WW Game of Thrones.

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
DocEspana said:
I guess its time I point out what i was hoping to discretely point out to Akd.

There is "at least 1" confirmed wolf among minnerbelle, fox hunter, emiloo and WTF.

Anyone like 25% odds? Perhaps 50% odds? I do.

lynch minnerbelle (i won't pick on fox hunter two days in a row)
Click to expand...

I can vouch for foxhunter, or at least what I was told at the beginning of the game was her identity. Can't vouch for if she's been converted since she was moved out of our original group.

but I am interested in minnerbelle based on the PM she sent our group asking if we had night roles and perhaps if we had night roles that's why we were silenced. Trying to gain wolf intel perhaps?
 
Official Vote Tally:
SnS - 1 (AKDream)
Minnerbelle - 1 (DocE)
Foxhunter - 1 (sheeps)

Lynch away!
 
Katie8 said:
I can vouch for foxhunter, or at least what I was told at the beginning of the game was her identity. Can't vouch for if she's been converted since she was moved out of our original group.

but I am interested in minnerbelle based on the PM she sent our group asking if we had night roles and perhaps if we had night roles that's why we were silenced. Trying to gain wolf intel perhaps?
Click to expand...

Ok I may remove my vote for foxhunter, my hesitation on minnerbelle is that she voted 3rd for IPB when the lynch vote was still tied between me and IPB, who ended up being bad.
 
DocEspana said:
You're in my group. Pm me the role name yhen. I wont blow up your spot without reason.
Click to expand...

How do I know that I can trust you though? I think it's an important role based on my "ability" or whatever but I don't know that I can trust you. ????
 
DocEspana said:
I guess its time I point out what i was hoping to discretely point out to Akd.

There is "at least 1" confirmed wolf among minnerbelle, fox hunter, emiloo and WTF.

Anyone like 25% odds? Perhaps 50% odds? I do.

lynch minnerbelle (i won't pick on fox hunter two days in a row)
Click to expand...

Where did this list come from? It's not like we are in a group together and you investigated the number of wolves in a group. 😕 ??
 
Emi, he's Eddard Stark. Unless he's been turned, I'd say you could trust him.

Avoiding, much?
 
I tend to think WTF is ok since she's silenced but I guess that doesn't always mean innocence. I still don't like lynching someone who's silenced and I know I'm good, but I have no feelings about fox or minner either. Assuming there even IS a wolf in that list.
 
Emiloo4 said:
How do I know that I can trust you though? I think it's an important role based on my "ability" or whatever but I don't know that I can trust you. ????
Click to expand...

..... Seriously? Let's leave it at my character dies because he refuses to be corrupted by the evils of human politics. that you question who you can trust is smart. That you question me given I role called, well that sounds like youre dragginf your feet to buy time to create a role that sounds innocent enough.

You still have time to pm me and change my mind, but you just made yourself go from who i was least concerned about to yhe #1.
unlynch minnerbelle, lynch emiloo
 
abbercadaver said:
Emi, he's Eddard Stark. Unless he's been turned, I'd say you could trust him.

Avoiding, much?
Click to expand...

Not avoiding, just haven't been following along well since I was pretty drunk all weekend lol. I'll PM him my role, but remember that if I get killed.
 
DocEspana said:
Someone has a very short memory.
Click to expand...

No this is just the first day I've been able to follow anything so whatever. I PMed you my role, do whatever you all want. I'd say a role protecting me from wolves makes me good, but what do I know 😎

I have been a wolf with DocE in the past, and I know how caniving DocE is 😉 so forgive me for not being trusting :meanie:
 
Can confirm her role exists and if its true is very much doubt she's evil. But id encourage emiloo to name her role publicly. I have some issues with how she described her power with that role.... But I need to think it over so I'm not pulling mu lynch vote yet.

If she did name her role (just the name) and no one else was the same person then shed be innocent. But that's up to emiloo to do on her own.
 
And I'm aware that's an age old defense "I can protect myself from wolves", but I actually have it for the first time ever and if you lynch me, oh well. I unfortunately haven't been very active in this game, so I'm not gonna even try and act like I know what's going on, or who is who... I truly have no clue right now and have no desire to go back and read it all.
 
Emiloo4 said:
No this is just the first day I've been able to follow anything so whatever. I PMed you my role, do whatever you all want. I'd say a role protecting me from wolves makes me good, but what do I know 😎

I have been a wolf with DocE in the past, and I know how caniving DocE is 😉 so forgive me for not being trusting :meanie:
Click to expand...

I definitely take that as a compliment.
 
DocEspana said:
Can confirm her role exists and if its true is very much doubt she's evil. But id encourage emiloo to name her role publicly. I have some issues with how she described her power with that role.... But I need to think it over so I'm not pulling mu lynch vote yet.

If she did name her role (just the name) and no one else was the same person then shed be innocent. But that's up to emiloo to do on her own.
Click to expand...


If it comes down to me, I will go public with it because I can't protect myself against lynches, and would rather risk a wolf attack, but I think with 6 + more hours to go, I'll just sit on it for a while.
 
I moved last night because I had the horse, no idea how Katie8 got moved.

Sheep and Devyn both know my role, and I know theirs. All 3 of us are good characters.

The night I didn't vote. I was drunk. I'll admit it. Had like 5 pages I needed to catch up on, and not a lot of time to vote. I KNEW wildcat's role was neutral (we had literally had a long conversation that day about it), and she told me she had decided to be good, because she felt that her role wouldn't do much for the wolfie side if she couldn't even know who the wolves were. She DID kill Sansa the first day, but she thought it silenced, not killed. I was still deciding for myself if she was good or not, and by that point in the lynch, plurality had almost already been reached, so really, would it have changed your opinion of her if I had voted?

This is the main reason I kept my vote for AKD yesterday, because again, neutral characters weird me out. After co-modding with SOV in the history game and seeing what Chaos(WTF) could do, and how many people they can play, I just have that weird little gut feeling that they want to be bad.
 
Does anyone know where any of the items are right now? Are they still circulating, or are they all breaking beyond repair (like the Dragonling suspicion)?
 
abbercadaver said:
Does anyone know where any of the items are right now? Are they still circulating, or are they all breaking beyond repair (like the Dragonling suspicion)?
Click to expand...


Haven't had anything, except the Raven. Can't remember what night I had it though.
 
abbercadaver said:
Does anyone know where any of the items are right now? Are they still circulating, or are they all breaking beyond repair (like the Dragonling suspicion)?
Click to expand...

I have the wall. It didn't mention in the PM whether or not it was broken. I have no idea how to use it.
 
nohika said:
I have the wall. It didn't mention in the PM whether or not it was broken. I have no idea how to use it.
Click to expand...

I am curious about "the wall" as well since part of my ability has something to do with it. Anyone have good insight about this for GoT noobs like me? 😀
 
Emiloo4 said:
I am curious about "the wall" as well since part of my ability has something to do with it. Anyone have good insight about this for GoT noobs like me? 😀
Click to expand...

All I know about The Wall is that it's guarded by the Night Watch and protects from things on the other side - the Others, the wildlings.
 
I also asked about it at the start of the game because I was confused about my role...( if that helps you trust me more DocE). 😕
 
nohika said:
All I know about The Wall is that it's guarded by the Night Watch and protects from things on the other side - the Others, the wildlings.
Click to expand...

So maybe if you "have" the wall, you are protected? Can anyone confirm that they were protected by it at some point?
 
Emiloo4 said:
So maybe if you "have" the wall, you are protected? Can anyone confirm that they were protected by it at some point?
Click to expand...

I've had it a couple nights so far and haven't been told I'm being protected at all. (note - these were not consecutive nights).
 
nohika said:
I've had it a couple nights so far and haven't been told I'm being protected at all. (note - these were not consecutive nights).
Click to expand...

The wall -> :bang:<- My understanding of it
 
shortnsweet said:
This is the main reason I kept my vote for AKD yesterday, because again, neutral characters weird me out. After co-modding with SOV in the history game and seeing what Chaos(WTF) could do, and how many people they can play, I just have that weird little gut feeling that they want to be bad.
Click to expand...

Well if it helps, in my description it said nothing about being neutral and personally I hate being a wolf. I find it more fun to have less information and try to figure things out than to have more and manipulate.

unlynch SnS since you seem to have a few supporters
lynch Minnerbelle since I've had a few suspicions

And I know WTF is silenced, but that does not mean she is good? Katie was a wolf in a past game and her being silenced was an awesome way to lay low. Not saying anything bad about WTF, but silence does not equal a reason to be considered safe.
 
alaskandream said:
Not saying anything bad about WTF, but silence does not equal a reason to be considered safe.
Click to expand...

True, I guess I've just noticed innocent people getting silenced, and as a wolf, we tended to silence innocent people with info if one of us had a silencing item.
Although thinking back, I (as a villager) silenced LIS just because I was excited to have an item and he was innocent. oops 😀
 
(In the Disney game I silenced LIS, not this one.)
 
Based on what youve said, SnS, then I feel comfortable to go ahead and lynch minnerbelle

And ditto to what AKDream said. Being a silenced wolf can almost be a blessing in disguise. Keep that in mind.
 
Katie8 said:
but I am interested in minnerbelle based on the PM she sent our group asking if we had night roles and perhaps if we had night roles that's why we were silenced. Trying to gain wolf intel perhaps?
Click to expand...

Um... well the only reason I asked that if you remember is because Ksmi started asking about starting a list of people who were silenced or not silenced, for which you answered first with who you knew was silenced. Then I added on with list of people who said things in thread during that day/night cycle. Then Nohika said, that she had a night action yet didn't get silenced. That's the only reason why I asked if anyone else was either in a situation where they either had a night action and didn't get silenced, or didn't have a night action but still got silenced anyway. I even said, you didn't have to say which so that you're not revealing if you actually had a night time action. I only asked to see if there even was a point to figuring out who was silenced/not silenced because we were basing our tallies on the fact that someone with a known night action WAS silenced.

Plus, I was one of the first people to lynch IPB when it was still totally in the air. AND I was the only person out of like 6 in our group in King's Landing who responded about my suspicions for SOV.
 
Actually, thinking back... LIS actually WAS a wolf in that game but it was just a lucky guess night 1. :meanie:
Now I'm just babbling 😳
 
alaskandream said:
Well if it helps, in my description it said nothing about being neutral and personally I hate being a wolf. I find it more fun to have less information and try to figure things out than to have more and manipulate.

And I know WTF is silenced, but that does not mean she is good? Katie was a wolf in a past game and her being silenced was an awesome way to lay low. Not saying anything bad about WTF, but silence does not equal a reason to be considered safe.
Click to expand...

Fair enough. I will believe you then. I know it takes a lot to come out about your role. I apologize. Like I said yesterday, I was thinking neutral/bad mainly based off the storyline in the books. Nothing personal, it's just where my mind went in the short amount of time we had to vote.

I agree with that comment about silencing though. It's hard for me to believe that with that many people silenced yesterday, that none of them were wolves. There are still quite a few silenced as well, or pretending to still be silenced to try and lay low perhaps?
 
Yeah, I was once silenced as a wolf and it was definitely a blessing. I just don't always like lynching silenced people who can't defend themselves unless we have good proof.
 
shortnsweet said:
I agree with that comment about silencing though. It's hard for me to believe that with that many people silenced yesterday, that none of them were wolves. There are still quite a few silenced as well, or pretending to still be silenced to try and lay low perhaps?
Click to expand...

Wasn't SOV silenced?
 
Prior to kristin dying we decided minnerbelle was the most suspicious of the four (she knew as well). I've talked with emiloo. And while I definitely have some serious suspicions about her power (its just not the best fit for her character), she is consistent about wanting to know about the wall.

I can see minnerbelle is the one people want gone and i can't disagree eith that.
 
Minnerbelle said:
Um... well the only reason I asked that if you remember is because Ksmi started asking about starting a list of people who were silenced or not silenced, for which you answered first with who you knew was silenced. Then I added on with list of people who said things in thread during that day/night cycle. Then Nohika said, that she had a night action yet didn't get silenced. That's the only reason why I asked if anyone else was either in a situation where they either had a night action and didn't get silenced, or didn't have a night action but still got silenced anyway. I even said, you didn't have to say which so that you're not revealing if you actually had a night time action. I only asked to see if there even was a point to figuring out who was silenced/not silenced because we were basing our tallies on the fact that someone with a known night action WAS silenced.

Plus, I was one of the first people to lynch IPB when it was still totally in the air. AND I was the only person out of like 6 in our group in King's Landing who responded about my suspicions for SOV.
Click to expand...

Did you share your role with anyone?
 
StartingoverVet said:
********************************************
Hope you all drop dead quickly in this game........

I get lynched (rightly or not) because I wasn't on the
thread for 4 freakin hours. Thanks a lot for nothing.

For that, I will not even bother to troll. :meanie:
*********************************************
Click to expand...

Ok so he posted that after he was dead. But the waking up comment was before the battle results were posted. So I dunno if he was silenced or not.
 
DocEspana said:
I've talked with emiloo. And while I definitely have some serious suspicions about her power (its just not the best fit for her character), she is consistent about wanting to know about the wall.
Click to expand...


I couldn't have made that role up if I tried lol. I don't even know what it means 😕. I was worried about coming out with it earlier because I didn't know what it meant or what it would look like to people who knew about GoT. Still have no clue. 👎
 
I wish youd role call to put my suspicoon to rest (you already gave away the useful part of yoir identity.... the power.) The name alone means nothing, but no one else claiming it means you're def telling the truth. One could always have abother wolf craft them an identity. Lord knows I've done that when i was a wolf for my compatriots.

But having a novel identityis the hard part.
 
DocEspana said:
I wish youd role call to put my suspicoon to rest (you already gave away the useful part of yoir identity.... the power.) The name alone means nothing, but no one else claiming it means you're def telling the truth. One could always have abother wolf craft them an identity. Lord knows I've done that when i was a wolf for my compatriots.

But having a novel identityis the hard part.
Click to expand...


Stannis Baratheon. There ya go. If someone else says they are him... lynch whichever of us you want, and then you'll know the truth. Like I said to you, DocE, I have NO idea who he is, or what he does or anything, so I was cautious about coming forward.
 
DocE, is it safe to assume your role as Ned stark allows you to pinpoint/narrow down wolves, hence why you know amongst those 4 that one must be a wolf? If that gives away too much then feel free to disregard this post.
 
Emiloo4 said:
Stannis Baratheon. There ya go. If someone else says they are him... lynch whichever of us you want, and then you'll know the truth. Like I said to you, DocE, I have NO idea who he is, or what he does or anything, so I was cautious about coming forward.
Click to expand...

I don't know enough about him yet (not that far into the series) but that when King Robert was killed, Stannis and the other Baratheon were the next in line/fighting for the thrown since Joffrey wasn't technically a Baratheon. Umm, I think he's good? He led many men into battles? that's all I got 😀
 
In my opinion Stannis is good, no one in the kingdom really likes him because he doesn't make friend easily and has strong morals and opinions
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
67 68 69 70 71
Replies
4K
Views
33K
katiemcat
katiemcat
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5
Replies
229
Views
15K
vampyrica
vampyrica
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
53K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top