- Joined
- Aug 21, 2011
- Messages
- 1,169
- Reaction score
- 1
I've been complete at NYU for about a month and a half and its been dead... some applicants who were complete after me have already heard back. Any thoughts?
I've been complete at NYU for about a month and a half and its been dead... some applicants who were complete after me have already heard back. Any thoughts?
Lol some threads on SDN are so funny.
I've been complete at NYU for about a month and a half and its been dead... some applicants who were complete after me have already heard back. Any thoughts?
I've been complete at NYU for about a month and a half and its been dead... some applicants who were complete after me have already heard back. Any thoughts?
I've submitted NYU 4 months ago, and sent the checks 2 months ago....
Maybe NYU just doesn't find you a match? Or, they want to interview students with higher stats first, then send out more interviews Post-Dec1 after students turn down their acceptance.
On another note, I would try to call to check the status of your application...
Check, as mentioned, sent early July, cashed by NYU mid July.
Got an e-mail yesterday saying my application has been on hold the whole time because I never sent in my application fee....![]()
I've been complete at NYU for about a month and a half and its been dead... some applicants who were complete after me have already heard back. Any thoughts?
Maybe this will make you feel a bit more comfortable...i was in the second batch...my stats are bit more higher than yours and im somewhat local...AND...still didnt hear a word from them other than the completion email which is whatever.
Point is...your not alone...i feel your pain...because i want to hear from them too!![]()
At least you got a completion email. See my previous post
Completion email > application on hold e-mail because we cashed your check but didn't mark it down on your application
I've been complete at NYU for about a month and a half and its been dead... some applicants who were complete after me have already heard back. Any thoughts?
Hey,
I would probably wait it out. It took about a month and a half for them to give me an interview invite after they had received my app.
Also, I usually don't suggest calling schools about apps because I am pretty sure they get that hundreds of times each week.
If you think something may actually be wrong, then definitely contact them but otherwise, just chill. Thats basically what I have been doing, a lot of chillin lol
Good luck man
You should remind them of the "first come first served" theory.
i called them, im still under review (as per the email) they said they have 3,800 applicants so be patient.
grrr.... gotta wait! hate it!
I just called them... explaining my scenario about how my application was delayed for 4 fricken months to their wrong doing, and asked if it was possible to be granted a courtesy interview.
He just said, "just because your application is delayed doesn't mean you get a courtesy interview."
Actually, sorta, kinda, really, royally pissed.
I guess rushing to get my AADSAS out the first batch doesn't matter. I'm now a mid-October applicant,
NOT
I just called them... explaining my scenario about how my application was delayed for 4 fricken months to their wrong doing, and asked if it was possible to be granted a courtesy interview.
He just said, "just because your application is delayed doesn't mean you get a courtesy interview."
Actually, sorta, kinda, really, royally pissed.
I guess rushing to get my AADSAS out the first batch doesn't matter. I'm now a mid-October applicant,
NOT
i called them, im still under review (as per the email) they said they have 3,800 applicants so be patient.
grrr.... gotta wait! hate it!
Wow, I'm sorry, but what on earth did you expect? What on earth is a "courtesy interview?" I find the fact that you believe such a thing would exist mind-boggling. Sounds like he thoughts your question was royally stupid and gave you an answer in kind. I would've done the same, and probably laughed at you, to be brutally honest.
If they granted a "courtesy interview" to everyone whose application they made a mistake on or didn't review quite thoroughly enough, they'd be handing them out left and right. Do you even know how many applications they get? What makes you think you're so special or even on their radar? Yes, you are at their mercy. Deal with it.
Some people have such a grand sense of entitlement... Yeesh.
damn dude, thats kind of harsh. as far as i remember you had a thread about not getting interviews, maybe its your attitude...
now granted I fight with cedar all the time, but even I think that situation is messed up.
Wow, I'm sorry, but what on earth did you expect? What on earth is a "courtesy interview?" I find the fact that you believe such a thing would exist mind-boggling. Sounds like he thoughts your question was royally stupid and gave you an answer in kind. I would've done the same, and probably laughed at you, to be brutally honest.
If they granted a "courtesy interview" to everyone whose application they made a mistake on or didn't review quite thoroughly enough, they'd be handing them out left and right. Do you even know how many applications they get? What makes you think you're so special or even on their radar? Yes, you are at their mercy. Deal with it.
Some people have such a grand sense of entitlement... Yeesh.
How is that at all mind-boggling? I'm not complaining about the fact that I didn't get an interview, or even that my application was delayed because my check got lost or was put aside for whatever reason, which isn't what happened. However, they CASHED my check, and did nothing with my application. I feel like that is what ticks me off the most. They pretty much just took my money, turned around and walked away.
I had my name and AADSAS # on the check, and it was even signed for by the school. I'd think it would be common COURTESY to at least mark that down on my file, if not courtesy a requirement/protocol to do that. Otherwise, what's the point of even calling it an application fee? Why not call it, send us money, and we'll think about looking at your application.
I sure did have a thread about not getting interviews, but mine was concerning whether there was anything particularly wrong with my application or my competitiveness. I already know that I'm complete and under review at all the schools. I was simply looking for second opinions on what may be placing me at the wayside for interviews. I'm worried about MY pitfalls, not the school's.
Cedar, on the other hand, expects to be granted his ultimate desire simply based on the fact that the school made a mistake in the processing of his application. Those are unrealistic expectations for common circumstances. It's childish to think that just because the school made a mistake, you're suddenly going to get what you want. Fortunately or unfortunately, the school owes him NOTHING. At the very most, a courteous apology. But certainly not an interview without a thorough review of his file. What if he's not competitive? What if the school wouldn't grant him an interview even if he was the first applicant reviewed? I'm not saying this is the case, but it's absolutely ludicrous to think that an applicant would be let through to the next filter just because someone forgot to tick a box on a form or some such.
How is that at all mind-boggling? I'm not complaining about the fact that I didn't get an interview, or even that my application was delayed because my check got lost or was put aside for whatever reason, which isn't what happened. However, they CASHED my check, and did nothing with my application. I feel like that is what ticks me off the most. They pretty much just took my money, turned around and walked away.
I had my name and AADSAS # on the check, and it was even signed for by the school. I'd think it would be common COURTESY to at least mark that down on my file, if not courtesy a requirement/protocol to do that. Otherwise, what's the point of even calling it an application fee? Why not call it, send us money, and we'll think about looking at your application.
get off your high horse, if it was you, you would be complaining too. please stop pretending like you dont have emotions and would not be pissed.
I just called them... explaining my scenario about how my application was delayed for 4 fricken months to their wrong doing, and asked if it was possible to be granted a courtesy interview.
He just said, "just because your application is delayed doesn't mean you get a courtesy interview."
Actually, sorta, kinda, really, royally pissed.
I guess rushing to get my AADSAS out the first batch doesn't matter. I'm now a mid-October applicant,
NOT
Wow, I'm sorry, but what on earth did you expect? What on earth is a "courtesy interview?" I find the fact that you believe such a thing would exist mind-boggling. Sounds like he thoughts your question was royally stupid and gave you an answer in kind. I would've done the same, and probably laughed at you, to be brutally honest.
If they granted a "courtesy interview" to everyone whose application they made a mistake on or didn't review quite thoroughly enough, they'd be handing them out left and right. Do you even know how many applications they get? What makes you think you're so special or even on their radar? Yes, you are at their mercy. Deal with it.
Some people have such a grand sense of entitlement... Yeesh.
I think you've mistaken my "pretending" for "being realistic." Of course I'd be pissed, but I wouldn't go so far as to call the school and demand an interview because *I* specifically was wronged. How does that not sound ludicrous in your head? I would be just as angry as anyone else, but I have the good sense not to make unreasonable demands.
I'm not sitting on any ivory tower. I haven't been granted an interview either. Chill.
But i dont think there is anything wrong with asking. I've learned a long time ago that sitting quiet in any situation is usually the worst move, the worst thing that happened to Cedar is the same thing that happened anyway (no interview at this time,) i doubt they "logged" his request somewhere in his file. What if they actually said yes, he interviewed in a week or two, and got the acceptance. Still a bad move? lol
I don't think its wrong to try, its just like the job market, jobs are often given to preferred applicants who either know the internal recruiter, their future boss or somewhere else in the company. That's really how the world works.
Thanks for not accusing me of anything in this post.
As for whether there's any harm in asking, I simply think that literally asking for an interview out of charity for your situation is an AWFUL idea. Asking for, perhaps, a faster or higher priority review of your file is a more realistic request that's far more likely to be approved. That's something that whoever you're talking to on the phone (a receptionist, not necessarily an actual admission's officer) might actually be able to facilitate. Asking for an interview outright, unfortunately, shows desperation, immaturity and a lack of tact and integrity. Not exactly the spitting image of a good dentist, or dental student, for that matter.
... in my opinion. Take it with a grain of salt. I feel for CedarZ4, but I honestly, truly think that he/she acted brashly here.
well now i think you're blowing it out of proportion. you're saying all these things because you personally would not the have guts to ask for a priority interview. Cedar should have probably rephrased it, but sometimes in life you simply need guts. Those who open their mouth get a lot more out of this world than the quiet types. I dont think it shows immaturity or desperation, it shows you are committed and badly want to interview at their school.
And again, even if it comes off desperate who cares? As long as it gets the job done then thats fine. Imagine if he got the interview and got in. What would you say then? Revoke his acceptance because he is desperate lol we are all desperate and we would all go to any fine d-school to pursue our dreams. Just because you wouldnt ask, dont put the guy down. Everyone has their own level of risk tolerance. Then again the school could have also said we apologize and we will try to remedy this as best as we can (and then move up his file for review for the following week.) Again it really boils down to having the guts to ask. He didnt do anything wrong, he just had some bad luck.
You can't boil everything down to do you "speak up" or "bend over and take it." I feel like you didn't quite understand what I was trying to say, or you did but decided to oversimplify it anyways.
I suppose if everyone felt the way you did, we'd all be looking for reasons to ask for things from schools, just out of courtesy. It's worth the risk, right?
We'll just have to agree to disagree. But you can get the last word in, if you'd like. I've run out of things to say, personally.
yes wizi very funny, anything else to add? wisecracks are not really useful in the real world lol
If something like that would happen to me, I would ask. Case closed. No guts, no glory. I don't want to regret being quiet for the rest of my life. remember Pride comes before the fallen.
PS I wouldn't call schools and randomly ask for interviews, that would be just weird. 🙂
Not true at all. Shows I am on top of my things, and I take action and make my own decision without just being a bystander and doing nothing, which is NOT a trait a dentist should have as a health profession provider. "Hey, so do you want a crown? I don't actually know how I feel about it, but I'll do it if you want." If anything, you blowing this thing out of proportion like you are actually shows your own immaturity, not mine.Asking for an interview outright, unfortunately, shows desperation, immaturity and a lack of tact and integrity. Not exactly the spitting image of a good dentist, or dental student, for that matter.
I'm afraid I have little to say except "tough luck." Let's not assume you've got the market cornered on having your hard-earned money wasted. I've applied to schools that on their website state that Canadians such as myself are welcome to apply, but the ADEA statistics state that in the past several years these schools have admitted zero Canadian applicants. It certainly has nothing to do with a lack of qualified students, more with a hidden preference or policy within the admissions process that negates our ability to gain entry. So I've been "fleeced" just as you have. But at least you have a chance. Chalk it up to bad luck. Dental schools are not retail establishments who are selling you something; they have no obligation to ensure that you're satisfied, and sure as hell have no obligation to give you a freebie, especially in the instance of an interview. I'm afraid you've got to just accept the hand you've been dealt. Demanding anything else is unreasonable.
Also,
Not true at all. Shows I am on top of my things, and I take action and make my own decision without just being a bystander and doing nothing, which is NOT a trait a dentist should have as a health profession provider. "Hey, so do you want a crown? I don't actually know how I feel about it, but I'll do it if you want." If anything, you blowing this thing out of proportion like you are actually shows your own immaturity, not mine.
And frankly, I honestly think you are so upset over this whole situation is because you applied to NYU and didn't get an interview, and you'd be royally pissed too if someone else got one (like me) because that just reduces your chances. If you have an NYU interview, you probably wouldn't be so against me "begging for a charity interview." Stop being so cut throat, and have respect for others. Otherwise, why are you even trying to be a dentist?
Terrible analogy. Just because they haven't accepted Canadian students in the past years doesn't mean they won't, and most importantly, doesn't mean they won't look at your application (because otherwise, how will they know you are Canadian?). So, you still do have a chance because you are being looked at. The point in my problem is, my application wasn't even looked at, it's not like they looked at it, said stats were too low, sent me an e-mail of rejection, then I called for an interview.
Ok,
First of all, did any word in my sentence mention about I am being a "wisecrack" to you?
Second, if you want to talk about real life, please look at yourself before you say that. If you have questions about your application, use your common sense and call them instead of spending hours on here...
3rd, no point of arguing with a guy on the internet. So peace.
I've submitted NYU 4 months ago, and sent the checks 2 months ago....
Maybe NYU just doesn't find you a match? Or, they want to interview students with higher stats first, then send out more interviews Post-Dec1 after students turn down their acceptance.
On another note, I would try to call to check the status of your application...
Check, as mentioned, sent early July, cashed by NYU mid July.
Got an e-mail yesterday saying my application has been on hold the whole time because I never sent in my application fee....![]()
Same here. My check was cashed in July and I got an email saying I haven't paid the fee yet.
Why is it ALWAYS that schools will never fail to cash your check but will fail to record the payment?
probably true! jooaky was like that too when i asked him how his Buffalo interview went, he gave me the silent treatment because he refuses to give his "competition" (aka me) any advantage. I know these kind of people and I hope to be as far away from them as possible (both in life and in d-school.)
listen homey, stop begging! thats just tooooooooo bad hahahahahha
(obv a joke)
PS please dont call the school, you will hurt my chances of getting an interview.
Mr.Avicii part of the 99%. wants everything handed to him
Actually I called them to ask for an expedited review. The person said that will be done as requested but sounded a bit annoyed. I'm now convinced it's because I must have called just after CedarZ lol.