Lurking Beloww: Sea Monsters Sign Ups and Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Day 1 Election Tally
allie (2) - allie, DVMD
Pippy (5) - Pippy, Skim, AM, SAR, capri
AM () - AM
genny (6) - genny, bryndi, Coffee?, Stagg, jboo, dolphin
Mel (2) - Mel, WZ

15/18
Missing: kc, SOV, Snowy

Day 2 Lynch Tally
SAR (4) - AM, genny, Skim, Pippy, genny, DVMD
kc (1) - Coffee?, Pippy
DVMD () - Pippy
bj (1) - Skim, WZ
Coffee? (5) - jboo, SOV, bj, Stagg, Snowy, SAR
Pippy () - kc
genny (1) - SAR, allie
jboo (2) - dolphin, Pippy
dolphin (1) - kc
Stagg () - genny
WZ (1) - bj

16/16

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Pippy (1) - DVMD, kc
Stagg () - jboo, genny
bj () - Pippy
Snowy () - AM
jboo (3) - Pippy, dolphin, SAR, bj, kc, allie, genny
dolphin (2) - Snowy, AM
allie () - Stagg
SAR (1) - Skim
genny (5) - Pippy, jboo, DVMD, SAR, Stagg

12/14
Missing: allie, SOV

Day 4 Lynch Tally
DVMD (1) - Pippy, SOV
SAR (4) - AM, Stagg, Skim, jboo
Snowy () - jboo
Pippy (1) - kc
kc () - Pippy
jboo (5) - Snowy, dolphin, SAR, bryndi, Pippy
dolphin () - SAR

11/14
Missing: Cray, allie, DVMD

Day 5 Lynch Tally
SAR (5) - DVMD, AM, bj, Stagg, DVMD, Cray, Skim, bj
DVMD (1) - Pippy, bj
AM (3) - DVMD, SAR, Skim, DVMD, SOV, kc, bj
dolphin (1) - Pippy
Pippy () - DVMD
Stagg (1) - dolphin
Skim () - bj

11/12
Missing: allie
 
PippyPony said:
Pocketypocketypock
Click to expand...
Fyi @SARdoghandler I freaked the **** out in my mod pm earlier today and gave everyone nicknames because I'm preeeeetty sure I am the only remaining villager, and this is the nickname I gave you. It makes its on-thread debut in light of your flip
 
PippyPony said:
Fyi @SARdoghandler I freaked the **** out in my mod pm earlier today and gave everyone nicknames because I'm preeeeetty sure I am the only remaining villager, and this is the nickname I gave you. It makes its on-thread debut in light of your flip
Click to expand...

I'm so curious for what my nickname could be.
 
PippyPony said:
Yeah, and in the process did you almost try to tie it up, but not make it all the way?

Sketch city
Click to expand...
I'm sorry, what? How would I have tied it? I think you need to slow down on the margaritas, because SAR was heavily in the lead, with or without my vote
 
PippyPony said:
Why are you trying to make AM into a wolf?
Click to expand...

I'm not?

I'm asking why she wouldn't vote to save SAR after basically saying she thought SAR was a villager while not saying anything to actually defend AM. The logic just doesn't make sense to me unless I'm missing something.

Are you really trying to imply that AM wasn't coming across as sketchy af earlier? Because I'm pretty sure I can find quite a few posts from you asking her why she was being so sketchy earlier unless I'm mixing people up.
 
PippyPony said:
If you pay me $20 I will tell you

Can't give that **** up for free, I'm a starving vet student over here who just had to buy a bottle of Cointreau for my most excellent margaritas
Click to expand...

I'm sorry, but my 20Q foundation just got defunded so I am unable to afford this fee. Even so, I cannot endorse posts sponsored by intoxicating beverages.
 
Stagg737 said:
I'm not?

I'm asking why she wouldn't vote to save SAR after basically saying she thought SAR was a villager while not saying anything to actually defend AM. The logic just doesn't make sense to me unless I'm missing something.

Are you really trying to imply that AM wasn't coming across as sketchy af earlier? Because I'm pretty sure I can find quite a few posts from you asking her why she was being so sketchy earlier unless I'm mixing people up.
Click to expand...
See my addendum

I think I misread your post the first time

Carry on
 
Skimble said:
And you chose to protect yourself vs our seer?
Click to expand...
...

...She got attacked twice?

...... would you prefer she DIDN'T protect herself?

"Our seer" sounds very "us villagers"

DVMDream said:
It implies she has an ability. I have had players tell me that and then turns out they can only PM pictures. I don't take it super seriously anymore unless something actually does happen. To me, it didn't mean more than she has an ability which it seems everyone does but me this game.
Click to expand...
This is straight bull**** though.

You maaaaay be vanilla village (I'm on the fence tbh), but ...W O W. You don't pay attention to role hints? Since when?

Skimble said:
Because it would have prevented the frustrating conversation we just had. I also think only protecting yourself makes the protector kind of pointless (just my opinion).
Click to expand...
Yeah it really sucks when those damn pesky protectors actually protect the people who get attacked

Skimble said:
Wow... the person I've voted to lynch every day is a wolf. That first post just gave me all the feels.
Click to expand...
This kind of reads to me like "oh look, see? I lynched a wolf"

kcoughli said:
**** I leave for a hot second and we actually lynched a wolf? We meaning the village because I definitely didn't help with this one.

I see AM revealed. Still not 100% convinced considering I don't recall anyone corroborating her supposed attacks or anyone receiving protection. But I suppose the question will likely be answered tonight anyway.
Click to expand...
Yes, I suppose it shall be. I think I may take this opportunity to say that if she is dead tomorrow morning after this hedge-fest threat of a statement, I may make it my personal goal to see that you get lynched
 
PippyPony said:
This is straight bull**** though.

You maaaaay be vanilla village (I'm on the fence tbh), but ...W O W. You don't pay attention to role hints? Since when?
Click to expand...


Ok, let's get on mutual ground. You can not call something I've personally experienced bull****. End of. Yes, I've had people tell me to "watch so and so because I told em stuff about my role" for them to be a role that PMs pictures, blocker, tracker, protector, seer, silencer, basically if the role exists people have said this to me..... so much that I do just go "meh whatever" as an initial reaction and I don't think twice about it unless something does happen.

Do not tell me I haven't experienced something I actually have.

I really, really hate when people pull that crap.
 
Upon consideration...

I'm not sure Jil would bus another wolf repeatedly like that. Still don't love those comments or the speed at which she latched on to voting AM today....but idk if she would do that & disagree with AM so vocally as a wolf.

DVMD still falls in the mild sketch category for me, I think, which I think she'll be thrilled about. She absolutely would bus SAR at this point in the game; have seen her do similar things.

Cray gets village points for coming on and lynching SAR. I think it would be highly unlikely she does that as a wolf.

Her being planned late-add village puts SOV back on the table for me as a wolf possibility.

Kinda want to see how dolphin flips to see if there was a multi-angle pocket attempt on me going on, though.

Bryndi's votes look kinda gross at first pass, but they almost look bad enough to not be actually sketch in my mind.
 
And one more thing.....

There is no "role hint" in what Snowy told me. .. I copy/pasted it. All it implies is that she has an ability. Do people who have more "important" abilities tend to do that more, yes, of course, but be honest, everyone in WW thinks their ability is important.

Except me, my ability sucks... I feel like I should at least be able to make a big splash or something.... even if it doesn't do anything. ... I'm like the most famous whale in literature.... what gives? Oh well, carry on my friends.
 
PippyPony said:
Upon consideration...

I'm not sure Jil would bus another wolf repeatedly like that. Still don't love those comments or the speed at which she latched on to voting AM today....but idk if she would do that & disagree with AM so vocally as a wolf.

DVMD still falls in the mild sketch category for me, I think, which I think she'll be thrilled about. She absolutely would bus SAR at this point in the game; have seen her do similar things.

Cray gets village points for coming on and lynching SAR. I think it would be highly unlikely she does that as a wolf.

Her being planned late-add village puts SOV back on the table for me as a wolf possibility.

Kinda want to see how dolphin flips to see if there was a multi-angle pocket attempt on me going on, though.

Bryndi's votes look kinda gross at first pass, but they almost look bad enough to not be actually sketch in my mind.
Click to expand...

Yeah, bused SAR day 2, last night and today. Also managed to be blocked on the only two no kill night. 😵:bored: Along with the only player to name reveal like you asked, minus AM but that was worse than pulling a carnassial with only 1 bad root.
 
DVMDream said:
Ok, let's get on mutual ground. You can not call something I've personally experienced bull****. End of. Yes, I've had people tell me to "watch so and so because I told em stuff about my role" for them to be a role that PMs pictures, blocker, tracker, protector, seer, silencer, basically if the role exists people have said this to me..... so much that I do just go "meh whatever" as an initial reaction and I don't think twice about it unless something does happen.

Do not tell me I haven't experienced something I actually have.

I really, really hate when people pull that crap.
Click to expand...
Ok so lets make sure we are on the same page, then.

What it sounds to me like you are saying is that if you were a wolf, you would straight up ignore/discount someone in PM saying "oh ps, I told this person about my role, maybe look into them if I die"?

Really?

...?

Because that kind of thing freaking SCREAMS power role, and you are far too good of a wolf for me to believe for one half of a millisecond that you would just totally ignore that and be like "oh lol guys, they probably have a gif sending role, totes not a priority to kill this person, definitely no opportunity to leverage this here PM message against the other party."

I'm going to borrow a line from AM and say that my eyes may permanently roll back into my skull if you suggest you would not even consider that kind of info as a wolf.
 
PippyPony said:
Ok so lets make sure we are on the same page, then.

What it sounds to me like you are saying is that if you were a wolf, you would straight up ignore/discount someone in PM saying "oh ps, I told this person about my role, maybe look into them if I die"?

Really?

...?

Because that kind of thing freaking SCREAMS power role, and you are far too good of a wolf for me to believe for one half of a millisecond that you would just totally ignore that and be like "oh lol guys, they probably have a gif sending role, totes not a priority to kill this person, definitely no opportunity to leverage this here PM message against the other party."

I'm going to borrow a line from AM and say that my eyes may permanently roll back into my skull if you suggest you would not even consider that kind of info as a wolf.
Click to expand...

Actually, yes, I do ignore those initially as a wolf, yup I tell fellow wolves but it is sketchy as all sketchballs to kill that player immediately. You know that. What is even more ridiculous is that I DIDN'T HAVE TO SAY ANYTHING ABOUT SNOWY MESSAGING ME. No one else was mentioning it. Heck AM posted before I did, nada from her. I could have just kept quiet. I already had a target the size of ****ing Texas on my back and I knew posting that info about Snowy WOULD MAKE IT BIGGER, so why the **** even bother and create a larger headache for myself if I wasn't say..... a villager wanting the whole village to have that important information?????
 
DVMDream said:
And one more thing.....

There is no "role hint" in what Snowy told me. .. I copy/pasted it. All it implies is that she has an ability. Do people who have more "important" abilities tend to do that more, yes, of course, but be honest, everyone in WW thinks their ability is important.
Click to expand...
She implied she was worried about dying as a result of sharing her ability. Does that really mean "basically a vanillager" to you?

Why are you downplaying your own inductive reasoning capabilities so hard?

Also, I'm kind of over the complaining about the vanilla deal; a lot of people in this game are vanilla, I'm functionally vanilla, it's becoming tired.

The whaling industry was/is a huge bummer -- if you actually are a benign vanillager, I think that would actually be kind of a nicely poignant middle finger to a novel that makes a whale out to be a huge evil dingus while glorifying that industry. But maybe that's just me.
 
PippyPony said:
She implied she was worried about dying as a result of sharing her ability. Does that really mean "basically a vanillager" to you?

Why are you downplaying your own inductive reasoning capabilities so hard?

Also, I'm kind of over the complaining about the vanilla deal; a lot of people in this game are vanilla, I'm functionally vanilla, it's becoming tired.

The whaling industry was/is a huge bummer -- if you actually are a benign vanillager, I think that would actually be kind of a nicely poignant middle finger to a novel that makes a whale out to be a huge evil dingus while glorifying that industry. But maybe that's just me.
Click to expand...

I never said it meant she was basically vanillager did I???? No, no I did not, get off my back. Now you're just annoying.
 
DVMDream said:
Actually, yes, I do ignore those initially as a wolf, yup I tell fellow wolves but it is sketchy as all sketchballs to kill that player immediately. You know that. What is even more ridiculous is that I DIDN'T HAVE TO SAY ANYTHING ABOUT SNOWY MESSAGING ME. No one else was mentioning it. Heck AM posted before I did, nada from her. I could have just kept quiet. I already had a target the size of ****ing Texas on my back and I knew posting that info about Snowy WOULD MAKE IT BIGGER, so why the **** even bother and create a larger headache for myself if I wasn't say..... a villager wanting the whole village to have that important information?????
Click to expand...
Pfffft.

How would you know Snowy didn't tell AM she had told you to pull the trigger on her?

If Snowy had said something to AM, and you DIDN'T say anything, you would be freaking crucified .

If you had any doubts, best thing to do would be to get ahead of that ASAP, which you did.
 
PippyPony said:
Pfffft.

How would you know Snowy didn't tell AM she had told you to pull the trigger on her?

If Snowy had said something to AM, and you DIDN'T say anything, you would be freaking crucified .

If you had any doubts, best thing to do would be to get ahead of that ASAP, which you did.
Click to expand...

Except AM posted BEFORE me and didn't say a damn word. So no, I didn't post first. Nice try.
 
DVMDream said:
Except AM posted BEFORE me and didn't say a damn word. So no, I didn't post first. Nice try.
Click to expand...
I don't see how the order in which you posted makes any real difference whatsoever.

What makes you think she wouldn't have withheld a little tidbit like that until you had posted, to see if you'd say anything or not? That would be the smartest thing for her to do, actually, imo.
 
PippyPony said:
I don't see how the order in which you posted makes any real difference whatsoever.

What makes you think she wouldn't have withheld a little tidbit like that until you had posted, to see if you'd say anything or not? That would be the smartest thing for her to do, actually, imo.
Click to expand...

You could say the same thing for me though.... that goes in both directions. Both of us had that decision. I knew I was working so yeah I posted earlier in the day and because longer discussion is better for village.
 
PippyPony said:
She could have, if she didn't want to trap you

Do you think she is the type who might try to trap someone? Or the type to toss all info on the thread immediately?
Click to expand...

Seriously just stop. This is so stupid now. You're so ****ing caught up in this, you aren't even looking at anything else. You've been on my damn back all damn game go bother someone else and find a wolf.
 
Unlynch KC
Contingency lynch DVMD

If you're vanilla village, why are you so upset about the prospect of getting lynched that you are literally countering every single thing that someone says against you?

And let's hold the explosive insults, please -- I am attacking your game play logic right now, not you as a person. Cool your jets dude
 
PippyPony said:
Unlynch KC
Contingency lynch DVMD

If you're vanilla village, why are you so upset about the prospect of getting lynched that you are literally countering every single thing that someone says against you?

And let's hold the explosive insults, please -- I am attacking your game play logic right now, not you as a person. Cool your jets dude
Click to expand...

I don't care anymore, you can eat your hat twice. I'm honestly over this because of you, not even having fun anymore.

I'm honestly trying, my logic is fine and consistent, you're the one who is all over the damn place.
 
@allieh8607 , @StartingoverVet , @Crayola227

I'd really, really, really like for you all to actually come on and give some reads beyond just a lynch vote. We're in mid-game and potentially moving into late game and we have almost nothing from any of you. Cray has an excuse, but Allie and SOV need to start making some actual contributions and not just popping in for lynch votes and skating by.
 
And after you guys decide to lynch me to find I'm vanilla village, do not follow anymore of Pippy's ideas, I'm on the fence about her but slightly leaning more village. She just can't read anyone so flip flop her reads and you'll find a wolf.
 
DVMDream said:
I don't care anymore, you can eat your hat twice. I'm honestly over this because of you, not even having fun anymore.

I'm honestly trying, my logic is fine and consistent, you're the one who is all over the damn place.
Click to expand...
I'm sorry the game is not fun for you anymore. Certainly not my intent.

But, I also don't think it's a reasonable expectation to think people will avoid questioning you just because you don't want to be questioned.

And, I'm honestly trying, too :-/ I realize I've been all over the place, but I hope it's evident that I am also making an effort, even if it's a horrendously bad one this time. I'm definitely not accusing you of not trying, so I'm truly sorry if it came across that way.
 
PippyPony said:
I'm sorry the game is not fun for you anymore. Certainly not my intent.

But, I also don't think it's a reasonable expectation to think people will avoid questioning you just because you don't want to be questioned.

And, I'm honestly trying, too :-/ I realize I've been all over the place, but I hope it's evident that I am also making an effort, even if it's a bad one this time. I'm definitely not accusing you of not trying, so I'm truly sorry if it came across that way.
Click to expand...

The thing is I've been questioned and ridiculed for my thoughts all damn game, like lynch me or look elsewhere already. It is obnoxious to be the one person who is non stop being questioned every lynch cycle. It really doesn't make it fun. It makes it annoying.
 
DVMDream said:
And after you guys decide to lynch me to find I'm vanilla village, do not follow anymore of Pippy's ideas, I'm on the fence about her but slightly leaning more village. She just can't read anyone so flip flop her reads and you'll find a wolf.
Click to expand...
Come on, dude. I'm the first person to admit I'm really sucking right now, and have vocally said I am struggling this time around. Kinda harsh.
 
PippyPony said:
I'm sorry the game is not fun for you anymore. Certainly not my intent.

But, I also don't think it's a reasonable expectation to think people will avoid questioning you just because you don't want to be questioned.

And, I'm honestly trying, too :-/ I realize I've been all over the place, but I hope it's evident that I am also making an effort, even if it's a horrendously bad one this time. I'm definitely not accusing you of not trying, so I'm truly sorry if it came across that way.
Click to expand...

Go play 100 questions with Bryndi or Dolphin or SOV.... there's plenty of other players besides me, who has given you more than anyone else. I quite literally don't know what else you want from me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

supershorty
Here It GGOATS Again (GGOATS ThWWee) - Sign Up Thread - Sign Ups CLOSED
2
Replies
68
Views
3K
SARdoghandler
SARdoghandler
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (OPEN)
2 3 4
Replies
150
Views
7K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
WildZoo
Season 12 Mafia Championship Practice - Sign Ups
2
Replies
87
Views
4K
holdthemayo
holdthemayo
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
43K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
Top