Monster Mash WW - Sign Ups and Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Lawper said:
Boom! I knew @genny is a wolf once again!

Cray being a wolf comes as no surprise. @SkiOtter called it but i wanted to stick with my pre game prediction that Cray is village.

Also called it that Mixy the @MixedAnimals77 was village! I'd be sad if she flipped wolf this game :dead::hungover:

Good game to all. It's been fun watching.
Click to expand...
Yay Lawper :clap:
 
I just hate how the game ended, because I knew cray was a wolf and would probably flip her vote at the last minute, so as a villager my only option was to pick from the remaining choices. Logically, her best move would be to follow mine, regardless of me picking a wolf, so it was either give her the game or just make a choice, either way the odds were bad.
 
Coopah said:
Thanks you were the only one I could protect as I couldn't protect myself. I was so agry they killed LIS on a night when they had 2 cleared villagers. I kept the mods plenty entertained with my outbursts in PM
Click to expand...

the night you could protect and there were outed confirmed villagers... we figured that the protector would most likely go there and so we picked another target and crossed our fingers
 
Crayola227 said:
Sorry Kara... with the combined sketch factor of Coffee the noob wolf already on LIS' noob wolf sketchdar (and he indeed placed a hit that very night as she lost her protection and we were notified)

plus that we had a noob wolf and me with my 2nd wolf out wanting to do our best....

and you are a really smart villager coming out swinging and talking...

and I wasn't aware of the social aspect of how often you play etc....

genny said she could go either way as she felt bad but it's a smart move

so she left it up to Coffee and I... I'm pretty ruthless about killing good villagers before they can heavily suspect anyone in wolfpack on thread
Click to expand...
Coffee doesn't know anybody so that first night was just go with the flow
 
I wanted to believe Cray was village since i felt bad about her lynch in the rehab game. But as i read her posts, they didn't seem right at all and felt she's wolf... i didn't want to deviate much from my initial predictions so i stuck with them.

2/3 isn't so bad!
 
well, I hope you guys can appreciate how hard the win was worked for, no skating here

it's really a bummer because people like my wolf play and call it good villaging more than when I village!
yet it's bad wolf play since everyone sees through it!

either everyone's going to just lynch me all the time, or I hope people will at least give me the chance as villager, even though it mean my wolf game is pretty sunk

I try suuuuper hard to stick to my meta but it doesn't seem to work
 
Ugh. Knew it with cray and skimble. Just not enough village working together on thread. Good job wolves!
 
Superlatives:

Best co-mods: @vetmedhead and @kaydubs
This game went a titch longer than expected due to the lack of vig kills, and they picked up the slack when my schedule got more busy. You guys are da best.

Best wolf hunter: @LetItSnow. Likely to have killed two wolves if not for bad luck. Honorable mention for mod entertainment as well.

Best mod entertainment: @Coopah This needs no explanation 😉


And the Chattiest Cathy award of course goes to @Crayola227, who made our eyes bleed with approximately 5000 posts, but proved that flooding the thread can be an effective wolf strategy. And kudos to @Haxx for picking up on that, even though he didn't see it through 😛
 
You guys may be more aware of who is suspicious of you, if you want to tell me who so I can add to the tabs, or add your own notes:

Wolfy Tabs

N1 - seered AM, blocked Johnna, kill on Kara protected away
AM vanillager, no vigilante kill but Coffee lost protection

N2 - seered Haxx, blocked LIS, kill Kara
Haxx vanillager, LIS blocked, Kara killed, Coffee still alive

N3 - seered Snowy/Mel, blocked LIS, kill LIS
Smel vanillager, LIS blocked and killed, he was vigilante who got Coffee last night

N4 - seered Ally, blocked MJ for shiggles, kill AM
Ally vanillager, AM killed

N5 - seered MJ, blocked Coop, kill WM
MJ vanillager, Coop blocked, WM killed

N6 - seered Coop, blocked Coop for shiggles, kill Haxx
Coop EON protector, Haxx killed

SnowyMel - vanillager
Allie - vanillager
MJ -vanillager
Coop - every odd night protector

Johnna - dead vanillager
Kara - dead vanillager
Mel - dead vanillager
LIS - dead vigilante
BJ - dead seer
AM - dead vanillager
YK - dead vanillager
WM - dead vanillager
Stella - dead vanillager
Haxx - dead vanillager
 
And remind me never to run a game in February again. I should get some kind of award for highest percentage of substitutions required in a game.

Also if people have thoughts on the way this game was setup and run, please share! We chatted about it some in dead chat but I'm always open to more feedback.
 
WildZoo said:
Superlatives:

Best co-mods: @vetmedhead and @kaydubs
This game went a titch longer than expected due to the lack of vig kills, and they picked up the slack when my schedule got more busy. You guys are da best.

Best wolf hunter: @LetItSnow. Likely to have killed two wolves if not for bad luck. Honorable mention for mod entertainment as well.

Best mod entertainment: @Coopah This needs no explanation 😉


And the Chattiest Cathy award of course goes to @Crayola227, who made our eyes bleed with approximately 5000 posts, but proved that flooding the thread can be an effective wolf strategy. And kudos to @Haxx for picking up on that, even though he didn't see it through 😛
Click to expand...
What, no thanks to the 3 subs?! :yeahright:
 
Wolf Cray is very careful about what she does to look village

Villager Cray plays cray cray because I don't worry about looking village or making sense when I wolf hunt, all the things people think are wolfy I just assume people can look past, but no one gives me credit that I would only do those things as a villager, not as a wolf. I'm not a stupid player making stupid mistakes except when I village. Hence my defense, "would I really do something that wolfy if I was wolf?" Sure you can WIFOM but I'm not that brave to play as wolf the way I do as village.

The fact that people can tell I'm a wolf when I wolf I still wouldn't call stupid play. I just haven't figured out how to keep it all the same.

As a wolf all my posts I can just think abut what it looks like, making it make sense, and since I know who's who I can make all arguments without a tinfoil hat
Villager Cray in the dark comes up with weird shyte I have yet to figure out how to duplicate as a wolf

typos? typing ###coop###, past/tense future tense on a post before flip of "I said AM was villager!!" these are seriously not ways that you will ever find wolf cray, these are villager cray mistakes
 
Night Actions:

N1

Genny blocks jboo > blocked
Coop protects Kara > protected
bryn seers AM > villager
Cray seers AM > vanilla
Wolves kill Kara > NOT DEAD
LIS kills Coffee 😱 > failure to launch

N2

Genny blocks LIS > success
bryn seers Haxx > villager
Cray seers Haxx > vanilla
Wolves kill Kara > deaded
LIS kills AM > no kill again

N3

Genny blocks LIS > success
Coop protects AM > success
Cray seers Cheez > vanilla
LIS kills coffee > failed again :rage:
Wolves kill LIS > 😢

N4
Genny blocks MJ > success
Cray seers allie > vanilla
Wolves kill AM > dead

N5
Wolves kill WM > dead
Jil blocks Coop > success
Cray seers MJ > vanilla

N6
Skimble blocks Coopah > success
Cray seers Coopah > protector
Wolves kill Haxx > dead

N7
Skimble blocks coop > success
Wolves kill coop > dead
Coop may have submitted an action but it wouldn't have mattered anyway
 
Last edited:
I have to say all this because with my meta I'm not sure I'll ever get the benefit of the doubt as wolf ever again. But I don't want to be LIS' egg to crack early on every game. So the loss of trust here, I hope even if it sinks my wolf game that my villager game might not have to suffer more than it does.
 
Crayola227 said:
yeah, weird, huh?

genny thought Haxx's tight lipped ness might be PR, and we thought you were tight-lipped

with your sketch factor and tight lipped ness, we wanted to see if you had a PR too, a PR in your hands we wouldn't have loved
Click to expand...

I actually always get killed N1 when I have a PR (in games that aren't role madness). I don't even know what that would feel like.
 
@allieh8607 thanks for standing up for me, wolfiness aside.

I think there's a way to play and call people out for wolfiness or whatever without making them feel like dolts

I get my feelerz hurt for realz as wolf or villager, that's not really fake, so I appreciate what you said and I hope you don't feel duped for having said what you did
 
WildZoo said:
Night Actions:

N1

Genny blocks jboo > blocked
Coop protects Kara > protected
bryn seers AM > villager
Cray seers AM > vanilla
Wolves kill Kara > NOT DEAD
LIS kills Coffee 😱 > failure to launch

N2

Genny blocks LIS > success
bryn seers Haxx > villager
Cray seers Haxx > vanilla
Wolves kill Kara > deaded
LIS kills AM > no kill again

N3

Genny blocks LIS > success
Coop protects AM > success
Cray seers Cheez > vanilla
Wolves kill LIS > 😢

N4
Genny blocks MJ > success
Cray seers allie > vanilla
Wolves kill AM > dead

N5
Wolves kill WM > dead
Jil blocks Coop > success
Cray seers MJ > vanilla

N6
Skimble blocks Coopah > success
Cray seers Coopah > protector
Wolves kill Haxx > dead

N7
Skimble blocks coop > success
Wolves kill coop > dead
Coop may have submitted an action but it wouldn't have mattered anyway
Click to expand...
Still bitter about the LIS blocks and subsequent kill, I wanted to watch him windmill his hands around while he stabbed people left and right all game
 
Animal Midwife said:
I actually always get killed N1 when I have a PR (in games that aren't role madness). I don't even know what that would feel like.
Click to expand...

I actually worked to keep you alive as distraction once I knew you were villager - that's why I seered you

I thought it would be nice if you got to play, and sketchy quiet vanillagers aren't high on my kill list

you keep the paranoid chatter going, this is good for village AND wolf
 
I said in pack chat, that you are a much better player than you are given credit for, as wolf and villager

20 Qs while you play close to vest... you are able to gather data, and the wolves are in a catch 20/20... leave you alive cuz sketch, or not really knowing what you are making of what's on the thread... you could come out and scream WOLF! when you figure out the pieces, then you either get village cred when a wolf goes down, or when you flip village, your suspicions take better hold

if you're wolf, people will expect tight-lipped play from you

it's a tightwalk for you as far as living, but it's smart play because you draw people out onto thread without giving away your thoughts to wolves
 
It's also smart play because by not giving a lot away, the rapid fire questioning, the wolf doesn't really know what answer you are looking for

it's also harder to come up with lies fast on the spot

I imagine when you're wolf it might be easier to gather intel from villagers, or people look sketch if they can't rise to the challenge
 
bryndiana.jones said:
Good game everyone! And congrats to the wolves on this one, especially Genny and Skimble! Did not peg you for a wolf when I chose my three in deadchat
Click to expand...

@genny will always be wolf in prevet games. The RNG favors it 😏😏
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (OPEN)
2 3 4
Replies
150
Views
7K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
supershorty
Here It GGOATS Again (GGOATS ThWWee) - Sign Up Thread - Sign Ups CLOSED
2
Replies
68
Views
3K
SARdoghandler
SARdoghandler
SportPonies
Noob WW Game 2023 Sign Ups OPEN!
Replies
40
Views
2K
SportPonies
SportPonies
kaydubs
WW sign ups April 2024
Replies
47
Views
2K
kaydubs
kaydubs
Top