WW: -Omitted Topic-: Game Thread

Started by Navilly
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
KCgophervet said:
Add a day to all of my numbers I was thinking of the reverie vote as D0. And if you may recall Doggo had 0 votes when I voted for her D2 and she ended up lynched. I also mentioned Sardines that same day. The next day I voted for her and it could have just as easily taken off in the same way the doggo vote did the previous day.

But whatever, I'm giving myself credit for it even if you won't 😛
Click to expand...
O...k? I wasn't talking about doggo, she wasn't a wolf. I was talking about SAR specifically, and whether or not votes for her on a day when she wasn't lynched mean anything. Grebes voted early so that I would give more weight than your end of the day vote. Don't really care if you mentioned SAR, mentioning her means nothing, as you very well know. You can give yourself all the credit you like but I'm not seeing why you think anyone else should, and I have no idea why this is coming up in response to a post that was 0% about you.
 
Melchizedek said:
Unlynch Genny
:yeahright: My tunnel was so cozy.

based on tone read and how the votes accumulated on D2, I don't think Stagg is a wolf

@Trilt @mizchiefmanaged @PippyPony I'm fairly certain skim is not a wolf. I have confidence I can read her, and this isn't it. If you have specific things you found wolfy then I'm up to entertaining a discussion about them, because as it stands it feels like the three of you are there because of feels?

Barks has some super hedgy posts and ISO'ing her made me feel like I was reading Snowy but she did have 1 very village post. I could vote here, but I'd need to hear what exactly other people are seeing

I reaaaaalllly wanted to vote Capri, but the way she pushed Stagg and kept asking him for reads to nail down his early opinions just felt too village to fake.


If I'm believing genny's attacked claim (and for the moment I am) then my doughnuts are on Em or Allieh

Working on ISO'ing other people. Will be back with more substantive stuff later.
Click to expand...
Feelz d1 and then just not contributing anything that made me want to move off it. I didn't note that she was attacked early tbh. I think we need to take attack claims with a grain of salt but I'm also really not lynching based on anything big so it - and you - take slight wind out of my sails.

I need to iso Allie. I've notoriously (like, basically every game I've played recently) tunneled on her so kinda let that lay for others. I've felt pretty meh so far.
 
jaboo said:
K so upon further evaluation of the info I have, it may have been possible that SAR had a lynch avoidance. I was just a dumb ass and didn’t consider it. Now that my head is on straight

Lynch SAR
Click to expand...
seriously. after like three people specifically asked you for more info and you just yelled about it? 🙄
 
Skimble said:
I know you didn’t ask me, but miz is not a wolf.
Click to expand...

Are you vouching for Miz? If so, how strong is that vouch? And I'd still like an answer from @Barkley13 either way.

Skimble said:
I’m not sure, though others that I think are village seem to think she’s village too. I just wouldn’t be surprised if at least one of our reveried people is an antagonist (would really suck if they both were).
Click to expand...

Why do you think a reveried person is a wolf? How are you reading Barks and Pippy?
 
Okay the likelihood of me checking back in before close is low so I'm just going to stick with a

Lynch SARDines

iNUyHrE.png
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
I feel good about all 3
Click to expand...
Well it sounds like you've solved the game. Why don't you tell everyone who all the wolves are and we can just sheep you to Victory! No need to even enter ACt 2! Or are some of the wolves currently unlynchable? Thank God you have a fjcking list due to your unlimited role name seering ability
 
I’m ok with lynching sar again today. I think we should still keep discussion open to other wolves. Kcough is reading village to me at the moment.

I know it’s pot calling kettle black, but I don’t have much of a read on allieh. I know she played a game in the past few months where she was fairly active, and was quite good/fun to have around, but her norm is usually low post numbers.

I tend to prefer to allow replacements to have at least a day after they sub in, so they can be judged on their own play, and not that of the original player, so I’d prefer to give TG until at least tomorrow (unless something obviously sketch comes up before then).

Lynch SAR
 
WildZoo said:
O...k? I wasn't talking about doggo, she wasn't a wolf. I was talking about SAR specifically, and whether or not votes for her on a day when she wasn't lynched mean anything. Grebes voted early so that I would give more weight than your end of the day vote. Don't really care if you mentioned SAR, mentioning her means nothing, as you very well know. You can give yourself all the credit you like but I'm not seeing why you think anyone else should, and I have no idea why this is coming up in response to a post that was 0% about you.
Click to expand...
You were saying you don't give Grebes credit for starting a vote on someone who ultimately turned out to be a wolf because it didn't go anywhere. I mentioned Doggo because I did the exact same thing but it randomly DID end up getting Doggo lynched. I'm just saying you shouldn't make blanket statements about votes being meaningless because then what is meaningful?? But you do you.
 
D5 Unofficial Lynch Tally

sar (8) - sov, paws, m#, lamps, grebes, jboo, kc, Skim
Paws () -
genny () -
jboo (1) - AM
Skim (2) - trilt, pips
barks (2) - zigjazzy, dolph
capri (1) - dubz
Stagg (1) - Coffee?
allie (1) - miz

16/29

Deadline 10pm est (~3.5 hours)

giphy.gif
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
1. Our argument two days ago he seemed shut off to logic which is not a village sign
2. Tried to twist my explanation of the dark wizards and suggest if SAR is wolf Keke must be wolf
3. Defensive
4. Fixated on one of my strongest village reads
Click to expand...
1. I'm reading that argument right now and am not seeing what you're seeing there. You both were being pretty hardheaded about the whole thing, him about you voting for him and you about his self prez.

B. I need to reread a bunch of yesterday, did he actually suggest that or was it the whole confusion over the word dark that a lot of us were stuck on because the writeups originally referred to Keke as dark?

Coconut. Meh

😎 who's that?
 
KCgophervet said:
You were saying you don't give Grebes credit for starting a vote on someone who ultimately turned out to be a wolf because it didn't go anywhere. I mentioned Doggo because I did the exact same thing but it randomly DID end up getting Doggo lynched. I'm just saying you shouldn't make blanket statements about votes being meaningless because then what is meaningful?? But you do you.
Click to expand...
I didn't make a blanket statement. I said I would consider it. Also the "not in danger of being lynched" was in reference to the fact that 1) there were several people who would have resisted a SAR lynch at that time and 2) she couldn't be lynched (theoretically)
 
WildZoo said:
1. I'm reading that argument right now and am not seeing what you're seeing there. You both were being pretty hardheaded about the whole thing, him about you voting for him and you about his self prez.

B. I need to reread a bunch of yesterday, did he actually suggest that or was it the whole confusion over the word dark that a lot of us were stuck on because the writeups originally referred to Keke as dark?

Coconut. Meh

😎 who's that?
Click to expand...
Meh. I feel this was different.

He did actually explicitly say that

Yum

Miz
 
Stagg737 said:
People should know why Zig is village. Zig is vouching for Coffee, but even if Coffee is the role I think she is, that still doesn't clear her by any means to me. Especially after the vouch from Barks on MPM and MPM flipping as a minor antagonist.



Again, I'm not saying there aren't necessarily dark enemies, but if that's all we're going on then by that logic we should be searching to lynch Keke next if SAR flips wolf and I'm from write-ups I'm just not reading the Keke role as antagonistic.

Edit: So is there any reason other than the whole "dark = enemy" argument or is that it?
Click to expand...
@WildZoo
 
Stagg737 said:
Are you vouching for Miz? If so, how strong is that vouch? And I'd still like an answer from @Barkley13 either way.



Why do you think a reveried person is a wolf? How are you reading Barks and Pippy?
Click to expand...
Yes, I feel quite strongly miz is village based on things said in the pack chat at the time.

I just feel that with two people reveried, our chances of one of them being a wolf is higher, and I could see a wolf going for it. Between barks and pip, I’d pick pip to pull something that bold. They could both be villagers, I just wouldn’t be surprised if one was a wolf. FML if they are both wolves.
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
Keke does not have dark in his name.
Click to expand...
Jesus christ coffee. We've been over this, the early writeups specifically referred to him as a dark wizard. If you can't see how that caused confusion then just go ahead and lynch every single one of us that brought that up as a concern.
 
CoffeeQuestionMark said:
1. Our argument two days ago he seemed shut off to logic which is not a village sign
2. Tried to twist my explanation of the dark wizards and suggest if SAR is wolf Keke must be wolf
3. Defensive
4. Fixated on one of my strongest village reads
Click to expand...

1. No, I was not shut off to logic. I said I didn't understand why you would break the tie between 2 of your village reads when there were plenty of other people who could break the tie. Looking back I realize the timing made things stressful, but I stand by my vote in trying to self-prez. If you can't understand why I would vote for self-preservation, then I'm going to question all of your logic.

2. NO! That is not what I said. I said that if the only reason that SAR was considered a wolf was because she had the word "dark" in her name, then by that logic you should vote to lynch Keke too since she was referred to as "dark". I never suggested anyone should actually do that because I think Keke is village. I was pointing out the flaw in the whole "dark" logic. SAR turned out to be a wolf, but that's a perfect example of an STL situation.

WildZoo said:
B. I need to reread a bunch of yesterday, did he actually suggest that or was it the whole confusion over the word dark that a lot of us were stuck on because the writeups originally referred to Keke as dark?
Click to expand...

No, I didn't. I was pointing out that if the only reason that SAR was getting lynched was because she had the word "dark" in her name, then I didn't like that logic. I even asked everyone voting for SAR if they had any other reasons for it and no one responded. I wasn't about to jump on a wagon of someone that I didn't have a good read on just because of a role name in a game where we legitimately don't know if they mean anything. That's stupid.
 
WildZoo said:
Jesus christ coffee. We've been over this, the early writeups specifically referred to him as a dark wizard. If you can't see how that caused confusion then just go ahead and lynch every single one of us that brought that up as a concern.
Click to expand...
A dark wizard is a category. Distinctly different. You would not name your child Dark Shuffle and expect them to become a pediatrician would you?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.