WWalking in a WWinter WWonderland - 4th Annual Noob WW Game

[JustPaws]

Also, I can't believe I went the whole game, calling people out and asking as many questions as I did, and never got called suspicious until the last day!! I'd even tell my manator that I was so going to get lynched and it never happened.

Lawper would beg to differ

---

Members don't see this ad.

 

[Karabiner13]

I'm so proud of you n00blet! You played so well! I hope you enjoyed your time with your other manator, I wanted you to get different advice than mine!

She got 5 manators this game Coop. Raf was her original manator but then she got adopted by Pippy, Jayna, Finn, and I when she was converted

 

[JustPaws]

What does bring balance to the living mean to you??

Honestly there was so much going on and I was so brain fuzzy that I forgot to give you more hints. But other than what I told you about the tie, if you had lynched one wolf and four villagers you would have been rewarded in some way. Hadn't quite worked out what that was because kaydubs was trying to rein me in

4 villagers = 1 wolf? Harsh WZ, harsh

 

[SkiOtter]

Question asking is always the superior strategy!

THANK YOU FOR NOT TEACHING YOUR NOOB 20 QUESTIONS EVEN THOUGH SHE WASNT AROUND TO TEACH.

 

[Coopah]

She got 5 manators this game Coop. Raf was her original manator but then she got adopted by Pippy, Jayna, Finn, and I when she was converted

Excellent variety of experience! I am looking forward to you playing real games now

 

[Animal Midwife]

THANK YOU FOR NOT TEACHING YOUR NOOB 20 QUESTIONS EVEN THOUGH SHE WASNT AROUND TO TEACH.

She never role revealed either, so I'll take our win!

 

[WildZoo]

4 villagers = 1 wolf? Harsh WZ, harsh

Yes haha. Because typically, I run games at a 4:1 village to wolf ratio

Incidentally, since this was discussed...somewhere. I don't count third parties in those numbers. Basically disregard them entirely because I design them not to lean one way or the other. If anything they typically lean village anyway, so I certainly wouldn't count them in any way that would lead to decreasing wolf numbers.

 

[vetmedhead]

Great job, village!

I had fun manatoring you @flameshock , I hope I'll see you around in future WW games.

 

[cowgirl92]

Question asking is always the superior strategy!

I thought of you several times as I was attempting to grill someone about why they thought something!!!

BTW for all of you I was village including the lynch of capri. Then I was converted.

Thanks for saying. I was wondering when that would have gone down, you were so village up to that point.

Lawper would beg to differ

 

[MixedAnimals77]

I thought of you several times as I was attempting to grill someone about why they thought something!!!

Thanks for saying. I was wondering when that would have gone down, you were so village up to that point.

I thought of you several times as I was attempting to grill someone about why they thought something!!!

Thanks for saying. I was wondering when that would have gone down, you were so village up to that point.

Lawper was so sad in dead chat. They thought I was wolf way before I was and had you pegged swearing you were wolf.

 

[PippyPony]

Any nooblets want to answer what evidence there was for the conversion? There were a few signs pointing directly to both the timing and the player

 

[JustPaws]

Lawper was so sad in dead chat. They thought I was wolf way before I was and had you pegged swearing you were wolf.

I told them you both were village lol

 

[Karabiner13]

Any nooblets want to answer what evidence there was for the conversion? There were a few signs pointing directly to both the timing and the player

continuing Boot Camp I see. I approve

 

[Rozzieray]

Any nooblets want to answer what evidence there was for the conversion? There were a few signs pointing directly to both the timing and the player

I'll take a guess. Was it during the math homework we got from you?

 

[PippyPony]

I'll take a guess. Was it during the math homework we got from you?

Lol nope, don't think so, but that was put there for another lesson

(You were all very concerned with the question mark -- something probably not worth focusing on -- and STL, when it should have been apparent that he had NO influence on the game from the intro and the copious hints about looking at previous noob games, where NPCs existed).

 

[JustPaws]

Any nooblets want to answer what evidence there was for the conversion? There were a few signs pointing directly to both the timing and the player

Something about the footprints in the snow?

 

[cowgirl92]

Any nooblets want to answer what evidence there was for the conversion? There were a few signs pointing directly to both the timing and the player

Well, I don't know about signs exactly but Mixy was a great choice because she had a ton of village cred with taking down Capri. Also there was the quote below that definitely should have been a sign (that I didn't pick up on at the time).

As we sat down to breakfast though, we all couldn’t help but feel something was different. Had they put new tablecloths out? Were the candles always that off-white color? None of us could quite place it.

 

[PippyPony]

Something about the footprints in the snow?

Yes, there were clues in the write-up; specifically the part that cowgirl quoted above.

But riddle me this: what was miss mixalot's ability?

 

[PippyPony]

she had a ton of village cred with taking down Capri

hmm she did, she did

 

[JustPaws]

PotE was blocked, mixy was the blocker, potE couldn't be converted. Was it a rebound?

 

[JustPaws]

Yes, there were clues in the write-up; specifically the part that cowgirl quoted above.

But riddle me this: what was miss mixalot's ability?

PotE was blocked, mixy was the blocker, potE couldn't be converted. Was it a rebound?

 

[PippyPony]

PotE was blocked, mixy was the blocker, potE couldn't be converted. Was it a rebound?

PotE was not blocked

(But you're getting warmer)

 

[JustPaws]

PotE was not blocked

PotE thought he was blocked or protected

 

[PippyPony]

PotE thought he was blocked or protected

Check timing on that, perhaps?

 

[Karabiner13]

Check timing on that, perhaps?

I think @MixedAnimals77 told us she blocked PotE the night she was converted. I could be wrong about that

 

[JustPaws]

PotE was not blocked

(But you're getting warmer)

So mixy tried to block potE but the wolves found him there and converted him instead?

 

[WildZoo]

Heh, actually, PotE was blocked the same night Mixy was converted (n7)

But the two actions weren't related.

 

[Animal Midwife]

PotE thought he was blocked or protected

I thought it was particularly interesting when she never lynched him that day.

 

[Karabiner13]

Oh and a warm welcome to the Dubz family @Coquette22, @bryndiana.jones, @killerleaf, @SoFloGryffindor, and @johnnaboo

I hope you all keep playing!

This family tree is super complex and complicated. All those extra manators too. I'm going to need to re-draw the family tree I made

 

[JustPaws]

Heh, actually, PotE was blocked the same night Mixy was converted (n7)

But the two actions weren't related.

Huh. Ok. So mix did block potE that night. But PotE was village and not doing anything.

 

[PippyPony]

So, putting together some of these pieces...

- Mixalot was a blocker
- Mixalot had strong village cred for the capri lynch (why?)
- PotE was blocked the night that a conversion happened*
- There were 2 no kill nights in a row


*would not know that second part for sure except for in retrospect + hints from write up

 

[JustPaws]

I thought it was particularly interesting when she never lynched him that day.

The way PotE brought it up, I would have jumped on that lynch, It sounded sketchy lol

 

[PippyPony]

I thought it was particularly interesting when she never lynched him that day.

Boom.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Hope new players will consider playing one of my games sometime

Just let us know when the next one is!! Such a fun game! Thank you @SnowshoeDog143 for all of the advice. Can we find out who killed whom?

 

[PippyPony]

Follow up: what risky move could wolves have potentially done during a subsequent night to confuse things and buy mixy some additional cred (would not have worked perfectly because of the conversion night still hanging over things, but might have been interesting)

 

[SkiOtter]

Oh and a warm welcome to the Dubz family @Coquette22, @bryndiana.jones, @killerleaf, @SoFloGryffindor, and @johnnaboo

I hope you all keep playing!

This family tree is super complex and complicated. All those extra manators too. I'm going to need to re-draw the family tree I made

SCUSE YOU but @capri1722 is finny’s manatee and our tree has been merged with yours. TRYIN TO LEAVE MY MANASISTER OUT OF EVERYTHING

 

[SkiOtter]

Just let us know when the next one is!! Such a fun game! Thank you @SnowshoeDog143 for all of the advice. Can we find out who killed whom?

It’s in the night actions section of the spreadsheet which is in the table of contents post! (One of the first few posts on page 1)

 

[bryndiana.jones]

I thought it was particularly interesting when she never lynched him that day.

You're saying that it was interesting that MixedAnimals did not lynch PotE?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Follow up: what risky move could wolves have potentially done during a subsequent night to confuse things and buy mixy some additional cred (would not have worked perfectly because of the conversion night still hanging over things, but might have been interesting)

I know, I know!

 

[Karabiner13]

SCUSE YOU but @capri1722 is finny’s manatee and our tree has been merged with yours. TRYIN TI LEAVE MY MANASISTER OUT OF EVERYTHING

I said it was complex. I only tagged the direct descendants of allieh. It gets way more complex with kcough as stl's 'manator' and ash being co-manator for killer and you being co-manator for gryf

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Follow up: what risky move could wolves have potentially done during a subsequent night to confuse things and buy mixy some additional cred (would not have worked perfectly because of the conversion night still hanging over things, but might have been interesting)

On conversion nights there are no kills?

 

[PippyPony]

You're saying that it was interesting that MixedAnimals did not lynch PotE?

Mixy blocked Capri on a no kill night --> pushes a Capri lynch
Mixy blocked potE on a no kill night --> did not push a potE lynch

 

[PippyPony]

On conversion nights there are no kills?

Depends on the game, but that is often the case

 

[PippyPony]

I know, I know!

Hush, you

 

[capri1722]

I kind of want to see this family tree… I didn’t know that was even a thing…

 

[cowgirl92]

Mixy blocked Capri on a no kill night --> pushes a Capri lynch
Mixy blocked potE on a no kill night --> did not push a potE lynch

OOOHH!!! I finally get it, now I feel slow!

 

[bryndiana.jones]

@cosmokot you killed me!? (providing I was able to read the spreadsheet correctly)......so hurt lol

 

[cowgirl92]

Been so long for a village win, I feel thanks, my co-mod, @WildZoo & modlets, @Jilary & @Crayola227

Hope you enjoyed your matches and roles (you’re welcome!) and the roles of Krampus, menorah & chaos.

Hope new players will consider playing one of my games sometime

I'd love to play! I'd also still like to help mod, if you don't mind.

 

[Karabiner13]

I kind of want to see this family tree… I didn’t know that was even a thing…

it is a thing because I'm making a Dubz Family Reunion WW game at some point in the future Was waiting until this game ended to update what I have but it just got a lot more complex with the co-manators so that will be a weekend project. First I need to finish baking up WWhisk with PBC and KD so we can get another game going

 

[finnickthedog]

I kind of want to see this family tree… I didn’t know that was even a thing…

Manafamilies are very much in existence.

You manafamily was initially fairly simple. I'm your manator. Your grandmanator is fromthebox. Your manasisters are ski and britzen and your mananiece (via a previous game) is greeney.

BUT since ski/kc are the same person I declared our family merged with the Dubz family so you can call all of them slightly distant manacousins.