WWhat a Normal, Boring, Everyday Vet Clinic - Game Thread

Started by Trilt
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
And I guess you think PBC is sketchy? That's ok if you do. But I think you should have tried to wait for AM to come on and say she believed your ability claim or not. Even if you don't get lynched, you are pretty much wolf meat at this point.

I figured, there's not much I could do. AM did come on but said nothing about me so I figured the point was moot because two others jumped on me. Although since I'm apparently so sketch, the wolves will probably wait to see if I get lynched or not if not today then tomorrow 😉

I'll accept the claim for now, but am ultimately waiting to see it in action tonight.
 
For the love of god. I mentioned villager code first, but I also didn't post anything about Lyra or why it caught my attention until much later. It stood out to me and so I brought up my question. It is day one. Anything that is odd needs to be questioned - that is literally how this game is played.

Is this literally the only reason I'm taking the lead in votes? Because that is such bs.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
It's not that I don't know what to do in the game, it's that I can't understand what else you expect. It's D1 my analysis was based off of previous wolves and their interactions. I'm trying, I'm talking and thinking out loud that's way more than others are doing. Hmoo posted three times and said she was busy, Gwen posted twice (I think). How can I possibly get reads off that?

Anyways not that it matters I believe both serher and lyra which is why I haven't voted for them. For what it's worth I'm the village blocker/protector and can protect someone each night.

This. Is. Asinine.

You're going to be wolf killed, unless you can protect yourself. Even then, if you spend the entire game protecting yourself then what's the point? You can't help the village like you could have, had you not revealed.

I really don't see why you thought this would be a good move.
 
I don't know who else is in your group, but why AM? She seems sketchy to me and at least one other person.

I think ultrasound would be our best in hospital test.

And really wish you hadn't ability revealed on thread. Ugh.
AM has seemed sketchy to me too, Jilary. Do we want to do an ultrasound on Coopah? The problem is, if she truly is the protector, she'll be wolf killed soon anyways, and the DI would've been wasted.
 
Lynch Tally:
MJ (1) - LIS
Serher (5) - Sporty, gwen, ny, Cait, PBC
Ny (1) - NSFW
Coop (5) – Kara, 3m, Hmoo, WZ, Pippy
Pippy (1) - STL
Lyra (3) - MJ, LotF, serher
PBC (5) - DVMD, lyra, BBC, AM, Coop
AM (2) - Jil, cdo


23/24

~1 hr until lynch close
 
Last edited:
Unlynch serher lynch PBC

This is what I have for her

As far as I can tell AM was just speculating, this points to confrontation where there was none. This can be very distracting for the village.

She was asking about items. In the middle of a long day cycle, when we've had a night yet. Items are usually distributed at night, thought it's always possible that there could be items in play D1 . . . it's still a really weird thing to ask about. It's something no one can answer (and no one SHOULD answer because if they have an item right now, THEY HAVEN'T USED IT YET and you don't frickin' talk about items that are STILL IN PLAY.) It was a ridiculous question. It was also something that looks helpful on the surface, but isn't. at. all. So. I stand behind my reply.

PBC was the first to start the villager code nonsense on thread, also a rather big distraction.

I mentioned villager code, yet. It's mattered in some games. I was killed in one, even though I was a part of the villager code reveal (to confirm the player who posted it first). OH MY GOD the irony if I'm killed today. If you read my post, I was asking for everyone's opionon before I posted more info about the player in question. I didn't jump in and say "Lyra's violated villager code! Attack!" I also wasn't intentionally trying to derail the thread. And as I think STL said earlier, he was more involved in the "nonsense" you're referring to than I was.

She then calls villager code BS, and jumps on Lyra who seemed like an easy target. PBC is my best idea for a wolf this early.

She was and easy target. Go back and read the post I made, where I quoted the exact comments that made me suspect her. Posting "I don't know how to strategize like a wolf because I've never been one! :angelic:" is a huge faux pas, I don't care who you are. You're trying to seem innocent, but it's a comment that means nothing, and is just sketch as can be.
 
Exactly, that is why am not voting for her. I believe the role claim.

My issue is her saying that that claim makes it impossible for her to be a wolf. She very well could be, until we figure out what roles are and are not wolves. Or it could be completely RNG(personally think unlikely) or a wolf with a cover role (also not thinking likely).

This is not what I meant at all. Sorry if it came of that way. I said RNG wolf roles is definitely possible, but at this point we don't know enough to know whether this is the case or not. So assuming the wolf roles are RNG right now is not a good call in my opinion. I am in no way trying to rely on my role to tell you I'm a villager. I would like to point out that I have tried to defend my play the most out of the people in the lead right now.

Unrelated, but I said in pm earlier that coop was my highest wolf suspect currently, only to find out she has now role revealed on thread.......
 
fyi I was referring to me defending my play more than coopah and lyra, didn't see PBCs post above and hadn't seen all of her votes yet
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Okay, so Coop is in the lead for votes when she decides to role reveal as a protector. She's played before and she has to have known that she wasn't going to live long after that. So why do it? This is bothering me. It's a short term solution (maybe), but it just makes bigger problems. She'll be killed as soon as the wolves can manage it. Or, if she's not killed at all, she can claim she's protecting herself.

Or she's a wolf (protector or not) and she didn't need to worry about a role reveal, because duh, she's got not going to get wolf killed, and surviving lynch was #1 priority. A little far fetched (maybe a lot far fetched) but Coop is a smart player. She should have known better. Why didn't she?
 
I wouldn't have slipped up with a sketchy post as my very first post of the game when I made it the whole time as a wolf without posting anything remotely sketchy. Seriously people. I give my honest opinions and then boom I get all of the lynch votes

I forget who said it, but of course I am defending myself. It is a sucky game when no one defends themselves from being lynched. I am a pissed of villager atm
 
Screw it, I'm voting for the outed protector. Self preservation, it was a stupid move on her part to reveal, and even if she's village she won't be able to use her ability at all.

Unlynch Ser

Lynch Coop
 
Yeah after thinking about Coop's role reveal more and seeing PBCs post above, we could very well have a wolf protector, couldn't we? I was that last game!

The reasons I thought Coop was the most wolfy so far is that as a noob wolf last game, I made an extra effort to try to be helpful at the beginning of the game. I was kind of getting that feeling from some of her posts at the beginning, although it might mean nothing
 
Hmmmm... someone remind me, what did serher claim? Something with thyroid, right?

I'm tempted to Lynch coopah tonight, and do a T4 panel of Serher.

If we lynch Coop today, I think you should do a test on her so we can match your results to whatever mod gods' put in the write up. I think that will give us the most information.
 
She was asking about items. In the middle of a long day cycle, when we've had a night yet. Items are usually distributed at night, thought it's always possible that there could be items in play D1 . . . it's still a really weird thing to ask about. It's something no one can answer (and no one SHOULD answer because if they have an item right now, THEY HAVEN'T USED IT YET and you don't frickin' talk about items that are STILL IN PLAY.) It was a ridiculous question. It was also something that looks helpful on the surface, but isn't. at. all. So. I stand behind my reply.

As I said in my follow-up post, I don't want anyone to tell me if they have items. It doesn't benefit me or them. I was just questioning if it would be possible as a mechanic in this game. Thought it was like asking about chaos/neutral players or posting restrictions.

I think in the DRoP game an item was questioned on the thread.
 
Just went to check timing, and coopah ability revealed a powerful role 2 hours before lynch close... hrmmmmmmmmm that feels super weird to me. I would think she would have waited a little longer if it's true?

@Coopah is there a reason you posted that so early? It's not like we had plurality to worry about
 
As I said in my follow-up post, I don't want anyone to tell me if they have items. It doesn't benefit me or them. I was just questioning if it would be possible as a mechanic in this game. Thought it was like asking about chaos/neutral players or posting restrictions.

I think in the DRoP game an item was questioned on the thread.

It's a lot more common for items to be talked about after a few cycles. Not day one. And it's a Trilt game, so yeah, I'm expecting items.

To elaborate, it can be helpful to talk about items and keep track of who had what, on what night, what actions were used on whom . . . it's just not a D1 question or concern.
 
If we lynch Coop today, I think you should do a test on her so we can match your results to whatever mod gods' put in the write up. I think that will give us the most information.
What if we lynched serher tonight, since coopah is a sitting duck if she's telling the truth- that way we're not killing a confirmed villager. I'll run something on coopah. Worst comes to worst, coopah's lying about her affilitiation, we'll pick it up on the test, and we Lynch her tomorrow.
 
Unofficial Lynch Tally:
MJ (1) - LIS
Serher (4) - Sporty, gwen, ny, Cait
Ny (1) - NSFW
Coop (6) – Kara, 3m, Hmoo, WZ, Pippy, PBC
Pippy (1) - STL
Lyra (2) - MJ, LotF
PBC (6) - DVMD, lyra, BBC, AM, Coop, serher
AM (2) - Jil, cdo


23/24

< 30 min until lynch close
 
What if we lynched serher tonight, since coopah is a sitting duck if she's telling the truth- that way we're not killing a confirmed villager. I'll run something on coopah. Worst comes to worst, coopah's lying about her affilitiation, we'll pick it up on the test, and we Lynch her tomorrow.

Do you think I am the most likely wolf out of the people up for lynch right now? I'm obviously not a fan of being a trial lynch looooool. I'd rather lynch the person that will inevitably die in the next couple of days if they are telling the truth
 
What if we lynched serher tonight, since coopah is a sitting duck if she's telling the truth- that way we're not killing a confirmed villager. I'll run something on coopah. Worst comes to worst, coopah's lying about her affilitiation, we'll pick it up on the test, and we Lynch her tomorrow.
She's not in the lead though. Coop and I are tied. One of us is probably going down, since we're ~25 minutes from close.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
until I hear more about Coopah's reasoning

unlynch PBC
lynch coopah

I have to stick with who I had the strongest feels for earlier. Sorry if I'm wrong.
 
Just went to check timing, and coopah ability revealed a powerful role 2 hours before lynch close... hrmmmmmmmmm that feels super weird to me. I would think she would have waited a little longer if it's true?

@Coopah is there a reason you posted that so early? It's not like we had plurality to worry about

Because I know what happens when someone role reveals right before close. In hindsight probably not a good idea to do it at all. I suppose I should've just let you guys lynch me. I didn't know what else to do.
 
It's a lot more common for items to be talked about after a few cycles. Not day one. And it's a Trilt game, so yeah, I'm expecting items.

To elaborate, it can be helpful to talk about items and keep track of who had what, on what night, what actions were used on whom . . . it's just not a D1 question or concern.

This is the only type of answer I was looking for.
 
Damn, I'm gone for only a few hours.

Coop, it does not make sense to reveal that role when you did. As other have stated, if you are a wolf there's nothing stopping you from claiming you're protecting yourself as nauseum. And you'll be the first on the wolves' kill list. No matter which way it's sliced, you've put a very large target on your back.

###unlynch ser###
###lynch coop###
 
This is reminding me a heck of a lot of cdo's premature village role reveal last game. I'm really conflicted.
 
Alright.. I wanna get back to AM tomorrow. But for now,

Unlynch AM
LYNCH Coopah

I think I want to do a thyroid panel on serher, unless anyone has better ideas.

I mentioned it before, but I'd really like to compare your results to a known entity. So if you use your test on whoever we lynch today, then we can compare the information we get from both sources and have a better idea of how to use your tests in the future.
 
I mentioned it before, but I'd really like to compare your results to a known entity. So if you use your test on whoever we lynch today, then we can compare the information we get from both sources and have a better idea of how to use your tests in the future.

I concur with pbc.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
This is kind of unrelated, but I definitely am getting a different vibe from AM this game than the last two. Either she's trying to be a more helpful villager, or she's trying a lot harder to hide her wolfiness... hrm.
 
I mentioned it before, but I'd really like to compare your results to a known entity. So if you use your test on whoever we lynch today, then we can compare the information we get from both sources and have a better idea of how to use your tests in the future.
So okay. We can do that. She's claimed transitional cell carcinoma (fancy bladder cancer). Ultrasound? UA?
 
I seriously don't even know what you would run on Coopah though. Just choosing one test for cancer? I think we need a vet for that decision (unless I missed someone post a test earlier)