Hematology/Oncology 2022-2023 Fellowship Application Cycle

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Pa22 said:
I can't seem to assign the LoRs to ERAS if they have not been processed by EFDO. This means that the programs will not have access to those letters when they download the application. What do I do? Just apply with two letters and assign the remainder once they are processed by EFDO? Some programs mention on their websites that they do not review incomplete applications.
Click to expand...
Yes, just apply. "Incomplete application" is kind of a meaningless phrase since everyone has different definitions of complete.

And there's no more downloading, so don't worry about that.

If a program is setting filters to only look at apps w/ X LORs, and you have X-1, your app won't even exist to them so it doesn't matter if you submitted or not. BUT...that's a really stupid thing to filter on for an initial run-through of apps, so I doubt (m)any programs are using that. When I used to review apps for fellowship, I would be interviewing people who didn't have all X of their LORs in so clearly, it's not really that important.

Control what you can and hit the submit button as soon as possible.
Members don't see this ad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Pa22 said:
July 18th will be 5 business day but given that the past letters took more than 5, I am worried I may not have them processed before July 20th
Click to expand...
I understand the frustration. It may be due to Omicron BA.5 work shortages? Either way, you're not the only one with this issue. I'm still waiting on our PD letter to process which won't be done before July 20th. All my friends are still waiting for at least one letter to process as well. I think some fellowship PDs are aware. Just go ahead and submit.
 
Hi everyone.

I would appreciate any advice on which LoRs to combine.

My PD told me their letter was comprehensive, strong and included lots of comments on my clinical skills.

My other 3 letters are all from heme/onc faculty. 2 of them are from my old mentors (from a well known academic center) whom I worked with during a research fellowship for 2+ years right before residency, both their letters are very strong and commented both on my clinical and research skills. I worked with both of them in the clinical setting however my clinical work with them was before I started residency. My third letter is from a heme/onc chairman in my current institution whom I also worked with but mostly in the research setting. This chairman offered to write me a letter (I did not ask him to) and told me that his name will weigh more than other people even though he will not mention my clinical skills, then he assured me that his letter will be strong. I have one more letter also from a heme/onc faculty in my current institution whom I worked with in the clinical setting only and he also told me that his letter is personalized and strong.

I'm torn between choosing the chairman letter or the other letter from my current institution. Any advice? I'm open to suggestions even regarding my other letter. Thanks a ton and sorry for the long post.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Coffee92 said:
Hi everyone.

I would appreciate any advice on which LoRs to combine.

My PD told me their letter was comprehensive, strong and included lots of comments on my clinical skills.

My other 3 letters are all from heme/onc faculty. 2 of them are from my old mentors (from a well known academic center) whom I worked with during a research fellowship for 2+ years right before residency, both their letters are very strong and commented both on my clinical and research skills. I worked with both of them in the clinical setting however my clinical work with them was before I started residency. My third letter is from a heme/onc chairman in my current institution whom I also worked with but mostly in the research setting. This chairman offered to write me a letter (I did not ask him to) and told me that his name will weigh more than other people even though he will not mention my clinical skills, then he assured me that his letter will be strong. I have one more letter also from a heme/onc faculty in my current institution whom I worked with in the clinical setting only and he also told me that his letter is personalized and strong.

I'm torn between choosing the chairman letter or the other letter from my current institution. Any advice? I'm open to suggestions even regarding my other letter. Thanks a ton and sorry for the long post.
Click to expand...
I would actually send both from your residency and just pick one from your pre-residency research year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Trying to figure out how many programs to apply to:
DO applicant
Step 1 210s, Step 2 220s
Levels 1-3 530-550s
Residency: average university program
Have at least 7 Pubmed indexed publications(first auth on 3), at least 8 poster presentations (4 first author)
Good letters of rec (2 heme/onc)

I know scores aren't great plus the DO degree might make it harder but tried doing some research to improve it. Hoping odds are good if I apply broadly?
 
IdahoUdaho said:
Trying to figure out how many programs to apply to:
DO applicant
Step 1 210s, Step 2 220s
Levels 1-3 530-550s
Residency: average university program
Have at least 7 Pubmed indexed publications(first auth on 3), at least 8 poster presentations (4 first author)
Good letters of rec (2 heme/onc)

I know scores aren't great plus the DO degree might make it harder but tried doing some research to improve it. Hoping odds are good if I apply broadly?
Click to expand...
Look at where people in your program have matched in the past and target that “tier”, with some reaches and some safeties on each end. Then take geography into account.

Nobody can give you a safe number. 30 programs won’t be enough if you’re only looking at the MSKCC/MDACC/DFCI level programs. 10 will be too many if you only apply to IMG heavy programs in the NYC area.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
gutonc said:
This is a bad idea, please don't do this. Submit and let your LORs roll in when they do.

Your previous chief is an idiot. This is terrible advice and patently false. Noon conference/morning report presentations like listing all the onc patients you presented on rounds.
Click to expand...
I'll only have 2 LORs that I could assign by the time the deadline approaches. Will programs even review applications with only 2 LORs?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
HemeOncHopeful19 said:
I would actually send both from your residency and just pick one from your pre-residency research year.
Click to expand...
I see. I'm just not 100% sure how strong the ones from my residency are. I worked only briefly with the clinical faculty (2 weeks) so even if they wrote me good letters they know me briefly and they can only write so much even with good intentions, whereas both ones from my old institution I worked with them for 2+ years, I know how strong their letters are.
 
Coffee92 said:
I see. I'm just not 100% sure how strong the ones from my residency are. I worked only briefly with the clinical faculty (2 weeks) so even if they wrote me good letters they know me briefly and they can only write so much even with good intentions, whereas both ones from my old institution I worked with them for 2+ years, I know how strong their letters are.
Click to expand...
In your previous post, you mentioned that the heme onc chief and a prof at your current institution assured you the letter would be strong. If that's really the case, I don't see any reason to believe that it wouldn't be. Usually faculty is very honest about their assessment of letter strength. For example, one of the faculty i approached for a letter said that he would be happy to write me one but he didn't think it would be strong enough. In your case they told you no such thing. I would attach the recent letters if I were you.
PS: All 3 out of my 4 letter writers assured that the letter will be strong. The 4th one is a nationally renowned oncologist and chief of oncology at my program. Although he did not comment on the strength but I am told he wouldn't agree to write one if it wasn't strong and he is the CHIEF!
 
I have 4 letters uploaded (including PD’s) and I’m tempted to assign all of them. That being said, one letter is probably my strongest from a rockstar in the field. The other 2 letters are from attendings at my program. If I assign all, do I run the risk of a program randomly choosing 3 out of the 4 while overlooking the rockstar’s letter?
 
wolfofparkstreet said:
I have 4 letters uploaded (including PD’s) and I’m tempted to assign all of them. That being said, one letter is probably my strongest from a rockstar in the field. The other 2 letters are from attendings at my program. If I assign all, do I run the risk of a program randomly choosing 3 out of the 4 while overlooking the rockstar’s letter?
Click to expand...
No
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
How many programs do I apply to? I understand its a hard question to answer but I have 49 programs on my list, selected according to location. I am a family person and would want to stay with my spouse and kid, so do not see myself moving to states/cities other than mentioned below.
These are my stats -

Step 1,2 - 220s, Step 3 - 210
FMG from a top tier medical school (harvard equivalent in my country)
IM Residency at a university affiliated program in north east
Currently in a 2 year preventive medicine residency and a combined MPH program at a top 20 university program in north east
3 poster presentations in IM residency (non heme-onc), 1 publication (case series, non heme onc) in IM residency, 1 published BMJ case report (non-heme onc) in medical school, 2 onc-related poster presentations in prev med res (preparing manuscript), 1 original research abstract submitted to ASCO Quality care 2022 (pending decision of acceptance/rejection, preparing manuscript)
Bunch of extracurriculars in oncology (advocacy, volunteer, presentations, etc.)
Gap between med school and IM residency of 5 years (I trained and worked in primary care in my home country for 2.5 years, 1 year research in USA, 1.5 years can't be explained)
Letters - 2 from each residency PD (one of them will be outstanding, other will be excellent), 1 from research mentor who is an IM professor (outstanding), 1 from a nationally renowned breast oncologist (who is also the chief of heme-onc at my current institution) (strong, but probably not outstanding)
Visa status: Green card
I am considering applying to about 49 programs (almost all in tri state, and mid-tier and top-tier in Boston, Rhode Island, Washington DC, SF, Chicago, Seattle, Philadelphia)
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Hello

If I did non accredited ACGME training , how can I add it to the ERAS application? lets say I did BMT fellowship can I just add hematology in training and in comment list that it is non acgme accredited or list it only under working experience?
 
Art Nostrand said:
Hello

If I did non accredited ACGME training , how can I add it to the ERAS application? lets say I did BMT fellowship can I just add hematology in training and in comment list that it is non acgme accredited or list it only under working experience?
Click to expand...
Pick one. I would probably put it in training. But it doesn't really matter. You were doing it for the LOR anyway.
 
Pa22 said:
How many programs do I apply to? I understand its a hard question to answer but I have 49 programs on my list, selected according to location. I am a family person and would want to stay with my spouse and kid, so do not see myself moving to states/cities other than mentioned below.
These are my stats -

Step 1,2 - 220s, Step 3 - 210
FMG from a top tier medical school (harvard equivalent in my country)
IM Residency at a university affiliated program in north east
Currently in a 2 year preventive medicine residency and a combined MPH program at a top 20 university program in north east
3 poster presentations in IM residency (non heme-onc), 1 publication (case series, non heme onc) in IM residency, 1 published BMJ case report (non-heme onc) in medical school, 2 onc-related poster presentations in prev med res (preparing manuscript), 1 original research abstract submitted to ASCO Quality care 2022 (pending decision of acceptance/rejection, preparing manuscript)
Bunch of extracurriculars in oncology (advocacy, volunteer, presentations, etc.)
Gap between med school and IM residency of 5 years (I trained and worked in primary care in my home country for 2.5 years, 1 year research in USA, 1.5 years can't be explained)
Click to expand...
Were you in prison? Because if you can't explain your time away from medicine, the assumption will be that you were in prison, or worse.
Pa22 said:
Letters - 2 from each residency PD (one of them will be outstanding, other will be excellent), 1 from research mentor who is an IM professor (outstanding), 1 from a nationally renowned breast oncologist (who is also the chief of heme-onc at my current institution) (strong, but probably not outstanding)
Visa status: Green card
Click to expand...
As in you have a GC? If so, forget visa status completely, you're golden.
Pa22 said:
I am considering applying to about 49 programs (almost all in tri state, and mid-tier and top-tier in Boston, Rhode Island, Washington DC, SF, Chicago, Seattle, Philadelphia)
Click to expand...
I'm going to make some assumptions here so correct me if I'm wrong. DFCI, MGH, UCSF, Stanford, UofC, NW, UW/Hutch (or whatever they're calling it this year, I understand another rebranding is in the works) and Penn are going to be donations to ERAS. It's only a couple of Benjamins, so do it you want, but don't expect much.

30-40 is a pretty good number though.
 
gutonc said:
Were you in prison? Because if you can't explain your time away from medicine, the assumption will be that you were in prison, or worse.

As in you have a GC? If so, forget visa status completely, you're golden.

I'm going to make some assumptions here so correct me if I'm wrong. DFCI, MGH, UCSF, Stanford, UofC, NW, UW/Hutch (or whatever they're calling it this year, I understand another rebranding is in the works) and Penn are going to be donations to ERAS. It's only a couple of Benjamins, so do it you want, but don't expect much.

30-40 is a pretty good number though.
Click to expand...

I had moved from my home country to the USA. Didn’t have a work visa and took steps in those 1.5 years. Is that a good enough explanation?

You are right about the program selection above, in addition to some more mid tier programs in these states/cities
 
I know we shouldn't expect interview invitations for a while, but does anyone know how most are scheduled? Are they more commonly scheduled through ERAS or outside scheduling mechanisms?

Also trying to think ahead about how many interviews to attend. I know there can't possibly be a set answer to this question. Coming from a top tier med school and residency, good test scores and LORs, mediocre research experience/CV, and I'm geographically targeting where I'm applying due to where my spouse and I want to live (primarily midwest but also some east coast and scattered elsewhere, 25 total) applying to a mix of mid tier and some top tier programs. I'm thinking 10 might be a good place to stop, if I'm fortunate to get that many interviews, but also wondering if I should just interview at more than that to be on the safe side (e.g. up to 15), seeing as Heme/Onc has gotten more competitive.
 
Pa22 said:
I had moved from my home country to the USA. Didn’t have a work visa and took steps in those 1.5 years. Is that a good enough explanation?
Click to expand...
Yes. Like I said, you just need to tell them what you were doing. An 18 month gap = prison +/- rehab unless you tell me otherwise.

"Moved to US, studied for and took USMLE Examinations" is all you need.
 
gutonc said:
This is a bad idea, please don't do this. Submit and let your LORs roll in when they do.

Your previous chief is an idiot. This is terrible advice and patently false. Noon conference/morning report presentations like listing all the onc patients you presented on rounds.
Click to expand...
How about Grand rounds? Do you think its worth listing if you did Onc Grand rounds ?
 
ivafactor said:
How about Grand rounds? Do you think its worth listing if you did Onc Grand rounds ?
Click to expand...
Personally as a fellowship recruitment committee member and a person who evaluates apps and interviews prospective fellows I would only include this if it was related to research you did. If you gave grand rounds on a topic or a case presentation I really don’t see the value
 
How badly are your chances of receiving interviews affected if your MSPE and med school transcript are still EFDO processing?
 
NK9 said:
How badly are your chances of receiving interviews affected if your MSPE and med school transcript are still EFDO processing?
Click to expand...
This week? Not at all. Not ready by November? You might be in trouble.

Seriously, don't worry about the stuff you can't control. As long as it's just EFDO and not them waiting on you to do something, it will happen, and lots of other applicants are also hung up at that step.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
In the previous years’ threads people have mentioned reaching out to programs personally for interviews or having your mentors reach out. When is the time for that? Wait until a few weeks?
 
Acknowledgement from UBuffalo today? Anyone with invites or rejections, do realize its too early for anything though
 
Pa22 said:
Acknowledgement from UBuffalo today? Anyone with invites or rejections, do realize its too early for anything though
Click to expand...
No invites, rejections, or acknowledgement emails for me yet. I think it's likely too early to expect much.

Does anyone know if there is a spreadsheet circulating yet to track invites, etc?
 
Pa22 said:
Acknowledgement from UBuffalo today? Anyone with invites or rejections, do realize its too early for anything though
Click to expand...
Do you require a visa? During residency match, they sent out acknowledgment/invitations emails in patches, starting with people who don't need a visa
 
Can we keep the invites and rejections here?

I feel it’s easier to follow and for people to give advice here.
 
melsayed8 said:
Do you require a visa? During residency match, they sent out acknowledgment/invitations emails in patches, starting with people who don't need a visa
Click to expand...
I don't need a visa. But I just checked my emails from residency match. At the time, I did have visa requirement. I started receiving acknowledgements 5 days after submission, rejection 2 weeks after submissions, and invites, 3 weeks after. Almost all the places that sent acknowledgement ended up sending rejections. So my sense is acknowledgements don't really mean anything.
 
Acknowledgement from UB today in my inbox. No invitations or rejections yet!

Non visa requiring IMG!
 
It is little bit early for invites.

I expect early August they will start sending invites
 
Anyone have access to the 2021/2022 spreadsheet? Seems like they made it private. I think dates are a little off on the 2020/2021 spreadsheet because the deadline was in August. Last years spreadsheet would be useful.
 
carbotaxl said:
Anyone have access to the 2021/2022 spreadsheet? Seems like they made it private. I think dates are a little off on the 2020/2021 spreadsheet because the deadline was in August. Last years spreadsheet would be useful.
Click to expand...
If only there was a different place where you could discuss things and have it archived for future years…
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Is it true that yog>10 years discourage the fellowship applications? Did you guys hear that programs still use yog filter for fellowship?
I was listening to a video on youtube; a PD for a small program in St loius said they don't extend invitations to people with yog>10 years.
 
First rejection of the year - UNC

(IMG no visa required)
 
medini said:
First rejection of the year - UNC

(IMG no visa required)
Click to expand...
I'm only asking cause your profile lists your 3 months of USCE. Did you also list those 3 months on your fellowship CV?
 
DoctorJayy said:
Same, US MD. My scores and research average so thinking didn’t make the cut off
Click to expand...
Hi. If you don't mind, what is your sense of the strength of your letters? Good vs strong? I did not apply to UNC but I am an IMG and I am wondering what kind of filters they use.
 
melsayed8 said:
Is it true that yog>10 years discourage the fellowship applications? Did you guys hear that programs still use yog filter for fellowship?
I was listening to a video on youtube; a PD for a small program in St loius said they don't extend invitations to people with yog>10 years.
Click to expand...
It's clearly true for that program. Or at least it was when the video was made. How generalizable that is is something that is unknowable.
 
Pa22 said:
Hi. If you don't mind, what is your sense of the strength of your letters? Good vs strong? I did not apply to UNC but I am an IMG and I am wondering what kind of filters they use.
Click to expand...
Very strong and well known in the field. I doubt they even looked at the letters
 
Based on the requests above to note invites/rejections here, just sharing update, got interview invite from UC Davis. These were the interview dates they had in case this is helpful for anyone applying this year or in the future: 8/26, 8/29, 9/2, 9/9, 9/12, 9/19, 9/23, 9/26
I'll try to update both the spreadsheet and SDN as invites and rejections pour in (hoping the former more than the latter but we shall see lol!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
BigBangFan said:
Based on the requests above to note invites/rejections here, just sharing update, got interview invite from UC Davis. These were the interview dates they had in case this is helpful for anyone applying this year or in the future: 8/26, 8/29, 9/2, 9/9, 9/12, 9/19, 9/23, 9/26
I'll try to update both the spreadsheet and SDN as invites and rejections pour in (hoping the former more than the latter but we shall see lol!)
Click to expand...
Do you mind sharing the spreadsheet link?
 
UNC. Based on the spreadsheet, it looks like interview offers have only come from UNC, Iowa, UC Davis, Florida Jacksonville, and Pembroke Pines Memorial Healthcare so far. A very small minority of programs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
You must log in or register to reply here.
Next unread thread

Similar threads

A
  • Sticky
Hematology/Oncology Fellowship 2023-2024 application cycle
2
Replies
86
Views
41K
HaemOnculus
HaemOnculus
I
Heme Onc fellowship swap
Replies
11
Views
3K
npat
N
T
Heme/Onc Fellowship Chances
Replies
11
Views
2K
HemOncCheng
HemOncCheng
S
  • Question
What's the average salary for an academic oncologist?
Replies
21
Views
2K
gutonc
gutonc
D
  • Locked
Hematology/Oncology 2021-2022 Fellowship Application Cycle
2 3 4 5
Replies
246
Views
148K
gutonc
gutonc
Top