Yes. I'm trying not to go into my ISOs (whenever they may happen) with too many preconceived notions but I'm suspecting genny and fruit less, which leaves me with ???
I will take suggestions but I’m not going to reveal my list.
Ope
I’d actually appreciate if you did so we can know where your head is at.
It’s a mountainous game with a couple extra steps
My head is at trying to help the rest of the village as much as possible, while also not revealing everything to wolves so they can't base their yeet pick on who's got the emptiest eel pool.
Don’t you break my blocc.
I mean we’ve already got a wolf. There’s likely 2 left. Those 2 left being within two of reads isn’t unreasonable.
There really doesn’t.
She said shouldn't be MORE than 3 max. I agree with her, if I had to bet money I'd think there are two left
You’re village. You win
Feel this, I’m just confused and tired and still not 100% feeling better, so I think this is for the better ….
*sigh*
Idk, had a feeling about DVMD, PSV, Zenge
Sorry if I've missed this (I probably have) but what are your reads on fruit and genny?
Maybe? Definitely sketchier than some but I didn’t know if you could name others already up
You can put up whatever 3 you want. DVMD, PSV and Zenge is definitely an interesting choice
Okay, giving peeps 5 min before I send in my names and go back to sleep to convince me otherwise……
Now knowing that you can, does that change your responses?
Those are overall fine. I’d prefer you take out Zenges and replace with genny or fruit but I can live with it.
Interesting sheep choice
I will point out as a bit of a counter to this assessment that Indy's reads list came out after several events that might be important context
I truly think wolf genny would have been less meh about Stagg. Calling it a "lazy but fine" (paraphrased) vote is just not how I would expect her to interact with packmate!Stagg. I'd give genny's interactions with Stagg a slight village lean
Given fruits expressed they don't like to bus, this is still a pretty bad look. I don't think they could realistically say they have no problem with bussing when Jay asked, because that doesn't seem to be reflected in their behavior in Mission Impossible.
And then this is interesting because it makes fruit look a little worse than indy but I think tonally, recently, indy has felt a little worse
THE CLEARED GROUP IS CLEAR PLS
They felt very comfortable in the thread until the moment when things got serious. Chaotic d1, does not appear that they're being coached by anyone, but also not dropping questions in the thread very often like we usually see from nooblets all out on their own. I don't think that's necessarily wolfy, just a mental note that we don't have something like that pure unaccompanied nooblet vibe that we saw with beans last game. This is a good point from Jay. It's a really good point.
because I'm not sure how you can reasonably say samac had been lacking in substance up to that point in the game, regardless of her activity on that particular dayAgain focusing on retaliatory reads, which is just classic noob behavior and I feel like more often village indicative than wolf (most wolves I feel try to placate their accusors rather than pushing them, villagers more likely to be tilted by incorrect suspicion, I don't have data on that, it's just my general impression).
I get it, I do.I don't think reading through Indy's ISO helped me too much
Not gonna quote every single post but a few key things came up while I was reading
This is a good point from Jay. It's a really good point.
This quote is....
The consistent retaliatory push on rae does lean village for me, they also had a similar take after Jay voiced suspicion of them in the quote above. Those are points in the village noob bucket.
I forgot about rae's wall post about Indy and am reading it for the first time (sorry rae). There are good points there. It's solid. And since out of any of us rae does actually know Indy's personality the best, maybe it is worth pursuing for that reason.
Again focusing on retaliatory reads, which is just classic noob behavior and I feel like more often village indicative than wolf (most wolves I feel try to placate their accusors rather than pushing them, villagers more likely to be tilted by incorrect suspicion, I don't have data on that, it's just my general impression).
I just wish I saw more overall here that seemed outright WOLFY and wasn't largely based on floundering, chaotic, and retaliatory stuff that could all be attributed to being a new player.
And the softy part of me really wants to get this right because it sucks a little extra to be misyeeted in your first game.
