Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

[Coopah]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I see literally nothing has happened since I went to sleep. What the hell guys? All the talkative people are dead. It's just me and Cray talking to ourselves. Mel where you at? Come on and defend yourself, please.

 

[Crayola227]

@CoffeeQuestionMark I know you're new, but do you have any more thoughts thus far on today's events?

I need to go back and look more at MA's posts, especially since she sorta came out as AM 2.0 with all the questions and little else. Especially since WM has taken over and has a more aggressive style I don't know what to make of.

 

[Crayola227]

Answered! I will lynch vote closer to close because I'm about to be gone for a few hours and give who on why then. Will also break any ties at that time if there are any. Although currently leaning MJ (no reason on Mel? maybe this is a thing they do?) Jboo or AM. Would consider others following more interaction. Not feeling the coop or brynd lynch yet because coop is always sketchy but is making some sense and then I'm not sure how I feel about brynd's lynch of Stella like I get why Brynd wants to but I'm also against a Stella lynch right at this moment just because it is D1 and I want them to post some strategy first. Plus then it'd be me lynching one of them for a bandwagon and I'm not going to do that when I currently don't have strong feels one way or another.

Feels wolfy. I let it go as some noob wishy washy. Just seems like they are trying to play safe and not make enemies. Noob wolves tend to do that.

 

[Crayola227]

AM knows better and last time she was wolf she was quite and simple answers plus I quoted her posts and give her sketch. Jboo I've called out on thread to reply so will wait and see what both have to say. Plus they've both been on and interacted somewhat to give feels other than Stella a "hey and what's Pm rule?" Like I said I'm not discounting it but 2 games ago I pm'ed with her and like legit needed some help so I'm willing to give her somewhat of a chance meaning I'm not I'm gonna lynch her today. If you still want to lynch her go for it.

This means NOTHING. Wolves do what they want #1 rule of wolfing.
Ok, but like you can derive some feels...I'm not expecting anyone to write a strategy book D1.
Anyway I'm off for a few hours and will respond to anything later.

Also wolfy. At the time I didn't really like the whole noob says "#1 rule of wolfing." Like, how would you know? Or do you just want to plant the idea while you continue to noob wolf?

 

[Crayola227]

Coming back to D1 like this has actually reaffirmed my sense of Coop as villager, with MA standing out more wolfy. Which them makes me wonder of WM's current suspicions.

 

[Crayola227]

You got anyone other than bryndy and sort of stella you're looking at?



mixy, why you in my head? What you pointed out is why I tagged jboo before you did Did I do too good a job training my wolfatees in my approach to ww?

Kara's post to MA just contributes to my sense of nervousness. It seems Kara has trained MA in the art of wolfing and suggests that she might be putting that training to use, if I'm reading this right.

 

[Crayola227]

Ok I see your point, it's valid but also not indicative of a wolf. There are players like Nyanko who use this strategy as a wolf or a villager and there's simply no way to distinguish them. I think it's a bit unfair to target quiet people because they're quiet until mid-game where they've at least proven to have nothing to contribute. If the vote was to encourage her to talk more I'd be more ok with it, but as of now it's kinda a dick move. Last game is a bad example but there has been plenty of times when Nyanko is a super helpful villager but is still quiet. Just pointing out a potential flaw with your logic.

My two reasons were to
1) Either she's trying to get stella to talk more OR
2) Wolf going for an easy lynch

I didn't want to spell it out in case she didn't have a great answer. So far the only thing I understand from her is I lynched her because she's historically quiet, which is kinda stupid imo.

Also I didn't vote because I was in class (on lunch now) and didn't have time to type up reasoning or look all that hard. The only votes out there at that point were bryn and joke votes. I dislike joke votes because I've had my ass kicked a few times putting one of those out there. Hell, one time I got lynched for tagging someone too early.

So yeah lynching someone cause they're quiet isn't valid D1 lynch in my book so

Lynch Bryn

+2 village points to Coop
+ 0.5 sketch points

don't ask how my brain works

 

[Crayola227]

Sorry was working. Didn't realize there was a content post requirement. YK has given me some sketch feels but feel bad lynching her again and it's probably noobness.

I agree with mel that on further reading coopah vs bryndy seems like village on village.

Unlynch bryndy

Lynch AM

Maybe I'm just extra paranoid that last time she was a wolf, I read her as village the whole time... but she's giving me feelz and is still on her rng vote of coop.

Mods LOVE ties! Officialish D1 Monsterish Tally of Votes

Kal (0) - Mixy
Mel (3) - Kara, Cray, MJ
Coop (3) - AM, allie, LIS
Mixy (1) - genny
AM (2) - jboo, Snowy
Bryn (3) - kal, Snowy, coop, Haxx
kara (0) - LIS
Stella (1) - bryn
MJ (1) - LIS, Coffee?
LIS (1) - Mel

15/17 votes
Roll Call: @Stella Mudd

@Coopah , @Melchizedek , @bryndiana.jones Y'all are winning!

I dunno. This looks like the sort of wish washy-ness that actually looks like a wolf possibly afraid to be on the lynch of who they know is a villager, going down on the first day. Making the "safe" vote elsewhere. Because we all know that people tend to look closely at those voting on whoever actually dies in a lynch - and less on the votes that didn't affect the ultimate outcome.

 

[WildZoo]

Is the answer to all my mod requests no?

No

 

[Crayola227]

I think all posts should count as strategy. I'm less inclined to kill funny wolves than dingus wolves. Therefore, any joking post = strategic content designed to make the poster live longer.

This is a good wolf hunting tip from Genny, about MJ. Not sure which of them is a wolf, but the statement stands.

 

[Skimble]

@Crayola227 you've been crazy quiet what do you think?

Why? Why did you have to say this? Look what you've done!!!

 

[Mad Jack]

This is a good wolf hunting tip from Genny, about MJ. Not sure which of them is a wolf, but the statement stands.

Injecting fun into the game tends to keep one alive longer

 

[Skimble]

Honestly I could vote coop or allieh today. Mel was rubbing me a little wrong yesterday, but I think I'd prefer to get rid of coop or allieh first. Something tells me they likely aren't both wolves, but it feels likely that one of them is.

Lynch allieh

For now. We'll see what happens as the day progresses. Coop's post lynch comment just didn't seem genuine, so it wouldn't take much for me to switch to her.

 

[Crayola227]

Lynch AM

Maybe I'm just extra paranoid that last time she was a wolf, I read her as village the whole time... but she's giving me feelz and is still on her rng vote of coop.

What feelz? And I feel like you should be familiar with the bolded considering how many games we've played together.

I call you out for ghosting and you bandwagon my lynch vote with a non-committal reason? You definitely just shot up on my sketch list.

What is sketch?

Some of Snowy's interactions with now dead villagers. I get it, villager on villager violence happens, we're all guilty of killing a few.
BUUUUT, the reasoning is just weak.

I think Snowy may have been low on the radar for being busy and having to sub out, but that doesn't mean she isn't a wolf.

 

[Crayola227]

Injecting fun into the game tends to keep one alive longer

What is this fun you speak of? Define "fun", lol. I need to take notes.

 

[Crayola227]

I gave your guys play sketch points not who's voting for who.It's D1...also pointing out its not just nothing if you read all my posts especially the most recent 2.Feeling the same feels though...This is all too similar to wolf I've seen out of AM. So I gotta go with my feels here.
###lynch AM###

If you go back to this original post, the whole thing just feel wrong.

 

[Melchizedek]

I see literally nothing has happened since I went to sleep. What the hell guys? All the talkative people are dead. It's just me and Cray talking to ourselves. Mel where you at? Come on and defend yourself, please.

No.
I already told you what I thought was going on through Snowy's head. I'm not defending myself against accusations of someone else's play. Feel free to look at my play since subbing in, and if you find it wolfy, I'll address it. Otherwise go ahead an lynch me based on your Snowy read. I'll flip village, and you'll have data.


and for the love of God, Cray can you please just take notes somewhere else and come back with one big consolidated post? You're making my eyes bleed, and I'm tempted to put you on ignore until this game is over.

 

[Crayola227]

So I have an early morning and won't be around much tomorrow (12 hours at the human hospital yay). I'll agree the coop, Brandi thing feels villagey but I need to go back if I get a chance and reevaluate that. Stella feels more village to me now swapping her vote as quickly as she did unless coop is wolf and she's a wolf. AM her last few comments are starting to sound more village-will evaluate todays actions based on how that goes. Jboo is still on my sketch kind of for her call out on Snowy since I felt Snowy's AM lynch wasn't 100% baseless because they're fond of AM usually. Would like to hear more from those who were particularly more quite yesterday than others. Current wolf list though there's almost guaranteed a wolf that was voting for Mel or Coop so will evaluate those players when I get a chance tomorrow after work.

I thought you just said jboo was fine.

Didn't you call me out for this?

Ugh, not sure why I sorta forgot about all this D1 stuff. I had AM as village, but now that I know... all this looks like wolf on village.

I think MA fell off the radar needing a sub, but that doesn't prove affiliation at all.

 

[Crayola227]

Because she like actually gave more than a single sentence answer... that's my problem with how you've been playing thus far. Plus when KB asked who else you would pressure you picked some of the easiest targets and then didn't bother to elaborate why... of course we would probably all like to hear from them more because they've been quite. I just feel like we are not getting quality posts out of you to benefit village like we've been getting from others even if they are wolf they're contributing quality posts.

What the heck is this nonsense?

I'm saying like her play is not contributing to help village much imo. Yes I know wolves are out to win. With that though if they are at least contributing to thread after we flip a wolf at least go back and I can find some truth in some of their posts to help me differentiate some village off my sketch list. So a contributing wolf for me is more helpful than what AM was putting out during lynch.

Are you kidding me? You think you'll get anything truthful out of a wolf post? Good luck with that.

This whole thing where MA tries to argue for the value of a wolf for village, and leaving them alive... so noob it hurts. But could be soooo wolf noob trying to plant the idea.

 

[Crayola227]

No.
I already told you what I thought was going on through Snowy's head. I'm not defending myself against accusations of someone else's play. Feel free to look at my play since subbing in, and if you find it wolfy, I'll address it. Otherwise go ahead an lynch me based on your Snowy read. I'll flip village, and you'll have data.


and for the love of God, Cray can you please just take notes somewhere else and come back with one big consolidated post? You're making my eyes bleed, and I'm tempted to put you on ignore until this game is over.

Sorry, I was trying to do this in such a way that people could either skip my posts or just look where I've quoted them or a person of interest. I did this in the middle of the night last game when it was quiet and it didn't seem to bug people too much.

I can quit. It was quiet.

I've tried the notes thing, but when I go back over my notes I have no idea what I was referring to. I was hoping to build better cases based on something more concrete than gut feels from a week of play. I think it's good for village to review together points of interest.

Like I said, I'm against just ISO'ing and putting up quotes, unless the person quoting has some analysis to add. That tells you about the people quoted and the person doing the commentary, and I hope fosters more analysis.

 

[Crayola227]

No.
I already told you what I thought was going on through Snowy's head. I'm not defending myself against accusations of someone else's play. Feel free to look at my play since subbing in, and if you find it wolfy, I'll address it. Otherwise go ahead an lynch me based on your Snowy read. I'll flip village, and you'll have data.


and for the love of God, Cray can you please just take notes somewhere else and come back with one big consolidated post? You're making my eyes bleed, and I'm tempted to put you on ignore until this game is over.

I appreciate you're not trying to silence me just by threatening to lynch me, which is one way that wolves will try to bully silence.

I already posted a large post that was my feelz on people, but much of it I said needed a thorough going over and reevaluation.

I dunno. I don't want to be put on ignore and I don't want to be lynched for being annoying. See you guys later for now.

 

[Coopah]

Feels wolfy. I let it go as some noob wishy washy. Just seems like they are trying to play safe and not make enemies. Noob wolves tend to do that.

You relive she's dead and flipped village right?

 

[Coopah]

Coming back to D1 like this has actually reaffirmed my sense of Coop as villager, with MA standing out more wolfy. Which them makes me wonder of WM's current suspicions.

I guess not then

Also from last post realize*

 

[Coopah]

Why? Why did you have to say this? Look what you've done!!!

... bad coop

In my defense they've all been really helpful at least to me.

 

[Coopah]

This whole thing where MA tries to argue for the value of a wolf for village, and leaving them alive... so noob it hurts. But could be soooo wolf noob trying to plant the idea.

SHE'S DEAD lol I realize you posted all of these before I posted mine but it makes be feel better

 

[Coopah]

No.
I already told you what I thought was going on through Snowy's head. I'm not defending myself against accusations of someone else's play. Feel free to look at my play since subbing in, and if you find it wolfy, I'll address it. Otherwise go ahead an lynch me based on your Snowy read. I'll flip village, and you'll have data.


and for the love of God, Cray can you please just take notes somewhere else and come back with one big consolidated post? You're making my eyes bleed, and I'm tempted to put you on ignore until this game is over.

How about at least your reads then?

 

[Melchizedek]

I appreciate you're not trying to silence me just by threatening to lynch me, which is one way that wolves will try to bully silence.

I already posted a large post that was my feelz on people, but much of it I said needed a thorough going over and reevaluation.

I dunno. I don't want to be put on ignore and I don't want to be lynched for being annoying. See you guys later for now.

Don’t get me wrong, I want to see your thoughts because so far the analysis has been good. i’m Just hoping it can be presented in a less headachey way. I’m trying to cram info into my head for exams tomorrow and Wednesday and it’s rough trying to parse out your posts.

 

[Crayola227]

I mean, I'm on page 8 so I'm just about 1/3 done with this process, it's dead, and there's ~6 hrs to deadline.

And it seems like people are showing up to talk as a result, and actually have something to talk about. I'd like to continue but I'm not sure how.

 

[Melchizedek]

How about at least your reads then?

If you don’t know my reads by now, you’re not paying attention.

 

[Crayola227]

where is @allieh8607

also @Mad Jack and @Haxx - it's Sunday, where are you?? I don't care about if you have lives outside school and WW.

 

[Coopah]

If you don’t know my reads by now, you’re not paying attention.

They're buried in 18000000 cray posts. I just woke up. Please?

 

[Skimble]

They're buried in 18000000 cray posts. I just woke up. Please?

If I remember correctly from yesterday, he pretty much thought everyone was a wolf, except himself, maybe.

 

[kaydubs]

I'm into killing, but I'm not into mercy, so I'm conflicted about what to do here

Don’t ask me 😀

 

[kaydubs]

Oh my bitter modites @WildZoo @vetmedhead

 

[Melchizedek]

They're buried in 18000000 cray posts. I just woke up. Please?

hahaha fair enough since I feel your pain.

Skimble is my biggest wolf read.
See this post for reasons:

Says Coops looks wolfy, gives a reason for it, but wants to keep vote on Mixy, and gives a flimsier reason for it. Okay maybe its just my interpretation, but there seemed a stronger case to vote coops at that point in the game v.s. reason stay on a joke vote for Mixy. Coupled with this:

Vote count had Coop in the lead, Mel#1 and AM close seconds, Jboo not even on the board with ~30 mins til lynch. Little late for a pressure vote. Feels like a wolf avoiding picking between lynching 3 villagers. Coop never comes back up after this.
I'm not seeing consistent logic, and there hasn't been much in the way of wolf hunting.

Lynch Genny

Nothing Skimble has done has helped me figure one way or another.

There's a wolf between MJ/Stella. I think of the two of them, one bussed Coffee? for village cred.

Allie I think is village based on her reactions to Coops D1. If it was a wolf trying to set up a mislynch she would have dropped the line of questioning when the lynch didn't take hold, but she continued to press it on D2 which reads villager to me.

Coops' D1 back and forth with BJ I had read as a V on V misunderstanding, but I'm reassessing this read based on the BJ lynch and subsequent events. Its possible Mel #1 accidentally just gave coops a way out of that situation. Coops' subsequent reiterations that she doesn't pick up on subtlety just rubs me the wrong way.

Cray. Either she's village, or she's wolf working really hard for her village cred. Willing to believe she's wolf for now until someone pulls out some hard evidence against her. The one thing I'm really confused about is her reading Mel #1 D1 before the flip. That seems wonky to me.

 

[Melchizedek]

hahaha fair enough since I feel your pain.

Skimble is my biggest wolf read.
See this post for reasons:


Nothing Skimble has done has helped me figure one way or another.

There's a wolf between MJ/Stella. I think of the two of them, one bussed Coffee? for village cred.

Allie I think is village based on her reactions to Coops D1. If it was a wolf trying to set up a mislynch she would have dropped the line of questioning when the lynch didn't take hold, but she continued to press it on D2 which reads villager to me.

Coops' D1 back and forth with BJ I had read as a V on V misunderstanding, but I'm reassessing this read based on the BJ lynch and subsequent events. Its possible Mel #1 accidentally just gave coops a way out of that situation. Coops' subsequent reiterations that she doesn't pick up on subtlety just rubs me the wrong way.

Cray. Either she's village, or she's wolf working really hard for her village cred. Willing to believe she's village for now until someone pulls out some hard evidence against her. The one thing I'm really confused about is her reading Mel #1 D1 before the flip. That seems wonky to me.

*Fixing typo

 

[Haxx]

where is @allieh8607

also @Mad Jack and @Haxx - it's Sunday, where are you?? I don't care about if you have lives outside school and WW.

Wif's grandpa just got put on hospice today. Sorry if I'm not around to write 1827349817230498 posts and comb through pages of theories.

 

[Haxx]

We're really voting only on play style at this point because we have no relevant villager abilities left for harder info. Cray seems like she's trying much too hard to act villager. I know that this is her usual style, I get that, but for me it is entirely unhelpful to the villager team because there are so many "feels" that none of them carry any weight. It's like she's the boy who called wolf. Oh wait, that's exactly what it is.

 

[Haxx]

That being said, Coop is the other person that seems "off" to me right now. A little too much commentary on the lack of activity or the voting history just seems a little forced and wolfy.

But for now,
Lynch Crayola

 

[kaydubs]

Wif's grandpa just got put on hospice today. Sorry if I'm not around to write 1827349817230498 posts and comb through pages of theories.

Sorry, Haxx 🙁

 

[Skimble]

hahaha fair enough since I feel your pain.

Skimble is my biggest wolf read.
See this post for reasons:


Nothing Skimble has done has helped me figure one way or another.

There's a wolf between MJ/Stella. I think of the two of them, one bussed Coffee? for village cred.

Allie I think is village based on her reactions to Coops D1. If it was a wolf trying to set up a mislynch she would have dropped the line of questioning when the lynch didn't take hold, but she continued to press it on D2 which reads villager to me.

Coops' D1 back and forth with BJ I had read as a V on V misunderstanding, but I'm reassessing this read based on the BJ lynch and subsequent events. Its possible Mel #1 accidentally just gave coops a way out of that situation. Coops' subsequent reiterations that she doesn't pick up on subtlety just rubs me the wrong way.

Cray. Either she's village, or she's wolf working really hard for her village cred. Willing to believe she's wolf for now until someone pulls out some hard evidence against her. The one thing I'm really confused about is her reading Mel #1 D1 before the flip. That seems wonky to me.

Ironic that you want to lynch me based on genny's play but asked people not to lynch you based on Snowy's play.

You just seem so sure that so many people are wolves, and I'm having a hard time following. You think I'm a wolf based on some perceived weird voting from genny d1. I can't speak for genny, but I usually avoid d1 bandwagons unless I feel pretty strongly about the reasoning. So the fact that she stayed off the three leaders doesn't seem that odd to me.

What are your reasons for thinking MJ/stella are wolves, because your reason for thinking genny was a wolf seems pretty flimsy to me, unless there is more to it that you aren't explaining.

 

[WildZoo]

Wif's grandpa just got put on hospice today. Sorry if I'm not around to write 1827349817230498 posts and comb through pages of theories.

Sorry to hear 🙁

 

[Crayola227]

Wif's grandpa just got put on hospice today. Sorry if I'm not around to write 1827349817230498 posts and comb through pages of theories.

sorry Haxx

 

[Crayola227]

I was making a joke about ppl's IRLs and it's like the second time this game I've gotten really burnt for it. I'm sorry and I can appreciate how that rubs people wrong.

I don't really need the constant flak for my play or my posts. I'm sorry if I'm ruining the game. Feedback received, course adjusted. Have a lovely Sunday everyone, if you can.

I'm dropping a vote and then taking a step back.

Good luck village.

 

[Melchizedek]

Ironic that you want to lynch me based on genny's play but asked people not to lynch you based on Snowy's play.

You just seem so sure that so many people are wolves, and I'm having a hard time following. You think I'm a wolf based on some perceived weird voting from genny d1. I can't speak for genny, but I usually avoid d1 bandwagons unless I feel pretty strongly about the reasoning. So the fact that she stayed off the three leaders doesn't seem that odd to me.

What are your reasons for thinking MJ/stella are wolves, because your reason for thinking genny was a wolf seems pretty flimsy to me, unless there is more to it that you aren't explaining.

No, I already said that it's perfectly valid to lynch me based off of snowy, but that I'm not going to defend myself against accusations made against someone I replaced.

You're consistently misreading what I've said or purposely trying to make me seem more alarmist than I am. There are two wolves left. I think one of them is you, and that the other is between MJ/Stella. This seems perfectly reasonable.
If you're not going to go back and look at what happened around the Coffee? lynch and refuse to analyze the things I quoted to you yesterday, what more reasoning can I give you about my reads? You've literally just said I'm going to just play the game from scratch.

 

[Crayola227]

JFC. How did I miss that WM was dead????

This is worse than an LIS given all the quotes of her posts I made. And that she was a villager.

Night kills have so little fanfare.

Yeah, clearly I need to just quit.

 

[Crayola227]

can we get a tally, pls?

 

[Crayola227]

lynch MJ

I feel bad. It's mostly a lack of data. I could waffle to so many others, but we see how well that goes down when I do it, so let's just see what other people have to post.

 

[Mad Jack]

where is @allieh8607

also @Mad Jack and @Haxx - it's Sunday, where are you?? I don't care about if you have lives outside school and WW.

I'm engaging in hedonistic shenanigans, prioritiesssss

 

[Coopah]

I'm engaging in hedonistic shenanigans, prioritiesssss