Death Nommy - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I get DVMD's hair standing on end feeling but...idk. It doesn't to me match the gamestate? Like I think the only reason it may feel like there's something rotten is because that is the feeling the brain gets when you keep yeeting villagers, but from my perspective that was the nature of the game for two days and not an indication that the POE is wrong.
 
How Dare You Drama GIF by Paramount+
I SAID SORRY, POSTS OVER 30 WORDS DON'T PLAY NICE WITH MY GOLDFISH BRAIN
 
I get DVMD's hair standing on end feeling but...idk. It doesn't to me match the gamestate? Like I think the only reason it may feel like there's something rotten is because that is the feeling the brain gets when you keep yeeting villagers, but from my perspective that was the nature of the game for two days and not an indication that the POE is wrong.
I agree.
Only yesterday we may have got it wrong. But I think we only had villagers yesterday.
The day before I think it was all village on the board.

I don’t think we’re not anywhere near throwing our reads into the trash until we’re actually flipping our reads.
 
I agree.
Only yesterday we may have got it wrong. But I think we only had villagers yesterday.
The day before I think it was all village on the board.

I don’t think we’re not anywhere near throwing our reads into the trash until we’re actually flipping our reads.
Yeah. Like to be fair April could still be a wolf, I just still don't think she is.
 
I'm gonna do this for now I think, I still want to do more thorough genny and fruit reading but I'm running into time constraints. @fruitsalad if you could talk about who you would be putting on the ballot if you are voted out today/where your reads stand right now, that would be swell.

yeet fruit
 
I think if Indy flips and is village it would make sense to put fruit and genny back on the board but I suppose it may be too late to request that.

Idk if strategically it makes sense to go for a whole new grouping unless we are SUPER convinced the other two are village after all? Or are we doing this bracket style :thinking:
 
I think if Indy flips and is village it would make sense to put fruit and genny back on the board but I suppose it may be too late to request that.

Idk if strategically it makes sense to go for a whole new grouping unless we are SUPER convinced the other two are village after all? Or are we doing this bracket style :thinking:
I agree. I’d like fruit genny and PSV tbh
 
I’m here and a bit down, sorry if I’m a little sloppy

My top 3 would be indy, psv, genny as before
 
Just for the sake of seeing what people will do when the playing fields are slightly more even

Yeet fruit

Might switch to indy later but we don't need to get that close to hammering at this point in the day, will wait to almost yeet close
 
Day 4 Yeet Tally
indy (4)
- Zenge, samac, indy, rae
fruit (2) - Dubz, April

6/11
yeet close in ~3 hours
 
Just for the sake of seeing what people will do when the playing fields are slightly more even

Yeet fruit

Might switch to indy later but we don't need to get that close to hammering at this point in the day, will wait to almost yeet close
Ya know what?
Fun

Unyeet Indy
Yeet fruit
 
I think something else contributing to general tiredness is that, without NKs, this setup necessarily means there are more people to evaluate for longer and it's likely to be a longer game unless we get things exactly right. So that's exhausting.
 
I've been trying to figure it out on my own because I am smart cookie but I am also bab.... what does ISO stand for
 
I've been trying to figure it out on my own because I am smart cookie but I am also bab.... what does ISO stand for
I say “in search of” cause that’s what my brain did when I started, most people say isolating.

Looking at one individual’s posts
 
Assembling a fruit parfait. Here we go:
samac feels generally villagey, and Clem’s entrance gives off pretty solid village vibes
Very beginning of the game. Hate to harp on the Clem read again, but I can't let it go.
i think i feel most ok with samac, clem, dvmd
MY WOLF READS ARE CLEM, DVMD, PSV, AND INDY
Switching around on not just Clem, but DVMD. I'm not sure I noticed that the first time I read the thread.
Samac
JJJ
April
Zenge

Rae
WZ

SAR
Stagg
genny

Indy
DVMD
PSV
Clem
First colored reads list. Note the lower half-- that will be relevant.
Clem and Zenge aren’t both village, i maintain this
Justification for the Clem switchup. Though as later noted, the Clenge disagreement wasn't very aggressive, so a little strange to make this read.
I think i’ll move indy to neutral
Indy getting a lil boost...
Indy’s constant switching from wolfreading JJJ to village reading JJJ is coming across from a confused villager perspective

But i also feel indy just looked at the tally to cast a vote on JJJ that came across as wolfy to me initially
And an explanation...
i was basing the clem read in reference to zenge, arguing they arent both village

Stagg was an independent bad read
I don't remember why I quoted this. I guess explanation?
yeah i’m aware saying i oppose bussing makes me look worse in the context of defending stagg, but having a bad read doesn’t make me a wolf, i was wrong
Fruit asserted there is no compatibility between them and Stagg. I disagree.
Need to work on that, every time i’m yeeted is for correct reasons (including the misyeet)
Okay I feel bad about this one but also the wording interested me. Piqued my interested that it's phrased as "the misyeet" when it seems the discussion is also being had about a potential yeet this game. Would that not be a misyeet?
I’m starting to doubt my earlier statement that clem is a wolf
Double uno reverse is simply a 360.
I have a lot of green reads that i think a wolf may be lying among them
This was an interesting assertion and later clarified that Zenge was the likely lurker. It went no further.
Rae isn’t really unpaired from stagg though

She had like 5 orange/sus reads and placed a vote on stagg (that’s presented as an idk read) for activity reasons
Going from pushing Clem to pushing Rae for not being unpaired with Stagg, which is ?
JJJ
samac
Zenge

WZ
Clem
Indy

SAR
rae
DVMD

genny
April
PSV
reads progress: April down, Clem and Indy up.
Indy wolfread stagg and went with the vote, a bit passive but little strong imo
Clearing Indy for light Stagg reasons.
i don’t understand the indy suspicions
And not understanding the Indy suspicions despite earlier being suspicious of Indy...
samac
JJJ
Zenge
WZ

indy
April

rae
SAR
DVMD

genny
PSV
April did a big jump
samac
Zenge
WZ

JJJ
April
rae

SAR
DVMD
Indy

genny
PSV
And Indy plummeted
well i don’t feel good about DVMD, SAR, and PSV at the very least
This, in response to who might be a wolf based on the reaction test, is interesting because then Fruit goes on to talk about Indy/me/Genny being the ones of interest for their top picks.
I’m here and a bit down, sorry if I’m a little sloppy

My top 3 would be indy, psv, genny as before
^^ here
samac
Zenge
WZ

rae
April

SAR
DVMD

indy
genny
PSV
And the final reads. Indy back in the bottom, along with me and genny. SAR and DVMD just above us.
What sticks out to me doing this ISO is that, despite changing a lot of reads on some people, others have remained intriguingly static. Mine, for instance, which seems to have started as wolfy before I even entered the thread and has not changed at all. genny, as well. DVMD also has remained near the bottom of the reads list. Indy is the one who's bounced around Fruit's POE the most, from in to out to in again. genny, myself, and DVMD seem to be sitting in the POE completely impervious to reevaluation, unlike others.
Obviously things around myself stick out. But I've talked myself out of village leaning fruit.
 
Assembling a fruit parfait. Here we go:
Very beginning of the game. Hate to harp on the Clem read again, but I can't let it go.


Switching around on not just Clem, but DVMD. I'm not sure I noticed that the first time I read the thread.

First colored reads list. Note the lower half-- that will be relevant.

Justification for the Clem switchup. Though as later noted, the Clenge disagreement wasn't very aggressive, so a little strange to make this read.

Indy getting a lil boost...

And an explanation...

I don't remember why I quoted this. I guess explanation?

Fruit asserted there is no compatibility between them and Stagg. I disagree.

Okay I feel bad about this one but also the wording interested me. Piqued my interested that it's phrased as "the misyeet" when it seems the discussion is also being had about a potential yeet this game. Would that not be a misyeet?

Double uno reverse is simply a 360.

This was an interesting assertion and later clarified that Zenge was the likely lurker. It went no further.

Going from pushing Clem to pushing Rae for not being unpaired with Stagg, which is ?

reads progress: April down, Clem and Indy up.

Clearing Indy for light Stagg reasons.

And not understanding the Indy suspicions despite earlier being suspicious of Indy...

April did a big jump

And Indy plummeted

This, in response to who might be a wolf based on the reaction test, is interesting because then Fruit goes on to talk about Indy/me/Genny being the ones of interest for their top picks.

^^ here

And the final reads. Indy back in the bottom, along with me and genny. SAR and DVMD just above us.
What sticks out to me doing this ISO is that, despite changing a lot of reads on some people, others have remained intriguingly static. Mine, for instance, which seems to have started as wolfy before I even entered the thread and has not changed at all. genny, as well. DVMD also has remained near the bottom of the reads list. Indy is the one who's bounced around Fruit's POE the most, from in to out to in again. genny, myself, and DVMD seem to be sitting in the POE completely impervious to reevaluation, unlike others.
Obviously things around myself stick out. But I've talked myself out of village leaning fruit.
My village reads are mostly unchanged too, so not sure why you’re ignoring that, also i mentioned i might be misclearing people
 
There’s a 3-3 tie with you and Indy. Why not self pres?
I want to discuss genny too since the gamestate’s focused specifically on me and indy, and i also think votes may change leading up to yeet close
 
Okay. genny is next. The fruit one took me way longer than intended but I believe genny and indy both have fewer posts so should have tons of time to chat before close.
 
Okay I feel bad about this one but also the wording interested me. Piqued my interested that it's phrased as "the misyeet" when it seems the discussion is also being had about a potential yeet this game. Would that not be a misyeet?
The misyeet refers to last game
 
Fruits pls, you gotta read the whole spoiler and not just the blurb at the end!
Your ISO complains i’m static toward you, genny, and DVMD (not so much on DVMD since i had her village initially, then moved to neutral, while hovering around there)

Also i dont really understand your bringing up the clem situation
 
DVMD also has remained near the bottom of the reads list. Indy is the one who's bounced around Fruit's POE the most, from in to out to in again. genny, myself, and DVMD seem to be sitting in the POE completely impervious to reevaluation, unlike others.
I dont know why you’re bringing up dvmd when in your own iso, you referenced i dropped her from village to wolf to neutral in the changing reads
 
Also warning my internet is on the fritz and if it cuts out again, I am not going to be able to go back through individual posts because that is a pain in the arse to do on my phone and I don't want to do it on my phone.

So hopefully it continues to cooperate but no promises, the entire neighborhood has been having internet issues today.
 
genny's ISO took much less time. Wahoo.
oh no we may actually have to talk to each other about our reads
First post. I think this is a fine, funny intro.
and we get punished for yeeting a wolf i guess. no yeet is not allowed.
This feels like genuine exacerbation.
thread consensus could be disastrous if wolves have thread control
An insight no one else had pointed out yet.
oh JJ you're going to love this then. i'm seriously thinking about voting for you. because 1) this game plays to your strengths as a wolf and i think you'd be really hard to catch. and 2) if you are village, i think you'd do a good job setting us up for a good D2 yeet.
Spicy on JJJ, but mainly quoted for 2 because it foreshadows something later on.
You’re gonna wolf read me and then not even remember that? Ok boomer.
Annoyed with JJJ but doesn't seem overly defensive. Pretty chill.
I have 2 minutes between appointments. I’ve decided I’m not voting for the following folks today: dvmd, Clem, samac, Dubz, JJ, Rae, Indy, April.
Despite earlier annoyance, not willing to vote JJJ.
yeet fruit
First genny vote on the board is thrown fruit's way.
stagg is a lazy vote, but never really wrong. i could go for indy, but i'd feel bad about it.

i'm tempted to go for zenges just because clem was so forceful about it.
The stagg part has been discussed already but I'm more interested in the Indy bit. genny and Indy are incompatible.
i have been sharing them as i go. i think you're village and i'm sorry you can't read me. i do agree with your take on indy. but i don't know if i'd go there D1 since indy is brand new.
This was @ DVMD. And I want to point toward the Indy sus again.
i maintain that i get wolf read when i'm busy (like tuesdays/wednesdays), and not wolf read when i can participate. if y'all have to yeet me this game to see that, PLEASE REMEMBER IT FOR NEXT TIME.
I honestly don't think a wolf would include the second sentence. The first, absolutely, but the second? Mmm...
But that's my opinion.
i don't think april is a hit. and i think i might prefer dubz to choose the next day's candidates.
Okay, this is what I was talking about when I mentioned her JJJ sus foreshadowing something. This seemed weird at the time but there actually was a precedent for genny thinking this way.
i wouldn't complain about why. i know i don't fall in line very well. and i don't really care to.
I just think this is funny and encapsulates genny well.
again, you're throwing shade at me for not yeeting village jj. yes, please, continue to berate me for not yeeting a villager.
Annoyed with fruit.
I will take suggestions but I’m not going to reveal my list.
This made me hmm but it seems in line with her previous thinking.
What I've gleaned from genny's ISO is that she isn't really thinking about the game the way most other people are: and I mean that as a compliment. I think she has unique insight and approaches the setup differently which is contributing to her seeming like she might not be giving reads (but she is). I am village-reading genny.
Of note: genny is not compatible with either Indy or fruit. If genny flips wolf, I struggle to see Indy or fruit being a packmate. If Indy or fruit flip wolf, I have no interest in voting genny.
 
Ok, gonna be honest and admit I had an absolutely lovely day with my family and didn't look at the thread once

Now I will be here and probably stay up late to actually be around for close to make up for it. Planning to do my own iso of Indy and Fruits since I did one the other day on genny already to see how they stack up. Tbh genny has felt more in line with the genny way in the past day or so but she can also hit stride as a wolf well so I'm not totally discounting that yet
 
Top