beastmaster said:
The problem is that threads like these are nothing but speculation in the absence of any facts or evidence. The facts are that admission standards are increasing, not decreasing (the more perceptive among us know its not hard to figure out why). You will see this in the next publication of said statistics. The growth of new schools isn't "uncontrolled." New residency spots are opening up. All of this hysteria about 300 new total DO students is silly. It will create a more competitive field of potential future residents -- why in the world would allopathic residency directors object to this? The idea of them suddenly closing the doors to DOs is so absurd that whoever suggested it really needs to have their head examined. The ramifications would not be pretty. DOs aren't there as personal favors to the AOA. They are the residents deemed most qualified for the positions. And the more of them that rise to positions of power the more likely this trend will continue -- a more competitive field via more DO schools facilitates this.
You really have no idea what you are talking about do you?
The fact of the matter is that 3-4 new DO schools will produce close to 900 new grads a year. Now since you like facts so much try these on. 1) If you forget about having a choice of specialty and location and you had every single DO stundent currently graduating go into a DO program there will be fully one THIRD of that class wihtout a residency position. Again this is just body filling a spot and not saying that you want X residency.
2) Of the 1500 DO's who applied to the ACGME match this year a THIRD of them did not match. Thats 500 people! I wonder what an additional 900 would do?
3) MD schools are increasing there student output by 10-15% over the next several years. MD's go into MD residencies. More MD's mean less ACMGE slots for everyone who is not a graduate of a US MD school.
4)DO's are ALLOWED to match to them as well. This CAN be changed. It is not a RIGHT or a LAW. We do have our own GME system.
Now even thou new DO resdiencies are opening there is now way that enough will open to absorb the influx of another 900 students. The biggest problem with DO GME is that it is for the mot part located exclusivley in the midwest/northeast. I, as well as a good number of my fellow students, do NOT want to live in the midwest one second longer than we have to. Just because we went the DO route does not mean that we should be forced into living in only a certain part of the country. The AOA needs to "redistribute"/fix the current GME system.
So new schools = more graduates. No (or not enough) new residencies BEFORE hand = more grad's with no place to go. Even forgeting the issues of quality applicants and impact on the view of the profession overall, this is a hughe issue that needs to be delt with. We can not have a profession that is Unique and then say that we reliy on MD residencies for half of our grads train ing because we cant support them. If thats the case we should all just give it up and switch the whole profession to MD.
And lastly, the motivation behind opening the new schools is dubious. Touro first open in only 1994. They just opened a brach campus in 2004 in Las Vegas and now the want to open one in New York!!! Are you kidding me?!! How can they possibly be taking care of there students?! By comparison my school, DMU, has been open for more than 100 years. It has ZERO branch campuses and has just built a 30 million dollar new facility FOR the students ( New library, tons of new study space, cafiteria, gym etc...). Arizona already HAS a DO school, which is a branch campus of CCOM! There is a new MD school opening in Arizona as well. Doesnt seem like a shortfall of schools on Az.
Do some homework before making blanket statements.