Could you explain what you mean by Jay on Jay violence? And why I was brought up as a vote candidate?
Click to expand...
He's Jay and I am also Jay, hence Jay on Jay violence.

I was answering Moon's question of who I wasn't ready to vote for, you.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
beans2020 said:
Yes, when I am back on my computer
Click to expand...
Some of the RDR quotes:
reddeadrobin said:
That’s what it means on the Doritos bags
Click to expand...

reddeadrobin said:
We do love to make people a secret third thing
Click to expand...

reddeadrobin said:
That was my nickname in high school
Click to expand...
I'd say the things she's been posting over the past few minutes are good examples too. These are all fluffy posts, but they don't feel like they have any kind of agenda behind them. Like she's not trying to mimic her village self. I think that's what I mean by "loose".
 
Sorry doing my best to keep a float after a busy day and catch up on the conversation, I am a bit whelmed.

Currently still trying to get a feel on everything, this is my second game on this forum (the first being the noob one) and I dont have much werewolf experience prior. Maybe I missed it but I am curious as to the solo votes that remain, and want to hear more on the Katie, ADR, and apop votes. I dont know how most have you played in the past so I dont have that solid frame of reference but I do like JJJs solving and Beans breakdown and thoughts and am hesitant to hop on either wagon.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Okay. You also said you'd be open to wagoning others and "hearing out other arguments." Did you have anyone in mind when you said that?
Click to expand...
Preferably SAR or genny. However, if people have someone else they are sus of and would be willing to send over instead of me, I am fine with moving to them.
 
basille said:
Sorry doing my best to keep a float after a busy day and catch up on the conversation, I am a bit whelmed.

Currently still trying to get a feel on everything, this is my second game on this forum (the first being the noob one) and I dont have much werewolf experience prior. Maybe I missed it but I am curious as to the solo votes that remain, and want to hear more on the Katie, ADR, and apop votes. I dont know how most have you played in the past so I dont have that solid frame of reference but I do like JJJs solving and Beans breakdown and thoughts and am hesitant to hop on either wagon.
Click to expand...
Welcome back! You're doing great.
 
beans2020 said:
Preferably SAR or genny. However, if people have someone else they are sus of and would be willing to send over instead of me, I am fine with moving to them.
Click to expand...

I have seen a few posts that mention how suspicious Genny is currently being. How is their current play style so different than how they would play villager?
 
basille said:
Trying very hard to use my last brain cell to get involved!

Also I would like to hear your thoughts Black Kat, reading through your posts here I haven't seen your analysis yet but maybe I missed it
Click to expand...
I havent made a full on reads list but I:ve sprinkled them throught

I wouldnt yeet Clem, SAR, JJJ, AM and dya

I feel fine bout monster,

Feel not fine about apop mostly cuz she isn't noticing me but reacts to other stuff like apop pls

I know Im missing people but hav a hard time remembering who is who from the lowpostersss
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
moonstermash said:
@Black Kat @Jagged Jimmy Jay

So, beans' progression on JJJ and dya so far is just two comments, but in the context of the thread they ping me.

(Caveat that this argument is was a weaker point of sus on beans because it relies relied on knowing/assuming how much beans had read at each comment, which I didn't ask about because wolves can just lie, tbh. However, the parts about dya are new thoughts I had while writing this, and in combination with the JJJ thoughts, I like this argument more.)

Comment the first:

This just doesn't feel like an accurate assessment of JJJ's play up to that point - or dya's, for that matter. Even if we assume beans had only read pg1 (the only page dya posted on by then), both of them had a decent mix of seriousness, with JJJ's being more obvious (/wordy) IMO. And certainly by this point on pg3 JJJ had demonstrated additional seriousness. So lumping them both together and not giving reads feels like beans either 1) hasn't read or 2) is dodging the question, tbh.

(I was originally planning to quote some JJJ/dya posts to fully make my point, but it feels like overkill tbh. I can if people really need me to, though.)

Comment the second:

So, possibly beans wasn't fully caught up as of the first comment? I'm not exactly sure what she means by "all the overnight stuff - everything between her initial read and this update? More?

However, I would argue that JJJ's first serious comment was post 19 (made clear by his follow-up in post 26), so unless she'd barely read the thread at all when she gave her initial impression (something I would expect her to note), I figure she probably would have seen at least those.

To be fair, are there certain segments of the game that, had beans solely read them, JJJ would seem like he was mostly just having fun/being silly? Perhaps, especially on pg2 around when beans was first posting. But those parts of the game don't really overlap with when dya had posted, and again I would have expected beans to note if she hadn't read a significant portion of the game or was reading more idiosyncratically when she first talked about them, IDK.

(I'll also reiterate quickly that I'm not sure what about dya's treatment of AM would be a bold move for a wolf? IMO that last bit feels like stretching to make a townread for something NAI.)
Click to expand...
Bookmarked ty


beans2020 said:
AM - Current village lean. I feel like I'm seeing solvey AM. To be fair I don't think I've ever played with wolf!AM so this is certainly something to re-evaluate as needed, but for the moment I feel okay about her.
basille - Neutral. Nothing AI at this point in time. I am hesitant to vote for her because it feels cruel to D1 vote out a noob, but I am squinting at her. I also am trying to take into account that she may just be overwhelmed as this game is a lot more post-heavy than the noob game was, so I want to give her some time to get her footing.
apop - Village lean (maybe not as strong as AM). I agree overall with the take that she wouldn't throw a vote on JJJ as a wolf. I also think she would have made more of an effort to appear "solvey" if she was a wolf. She hasn't posted a lot, but everything she has posted feels like busy villager.
CG - Neutral. I don't feel confident giving her a village lean right now but she also hasn't posted anything inherently wolfy. She does get village points for some of the questions she's been asking and for not immediately jumping onto my wagon - I'm pretty sure I've seen wolf!CG hop onto convenient wagons like that before (but correct me if I'm wrong).
Clem - Village lean for now at least. I feel like he's been very helpful/solvey to an extent that I don't normally see with him in early game. I don't think that's wolfy. I liked his questions to dya and to JJJ (namely about JJJ's townread on clem) - those both felt villagey to me.
Katie - Neutral. I don't feel comfortable giving a read on her with so few posts to go off of. I would like to develop this read more when she gets the chance to post.
dyachei - Neutral. I know I started with them as a village lean, but some of their posts this afternoon made me squint a little bit. (Namely the interaction with Kat and the voting with apop for JJJ but they seem to be somewhat scumleaning apop?) I don't think I'd be wanting to vote here today, but it is worth noting.
genny - Slight scumlean. I do think there is a wolf on my wagon and I don't love how genny voted for me without much explanation (if any?) as to why. I don't disagree with her on her JJJ read though which is making me feel very conflicted.
SAR - Scumlean, again because of the "wolf on my wagon" reasoning. I don't think clem and moon are wolfing here, which leaves me with SAR and genny. I am curious about SAR's apparent post restriction and would love to know more about that.
JJJ - Scumlean. I know I was townreading him earlier. But watching his progression through the day is freaking me out because it is so similar to his D1 in the game we played together where he was a wolf. Namely, the vote on RDR is making me squint - it felt like it didn't have much reasoning to it and like an easy vote.
moon - Village lean. I feel like her vote on me is genuine and she is trying to solve. She seems similar to other games where I've seen village!moon.
Alex - Neutral. Very similar to Katie. I don't feel comfortable giving a read on her at this time.
Black Kat - Village lean. I like her questioning and solving - it all feels very genuine. I have had the pleasure of wolfing with Kat previously and she does not feel like a wolf in this game.
Chilly - I don't want to vote here today for similar reasons as basille. I'm getting vibes of noob that is trying but is a bit lost in the sauce. I would say I am village leaning Chilly more than basille at this point.
RDR - So far she's mostly been fluffposting which is NAI for RDR. However, she does feel loose (if that makes sense?) in a way that I associate with her being village. This read may change once she's done traveling and we get more posts from her.
Click to expand...
Another bookmark
 
Concerns about beans:

- Suspicion and vote for me is branded as though it has substantive reasoning when it could easily just be to protect herself in the tally.
- Assertion that my robin vote isn't well-founded is true -- but nobody has placed a well-founded vote for anyone in this game, perhaps apart from votes for me (because I have by far the most material to criticize). There can be no well-founded vote; the game has very little to work with.

Will allow beans time to respond.
 
beans2020 said:
genny - Slight scumlean. I do think there is a wolf on my wagon and I don't love how genny voted for me without much explanation (if any?) as to why. I don't disagree with her on her JJJ read though which is making me feel very conflicted.
Click to expand...

beans2020 said:
Preferably SAR or genny.
Click to expand...
you like my read on jjj, but you want to hop off the jjj vote and go for me instead?
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

GoSpursGo
The 7th gWWuest - Sign ups thread!
2 3 4
Replies
168
Views
5K
samac
samac
katiemcat
TWWilight (game thread)
25 26 27 28 29
Replies
1K
Views
22K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
StardeWW 3: Beyond the WWalley - GAME THREAD
94 95 96 97 98
Replies
5K
Views
100K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Ten - Game Thread
79 80 81 82 83
Replies
4K
Views
110K
beans2020
beans2020
supershorty
The Good PWWace - GAME THREAD
79 80 81 82 83
Replies
4K
Views
153K
samac
samac